Difference between revisions of "Weak Atheism"
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| + | {{uncited2}} | ||
| + | |||
'''Weak atheism''' describes all belief systems which lack a belief in [[God]], without claiming to meet the [[burden of proof]] that God does not exist. It differs from [[strong atheism]], which claims to have positive reason or evidence proving that God does not exist. | '''Weak atheism''' describes all belief systems which lack a belief in [[God]], without claiming to meet the [[burden of proof]] that God does not exist. It differs from [[strong atheism]], which claims to have positive reason or evidence proving that God does not exist. | ||
Revision as of 23:38, August 21, 2007
| ! | This article has an inadequate number of citations. You are encouraged to add sources for verifiability, but please abide by The Conservapedia Commandments & Style Guide. |
Weak atheism describes all belief systems which lack a belief in God, without claiming to meet the burden of proof that God does not exist. It differs from strong atheism, which claims to have positive reason or evidence proving that God does not exist.
Most commonly, weak atheism is premised on the belief that the theist, not the atheist, bears the burden of proof to show that God does not exist, because it is the theist who is asserting the existence of an entity. They typically compare belief in God with belief in absurd beings like "flying spaghetti monsters," "bigfoot," or "invisible pink unicorns," and argue, "The person attempting to convince me that the flying spaghetti monster exists has the burden of proof. In the absence of sufficient proof to warrant belief, I am justified in disbelieving in all these beings."
As George Smith wrote,
- "If one presents a positive belief (i.e. an assertion which one claims to be true), one has the obligation to present evidence in its favor. The burden of proof lies with the person who asserts the truth of a proposition. If the evidence is not forthcoming, if there are not sufficient grounds for accepting the proposition, it should not be believed."
The end result of weak atheism and strong atheism is the same: atheism, a denial of the existence of God. The difference between the two types of atheism lies in the justification for that denial. Strong atheists claim to have positive proof for God's non-existence. Weak atheists do not claim to have such proof -- and they claim their belief is justified even without such proof, because they do not bear the burden of proof.
Theistic responses
Most commonly, theists respond by saying that theists have, in fact, met the burden of proof, through arguments for the existence of God. Other theists criticize soft atheism as seeking to "dodge the issue." Terry Miethe argued:
- "the "negative atheist" ends up denying God's existence just as much as the "positive atheist." For the believer (and in reality) to deny the idea of God is to deny the actual existence of God no matter what language game you want to play. Remember, Hans Kung is quite correct in pointing out that there is also an "atheistic language game" that is not self-justified…We must not---cannot---arbitrarily "define" out of existence vast ranges of reality simply because they do not meet our predetermined definition. It is not good enough to say that I have no idea of God therefore I am denying nothing about "his" actual existence. You must examine all of reality and answer or explain why millions have had what they thought was an adequate idea or concept of God, from great philosophers to the 'common folk.'"