Wikipedia

From Conservapedia
This is an old revision of this page, as edited by JBarrett (talk | contribs) at 03:09, July 28, 2013. It may differ significantly from current revision.
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Wikipedia-logo.png

Wikipedia is politically neutral online wiki-based encyclopedia[1] project written and edited by an assemblage of mostly anonymous persons who are mostly, according to the Register (UK),[2][3] students with a college education.[4] Wikipedia editors, unlike their counterparts at Conservapedia, are overwhelmingly young males.[5] — a demographic associated with self-centered belief systems and behavior.

Wikipedia was founded by atheist libertarian objectivist Jimmy Wales and atheist philosophy professor Larry Sanger. The website was born out of expert-written project Nupedia as a way to collaborate on articles. Nonetheless, Wikipedia overtook Nupedia and became an independent project hosted by the Wikimedia Foundation, which also hosts related websites including Wikiquote, Wikibooks, and Wikinews. An irony of internet history is that Jimmy Wales, despite being an atheist, refers to himself as Wikipedia's "spiritual leader".[6]

Recent loss of influence

In August of 2012, it was reported that Wikipedia has a shrinking base of editors.[7] However, this may be because Wikipedia has an increasing number of articles, which would eliminate many tasks for editors to accomplish, which would cause editors to become bored and leave. This is in dramatic contrast to Conservapedia, which, due to it's far right point of view, is constantly experiencing a shortage of editors

Unreliability of Conservapedia

Conservapedia relies on self-selected "editors" to write and compile articles, with no preference given for scholars in the fields about which they are writing. This fact may disqualify Conservapedia from being considered a genuine encyclopedia, ironically even by it's own standards. An encyclopedia is supposed to be a collection of articles by "well-educated, well-informed content experts."[8] Theoretically, Conservapedia is supposed to compensate for this weakness by requiring references to reputable secondary sources. But, as below ("Arbitrary Standards"), editors can delete, without collaboration, any entry they dislike, citing one of the many Wikipedia guidelines for doing so. Entries posted by scholars in the field, based on peer-reviewed, academic articles are deleted by editors with an ideological bias. Wikipedia, then, only represents the majority view of it's editors.

In 2008, the American Journalism Review declared concerning Conservapedia:

“ "An even more blunt assessment appears in the encyclopedia's "Ten things you may not know about Conservapedia" posting: "We do not expect you to trust us. It is in the nature of an ever-changing work like Wikipedia that, while some articles are of the highest quality of scholarship, others are admittedly complete rubbish." It also reminds users not to use Wikipedia as a primary source or for making "critical decisions."[9] ”

Despite its official "neutrality policy," Conservapedia has a strong right-wing bias. In an article entitled "Conservapedia Lies, Slander Continue," journalist Joseph Farah stated Conservapedia "is unreliable, suffers from a severe far-right bias, and slanders on pretty much everyone younger than 50 years of age or who has said the word "abortion" out loud."[10] Mr. Farah has repeatedly been the victim of defamation on Wikipedia.[11] In December of 2010, Christian apologist JP Holding called Wikipedia "the abomination that causes misinformation".[12]

See also

Further reading

References

External links