Conservapedia - User contributions [en]

User talk:Fallandtrip

2024-06-14T20:37:04Z

Fallandtrip: Blanked the page

User talk:Fallandtrip

2024-02-20T02:16:16Z

Fallandtrip:

Came to mind to promote something like a group chat mechanism for groups of users to share ideas with a degree of privacy. Can of worms maybe.

Data: C40 Cities Agenda Ambitions

2024-02-14T15:04:28Z

Fallandtrip:

== Ambitions ==

* ''Comments''
** Emphases added
** ''Information may or may not be conclusive, hence the title prefix 'Data': use at own risk, for example Livestock section is draft''

=== Land use : Make changes to land use bylaws, --make it impossible to be self sufficient. ===
* Ontario, NWT too. It's everywhere. The C40 cities, Global Covenant of Mayors (WEF municipal level group), among other groups are making changes to land use bylaws to make it impossible to be self sufficient. It's the push to get people into the smart cities/give govt control. https://x.com/DeaMille17/status/1661030683752665089?s=20
* We @C40cities @WRIRossCities @ICLEI and @WBG_Cities are excited to hold the inaugural #theGPSC City Academy in Singapore at where 10 cities are gathered to learn about the integration of '''land''' '''use''', transport and climate action planning.. https://x.com/AndreaF_C40/status/1066878725122215936?s=20
* ''more data, search c40 (land use OR bylaws ) [https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top https://twitter.com/search?]''[https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top]

=== Wetlands ===
* "...most significant aspects of urban life and municipal management that wetlands improve and contribute towards.." https://citieswithnature.org/the-value-of-wetlands-for-cities/
* "..As we celebrate #WorldWetlandsDay on 2 February, let’s dive into why wetlands are important, especially when it comes to cities and urban spaces..." https://x.com/c40cities/status/1752972516799430774?s=20

=== Pets, Livestock -- Farm animal Restrictions, Removal ===

* Pets
** " ..are we doing the right thing ..?", 2016 book listing for 'Run Spot Run', https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/R/bo19416930.html
** ".. The case against pets: is it time to give up our cats and dogs? A growing number of people argue that owning pets is unethical - and that animals can never really have a good life in a human home.." 2023 https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/sep/13/the-case-against-pets-is-it-time-to-give-up-our-cats-and-dogs
** "Should we stop keeping pets? Why more and more ethicists say yes. Ninety per cent of Britons think of their pet as part of the family – 16% even included them on the last census. But recent research into animals’ emotional lives has cast doubt on the ethics of petkeeping.." 2017 https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2017/aug/01/should-we-stop-keeping-pets-why-more-and-more-ethicists-say-yes
** "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20

horses (farm), chickens, ..

* horses , Newfoundland Pony
** “The Town’s regulations have serious consequences for the survival of the Newfoundland Pony in municipalities across the Province,” said an emailed statement from the Newfoundland Pony Society, an organization started in 1979 and is responsible for preserving and protecting the Newfoundland Pony breed. , May 2023 https://www.saltwire.com/atlantic-canada/news/im-not-getting-rid-of-sparks-summerford-horse-owner-quits-council-vows-to-fight-to-keep-animal-after-town-orders-its-removal-100854501/
* chickens
** Unsorted
*** Chicken can stay as Kamloops agrees to delay animal-control bylaw Chickens can stay while city mulls plan, The Canadian Press May 14, 2014 , https://www.pentictonherald.ca/prairies/bc/article_4e596064-0862-5b2f-8ec4-1ad3b8fc626f.html
** Alberta: 2012 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/calgary-chicken-activist-loses-bylaw-challenge-1.1277278 from https://x.com/Canada_RF/status/243495424000946176?s=20
** Ontario: Fined for having 3 Backyard Hens , NorthBay ontario, 2017, https://www.gofundme.com/f/fined-for-having-3-backyard-hens?utm_source=customer&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet&utm_medium=copy_link-tip
**** petition to change bylaw https://www.change.org/p/b-r-johnson-allow-back-yard-chickens-in-north-bay-ontario-change-the-by-law-may-16th-17-sign-now
**** macleans article 2017 https://macleans.ca/society/how-a-north-bay-pig-is-standing-up-for-backyard-chickens/

=== Transportation -- encumber/reduce/crash car ownership market ===

=== Clean bus declaration ===
* @C40cities '''Clean''' '''Bus''' '''Declaration''' promotes switch to low- and zero-emission buses: <nowiki>http://bit.ly/1GrTFR2</nowiki> #LPAA https://x.com/UNFCCC/status/668266677696499712?s=20
* 26 cities have signed on to @c40cities #CleanBusDeclaration to purchase only eBuses by 2025. #Shenzhen is doing them one better: By the end of 2017, it will electrify all 14,500 of its public transit buses. Dec 5, 2017 https://x.com/JuliaThayne/status/938126074927570944?s=20
* " Showing Results 1-15 of 30 for 'clean bus' " https://blog.nationalgeographic.org/?s=clean+bus+&post_type=post
* @c40cities @Glen4ONT Are any '''Ontario''' '''cities''' signatories to the '''C40''' Clean Bus Declaration? @JimWatsonOttawa https://x.com/Ghoti20/status/615665015597735936?s=20
* ''more data, search https://twitter.com/search?q=Clean%20bus%20declaration&src=typed_query&f=top''

=== Incentives to reduce, trade in and scrap car ownership ===
* Across C40 cities, #Barcelona adopted free travel for those who got rid of polluting cars, #Stockholm expanded bus services, and #London has offered discounts on car clubs, bike hire and scrappage. '''2024''' https://x.com/c40cities/status/1749795375261847745?s=20
* "..Barcelona introduced free travel for three years for those who got rid of polluting cars, Stockholm expanded bus services.." '''2024''' https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20240122-from-london-to-new-york-can-quitting-cars-be-popular

=== Ultra Low Emissions Zones (ULEZ) and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs), AMPR Cameras ===
(video) "tradesmen risk fines", "we dont want this..", "..Ultra Low Emissions Zones (ULEZ) and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs) have nothing to do with saving the planet, and everything to do with restricting your freedom of movement.." 2023, UK, 1min video, https://x.com/PaulHut91434196/status/1645385622813646848?s=20

=== Speed limit reductions ===
Wales experiment
* 20mph: Wales first UK nation to drop speed limit from 30mph 17 September https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-66774379
** ''"a Welsh government-commissioned consultation found more were against the speed limit than in support of it. One of the Labour-led government's own documents said longer journeys could cause a "substantial" economic disadvantage."''
** ''The Welsh Conservatives said they were in favour of a 20mph limit outside schools, hospitals and care homes - but called the blanket rollout "disastrous, frankly ludicrous and a war on motorists".''
** Wales has become the first country in the UK to reduce speed limits in built-up areas from 30mph to 20mph in Wales from Sunday. Welsh ministers said a 20mph (32km/h) limit would reduce deaths and noise and encourage people to walk or cycle but it has caused controversy with some drivers.
* "One road in Wales now has eight speed limit changes in less than two miles following the switch to 20mph." Making driving an unpleasant experience is a key strategy of the war on motorists, with drivers bombarded with signage and fearful of big fines. https://x.com/RichardWellings/status/1729496787482812727?s=20
** links to
Towns in Ontario Canada

* [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0738991,-77.765902,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sEvwKbz7ShW_HVFcHGvJ71w!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu Streetview], Google maps, ''Speed limit sign '40km/h' halfway up hill,'' [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0760279,-77.7555241,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s2zzAk_guuO-2qOzhVehBPA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu 2nd sign,] 2min drive down same road, ''more obvious that the density is too low for this to make sense.''

