Difference between revisions of "Circular reasoning"

From Conservapedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
(An example of flawed circular reasoning is to rely entirely on carbon dating to determine whether the Shroud of Turin is miraculous, as a miraculous imprint could have altered ordinary decay of the material.)
 
(54 intermediate revisions by 31 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
[[Image:X_mark.jpg|200px|right]]
+
'''Circular reasoning''' is a form of [[Logical fallacy#Proof by assertion|proof by assertion]], often used by [[Atheist]]s and [[evolutionist]]s in which one uses a [[conclusion]] of an argument as a [[premise]] to that same argument, that is, ending where it began. This is also known as ''petitio principii'' or ''begging the question.'' It is considered invalid and therefore is not permitted by the rules of [[formal logic]]. Nevertheless, circular reasoning is the current trend in [[science]] or rather [[postmodern science]], respectively, when new discoveries are interpreted within the prevailing paradigms so as to appear to bolster it, especially by using the popular media.<ref name="DismantlingBB">{{cite book|author=Alex Williams, John Hartnett|title=Dismantling the Big Bang|publisher=Master Books|location=Green Forest, AR, USA|year=2005|page=101|pages=269|isbn=978-0-89051-437-5|url=https://books.google.com/books?id=FR7basoxkSwC&printsec=frontcover&dq=hartnett+dismantling+the+big+bang&hl=en&sa=X&ei=JvNwT_6nJJOP4gTP6fG_Ag&sqi=2&ved=0CC4Q6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=hartnett%20dismantling%20the%20big%20bang&f=false}}</ref> 
−
 
 
−
: ''Adapted from an article in [[CreationWiki]], which is under GNU Free Documentation License''--[[User:TerryH|TerryH]] 23:51, 5 March 2007 (EST)
 
−
 
 
−
[[Circular reasoning]] is a form of [[logical fallacy]] in which one assumes the fact that one is trying to prove.
 
  
 +
An example of flawed circular reasoning is to rely entirely on [[carbon dating]] to determine whether the [[Shroud of Turin]] is miraculous, as a miraculous imprint could have altered ordinary decay of the material.
 
== An analysis ==
 
== An analysis ==
−
Usually, if one is trying to prove something, one must start with something else already accepted as valid. Thus the simplest argument would use the Law of Detachment and run this way:
+
The simplest argument is a single inference, as per the Law of Detachment:
  
 
*If P, then Q.
 
*If P, then Q.
Line 12: Line 9:
 
*Therefore, Q.
 
*Therefore, Q.
  
−
For a slightly more complex example, one uses the Law of the Syllogism to establish an ''intermediate'' fact between the already-accepted fact and the fact one wishes to prove. Thus:
+
The Law of the Syllogism uses Detachment to establish an ''intermediate'' conclusion between the original premise and the eventual conclusion. Thus:
  
 
*If P, then Q.
 
*If P, then Q.
Line 20: Line 17:
 
*Therefore, Q and R.
 
*Therefore, Q and R.
  
−
Finally, one can use ''contraposition'' to prove that a thing is ''not'' true:
+
''Contraposition'' uses Detachment in reverse to show that a thing is ''not'' true:
  
 
*If P, then Q.
 
*If P, then Q.
Line 26: Line 23:
 
*Therefore, not P.
 
*Therefore, not P.
  
−
Notice that all these proofs ''must'' start with a proposition already verified or denied.
+
All these proofs start with a proposition already verified or denied.
  
−
Now examine this line of reasoning:
+
This is the classic structure of circular reasoning, that is an abuse of the Law of the Syllogism:
  
 
*If P, then Q.
 
*If P, then Q.
Line 38: Line 35:
 
*Therefore, P.
 
*Therefore, P.
  
−
Each of these three conditional statements might be part of a valid argument if one uses it alone. But when one uses them all together, and then tries to assert P, one finds that ''the assertion is a necessary step in the proof.'' The line of reasoning is thus not a line at all, but a ''circle.'' One might as well assert "P; therefore P" and expect that to stand--and thus commit the related fallacy of ''proof by assertion.''
+
Each of these three conditional statements would be valid by itself. Together, they create a flawed argument, because P now depends on itself to be true. The line of reasoning ends where it began, and is thus a circle. The only difference between this and ''proof by assertion'' is that the latter attempts to use a single conditional statement--"if P, then P"—while circular reasoning uses at least two, and typically three or more, syllogisms.
 +
 
 +
Circular arguments can be very difficult to detect. Circular arguments found in the professional literature, or in [[propaganda]], typically use five or six (or more) syllogisms.
  
