Difference between revisions of "Origin of Life"
Conservative (talk | contribs) |
Conservative (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
==Some Specific Problems for Naturalistic Explanations of the Origin of Life== | ==Some Specific Problems for Naturalistic Explanations of the Origin of Life== | ||
The attempt to explain the origin of life faces numerous difficult problems which is why the theory has not fared well in recent times: | The attempt to explain the origin of life faces numerous difficult problems which is why the theory has not fared well in recent times: | ||
| − | #'''Chicken or the Egg problem regarding [[DNA]] and [[proteins]]''': John Horgan wrote: "Many investigators now consider nucleic acids to be much more plausible candidates for the first self-replicating | + | #'''Chicken or the Egg problem regarding [[DNA]] and [[proteins]]''': John Horgan wrote: "Many investigators now consider [[nucleic acids]] to be much more plausible candidates for the first self-replicating [[molecule]]s. The work of Watson and [[Francis Crick|Crick]] and others has shown that proteins are formed according to the instructions coded in DNA. But there is a hitch. DNA cannot do its work, including forming more DNA, without the help of [[catalytic proteins]], or [[enzyme]]s. In short, proteins cannot form without DNA, but neither can DNA form without proteins. To those pondering the origin of life, it is a classic chicken-and-egg problem: Which came first, proteins or DNA?" (Horgan, John [science writer], "In The Beginning...," Scientific American, Vol. 264, No. 2, February 1991, pp.100-109, p.103)"<ref>http://members.iinet.net.au/~sejones/orignl01.html#orgnflfmjrprblmschcknndgg</ref> |
| + | |||
== Philosophical Presuppositions and Origin of Life Scenarios == | == Philosophical Presuppositions and Origin of Life Scenarios == | ||
Revision as of 05:44, September 17, 2007
There have been a number of proposals regarding the origin of life on earth. However, the various proposals fall into two schools of thought. The first held by creationist is that life originated supernaturally. The second school of thought is that non-life became life solely by means of natural processes in this proposal is commonly referred to as abiogenesis. [1] The proposal that first life came about through natural processes has not fared well in recent times. Dr. Walter Bradley stated the following: "The optimism of the 1950's is gone. The mood at the 1999 international conference of the origin of life was described as grim - full of frustration, pessimism, and desperation."[2] Prominent origin of life researcher Klaus Dose wrote about the "immensity of the problem" for naturalistic explanations of the origin of life and stated, "At present all discussions on principle theories and experiments in the field either end in stalemate or in a confession of ignorance."[3] In 1996, John Horgan wrote the following in the Scientific American: "The origin of life is a science writer's dream. It abounds with exotic scientists and exotic theories, which are never entirely abandoned or accepted, but merely go in and out of fashion." [4] Even Stanley Miller who helped conduct the famous Miller-Urey experiment wrote in Scientific American that the "problem of the origin of life has turned out to be much more difficult than I, and most other people, envisioned.[5] In 1996, John Horgan wrote that Stanley Miller had referred to current proposals of the origin of life as "nonsense" and "paper chemistry". [6] Stanley Miller, however, wasn't the first to highly disparage the existing proposals that scientists had come up with for the origin of life though natural means. Chemist and science writer Andrew Scott had stated in 1988 the following: "Due to this scarcity of financial resources the study of the origins of life has been forced to become a most efficient and cost-effective industry from just a thimble-full of facts the scientists engaged in that study manage to generate a virtually endless supply of theories!"[7]
Some Specific Problems for Naturalistic Explanations of the Origin of Life
The attempt to explain the origin of life faces numerous difficult problems which is why the theory has not fared well in recent times:
- Chicken or the Egg problem regarding DNA and proteins: John Horgan wrote: "Many investigators now consider nucleic acids to be much more plausible candidates for the first self-replicating molecules. The work of Watson and Crick and others has shown that proteins are formed according to the instructions coded in DNA. But there is a hitch. DNA cannot do its work, including forming more DNA, without the help of catalytic proteins, or enzymes. In short, proteins cannot form without DNA, but neither can DNA form without proteins. To those pondering the origin of life, it is a classic chicken-and-egg problem: Which came first, proteins or DNA?" (Horgan, John [science writer], "In The Beginning...," Scientific American, Vol. 264, No. 2, February 1991, pp.100-109, p.103)"[8]
Philosophical Presuppositions and Origin of Life Scenarios