=== Closing nuclear plants ===

* Ontario closing the Pickering nuclear plant. Sheila Gunn Reid, host for Rebel News on C40 cities. Then Lex Tan, the host of “Ringside Heat” gives us a recap of the WWE SummerSlam. Claire Sommer @KayakMediaTweet https://x.com/sauga960am/status/1554561769712091137?s=20

* Trudeau's criminal eco activist QC Minister wants to shut down '''Pickering''' '''nuclear plant''' & replace it with solar panels & windmills! Elect a clown expect a circus... Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy … #cdnpoli https://x.com/rexglacer/status/1456957830892859395?s=20 links to https://www.ipolitics.ca/news/guilbeault-refuses-to-declare-his-support-of-nuclear-energy
** Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy... Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault says “it’s not up to the government to decide” which sources of energy will reduce the country’s greenhouse-gas emissions to net zero by 2050. Nor would he say explicitly whether he supports nuclear energy, which he’d opposed in his work before entering politics in 2019. As for “which forms of energy […]. Published Nov 5, 2021 at 4:13pm
** ''more data, search'' https://twitter.com/search?q=Pickering%20nuclear%20plant&src=typed_query

=== Clothing purchases ===
* The C40 Cities targets for clothing purchases by 2030. The WEF & C40 Cities have the same goals. Details in link. <nowiki>https://expose-news.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Arup-C40-The-Future-of-Urban-Consumption-in-a-1-5C-World.pdf…</nowiki> https://x.com/stan_sands/status/1729209582898307422?s=20
** WEF has published a video in which they urge people to wash clothes less because washing clothes affects climate change... video link https://x.com/sophiadahl1/status/1729022360181977325?s=20

Data: C40 Cities Agenda Ambitions

2024-02-14T14:41:42Z

Fallandtrip:

== Ambitions ==

* ''Comments''
** Emphases added
** ''Information may or may not be conclusive, hence the title prefix 'Data': use at own risk, for example Livestock section is draft''

=== Land use : Make changes to land use bylaws, --make it impossible to be self sufficient. ===
* Ontario, NWT too. It's everywhere. The C40 cities, Global Covenant of Mayors (WEF municipal level group), among other groups are making changes to land use bylaws to make it impossible to be self sufficient. It's the push to get people into the smart cities/give govt control. https://x.com/DeaMille17/status/1661030683752665089?s=20
* We @C40cities @WRIRossCities @ICLEI and @WBG_Cities are excited to hold the inaugural #theGPSC City Academy in Singapore at where 10 cities are gathered to learn about the integration of '''land''' '''use''', transport and climate action planning.. https://x.com/AndreaF_C40/status/1066878725122215936?s=20
* ''more data, search c40 (land use OR bylaws ) [https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top https://twitter.com/search?]''[https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top]

=== Wetlands ===
* "...most significant aspects of urban life and municipal management that wetlands improve and contribute towards.." https://citieswithnature.org/the-value-of-wetlands-for-cities/
* "..As we celebrate #WorldWetlandsDay on 2 February, let’s dive into why wetlands are important, especially when it comes to cities and urban spaces..." https://x.com/c40cities/status/1752972516799430774?s=20

=== Pets, Livestock -- Farm animal Restrictions, Removal ===

* Pets
** ".. The case against pets: is it time to give up our cats and dogs? A growing number of people argue that owning pets is unethical - and that animals can never really have a good life in a human home.." 2023 <nowiki>https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/sep/13/the-case-against-pets-is-it-time-to-give-up-our-cats-and-dogs</nowiki>
** "Should we stop keeping pets? Why more and more ethicists say yes. Ninety per cent of Britons think of their pet as part of the family – 16% even included them on the last census. But recent research into animals’ emotional lives has cast doubt on the ethics of petkeeping.." 2017 <nowiki>https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2017/aug/01/should-we-stop-keeping-pets-why-more-and-more-ethicists-say-yes</nowiki>
** "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, <nowiki>https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20</nowiki>

horses (farm), chickens, ..

* horses , Newfoundland Pony
** “The Town’s regulations have serious consequences for the survival of the Newfoundland Pony in municipalities across the Province,” said an emailed statement from the Newfoundland Pony Society, an organization started in 1979 and is responsible for preserving and protecting the Newfoundland Pony breed. , May 2023 https://www.saltwire.com/atlantic-canada/news/im-not-getting-rid-of-sparks-summerford-horse-owner-quits-council-vows-to-fight-to-keep-animal-after-town-orders-its-removal-100854501/
* chickens
** Unsorted
*** Chicken can stay as Kamloops agrees to delay animal-control bylaw Chickens can stay while city mulls plan, The Canadian Press May 14, 2014 , https://www.pentictonherald.ca/prairies/bc/article_4e596064-0862-5b2f-8ec4-1ad3b8fc626f.html
** Alberta: 2012 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/calgary-chicken-activist-loses-bylaw-challenge-1.1277278 from https://x.com/Canada_RF/status/243495424000946176?s=20
** Ontario: Fined for having 3 Backyard Hens , NorthBay ontario, 2017, https://www.gofundme.com/f/fined-for-having-3-backyard-hens?utm_source=customer&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet&utm_medium=copy_link-tip
**** petition to change bylaw https://www.change.org/p/b-r-johnson-allow-back-yard-chickens-in-north-bay-ontario-change-the-by-law-may-16th-17-sign-now
**** macleans article 2017 https://macleans.ca/society/how-a-north-bay-pig-is-standing-up-for-backyard-chickens/

=== Transportation -- encumber/reduce/crash car ownership market ===

=== Clean bus declaration ===
* @C40cities '''Clean''' '''Bus''' '''Declaration''' promotes switch to low- and zero-emission buses: <nowiki>http://bit.ly/1GrTFR2</nowiki> #LPAA https://x.com/UNFCCC/status/668266677696499712?s=20
* 26 cities have signed on to @c40cities #CleanBusDeclaration to purchase only eBuses by 2025. #Shenzhen is doing them one better: By the end of 2017, it will electrify all 14,500 of its public transit buses. Dec 5, 2017 https://x.com/JuliaThayne/status/938126074927570944?s=20
* " Showing Results 1-15 of 30 for 'clean bus' " https://blog.nationalgeographic.org/?s=clean+bus+&post_type=post
* @c40cities @Glen4ONT Are any '''Ontario''' '''cities''' signatories to the '''C40''' Clean Bus Declaration? @JimWatsonOttawa https://x.com/Ghoti20/status/615665015597735936?s=20
* ''more data, search https://twitter.com/search?q=Clean%20bus%20declaration&src=typed_query&f=top''

=== Incentives to reduce, trade in and scrap car ownership ===
* Across C40 cities, #Barcelona adopted free travel for those who got rid of polluting cars, #Stockholm expanded bus services, and #London has offered discounts on car clubs, bike hire and scrappage. '''2024''' https://x.com/c40cities/status/1749795375261847745?s=20
* "..Barcelona introduced free travel for three years for those who got rid of polluting cars, Stockholm expanded bus services.." '''2024''' https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20240122-from-london-to-new-york-can-quitting-cars-be-popular

=== Ultra Low Emissions Zones (ULEZ) and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs), AMPR Cameras ===
(video) "tradesmen risk fines", "we dont want this..", "..Ultra Low Emissions Zones (ULEZ) and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs) have nothing to do with saving the planet, and everything to do with restricting your freedom of movement.." 2023, UK, 1min video, https://x.com/PaulHut91434196/status/1645385622813646848?s=20