−
For this reason, every logical system ''must'' begin with a set of generally accepted assumptions called ''postulates'' or ''axioms'' (from the Greek '''αξιος''' or ''axios'' worthy or deserving). (Similarly, any set of definitions must start with a set of fundamental terms that need no definition.) But an axiom, by definition, must be a fundamental property of nature ''upon which all reasonable people can agree.'' To attempt to ''prove'' an axiom by asserting a condition that depends upon it, is unavailing and unacceptable.
+
Every logical system ''must'' begin with a set of generally accepted assumptions called ''postulates'' or ''axioms'' (from the [[Greek]] '''αξιος''' or ''axios'' worthy or deserving). Similarly, any set of definitions must start with a set of fundamental terms that need no definition. An axiom is usually a fundamental property of nature upon which all agree. Persons attempting to show that something is a fundamental property of nature when it is not, or a value of that property that is contrary to fact, typically use circular reasoning to make such an attempt.
 +
==Begging the question==
 +
'''Begging the question''' is a form of circular reasoning in which a claim is automatically assumed to be true without evidence other than the statement or claim itself.  The phrase is commonly confused with "raising the question," an error that has gained traction through incorrect popular usage.<ref>http://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-beg1.htm</ref>
  
−
== An example ==
+
==Examples==
−
<table style="border:1px solid #AAAAAA; background: #EDF1F1; float:right; width:100px; margin-left:15px;">
+
*Atheists use circular logic to "disprove" the existence of [[God]].  That is, they presuppose that God does not exist and then argue that all proofs for the existence of God must be flawed because He does not exist.  Christians can use [[presuppositional apologetics]] to break the circle of the atheists' circular reasoning.
−
<tr><td>{{fallacy|circular reasoning}}
+
*[[Muslim]]s also use circular logic to defend the [[Qur'an]].  They argue that the Qur'an is true because it is the Word of [[Allah]], that it is the Word of Allah because it says so, and that we can rely on it because it is true.
−
<tr><td>Use the <nowiki>{{fallacy|circular reasoning}}</nowiki> template to insert the above warning on a page containing an example of ''[[circular reasoning]]''. The warning label will then link back to this page.
+
*[[Mormon]]s and certain [[Protestantism|Protestants]] use circular reasoning to prove that a [[Great Apostasy]] occurred early in Christianity, based on the assertion that their own doctrines represent [[Early Christianity|New Testament Christianity]] and that [[Catholic Church|Catholicism]] and [[Orthodox Church|Orthodoxy]] are clearly [[Apostasy|apostate]], from the fact that Catholic and Orthodox doctrines are evident in the writings of the [[Apostolic Fathers|Apostolic]] and [[Ante-Nicene Fathers]] before A.D. 325 and so clearly refute the doctrinal claims of Mormons and Protestants against Catholicism. See [[Memory hole]] and [[Revisionism]].
−
</table>
+
*"If such actions were not illegal, then they would not be prohibited by the law."
  
−
Circular reasoning would include using any [[science|scientific]] model that assumed a particular fact of nature in order to infer that fact later on. The classic example of this is the use of [[carbon-14 dating]] to infer a great age for the earth. According to this model, cosmic rays strike atoms of nitrogen (specifically, <sup>14</sup>N) and convert them to <sup>14</sup>C. This <sup>14</sup>C then combines with oxygen in the air to form radioactive carbon dioxide. Plants take this up and form radioactive [[glucose]], and animals that consume these plants consume the sugars and thus take in <sup>14</sup>C into their bodily systems. As long as the animals are alive, the <sup>14</sup>C in their systems is in dynamic equilibrium with the level of <sup>14</sup>C in the atmosphere. When they die, the <sup>14</sup>C begins to decay and is no longer subject to replacement. Thus, by knowing the level of <sup>14</sup>C in the atmosphere and comparing it to the level of <sup>14</sup>C in the animal's remains, one can determine how long ago the animal died.
+
*Person 1:"He is very ugly."
 +
:Person 2: Why do you say that?"
 +
:Person 1: "Because he is so unattractive."
  
