Difference between revisions of "Homology"

From Conservapedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
m (→‎External links: HTTP --> HTTPS [#1], replaced: http://www.youtube.com → https://www.youtube.com)
 
(33 intermediate revisions by 9 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
== Creationist Scientist View ==
+
[[File:Gegenbaur 1870 hand homology.png|thumb|Homology of the hand to forelimbs]]
−
Creationist scientist assert the the following: the homology argument is not a legitimate argument for the [[Theory of evolution|evolutionary view]]; the homology argument has problems;  and homolgy is best explained by creation according to a common plan. <ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/home/area/cfol/ch1-homology.asp</ref><ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/creation/v14/i2/homology.asp</ref><ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/tj/v15/i1/homology.asp</ref><ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/creation/v14/i2/evolution.asp</ref>
+
'''Homology''' involves the theory that [[macroevolution]]ary relationships can be demonstrated by the similarity in the anatomy and physiology of different animals.<ref name="Bergman">Bergman, 2001</ref>
  
−
[[Chistian apologetics|Christian apologist]] [[JP Holding]] wrote regarding the homology argument:
+
== Invalidity of the Homology Argument ==
 +
Creation scientists claim that similarity can just as readily be explained by a common Designer as common ancestry, and that homology is therefore not evidence that can be used to support the [[Theory of evolution|evolutionary view]].<ref name="Bergman" /><ref>Parker</ref><ref>Anon., 1992</ref>
  
−
"Rather, the suggestion of a ‘biotic message’ is quite accurate. Homologous structures, far from pointing away from a designer of infinite wisdom, would have indicated to readers of the Bible in their time a designer who did indeed possess infinite wisdom and mastery over His creation. It is only because modern persons have arbitrarily decided that a certain degree of what they see as ‘originality’ is a proper means value that the evolutionists’ argument carries any apparent force.
+
Consequently, the widely cited chimp/human [[DNA]] homology argument is also invalid.<ref>Batten, 1996</ref><ref>Purdom, 2006</ref><ref>Sarfati</ref>
  
−
Something Old, Nothing New
+
Furthermore, they argue that the evidence of ''against'' the evolutionary view. For example, you would expect that similarity due to common ancestry would be controlled by similar genes passed down from ancestors to descendants.  Yet there are many examples where similar (homologous) structures are controlled by ''different'' genes.<ref>Kofahl, 1992</ref>
−
To frame our argument against the evolutionists’ misuse of homologous structures requires us to have an understanding of certain values critical to ancient persons. Roman literature of the New Testament period tells us that ‘(t)he primary test of truth in religious matters was custom and tradition, the practices of the ancients.’3 In other words, old was good, and innovation was bad. Change or novelty was ‘a means value which serves to innovate or subvert core and secondary values.’" <ref>http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/4781</ref>
 
  
 +
In addition, creationists argue that similarity is not just explainable by creation, but predicted.  [[Christian apologetics|Christian apologist]] [[JP Holding]] explains:
 +
{{cquote|Homologous structures, far from pointing away from a designer of infinite wisdom, would have indicated to readers of the Bible in their time a designer who did indeed possess infinite wisdom and mastery over His creation. It is only because modern persons have arbitrarily decided that a certain degree of what they see as ‘originality’ is a proper means value that the evolutionists’ argument carries any apparent force.
  
 +
To frame our argument against the evolutionists’ misuse of homologous structures requires us to have an understanding of certain values critical to ancient persons. Roman literature of the New Testament period tells us that ‘(t)he primary test of truth in religious matters was custom and tradition, the practices of the ancients.’ In other words, old was good, and innovation was bad. Change or novelty was ‘a means value which serves to innovate or subvert core and secondary values.’
  
 +
By itself, this demolishes one part of the evolutionists’ argument and makes it, clearly, a case of arbitrary imposition of modern values. In a context such as the above, ‘radically different design’ would have indicated to an ancient reader either no deity, or else a deity whose means was chaos and instability, or a deity who did not have mastery over creation.<ref>Holding, 2006</ref>}}
  
 +
== Bibliography ==
 +
* Anon., [http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/5154 Similarities don’t prove evolution], ''Creation'' 14(2):30–31, March 1992.
 +
* Batten, Don, [http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/622/ Human/chimp DNA similarity], ''Creation'' 19(1):21–22, December 1996.
 +
* Bergman, Jerry, [http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/1818 Does homology provide evidence of evolutionary naturalism?], ''Journal of Creation'', 15(1):26–33, April 2001.
 +
* Holding, James Patrick, [http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/4781 ‘Not to Be Used Again’: Homologous Structures and the Presumption of Originality as a Critical Value], Creation Ministries International, 29 November 2006.
 +
* Kofahl, Robert E., [http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/1926/ A serious problem for homology], ''Creation'' 14(2):31, March 1992.
 +
* Parker, Gary, [http://www.answersingenesis.org/home/area/cfol/ch1-homology.asp Comparative similarities: homology] (chapter 1 of Creation: The Facts of Life).
 +
* Purdom, Georgia,  [http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/am/v1/n2/human-and-chimp-dna If human and chimp DNA are so similar, why are there so many physical and mental differences between them?] ''Answers'', 1(1):64, 5 September 2006.
 +
* Sarfati, Jonathan, [http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/3835 Humans: images of God or advanced apes?] (Chapter 6 of Refuting Evolution).
  