=== Speed limit reductions ===
Wales experiment
* 20mph: Wales first UK nation to drop speed limit from 30mph 17 September https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-66774379
** ''"a Welsh government-commissioned consultation found more were against the speed limit than in support of it. One of the Labour-led government's own documents said longer journeys could cause a "substantial" economic disadvantage."''
** ''The Welsh Conservatives said they were in favour of a 20mph limit outside schools, hospitals and care homes - but called the blanket rollout "disastrous, frankly ludicrous and a war on motorists".''
** Wales has become the first country in the UK to reduce speed limits in built-up areas from 30mph to 20mph in Wales from Sunday. Welsh ministers said a 20mph (32km/h) limit would reduce deaths and noise and encourage people to walk or cycle but it has caused controversy with some drivers.
* "One road in Wales now has eight speed limit changes in less than two miles following the switch to 20mph." Making driving an unpleasant experience is a key strategy of the war on motorists, with drivers bombarded with signage and fearful of big fines. https://x.com/RichardWellings/status/1729496787482812727?s=20
** links to
Towns in Ontario Canada

* [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0738991,-77.765902,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sEvwKbz7ShW_HVFcHGvJ71w!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu Streetview], Google maps, ''Speed limit sign '40km/h' halfway up hill,'' [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0760279,-77.7555241,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s2zzAk_guuO-2qOzhVehBPA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu 2nd sign,] 2min drive down same road, ''more obvious that the density is too low for this to make sense.''

=== Closing nuclear plants ===

* Ontario closing the Pickering nuclear plant. Sheila Gunn Reid, host for Rebel News on C40 cities. Then Lex Tan, the host of “Ringside Heat” gives us a recap of the WWE SummerSlam. Claire Sommer @KayakMediaTweet https://x.com/sauga960am/status/1554561769712091137?s=20

* Trudeau's criminal eco activist QC Minister wants to shut down '''Pickering''' '''nuclear plant''' & replace it with solar panels & windmills! Elect a clown expect a circus... Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy … #cdnpoli https://x.com/rexglacer/status/1456957830892859395?s=20 links to https://www.ipolitics.ca/news/guilbeault-refuses-to-declare-his-support-of-nuclear-energy
** Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy... Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault says “it’s not up to the government to decide” which sources of energy will reduce the country’s greenhouse-gas emissions to net zero by 2050. Nor would he say explicitly whether he supports nuclear energy, which he’d opposed in his work before entering politics in 2019. As for “which forms of energy […]. Published Nov 5, 2021 at 4:13pm
** ''more data, search'' https://twitter.com/search?q=Pickering%20nuclear%20plant&src=typed_query

=== Clothing purchases ===
* The C40 Cities targets for clothing purchases by 2030. The WEF & C40 Cities have the same goals. Details in link. <nowiki>https://expose-news.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Arup-C40-The-Future-of-Urban-Consumption-in-a-1-5C-World.pdf…</nowiki> https://x.com/stan_sands/status/1729209582898307422?s=20
** WEF has published a video in which they urge people to wash clothes less because washing clothes affects climate change... video link https://x.com/sophiadahl1/status/1729022360181977325?s=20

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-14T14:37:40Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views ==
=== Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy ===
* "Nobel Laureate: “Climate science has metastasized into massive shock-journalistic pseudoscience"
** ".Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, has criticized the climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's economy and the well-being of billions of people."." , Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics,, https://twitter.com/tlloydjones/status/1679446611364134914 https://gript.ie/nobel-laureate-climate-science-has-metastasized-into-massive-shock-journalistic-pseudoscience/
* "..The climate garbage is ramping up. I have studied it since 2005. - the temperature data is manipulated, no evidence of an increase - the CO2 rise is not due to fossil fuel burning, it's a planet!.." October 2022 https://x.com/denisrancourt/status/1581048532860948480?s=20

* "This insane climate extremist believes he can control the weather. And he wants you to believe it as well..." video, 2023 https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1689734767829233664?s=20
Causes, failed policy, forest management, law enforcement
*"..Climate Change = scapegoat for gov't policy failure. Canada's PM Trudeau & US pols use it all the time..." https://x.com/ClimateScam/status/1668271992183697410?s=20

=== Scapegoats ===

==== Carbon emissions, deforestation ====

==== Farming , meat consumption (blamed for carbon emissions and deforestation) ====
"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..War on cow gas is stinky but necessary job in climate-.." 2023 march https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/war-cow-farts-is-stinky-necessary-job-2023-03-24/

".. Northern Ireland will need to '''lose more than 1 million sheep''' and cattle to meet its new legally binding climate emissions targets .." April 2022 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/apr/22/northern-ireland-faces-loss-of-1-million-sheep-and-cattle-to-meet-climate-targets

" Farmers in the Netherlands have been staging protests over emissions reduction targets since October 2019. .." 2023 November https://www.euronews.com/green/2023/11/30/dutch-farmers-could-be-paid-to-close-their-livestock-farms-under-new-scheme

"Carbon emissions could be a scapegoat used to distract us from looking into other possible reasons of what's damaging our atmosphere." February 2023, https://x.com/kurgatkogeyben/status/1626455056819036162?s=20
* "Red meat used as scapegoat in carbon emissions debate" 2019 https://www.farminguk.com/news/red-meat-used-as-scapegoat-in-carbon-emissions-debate_54508.html
* ".. When you start cutting the '''carbon''' credits pie, remember '''Irish farmers have skin''' in the '''game''' .." 2021
** https://x.com/gpse7en/status/1416856901439180807?s=20
** https://www.independent.ie/opinion/letters/when-you-start-cutting-the-carbon-credits-pie-remember-irish-farmers-have-skin-in-the-game/40663670.html
* "..Geologist Ian Plimer has criticised the move for Ireland to cull 200,000 head of cattle in a bold effort to meet climate targets..." 2023 December https://x.com/newstart_2024/status/1734092664629256533?s=20
* Pets
** "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20
** ".. The case against pets: is it time to give up our cats and dogs? A growing number of people argue that owning pets is unethical - and that animals can never really have a good life in a human home.." 2023 https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2023/sep/13/the-case-against-pets-is-it-time-to-give-up-our-cats-and-dogs
** "Should we stop keeping pets? Why more and more ethicists say yes. Ninety per cent of Britons think of their pet as part of the family – 16% even included them on the last census. But recent research into animals’ emotional lives has cast doubt on the ethics of petkeeping.." 2017 https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2017/aug/01/should-we-stop-keeping-pets-why-more-and-more-ethicists-say-yes
* see also Farmer protests: Netherlands, France, Germany..

==== Wildfires, smoke causes, influencers blame climate change ====
Politicians: "these fires because of climate change"
* "these fires"
** "because of climate change"
*** “We’re seeing more and more of these fires because of climate change,” Trudeau posted on June 7. “These fires are affecting everyday routines, lives and livelihoods, and our air quality. We’ll keep working – here at home and with partners around the world – to tackle climate change and address its impacts.”
** Politicians always have lots to say about wildfires ..., 2023
*** https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/warmington-politicians-always-have-lots-to-say-about-wildfires-except-when-arson-charges-laid
**** One man charged-connected to numerous fires
***** Quebec police have charged a 37-year-old man with arson in connection with what the CBC reports as “numerous forest fires that burned earlier this summer in the province’s north.”
**** Catching arsonists not easy, resource intense, specialists teamwork
***** "Catching Paré was no easy task. Sûreté du Québec Sgt. Hugues Beaulieu told CBC detectives received help from “behaviour analysis experts, criminal profilers and forensic psychologists”

Weather extremes, records, mild winter, winter 2024 Ontario

".. Winter never Really started!! We have had a few mild ones now..." 2023 Feb https://x.com/jamie_blom/status/1621465810182045697?s=20

"..Does Climate "boiling" mean we are going to have a mild winter?.." 2023 https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1689230762481012736?s=20

=== ''Useful as a distraction'' ===

==== Ignore how asphalt-rich locations will artificially elevate temperature sensor data, Urban heat island effect (UHIE) ====

