Difference between revisions of "Mulan"

From Conservapedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (An Editing of Conservapedia's Page on)
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
'''''Mulan''''' is a 1998 [[cartoon]] [[film]] released by the [[Walt Disney]] corporation, based on an epic poem of the same name.  The film is set in [[China]] during an invasion by the [[Mongol Armies|Huns]], and is somewhat known for its controversial depiction of what appears to be feminist messages and occultism.
+
'''''Mulan''''' is a 1998 [[cartoon]] [[film]] released by the [[Walt Disney]] corporation, based on the Chinese poem [[The Ballad of Mulan]].  The film is set in [[China]] during an invasion by the [[Mongol Armies|Huns]].
  
−
==Plot==
+
Mulan is a young [[woman]] who, following the custom of her people, is sent to a matchmaker for an arranged [[marriage]], but is rejected as unworthy to marry for her clumsiness, which carries a scourge of dishonor on her family.  Meanwhile, as the Huns invade China, her crippled father is drafted to fight the Huns.  Mulan sneaks out of the house and disguises herself as a man to take the place of her father, and becomes a hero by helping defeat the Huns.
−
Mulan is a young [[woman]] who, following the custom of her people, is sent to a matchmaker for an arranged [[marriage]], but is rejected as unworthy to marry for her clumsiness, which carries a scourge of dishonor on her family.  Meanwhile as the Huns invade China, her crippled father is drafted to fight the Huns.  Mulan sneaks out of the house and disguises herself as a man to take the place of her father, and becomes a hero by helping defeat the Huns.
+
 
 +
A live action remake was later released in 2020, which was notorious for basically kow-towing to Chinese censorship, including having concentration camp departments playing a key role in making the film.
  
 
==Criticism==
 
==Criticism==
−
The underlying message in ''Mulan'' is [[feminism]]. The film frequently takes aim at the custom in her society that women are unfit to fight.  The film also has a strong [[occult]] content, including  worship of ancestral spirits (which is actually not present in Chinese faiths such as Taoism or Confucianism), and a miniature [[dragon]] who has a central role in the movie serving as Mulan's [[familiar spirit]]; therefore, some people think that this makes ''Mulan'' questionable fare for [[Christian]] youth to view without parental guidance.
+
The central message in Mulan is [[filial piety]], but with a feminist twist. The film frequently takes aim at the custom in her society that women are unfit to fight.   
  
−
==Alternate View==
 
−
However, despite the obvious occult influences and feminism, user WilsonB notes on his blog that it might also have a conservative message too. For the Chinese army clearly is not in the mood for appeasing (used commonly by [[liberals]]) the invading Huns, who, through the laying of several Chinese villages to waste, are not even in the mood for appesement. Mulan also clearly acts selflessly and puts sevice to her country over herself. Thus, the fact that the film was released in 1998, which was 3 years before [[9/11]] and around the time of the US Embassy Bombings in Africa, suggests that the title character is an allegory for the USA and that the Huns are to be one for [[al-Qaeda]] terrorists. Also, to address occultic allegations, WilsonB reminds his opposition that, whether it be in the original poem or in the movie, the tale takes place in a BC (Before Christianity) era, so practices that would nowadays be concsidered "occultic" would have been common in Eastern countries.
 
 
[[Category:Animated Movies]]
 
[[Category:Animated Movies]]

Latest revision as of 02:47, September 11, 2020

Mulan is a 1998 cartoon film released by the Walt Disney corporation, based on the Chinese poem The Ballad of Mulan. The film is set in China during an invasion by the Huns.

Mulan is a young woman who, following the custom of her people, is sent to a matchmaker for an arranged marriage, but is rejected as unworthy to marry for her clumsiness, which carries a scourge of dishonor on her family. Meanwhile, as the Huns invade China, her crippled father is drafted to fight the Huns. Mulan sneaks out of the house and disguises herself as a man to take the place of her father, and becomes a hero by helping defeat the Huns.

A live action remake was later released in 2020, which was notorious for basically kow-towing to Chinese censorship, including having concentration camp departments playing a key role in making the film.

Criticism

The central message in Mulan is filial piety, but with a feminist twist. The film frequently takes aim at the custom in her society that women are unfit to fight.