| Feb–Mar 1930 |
Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. | Willis Van Devanter | James McReynolds | Louis Brandeis | George Sutherland | Pierce Butler | Edward T. Sanford | Harlan Fiske Stone
|
| Jun 1930–1932 |
Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr. | Willis Van Devanter | James McReynolds | Louis Brandeis | George Sutherland | Pierce Butler | Harlan Fiske Stone | Owen Roberts
|
| 1932–1937 |
Willis Van Devanter | James McReynolds | Louis Brandeis | George Sutherland | Pierce Butler | Harlan Fiske Stone | Owen Roberts | Benjamin Cardozo
|
| 1937–1938 |
James McReynolds | Louis Brandeis | George Sutherland | Pierce Butler | Harlan Fiske Stone | Owen Roberts | Benjamin Cardozo | Hugo Black
|
| 1938 |
James McReynolds | Louis Brandeis | Pierce Butler | Harlan Fiske Stone | Owen Roberts | Benjamin Cardozo | Hugo Black | Stanley Reed
|
| 1939 |
James McReynolds | Pierce Butler | Harlan Fiske Stone | Owen Roberts | Hugo Black | Stanley Reed | Felix Frankfurter | William O. Douglas
|
| 1940–1941 |
James McReynolds | Harlan Fiske Stone | Owen Roberts | Hugo Black | Stanley Reed | Felix Frankfurter | William O. Douglas | Frank Murphy
|
| Feb-Jul 1941 |
Harlan Fiske Stone | Owen Roberts | Hugo Black | Stanley Reed | Felix Frankfurter | William O. Douglas | Frank Murphy | (vacancy)
|