* "Cheap Asphalt That Can Suck Up Carbon Dioxide Has Been Created.." January 2015 https://www.sciencealert.com/cheap-asphalt-that-can-suck-up-carbon-dioxide-has-been-created https://x.com/computerwarez/status/554001284399771648?s=20
* 1m video "..Ever wondered how they're manipulating climate data? By strategically placing the majority of temperature sensors near asphalt runways at airports. That’s like arguing the ‘vaccines’ are safe and effective, because your favorite Hollywood actor told you so..." 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1685880783016218624?s=20
** "..The installation of these “weather“ stations at airports was never intended to measure changes in the climate!.." https://x.com/atpower111/status/1686011691346100225?s=20
** "..A significant issue I see with the current climate change narrative is how urban heat islands affect temperature readings. Urban heat islands (UHIs) are areas of high temperatures in cities caused by the replacement of natural land cover with dense concentrations of pavement, buildings, and other surfaces that absorb and retain heat. UHIs can cause temperatures in cities to be up to 10°F higher than surrounding rural areas..." 2023 https://x.com/TruthShepherrd/status/1680090256081833985?s=20
* "...Greenies like to go on and on about climate change, the new silly for global warming. They love to post charts of huge asphalt heat sinks like NY City, LA. Look at Fiji..." 2021 https://x.com/MrStache9/status/1407016015289106436?s=20
* "..Climate change my ass. It’s called Summer and it’s been around for eons. Take into consideration other things like more buildings, concrete, asphalt, etc..." 2023 https://x.com/misterchambo/status/1686894527594852354?s=20

==== Ignore that earth could be warming from the inside, "Exothermic (Cyclic) Core Theory of Climate Change" ====
"..the earth is, at least partly, warming from the inside..." https://x.com/OlMadeAmerica/status/1668104027198877697?s=20 https://x.com/EthicalSkeptic/status/1668045082417586177?s=20

"..''Recent climate change may originate from structural and exothermic phase changes in the nickel-iron core of the Earth, and not primarily from man’s activity alone.."'' https://theethicalskeptic.com/2020/02/16/the-climate-change-alternative-we-ignore-to-our-peril/

==== Ignore scale of Carbon emissions of recent volcanic activity ====
"..The Carbon Dioxide ‘footprint’ from this Canary Island eruption absolutely dwarfs the CO2 output of Canadians, and yet strangely there are no volcano Carbon Taxes..." 2021 https://x.com/PaulMitchell_AB/status/1441953860801601540?s=20

"..Between the shifting north magnetic pole that is causing Aurora Borealis to be visible as far south as the 45th parallel in November, and a couple of volcanoes about to erupt, Mother Nature is showing us that she's the one who really controls the climate. We’re also approaching what’s called “solar maximum,” which is essentially the sun’s peak storm season in an 11-year cycle... " 2023 https://x.com/Martyupnorth_2/status/1724255119469121823?s=20

==== Ignore arson as contributor to count and size of wildfires and smoke ====
"The astounding absurdity of a man arguing climate tax will .... prevent forest fires ignited through arson is not only extremely dangerous to Canada but worthy of a psychological evaluation". 2023 1min video https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1665803489316945920?s=20

"500 out of 650 fires in Alberta were caused by humans. We need to extricate the climate fear narrative from the claws of the climate alarmists. And we need better forest management & as well as more fire fighting equipment." 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1695174332350353875?s=20

"ALL 46 forest fires on Vancouver Island this year were caused by humans. Who wants to bet that the climate alarmists are insane enough to start a fire just so they can blame it on climate change?" 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1673876404340162561?s=20

==== Ignore instability in position of Magnetic poles ====
"..Between the shifting north magnetic pole that is causing Aurora Borealis to be visible as far south as the 45th parallel in November, ... Mother Nature is showing us that she's the one who really controls the climate. We’re also approaching what’s called “solar maximum,” which is essentially the sun’s peak storm season in an 11-year cycle... " 2023 https://x.com/Martyupnorth_2/status/1724255119469121823?s=20

"..Observation #5 in the article sums this up and shows how pole migration and climate change move in lock step.." 2023 https://x.com/EthicalSkeptic/status/1668119933518053377?s=20

"..Geomagnetic pole effects have been long-associated with changes in the Earth's climate. WEF just elected to forget about it, once they wanted power. Pole reversal? It is overdue, but the degrees of freedom on that event are rather large.." 2023 https://x.com/EthicalSkeptic/status/1658150314803965961?s=20

==== Ignore yesterday's manipulations of environment and atmosphere ====
"..Anybody know the last time it rained in Feb in Calgary??? Chemtrails are working..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/TheoFleury14/status/1753916919462367664?s=20

"..Chemtrails in Calgary are the real deal and it’s on the record. I have a ton of Canadian documents that show Alberta is heavily sprayed and regularly. Anyone can get them by filing a ATIA at the Ministry of Environmental under the Weather Modification Regulations Act..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/offgridstone/status/1754003999538532576?s=20

"..Can we pay carbon tax to stop the chemtrail spraying?.." https://x.com/WeaponizedNews/status/1753891976787935314?s=20

"..Chemtrails are more prevalent in Northern latitudes. #ClimateScam Zoom In for normal contrails and remnant of earlier Chemtrail..." feb 2024 https://x.com/allthewayjumper/status/1753150996782477377?s=20

"..climate hysteria is to distract from real issues like pollution and toxic dumping.." feb 2024 https://x.com/buzzard89/status/1753099838412230682?s=20

==== Ignore massive increase in all-cause mortality ====
"..Judging by the engagement on this story, [massive increase in all-cause mortality] might be the next big thing to be blamed on climate change.." February 2024, https://x.com/OpenSquirrel/status/1755428139369447661?s=20

==== Ignore recent scandals, avoid holding elite accountable ====
"..Climate alarmists, enabling 'leaders', and globalist elites will destroy civil society attempting to achieve unnecessary unachieveble fabricated targets, and then hold everyone else accountable for their failures..." 2022 https://x.com/JoeTheberge/status/1587680239119130625?s=20

"..#ClimateChange is a scam. It's a slush fund for elites. 1. Will one penny of "carbon credits" be audited? .. 4. Who is accountable for the $$? 5. Transparency?.." 2022 https://x.com/Flight1917/status/1508976967755870209?s=20

"..... hold those accountable to the fullest of the law. Wait, SQUIRREL Climate Change.." February 2024 https://x.com/BobReeves0270/status/1754202289378840859?s=20

=== Excuse for Power changes, power grabs ===

==== Diminish Constitutional Protections, Freedoms, Rights ====
"..DANIELLE SMITH: The targets being put forward by climate minister Gilbeault are arbitrary, not based on data, not based on science, & seem to be plucked out of thin air. They’re unachievable & unconstitutional. He needs to zip it..." Sept 2023 , video https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1697649073787158543?s=20

"Ampeldämmerung: Scholz government in crisis after doubtful budgetary manoeuvre to fund Green climate fantasies with unused Covid funds is declared unconstitutional.." November 2023 https://x.com/eugyppius1/status/1724836975872467081?s=20

"Germany's Constitutional Court has ruled that the country's 2019 climate protection act is in part unconstitutional following a complaint by a coalition of climate activists, including Fridays for Future." https://x.com/GretaThunberg/status/1387815038984015877?s=20

"..Sask: "we maintain that the carbon tax is unconstitutional because the federal government is applying a tax unevenly across the country based on their evaluation of provincial climate change plans, which they have no constitutional right to do" October 2018 https://x.com/nspector4/status/1057630933010935809?s=20

