Difference between revisions of "Logical fallacy"
(→Proof by authority: well then) |
|||
| Line 22: | Line 22: | ||
====Proof by authority==== | ====Proof by authority==== | ||
| − | An argument which is based on a person's authority, rather than on the merits of the authority's position. | + | An argument which is based on a person's authority, rather than on the merits of the authority's position. Note that an argument from authority can be valid when the authority is a relevant source who has access to more information about the topic than the people discussing it. Classic example from authority is to refer to a celebrity or religious leader for their opinion on a scientific issue. |
====Proof by assertion==== | ====Proof by assertion==== | ||
Revision as of 04:38, March 6, 2007
- This article is adapted from an article on CreationWiki. The content is under the GNU Free Documentation License.--TerryH 23:31, 5 March 2007 (EST)
A Logical fallacy is an argument which violates the laws of logic.
Some Fallacies
| Template:Fallacy |
| Use the {{fallacy|type}} template to insert the above warning on a page containing a logical fallacy. Replace the word "type" with the name of the fallacy to link the warning label to the appropriate page. |
Ad hominem
(Latin: "To the Man"); An argument which attacks people holding a contrary view, rather than attacking their view. Name-calling is a particularly crude form of this fallacy.
Overgeneralization
An argument which makes a statement so broad as to be ridiculous.
Non sequitur
- Main Article: Non sequitur
(Latin: "It does not follow"); An argument which moves from a premise to a conclusion where no connection exists between the two.
Proof by authority
An argument which is based on a person's authority, rather than on the merits of the authority's position. Note that an argument from authority can be valid when the authority is a relevant source who has access to more information about the topic than the people discussing it. Classic example from authority is to refer to a celebrity or religious leader for their opinion on a scientific issue.
Proof by assertion
An argument which simply states something as true without evidence or argument to support it.
Circular reasoning
Circular reasoning is any attempt to prove something by first asserting it and then trying to "prove" it through any number of intervening conditional statements.
Proving too much
The use of a classification which includes too many things in the classification.
Double standard
The unequal use of a criterion, by applying it differently in different cases.
Your theory does not work under my theory, so your theory must be wrong
A theory is judged by the premises and assumptions of another theory, rather than being judged against its own premises and assumptions.
Manufacturing facts from a theory
- Main article: Manufacturing facts from a theory
An undemonstrated, unobserved idea is stated as fact because it comports with a particular theory.
Genetic fallacy
According to a leading logical fallacy website, "The Genetic Fallacy is the most general fallacy of irrelevancy involving the origins or history of an idea. It is fallacious to either endorse or condemn an idea based on its past—rather than on its present—merits or demerits, unless its past in some way affects its present value. For instance, the origin of evidence can be quite relevant to its evaluation, especially in historical investigations. The origin of testimony—whether first hand, hearsay, or rumor—carries weight in evaluating it.
In contrast, the value of many scientific ideas can be objectively evaluated by established techniques, so that the origin or history of the idea is irrelevant to its value." Genetic Fallacy on The Fallacy Files
Tautology
A tautology is a statement that is true under all circumstances, such that the statement carries no meaning.
Contradiction
A contradiction is a statement that contradicts its own terms, such that it is false by logical necessity.
Conflation
Conflation is the logical fallacy of treating two distinct concepts as if they were one.
Infinite regression
An infinite regression results when one asserts that a given event caused another, and yet that first event requires another, identical event, to cause it. The "cyclic universe" model of the origin of the universe is an example of an infinite regression--for what shall we say caused the first among a never-ending series of explosions?
Loaded question
- Main Article: Loaded question
A loaded question is a question that assumes facts not in evidence, with the intent of trapping the other person into admitting those facts.
Special pleading
- Main Article: Special pleading
Special pleading means applying to other people a set of standards that one is not willing to apply to oneself, without offering any reasonable grounds for claiming such exemption. Jesus Christ, of course, had a word for this sort of behavior: hypocrisy.