−
The problem is that ''the model assumes that the level of <sup>14</sup>C in the atmosphere is itself in dynamic equilibrium.'' That in turn requires the earth to be very old. If the earth is ''young,'' then the level of <sup>14</sup>C would ''not'' have been at equilibrium in the earliest years of the earth (and still might not be), and thus all computed "ages" for organic fossils would be exaggerated, some greatly.
+
==See also==
 +
*[[No true Scotsman]], a specific example of circular reasoning
 +
== References ==
 +
<references/>
  
−
== See Also ==
+
== External links ==
−
* [[Logical fallacy]]
+
* [http://creationwiki.org/Circular_reasoning Circular reasoning] by [[CreationWiki]]
  
−
[[Category:Philosophy]]
+
[[Category:Logical Fallacies]]
−
[[Category:Logical fallacy]]
+
[[Category:Liberal Traits]]

Latest revision as of 17:47, July 27, 2023

Circular reasoning is a form of proof by assertion, often used by Atheists and evolutionists in which one uses a conclusion of an argument as a premise to that same argument, that is, ending where it began. This is also known as petitio principii or begging the question. It is considered invalid and therefore is not permitted by the rules of formal logic. Nevertheless, circular reasoning is the current trend in science or rather postmodern science, respectively, when new discoveries are interpreted within the prevailing paradigms so as to appear to bolster it, especially by using the popular media.[1]

An example of flawed circular reasoning is to rely entirely on carbon dating to determine whether the Shroud of Turin is miraculous, as a miraculous imprint could have altered ordinary decay of the material.

An analysis

The simplest argument is a single inference, as per the Law of Detachment:

  • If P, then Q.
  • P.
  • Therefore, Q.

The Law of the Syllogism uses Detachment to establish an intermediate conclusion between the original premise and the eventual conclusion. Thus:

  • If P, then Q.
  • If Q, then R.
  • Therefore, if P, then R.
  • P.
  • Therefore, Q and R.

Contraposition uses Detachment in reverse to show that a thing is not true:

  • If P, then Q.
  • Not Q.
  • Therefore, not P.

All these proofs start with a proposition already verified or denied.

This is the classic structure of circular reasoning, that is an abuse of the Law of the Syllogism:

  • If P, then Q.
  • If Q, then R.
  • If R, then P.
  • P.
  • Therefore, Q.
  • Therefore, R.
  • Therefore, P.

Each of these three conditional statements would be valid by itself. Together, they create a flawed argument, because P now depends on itself to be true. The line of reasoning ends where it began, and is thus a circle. The only difference between this and proof by assertion is that the latter attempts to use a single conditional statement--"if P, then P"—while circular reasoning uses at least two, and typically three or more, syllogisms.

Circular arguments can be very difficult to detect. Circular arguments found in the professional literature, or in propaganda, typically use five or six (or more) syllogisms.

Every logical system must begin with a set of generally accepted assumptions called postulates or axioms (from the Greek αξιος or axios worthy or deserving). Similarly, any set of definitions must start with a set of fundamental terms that need no definition. An axiom is usually a fundamental property of nature upon which all agree. Persons attempting to show that something is a fundamental property of nature when it is not, or a value of that property that is contrary to fact, typically use circular reasoning to make such an attempt.

Begging the question

Begging the question is a form of circular reasoning in which a claim is automatically assumed to be true without evidence other than the statement or claim itself. The phrase is commonly confused with "raising the question," an error that has gained traction through incorrect popular usage.[2]

Examples

  • Atheists use circular logic to "disprove" the existence of God. That is, they presuppose that God does not exist and then argue that all proofs for the existence of God must be flawed because He does not exist. Christians can use presuppositional apologetics to break the circle of the atheists' circular reasoning.
  • Muslims also use circular logic to defend the Qur'an. They argue that the Qur'an is true because it is the Word of Allah, that it is the Word of Allah because it says so, and that we can rely on it because it is true.
  • Mormons and certain Protestants use circular reasoning to prove that a Great Apostasy occurred early in Christianity, based on the assertion that their own doctrines represent New Testament Christianity and that Catholicism and Orthodoxy are clearly apostate, from the fact that Catholic and Orthodox doctrines are evident in the writings of the Apostolic and Ante-Nicene Fathers before A.D. 325 and so clearly refute the doctrinal claims of Mormons and Protestants against Catholicism. See Memory hole and Revisionism.
  • "If such actions were not illegal, then they would not be prohibited by the law."
  • Person 1:"He is very ugly."
Person 2: Why do you say that?"
Person 1: "Because he is so unattractive."

See also

References

  1. ↑ Alex Williams, John Hartnett (2005). Dismantling the Big Bang. Green Forest, AR, USA: Master Books, 269. ISBN 978-0-89051-437-5. 
  2. ↑ http://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-beg1.htm

External links