==== shortages: water, food, electricity, medicine, wood.. ====
"The next climate scare job to be unleashed by the environmentalists will be the water shortage. If they can sell the population on the great water shortage man will be at their mercy! They stay awake late, it's just one after another!.." 2023 October https://x.com/yonkojohn/status/1712395911140134956?s=20

"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized ..., the lower mainland Climate Change Bedwetters do not have water meters in their homes, now have a drought an water shortage..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

==== newer virus/pandemic/bioweapon/inoculation/immunization ====
"..Climate change impacts on West Nile virus transmission.." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4342965/

"..Climate change may worsen spread of West Nile virus.." 2023 https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2023/08/10/west-nile-virus-spread-symptoms/

".. Mar 15, 2023 — West Nile, '''Lyme, and other diseases''' are on the rise with climate change " https://www.statnews.com/2023/03/15/climate-change-diseases-west-nile-dengue-lyme/

"..Klaus Schwab stresses the importance of protecting against "a new virus possibly, or other risks which we have on the global agenda" and climate change. Those journalists who don't critically report on the WEF mafia are complicit. 1984 is real... " feb 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1622480961723338752?s=20

"..the individual responsible for enabling this 'plandemic' through PCR test fraud is now warning of a new virus and attributing it to climate change..." may 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1655234854735208449?s=20

==== more treaties, free trade agreements ====
"Dr. Meryl Nass explains how the WHO's proposed pandemic treaty will enable the WHO "to take over jurisdiction of everything in the world by saying that climate change,.. animals, plants, water systems [and] ecosystems are all central to health". In addition to that, it will remove human rights protections, enforce censorship and digital passports,.." Feb 2024 https://x.com/stephiereine/status/1755323524879622276?s=20 quote above also from 4hour video "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MrIsXDKrtE International Covid Summit III part 2 European Parliament, Brussels]"

Canada ukraine FT/carbon clause

"..It’s cuz Trudeau rammed in a carbon tax amendment into a pre-existing deal. If this deal does not pass, nothing happens. We already have a free trade agreement.." February 2024 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1755618090510164380?s=20

==== more taxes, more inflation, lower gdp ====
"..Stephen Guilbeault becomes completely unhinged and accuses those who don't believe his Climate Plan as deniers while repeating propaganda of how carbon tax makes life more affordable. As a Canadian, how sick are you of the psychopathic Liberal Govt?.. " 2024 February https://x.com/govt_corrupt/status/1754994957260103818?s=20

==== concept of 'carbon footprint', tracking and restricting movement, purchases ====
"The Canadian Alibaba Group president J. Michael Evans boasts at the World Economic Forum about developing an individual carbon footprint tracker to monitor what you buy, what you eat, and where/how you travel. That individual carbon footprint tracker, however, most likely won't….. " 2023 February https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1629986426392842240?s=20

"So of course - in 15-minute cities - it would be up to the “consumer”, on how they chose to use their rationed carbon credits for travel <insert sarcasm> " August 2023 https://x.com/RWMaloneMD/status/1697280037613867008?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized for using a reliable Natural Gas Furnace, an having water meters in their homes, ..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T03:58:39Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views ==
=== Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy ===
* "Nobel Laureate: “Climate science has metastasized into massive shock-journalistic pseudoscience"
** ".Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, has criticized the climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's economy and the well-being of billions of people."." , Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics,, https://twitter.com/tlloydjones/status/1679446611364134914 https://gript.ie/nobel-laureate-climate-science-has-metastasized-into-massive-shock-journalistic-pseudoscience/
* "..The climate garbage is ramping up. I have studied it since 2005. - the temperature data is manipulated, no evidence of an increase - the CO2 rise is not due to fossil fuel burning, it's a planet!.." October 2022 https://x.com/denisrancourt/status/1581048532860948480?s=20

* "This insane climate extremist believes he can control the weather. And he wants you to believe it as well..." video, 2023 https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1689734767829233664?s=20
Causes, failed policy, forest management, law enforcement
*"..Climate Change = scapegoat for gov't policy failure. Canada's PM Trudeau & US pols use it all the time..." https://x.com/ClimateScam/status/1668271992183697410?s=20

=== Scapegoats ===

==== Carbon emissions, deforestation ====

==== Farming , meat consumption (blamed for carbon emissions and deforestation) ====
"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..War on cow gas is stinky but necessary job in climate-.." 2023 march https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/war-cow-farts-is-stinky-necessary-job-2023-03-24/

".. Northern Ireland will need to '''lose more than 1 million sheep''' and cattle to meet its new legally binding climate emissions targets .." April 2022 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/apr/22/northern-ireland-faces-loss-of-1-million-sheep-and-cattle-to-meet-climate-targets

" Farmers in the Netherlands have been staging protests over emissions reduction targets since October 2019. .." 2023 November https://www.euronews.com/green/2023/11/30/dutch-farmers-could-be-paid-to-close-their-livestock-farms-under-new-scheme

"Carbon emissions could be a scapegoat used to distract us from looking into other possible reasons of what's damaging our atmosphere." February 2023, https://x.com/kurgatkogeyben/status/1626455056819036162?s=20
* "Red meat used as scapegoat in carbon emissions debate" 2019 https://www.farminguk.com/news/red-meat-used-as-scapegoat-in-carbon-emissions-debate_54508.html
* ".. When you start cutting the '''carbon''' credits pie, remember '''Irish farmers have skin''' in the '''game''' .." 2021
** https://x.com/gpse7en/status/1416856901439180807?s=20
** https://www.independent.ie/opinion/letters/when-you-start-cutting-the-carbon-credits-pie-remember-irish-farmers-have-skin-in-the-game/40663670.html
* "..Geologist Ian Plimer has criticised the move for Ireland to cull 200,000 head of cattle in a bold effort to meet climate targets..." 2023 December https://x.com/newstart_2024/status/1734092664629256533?s=20
* "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20
* see also Farmer protests: Netherlands, France, Germany..

==== Wildfires, smoke causes, influencers blame climate change ====
Politicians: "these fires because of climate change"
* "these fires"
** "because of climate change"
*** “We’re seeing more and more of these fires because of climate change,” Trudeau posted on June 7. “These fires are affecting everyday routines, lives and livelihoods, and our air quality. We’ll keep working – here at home and with partners around the world – to tackle climate change and address its impacts.”
** Politicians always have lots to say about wildfires ..., 2023
*** https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/warmington-politicians-always-have-lots-to-say-about-wildfires-except-when-arson-charges-laid
**** One man charged-connected to numerous fires
***** Quebec police have charged a 37-year-old man with arson in connection with what the CBC reports as “numerous forest fires that burned earlier this summer in the province’s north.”
**** Catching arsonists not easy, resource intense, specialists teamwork
***** "Catching Paré was no easy task. Sûreté du Québec Sgt. Hugues Beaulieu told CBC detectives received help from “behaviour analysis experts, criminal profilers and forensic psychologists”

Weather extremes, records, mild winter, winter 2024 Ontario

".. Winter never Really started!! We have had a few mild ones now..." 2023 Feb https://x.com/jamie_blom/status/1621465810182045697?s=20

"..Does Climate "boiling" mean we are going to have a mild winter?.." 2023 https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1689230762481012736?s=20

=== ''Useful as a distraction'' ===

==== Ignore how asphalt-rich locations will artificially elevate temperature sensor data, Urban heat island effect (UHIE) ====

