Difference between revisions of "Wikipedia copyright"
(remove statement that Conservapedia's terms allow for teaching and non-profit use; please cite specific language in Conservapedia:Copyrights that indicates this) |
(rewrite paragraph to clarify misunderstanding about CP changes vs. WP changes; CP's policy can change to remove rights already given in license; WP's merely gives another option for reusers) |
||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
As with [[Conservapedia]]'s terms, no special exceptions are made for teaching or other non-profit uses, but in both cases the [[fair use]] provisions of [[copyright law]] apply. | As with [[Conservapedia]]'s terms, no special exceptions are made for teaching or other non-profit uses, but in both cases the [[fair use]] provisions of [[copyright law]] apply. | ||
| − | + | [[Conservapedia]]'s copyright conditions are generally less restrictive and easier-to-use than Wikipedia's. However, Conservapedia's license to reuse content may be revoked "in very rare instances of self-defense" or changed to remove rights already given or add new rights, although Conservapedia's license has not changed since 2007.<ref>The Conservapedia copyright policy has not changed since July 2007, but the terms still expressly provide that the license is subject to change.</ref> On the other hand, Wikipedia's copyright license is irrevocable, but content may be additionally licensed under future licenses, that reusers may alternatively choose to follow.<ref>For example, contributions prior to June 15, 2009, were licensed under the GFDL version 1.2 or later. GFDL version 1.3 allows for reusers of Wikipedia content to relicense it under CC-BY-SA 3.0 or later. Thus, contributions prior to June 15, 2009 are available under both the GFDL and CC-BY-SA, and reusers can comply with the license terms of either.</ref> Conservapedia's copyright conditions also currently do not allow for entire sections of the site to be copied or mirrored, unlike CC-BY-SA 3.0. For details, see [[Conservapedia:Copyright]]. | |
| − | |||
| − | Conservapedia's copyright conditions do not allow for | ||
== References == | == References == | ||
Revision as of 20:15, April 22, 2012
Wikipedia uses a burdensome and complex system of copyrights, including statements like "any page which does not incorporate text that is exclusively available under the CC-BY-SA (Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike) license or a CC-BY-SA-compatible license is also available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License" (GFDL).[1] Wikipedia uses a byzantine system of rules -- as one might expect from its predominantly liberal editors. Authors always remain free to copy their own work, but cannot copy the contributions of others unless they comply fully with the requirements of CC-BY-SA.[2]
The basic requirements of the Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike license are the following:
- The work must attribute the authors in a specified manner (but not in a way that suggests endorsement)
- If the work is "alter[ed], transform[ed], or [built] upon," it must be distributed under "the same or similar license"[3]
A lengthier, 3000-word legal document describes the terms of the license in more detail.[4]
As with Conservapedia's terms, no special exceptions are made for teaching or other non-profit uses, but in both cases the fair use provisions of copyright law apply.
Conservapedia's copyright conditions are generally less restrictive and easier-to-use than Wikipedia's. However, Conservapedia's license to reuse content may be revoked "in very rare instances of self-defense" or changed to remove rights already given or add new rights, although Conservapedia's license has not changed since 2007.[5] On the other hand, Wikipedia's copyright license is irrevocable, but content may be additionally licensed under future licenses, that reusers may alternatively choose to follow.[6] Conservapedia's copyright conditions also currently do not allow for entire sections of the site to be copied or mirrored, unlike CC-BY-SA 3.0. For details, see Conservapedia:Copyright.
References
- ↑ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Reusing_Wikipedia_content
- ↑ For articles with no edits after 2009, anyone who wishes to reuse Wikipedia content may instead follow the terms of the GFDL.
- ↑ Creative Commons ShareAlike License Deed
- ↑ The Legal Code for CC-BY-SA-3.0
- ↑ The Conservapedia copyright policy has not changed since July 2007, but the terms still expressly provide that the license is subject to change.
- ↑ For example, contributions prior to June 15, 2009, were licensed under the GFDL version 1.2 or later. GFDL version 1.3 allows for reusers of Wikipedia content to relicense it under CC-BY-SA 3.0 or later. Thus, contributions prior to June 15, 2009 are available under both the GFDL and CC-BY-SA, and reusers can comply with the license terms of either.