Difference between revisions of "False dichotomy"

Latest revision as of 21:50, March 4, 2011

Redirect to:

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-A '''false dichotomy''', or "false choice," is a [[logical fallacy]] whereby one side of an argument presents to the other two unpleasant, opposite, and extreme alternatives, alleging that they are the only choices open in the matter up for debate.  The fallacy lies in disregarding the middle ground, or failing to credit the range of disagreement on the issue.  Some examples follow.
+#REDIRECT [[False Dilemma]]
-==Examples of a false dichotomy==
-*'''''America - love it or leave it!'''''  This is a false dichotomy because the third choice - be a [[patriot]] by seeking favorable change - is open but disregarded.  Unflinching support, after all, has never been a characteristic of [[American]] patriotism.
-*'''''If science fails to explain something, the only alternative must be divine intervention'''''  This false dichotomy fails to grasp the nature of [[science]] - that knowledge expands, and that some [[natural causes]] may not yet be descried.  The third option - continued [[research]] - is open but ignored.
-[[category:Rhetoric]]