* "Cheap Asphalt That Can Suck Up Carbon Dioxide Has Been Created.." January 2015 https://www.sciencealert.com/cheap-asphalt-that-can-suck-up-carbon-dioxide-has-been-created https://x.com/computerwarez/status/554001284399771648?s=20
* 1m video "..Ever wondered how they're manipulating climate data? By strategically placing the majority of temperature sensors near asphalt runways at airports. That’s like arguing the ‘vaccines’ are safe and effective, because your favorite Hollywood actor told you so..." 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1685880783016218624?s=20
** "..The installation of these “weather“ stations at airports was never intended to measure changes in the climate!.." https://x.com/atpower111/status/1686011691346100225?s=20
** "..A significant issue I see with the current climate change narrative is how urban heat islands affect temperature readings. Urban heat islands (UHIs) are areas of high temperatures in cities caused by the replacement of natural land cover with dense concentrations of pavement, buildings, and other surfaces that absorb and retain heat. UHIs can cause temperatures in cities to be up to 10°F higher than surrounding rural areas..." 2023 https://x.com/TruthShepherrd/status/1680090256081833985?s=20
* "...Greenies like to go on and on about climate change, the new silly for global warming. They love to post charts of huge asphalt heat sinks like NY City, LA. Look at Fiji..." 2021 https://x.com/MrStache9/status/1407016015289106436?s=20
* "..Climate change my ass. It’s called Summer and it’s been around for eons. Take into consideration other things like more buildings, concrete, asphalt, etc..." 2023 https://x.com/misterchambo/status/1686894527594852354?s=20

==== Ignore that earth could be warming from the inside, "Exothermic (Cyclic) Core Theory of Climate Change" ====
"..the earth is, at least partly, warming from the inside..." https://x.com/OlMadeAmerica/status/1668104027198877697?s=20 https://x.com/EthicalSkeptic/status/1668045082417586177?s=20

"..''Recent climate change may originate from structural and exothermic phase changes in the nickel-iron core of the Earth, and not primarily from man’s activity alone.."'' https://theethicalskeptic.com/2020/02/16/the-climate-change-alternative-we-ignore-to-our-peril/

==== Ignore scale of Carbon emissions of recent volcanic activity ====
"..The Carbon Dioxide ‘footprint’ from this Canary Island eruption absolutely dwarfs the CO2 output of Canadians, and yet strangely there are no volcano Carbon Taxes..." 2021 https://x.com/PaulMitchell_AB/status/1441953860801601540?s=20

"..Between the shifting north magnetic pole that is causing Aurora Borealis to be visible as far south as the 45th parallel in November, and a couple of volcanoes about to erupt, Mother Nature is showing us that she's the one who really controls the climate. We’re also approaching what’s called “solar maximum,” which is essentially the sun’s peak storm season in an 11-year cycle... " 2023 https://x.com/Martyupnorth_2/status/1724255119469121823?s=20

==== Ignore arson as contributor to count and size of wildfires and smoke ====
"The astounding absurdity of a man arguing climate tax will .... prevent forest fires ignited through arson is not only extremely dangerous to Canada but worthy of a psychological evaluation". 2023 1min video https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1665803489316945920?s=20

"500 out of 650 fires in Alberta were caused by humans. We need to extricate the climate fear narrative from the claws of the climate alarmists. And we need better forest management & as well as more fire fighting equipment." 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1695174332350353875?s=20

"ALL 46 forest fires on Vancouver Island this year were caused by humans. Who wants to bet that the climate alarmists are insane enough to start a fire just so they can blame it on climate change?" 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1673876404340162561?s=20

==== Ignore instability in position of Magnetic poles ====
"..Between the shifting north magnetic pole that is causing Aurora Borealis to be visible as far south as the 45th parallel in November, ... Mother Nature is showing us that she's the one who really controls the climate. We’re also approaching what’s called “solar maximum,” which is essentially the sun’s peak storm season in an 11-year cycle... " 2023 https://x.com/Martyupnorth_2/status/1724255119469121823?s=20

"..Observation #5 in the article sums this up and shows how pole migration and climate change move in lock step.." 2023 https://x.com/EthicalSkeptic/status/1668119933518053377?s=20

"..Geomagnetic pole effects have been long-associated with changes in the Earth's climate. WEF just elected to forget about it, once they wanted power. Pole reversal? It is overdue, but the degrees of freedom on that event are rather large.." 2023 https://x.com/EthicalSkeptic/status/1658150314803965961?s=20

==== Ignore yesterday's manipulations of environment and atmosphere ====
"..Anybody know the last time it rained in Feb in Calgary??? Chemtrails are working..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/TheoFleury14/status/1753916919462367664?s=20

"..Chemtrails in Calgary are the real deal and it’s on the record. I have a ton of Canadian documents that show Alberta is heavily sprayed and regularly. Anyone can get them by filing a ATIA at the Ministry of Environmental under the Weather Modification Regulations Act..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/offgridstone/status/1754003999538532576?s=20

"..Can we pay carbon tax to stop the chemtrail spraying?.." https://x.com/WeaponizedNews/status/1753891976787935314?s=20

"..Chemtrails are more prevalent in Northern latitudes. #ClimateScam Zoom In for normal contrails and remnant of earlier Chemtrail..." feb 2024 https://x.com/allthewayjumper/status/1753150996782477377?s=20

"..climate hysteria is to distract from real issues like pollution and toxic dumping.." feb 2024 https://x.com/buzzard89/status/1753099838412230682?s=20

==== Ignore massive increase in all-cause mortality ====
"..Judging by the engagement on this story, [massive increase in all-cause mortality] might be the next big thing to be blamed on climate change.." February 2024, https://x.com/OpenSquirrel/status/1755428139369447661?s=20

==== Ignore recent scandals, avoid holding elite accountable ====
"..Climate alarmists, enabling 'leaders', and globalist elites will destroy civil society attempting to achieve unnecessary unachieveble fabricated targets, and then hold everyone else accountable for their failures..." 2022 https://x.com/JoeTheberge/status/1587680239119130625?s=20

"..#ClimateChange is a scam. It's a slush fund for elites. 1. Will one penny of "carbon credits" be audited? .. 4. Who is accountable for the $$? 5. Transparency?.." 2022 https://x.com/Flight1917/status/1508976967755870209?s=20

"..... hold those accountable to the fullest of the law. Wait, SQUIRREL Climate Change.." February 2024 https://x.com/BobReeves0270/status/1754202289378840859?s=20

=== Excuse for Power changes, power grabs ===

==== Diminish Constitutional Protections, Freedoms, Rights ====
"..DANIELLE SMITH: The targets being put forward by climate minister Gilbeault are arbitrary, not based on data, not based on science, & seem to be plucked out of thin air. They’re unachievable & unconstitutional. He needs to zip it..." Sept 2023 , video https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1697649073787158543?s=20

"Ampeldämmerung: Scholz government in crisis after doubtful budgetary manoeuvre to fund Green climate fantasies with unused Covid funds is declared unconstitutional.." November 2023 https://x.com/eugyppius1/status/1724836975872467081?s=20

"Germany's Constitutional Court has ruled that the country's 2019 climate protection act is in part unconstitutional following a complaint by a coalition of climate activists, including Fridays for Future." https://x.com/GretaThunberg/status/1387815038984015877?s=20

"..Sask: "we maintain that the carbon tax is unconstitutional because the federal government is applying a tax unevenly across the country based on their evaluation of provincial climate change plans, which they have no constitutional right to do" October 2018 https://x.com/nspector4/status/1057630933010935809?s=20

==== shortages: water, food, electricity, medicine, wood.. ====
"The next climate scare job to be unleashed by the environmentalists will be the water shortage. If they can sell the population on the great water shortage man will be at their mercy! They stay awake late, it's just one after another!.." 2023 October https://x.com/yonkojohn/status/1712395911140134956?s=20

"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized ..., the lower mainland Climate Change Bedwetters do not have water meters in their homes, now have a drought an water shortage..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

==== newer virus/pandemic/bioweapon/inoculation/immunization ====
"..Climate change impacts on West Nile virus transmission.." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4342965/

