Moral Zeitgeist
Please see Liberal Point of View (LPOV).
The Moral Zeitgeist is a term used by atheists to describe the evolution of morality. Proponents of a moral Zeitgeist believe that morality evolved to help what they believe to be our ape-like ancestors survive in large groups as social animals. This theory suggests that moral acceptability is chosen by the masses. As people's view of what is morally right and wrong changes, the moral Zeitgeist is said to "shift." Of course Creationists and most Christians do not believe this to be true.
To Atheists, there appears to be a universal moral, nae, ethical consensus as to what makes something morally acceptable. Richard Dawkins illustrates this with respect to racism in chapter 7 of his book The God Delusion:
In the early part of the twentieth century, almost everybody in Britain... would be judged racist by today's standards. Most white people believed that black people... were inferior to white people in almost all respects except --- patronizingly --- sense of rhythm. The 1920s equivalent of James Bond was... Bulldog Drummond. In one novel, The Black Gang, Drummond refers to "Jews, foreigners, and other unwashed folk." In... The Female of the Species, Drummond is cleverly disguised as Pedro, black servant of the archvillain. For his dramatic disclosure... that "Pedro" is really Drummond himself... he chose these words: "Every beard is not false, but every nigger smells. That beard ain't false, dearie, and dis nigger don't smell [...]"... I read it... three decades after it was written, and it was (just) still possible for a boy to thrill to the drama and not notice the racism. Nowadays, it would be inconceivable.
The moral Zeitgeist is believed to be independent of any religious principles. However, it is freely admitted that the moral Zeitgeist changes universally and sometimes very quickly. This suggests to its proponents that something effects its changes, however, nothing has yet been found to do so. Detractors of the theory say this is simply Atheist avoidance of admitting the power of God.
The Evolution of Morality
The moral Zeitgeist was proposed to explain the evolution of morality. While natural selection favors individuals instead of populations, it has been proposed that it must have been more beneficial to the individuals of the species to behave somewhat morally (No society, not even a small clan of apes, can function well if the members go around killing each other). This is also used to explain why people have a tendency to be more moral to the people to whom they are most closely related.
The changing moral Zeitgeist is believed to be the evolution of morality. Detractors believe the constant change is nothing more than relativists blowing in the wind, never firmly grounded by fundamental, never changing, moral/religious principles.
The Word Zeitgeist
Zeitgeist is a German word meaning "spirit of the times."
Controversy
The moral Zeitgeist is incompatible with moral absolutism and religious morality. Moral absolutism suggests that actions are either morally right, acceptable, or wrong, regardless of the context. Religious morality suggests that actions are either morally right, acceptable, or wrong based on the religion's teaching (see Buddhism) or the revelations of a deity or deities[1]. The moral Zeitgeist suggests that actions are morally right, acceptable, or wrong based on the opinions of the masses.
Quotes
"There seems to be a steadily shifting standard of what is morally acceptable... Something... has shifted in all of us, and the shift has no connection with religion. If anything, it happens in spite of religion, not because of it." --- Richard Dawkins, The God Delusion
See Also
References
The God Delusion (Chapter 7) by Richard Dawkins
- ↑ Some religious people would consider their morals absolute