Perfect-solution fallacy
This is an old revision of this page, as edited by DavidE (talk | contribs) at 15:53, August 4, 2011. It may differ significantly from current revision.
The perfect-solution fallacy is the logical fallacy of assuming that just because a solution does not perfectly solve a problem, it is not worth trying at all.[1] It is a particular form of a false dilemma. The perfect-solution fallacy is similar but not identical to the Nirvana fallacy.
Examples
Liberals often commit the perfect-solution fallacy, as in the following examples:
- Because abstinence-only education does not completely eliminate teen pregnancy, abstinence should not even be mentioned in schools.
- Because sodomy laws did not completely eliminate HIV, there was no point in enforcing them.