"..Climate change may worsen spread of West Nile virus.." 2023 https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2023/08/10/west-nile-virus-spread-symptoms/

".. Mar 15, 2023 — West Nile, '''Lyme, and other diseases''' are on the rise with climate change " https://www.statnews.com/2023/03/15/climate-change-diseases-west-nile-dengue-lyme/

"..Klaus Schwab stresses the importance of protecting against "a new virus possibly, or other risks which we have on the global agenda" and climate change. Those journalists who don't critically report on the WEF mafia are complicit. 1984 is real... " feb 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1622480961723338752?s=20

"..the individual responsible for enabling this 'plandemic' through PCR test fraud is now warning of a new virus and attributing it to climate change..." may 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1655234854735208449?s=20

==== more treaties, free trade agreements ====
"Dr. Meryl Nass explains how the WHO's proposed pandemic treaty will enable the WHO "to take over jurisdiction of everything in the world by saying that climate change,.. animals, plants, water systems [and] ecosystems are all central to health". In addition to that, it will remove human rights protections, enforce censorship and digital passports,.." Feb 2024 https://x.com/stephiereine/status/1755323524879622276?s=20 quote above also from 4hour video "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MrIsXDKrtE International Covid Summit III part 2 European Parliament, Brussels]"

Canada ukraine FT/carbon clause

"..It’s cuz Trudeau rammed in a carbon tax amendment into a pre-existing deal. If this deal does not pass, nothing happens. We already have a free trade agreement.." February 2024 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1755618090510164380?s=20

==== more taxes, more inflation, lower gdp ====
"..Stephen Guilbeault becomes completely unhinged and accuses those who don't believe his Climate Plan as deniers while repeating propaganda of how carbon tax makes life more affordable. As a Canadian, how sick are you of the psychopathic Liberal Govt?.. " 2024 February https://x.com/govt_corrupt/status/1754994957260103818?s=20

==== concept of 'carbon footprint', tracking and restricting movement, purchases ====
"The Canadian Alibaba Group president J. Michael Evans boasts at the World Economic Forum about developing an individual carbon footprint tracker to monitor what you buy, what you eat, and where/how you travel. That individual carbon footprint tracker, however, most likely won't….. " 2023 February https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1629986426392842240?s=20

"So of course - in 15-minute cities - it would be up to the “consumer”, on how they chose to use their rationed carbon credits for travel <insert sarcasm> " August 2023 https://x.com/RWMaloneMD/status/1697280037613867008?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized for using a reliable Natural Gas Furnace, an having water meters in their homes, ..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T02:56:11Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views ==
=== Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy ===
* "Nobel Laureate: “Climate science has metastasized into massive shock-journalistic pseudoscience"
** ".Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, has criticized the climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's economy and the well-being of billions of people."." , Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics,, https://twitter.com/tlloydjones/status/1679446611364134914 https://gript.ie/nobel-laureate-climate-science-has-metastasized-into-massive-shock-journalistic-pseudoscience/
* "..The climate garbage is ramping up. I have studied it since 2005. - the temperature data is manipulated, no evidence of an increase - the CO2 rise is not due to fossil fuel burning, it's a planet!.." October 2022 https://x.com/denisrancourt/status/1581048532860948480?s=20

* "This insane climate extremist believes he can control the weather. And he wants you to believe it as well..." video, 2023 https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1689734767829233664?s=20
Causes, failed policy, forest management, law enforcement
*"..Climate Change = scapegoat for gov't policy failure. Canada's PM Trudeau & US pols use it all the time..." https://x.com/ClimateScam/status/1668271992183697410?s=20

=== Scapegoats ===

==== Carbon emissions, deforestation ====

==== Farming , meat consumption (blamed for carbon emissions and deforestation) ====
"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..War on cow gas is stinky but necessary job in climate-.." 2023 march https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/war-cow-farts-is-stinky-necessary-job-2023-03-24/

".. Northern Ireland will need to '''lose more than 1 million sheep''' and cattle to meet its new legally binding climate emissions targets .." April 2022 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/apr/22/northern-ireland-faces-loss-of-1-million-sheep-and-cattle-to-meet-climate-targets

" Farmers in the Netherlands have been staging protests over emissions reduction targets since October 2019. .." 2023 November https://www.euronews.com/green/2023/11/30/dutch-farmers-could-be-paid-to-close-their-livestock-farms-under-new-scheme

"Carbon emissions could be a scapegoat used to distract us from looking into other possible reasons of what's damaging our atmosphere." February 2023, https://x.com/kurgatkogeyben/status/1626455056819036162?s=20
* "Red meat used as scapegoat in carbon emissions debate" 2019 https://www.farminguk.com/news/red-meat-used-as-scapegoat-in-carbon-emissions-debate_54508.html
* ".. When you start cutting the '''carbon''' credits pie, remember '''Irish farmers have skin''' in the '''game''' .." 2021
** https://x.com/gpse7en/status/1416856901439180807?s=20
** https://www.independent.ie/opinion/letters/when-you-start-cutting-the-carbon-credits-pie-remember-irish-farmers-have-skin-in-the-game/40663670.html
* "..Geologist Ian Plimer has criticised the move for Ireland to cull 200,000 head of cattle in a bold effort to meet climate targets..." 2023 December https://x.com/newstart_2024/status/1734092664629256533?s=20
* "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20
* see also Farmer protests: Netherlands, France, Germany..

==== Wildfires, smoke causes, influencers: arson vs climate change ====
"The astounding absurdity of a man arguing climate tax will .... prevent forest fires ignited through arson is not only extremely dangerous to Canada but worthy of a psychological evaluation". 2023 1min video https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1665803489316945920?s=20

"500 out of 650 fires in Alberta were caused by humans. We need to extricate the climate fear narrative from the claws of the climate alarmists. And we need better forest management & as well as more fire fighting equipment." 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1695174332350353875?s=20

"ALL 46 forest fires on Vancouver Island this year were caused by humans. Who wants to bet that the climate alarmists are insane enough to start a fire just so they can blame it on climate change?" 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1673876404340162561?s=20

Politicians: "these fires because of climate change"
* "these fires"
** "because of climate change"
*** “We’re seeing more and more of these fires because of climate change,” Trudeau posted on June 7. “These fires are affecting everyday routines, lives and livelihoods, and our air quality. We’ll keep working – here at home and with partners around the world – to tackle climate change and address its impacts.”
** Politicians always have lots to say about wildfires ..., 2023
*** https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/warmington-politicians-always-have-lots-to-say-about-wildfires-except-when-arson-charges-laid
**** One man charged-connected to numerous fires
***** Quebec police have charged a 37-year-old man with arson in connection with what the CBC reports as “numerous forest fires that burned earlier this summer in the province’s north.”
**** Catching arsonists not easy, resource intense, specialists teamwork
***** "Catching Paré was no easy task. Sûreté du Québec Sgt. Hugues Beaulieu told CBC detectives received help from “behaviour analysis experts, criminal profilers and forensic psychologists”

Weather extremes, records, mild winter, winter 2024 Ontario

".. Winter never Really started!! We have had a few mild ones now..." 2023 Feb https://x.com/jamie_blom/status/1621465810182045697?s=20

"..Does Climate "boiling" mean we are going to have a mild winter?.." 2023 https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1689230762481012736?s=20

*

=== ''Useful as a distraction'' ===

==== Ignore yesterday's manipulations of environment and atmosphere ====
"..Anybody know the last time it rained in Feb in Calgary??? Chemtrails are working..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/TheoFleury14/status/1753916919462367664?s=20

"..Chemtrails in Calgary are the real deal and it’s on the record. I have a ton of Canadian documents that show Alberta is heavily sprayed and regularly. Anyone can get them by filing a ATIA at the Ministry of Environmental under the Weather Modification Regulations Act..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/offgridstone/status/1754003999538532576?s=20