Noted physicist and bioinformatician Hubert Yockey, who worked under Robert Oppenheimer on the Manhatten Project wrote the following regarding the crucial role the philosophical presuppositions play in the origin of life issue:
| “ | Faith in the infallible and comprehensive doctrines of dialectic materialism plays a crucial role in origin of life scenarios, and especially in exobiology and its ultimate consequence the doctrine of advanced extra-terrestrial civilization. That life must exist somewhere in the solar system on ‘suitable planets elsewhere’ is widely and tenaciously believed in spite of lack of evidence or even abundant evidence to the contrary.[9] | ” |
Yockey's statement regarding the philosophical presuppositions playing a crucial role in origin of life scenarios can be seen in regards to Sir Francis Crick the Nobel Prize winning biologist who was the British co-discoverer of the structure of DNA. Crick has described himself as an agnostic with "a strong inclination towards atheism."[10] In 1973, Francis Crick and the chemist Leslie Orgel published an article in the International Journal of Solar System Studies (Icarus) which posited that life may have arrived on earth by a process they called "Directed Panspermia".[11] The abstract for the aforemention Icarus article states that Directed Pamspermia is a "theory that organisms were deliberately transmitted to the earth by intelligent beings on another planet."[12]
In 1992, the popular magazine Scientific American published an interview which explored Crick's belief in the hypothesis Directed Panspermia.[13] American biochemist and intelligent design advocate Michael Behe wrote regarding the interview the following: "The primary reason Crick subscribes to this unorthodox view is that he judges the undirected origin of life to be a virtually insurmountable obstacle, but he wants a naturalistic explanation."[14]
The young earth creationist organization Creation Ministries International goes farther in in its criticism of the hypothesis Directed Panpspermia and wrote that "Crick’s atheistic faith leads to absurd pseudoscience".[15] Creation Ministries International further stated:
| “ | Although he tried to solve the problem of the source of intelligence for the creation of DNA without God, Crick only succeeded in pushing the problem into outer space where...it cannot be tested. After all, if such alleged aliens, in turn, were not created by a greater intelligence than themselves, then how did they evolve from non-living chemicals in the first place?[16] | ” |
Creationism Views
Creationist hold that God supernaturally created the various animals and plants on earth and naturalistic explanations are implausible. Creationist scientists offer numerous arguments on why naturalistic explanations of the origin of life are inadequate.[17] [18]
References
- ↑ http://www.creationresearch.org/crsq/articles/36/36_4/abiogenesis.html
- ↑ http://books.google.com/books?id=caGCTtPi-aMC&pg=PA107&lpg=PA107&dq=mood+and+conference+and+origin+and+life+and+bradley+and+grim&source=web&ots=iyVq9fDDDR&sig=ub92i66wAgY0UslPEM1WLlxSl9M
- ↑ http://books.google.com/books?id=caGCTtPi-aMC&pg=PA107&lpg=PA107&dq=mood+and+conference+and+origin+and+life+and+bradley+and+grim&source=web&ots=iyVq9fDDDR&sig=ub92i66wAgY0UslPEM1WLlxSl9M
- ↑ http://members.iinet.net.au/~sejones/orignl01.html#orgnflfmjrprblmschcknndgg
- ↑ http://books.google.com/books?id=caGCTtPi-aMC&pg=PA107&lpg=PA107&dq=mood+and+conference+and+origin+and+life+and+bradley+and+grim&source=web&ots=iyVq9fDDDR&sig=ub92i66wAgY0UslPEM1WLlxSl9M#PPA107,M1
- ↑ http://www.creationresearch.org/crsq/articles/36/36_4/abiogenesis.html
- ↑ http://members.iinet.net.au/~sejones/orignl02.html#orgnflfscntfcthrsnvblscntfcthrsnthrgnflfllthrsndxprmntsthrndnstlmtrncnfssnfgnrnc
- ↑ http://members.iinet.net.au/~sejones/orignl01.html#orgnflfmjrprblmschcknndgg
- ↑ http://www.genesispark.org/genpark/spongen/spongen.htm Reprint of an Creation Research Quarterly September 2001 article The Spontaneous Generation Hypothesis by David P. Woetzel
- ↑ Francis Crick, What Mad Pursuit: a Personal View of Scientific Discovery, Basic Books reprint edition, 1990, ISBN 0-465-09138-5, p. 145.
- ↑ http://www.spacedaily.com/news/life-04zzz.html
- ↑ http://www.spacedaily.com/news/life-04zzz.html
- ↑ http://www.genesispark.org/genpark/spongen/spongen.htm Reprint of an Creation Research Quarterly September 2001 article The Spontaneous Generation Hypothesis by David P. Woetzel
- ↑ http://www.genesispark.org/genpark/spongen/spongen.htm Reprint of an Creation Research Quarterly September 2001 article The Spontaneous Generation Hypothesis by David P. Woetzel
- ↑ http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/125
- ↑ http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/125
- ↑ http://www.answersingenesis.org/home/area/faq/origin.asp
- ↑ http://books.google.com/books?id=caGCTtPi-aMC&pg=PA107&lpg=PA107&dq=mood+and+conference+and+origin+and+life+and+bradley+and+grim&source=web&ots=iyVq9fDDDR&sig=ub92i66wAgY0UslPEM1WLlxSl9M