−
== Scientific View ==
+
==References==
−
 
+
{{Reflist}}
−
Biologists have noted that many (apparently unrelated) species of animals share common characteristics:
 
−
 
 
−
*[[Dolphin]]s, oceanic [[shark]]s, [[tuna]] fish, and the extinct [[ichthyosaur]]s, which all share a streamlined fishlike form, for their swift swimming predatory lifestyle. Tuna, ichthyosaurs, and certain oceanic sharks even have elevated body temperatures, just like the warm-blooded dolphin, supposedly to facilitate their high levels of activity, even though fish and reptiles are otherwise almost entirely cold-blooded.
 
−
 
 
−
*[[Hedgehog]]s, [[echidna]]s and certain types of Madagascan [[tenrec]]s - though widely separated geographically, all have a coat of protective spines and a prehensile snout ideal for snuffling for invertebrates.
 
−
 
 
−
*[[Penguin]]s of the Southern hemisphere and [[auk]]s of the Northern hemisphere both live by chasing fish underwater, using their short stubby wings to fly beneath the waves.
 
−
 
 
−
*The eye of an [[octopus]] and [[human]] - both contain a retina, a cornea, an iris, a lens and are fluid filled.  Some differences do exist - the photo receptors in the human are 'backwards' - catching light reflected off the back of the retina.  Additionally, the eye of an octopus is a modification of the skin, while the eye of a human is an extension of the brain.<ref>[http://www.daviddarling.info/encyclopedia/O/octopus_eye.html octopus eye]</ref><ref>[http://www.genome.org/cgi/content/full/14/8/1555 Comparative Analysis of Gene Expression for Convergent Evolution of Camera Eye Between Octopus and Human]</ref>
 
−
 
 
−
[[Darwin]] found evidence for [[Evolution through natural selection|his theory]] in examples of "convergent evolution", when (as he surmised) the same "adaptations" have "evolved independently" in different lineages of species under similar [[selection pressure]]s. <ref>[http://www.newscientist.com/channel/life/evolution/dn9953 Instant Expert: Evolution]</ref>
 
  
−
==References==
+
==External links==
−
<references/>
+
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6P6bXA50c0&feature=related Neo-Darwinism's Homology Problem - Video Clip]
  
 
[[Category:Biology]]
 
[[Category:Biology]]
 +
[[Category:Science]]

Latest revision as of 17:29, September 26, 2018

Homology of the hand to forelimbs

Homology involves the theory that macroevolutionary relationships can be demonstrated by the similarity in the anatomy and physiology of different animals.[1]

Invalidity of the Homology Argument

Creation scientists claim that similarity can just as readily be explained by a common Designer as common ancestry, and that homology is therefore not evidence that can be used to support the evolutionary view.[1][2][3]

Consequently, the widely cited chimp/human DNA homology argument is also invalid.[4][5][6]

Furthermore, they argue that the evidence of against the evolutionary view. For example, you would expect that similarity due to common ancestry would be controlled by similar genes passed down from ancestors to descendants. Yet there are many examples where similar (homologous) structures are controlled by different genes.[7]

In addition, creationists argue that similarity is not just explainable by creation, but predicted. Christian apologist JP Holding explains:

“ Homologous structures, far from pointing away from a designer of infinite wisdom, would have indicated to readers of the Bible in their time a designer who did indeed possess infinite wisdom and mastery over His creation. It is only because modern persons have arbitrarily decided that a certain degree of what they see as ‘originality’ is a proper means value that the evolutionists’ argument carries any apparent force.

To frame our argument against the evolutionists’ misuse of homologous structures requires us to have an understanding of certain values critical to ancient persons. Roman literature of the New Testament period tells us that ‘(t)he primary test of truth in religious matters was custom and tradition, the practices of the ancients.’ In other words, old was good, and innovation was bad. Change or novelty was ‘a means value which serves to innovate or subvert core and secondary values.’

By itself, this demolishes one part of the evolutionists’ argument and makes it, clearly, a case of arbitrary imposition of modern values. In a context such as the above, ‘radically different design’ would have indicated to an ancient reader either no deity, or else a deity whose means was chaos and instability, or a deity who did not have mastery over creation.[8]

”

Bibliography

References

  1. ↑ 1.0 1.1 Bergman, 2001
  2. ↑ Parker
  3. ↑ Anon., 1992
  4. ↑ Batten, 1996
  5. ↑ Purdom, 2006
  6. ↑ Sarfati
  7. ↑ Kofahl, 1992
  8. ↑ Holding, 2006

External links