"..Can we pay carbon tax to stop the chemtrail spraying?.." https://x.com/WeaponizedNews/status/1753891976787935314?s=20

"..Chemtrails are more prevalent in Northern latitudes. #ClimateScam Zoom In for normal contrails and remnant of earlier Chemtrail..." feb 2024 https://x.com/allthewayjumper/status/1753150996782477377?s=20

"..climate hysteria is to distract from real issues like pollution and toxic dumping.." feb 2024 https://x.com/buzzard89/status/1753099838412230682?s=20

==== Ignore massive increase in all-cause mortality ====
"..Judging by the engagement on this story, [massive increase in all-cause mortality] might be the next big thing to be blamed on climate change.." February 2024, https://x.com/OpenSquirrel/status/1755428139369447661?s=20

==== Ignore recent scandals, avoid holding elite accountable ====
"..Climate alarmists, enabling 'leaders', and globalist elites will destroy civil society attempting to achieve unnecessary unachieveble fabricated targets, and then hold everyone else accountable for their failures..." 2022 https://x.com/JoeTheberge/status/1587680239119130625?s=20

"..#ClimateChange is a scam. It's a slush fund for elites. 1. Will one penny of "carbon credits" be audited? .. 4. Who is accountable for the $$? 5. Transparency?.." 2022 https://x.com/Flight1917/status/1508976967755870209?s=20

"..... hold those accountable to the fullest of the law. Wait, SQUIRREL Climate Change.." February 2024 https://x.com/BobReeves0270/status/1754202289378840859?s=20

=== Excuse for Power changes, power grabs ===

==== Diminish Constitutional Protections, Freedoms, Rights ====
"..DANIELLE SMITH: The targets being put forward by climate minister Gilbeault are arbitrary, not based on data, not based on science, & seem to be plucked out of thin air. They’re unachievable & unconstitutional. He needs to zip it..." Sept 2023 , video https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1697649073787158543?s=20

"Ampeldämmerung: Scholz government in crisis after doubtful budgetary manoeuvre to fund Green climate fantasies with unused Covid funds is declared unconstitutional.." November 2023 https://x.com/eugyppius1/status/1724836975872467081?s=20

"Germany's Constitutional Court has ruled that the country's 2019 climate protection act is in part unconstitutional following a complaint by a coalition of climate activists, including Fridays for Future." https://x.com/GretaThunberg/status/1387815038984015877?s=20

"..Sask: "we maintain that the carbon tax is unconstitutional because the federal government is applying a tax unevenly across the country based on their evaluation of provincial climate change plans, which they have no constitutional right to do" October 2018 https://x.com/nspector4/status/1057630933010935809?s=20

==== shortages: water, food, electricity, medicine, wood.. ====
"The next climate scare job to be unleashed by the environmentalists will be the water shortage. If they can sell the population on the great water shortage man will be at their mercy! They stay awake late, it's just one after another!.." 2023 October https://x.com/yonkojohn/status/1712395911140134956?s=20

"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized ..., the lower mainland Climate Change Bedwetters do not have water meters in their homes, now have a drought an water shortage..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

==== newer virus/pandemic/bioweapon/inoculation/immunization ====
"..Climate change impacts on West Nile virus transmission.." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4342965/

"..Climate change may worsen spread of West Nile virus.." 2023 https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2023/08/10/west-nile-virus-spread-symptoms/

".. Mar 15, 2023 — West Nile, '''Lyme, and other diseases''' are on the rise with climate change " https://www.statnews.com/2023/03/15/climate-change-diseases-west-nile-dengue-lyme/

"..Klaus Schwab stresses the importance of protecting against "a new virus possibly, or other risks which we have on the global agenda" and climate change. Those journalists who don't critically report on the WEF mafia are complicit. 1984 is real... " feb 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1622480961723338752?s=20

"..the individual responsible for enabling this 'plandemic' through PCR test fraud is now warning of a new virus and attributing it to climate change..." may 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1655234854735208449?s=20

==== more treaties, free trade agreements ====
"Dr. Meryl Nass explains how the WHO's proposed pandemic treaty will enable the WHO "to take over jurisdiction of everything in the world by saying that climate change,.. animals, plants, water systems [and] ecosystems are all central to health". In addition to that, it will remove human rights protections, enforce censorship and digital passports,.." Feb 2024 https://x.com/stephiereine/status/1755323524879622276?s=20 quote above also from 4hour video "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MrIsXDKrtE International Covid Summit III part 2 European Parliament, Brussels]"

Canada ukraine FT/carbon clause

"..It’s cuz Trudeau rammed in a carbon tax amendment into a pre-existing deal. If this deal does not pass, nothing happens. We already have a free trade agreement.." February 2024 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1755618090510164380?s=20

==== more taxes, more inflation, lower gdp ====
"..Stephen Guilbeault becomes completely unhinged and accuses those who don't believe his Climate Plan as deniers while repeating propaganda of how carbon tax makes life more affordable. As a Canadian, how sick are you of the psychopathic Liberal Govt?.. " 2024 February https://x.com/govt_corrupt/status/1754994957260103818?s=20

==== concept of 'carbon footprint', tracking and restricting movement, purchases ====
"The Canadian Alibaba Group president J. Michael Evans boasts at the World Economic Forum about developing an individual carbon footprint tracker to monitor what you buy, what you eat, and where/how you travel. That individual carbon footprint tracker, however, most likely won't….. " 2023 February https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1629986426392842240?s=20

"So of course - in 15-minute cities - it would be up to the “consumer”, on how they chose to use their rationed carbon credits for travel <insert sarcasm> " August 2023 https://x.com/RWMaloneMD/status/1697280037613867008?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized for using a reliable Natural Gas Furnace, an having water meters in their homes, ..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T02:55:28Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views ==
=== Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy ===
* "Nobel Laureate: “Climate science has metastasized into massive shock-journalistic pseudoscience"
** ".Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, has criticized the climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's economy and the well-being of billions of people."." , Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics,, https://twitter.com/tlloydjones/status/1679446611364134914 https://gript.ie/nobel-laureate-climate-science-has-metastasized-into-massive-shock-journalistic-pseudoscience/
* "..The climate garbage is ramping up. I have studied it since 2005. - the temperature data is manipulated, no evidence of an increase - the CO2 rise is not due to fossil fuel burning, it's a planet!.." October 2022 https://x.com/denisrancourt/status/1581048532860948480?s=20

* "This insane climate extremist believes he can control the weather. And he wants you to believe it as well..." video, 2023 https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1689734767829233664?s=20
Causes, failed policy, forest management, law enforcement
*"..Climate Change = scapegoat for gov't policy failure. Canada's PM Trudeau & US pols use it all the time..." https://x.com/ClimateScam/status/1668271992183697410?s=20

=== Scapegoats ===

==== Carbon emissions, deforestation ====

==== Farming , meat consumption (blamed for carbon emissions and deforestation) ====
"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..War on cow gas is stinky but necessary job in climate-.." 2023 march https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/war-cow-farts-is-stinky-necessary-job-2023-03-24/

".. Northern Ireland will need to '''lose more than 1 million sheep''' and cattle to meet its new legally binding climate emissions targets .." April 2022 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/apr/22/northern-ireland-faces-loss-of-1-million-sheep-and-cattle-to-meet-climate-targets

" Farmers in the Netherlands have been staging protests over emissions reduction targets since October 2019. .." 2023 November https://www.euronews.com/green/2023/11/30/dutch-farmers-could-be-paid-to-close-their-livestock-farms-under-new-scheme

"Carbon emissions could be a scapegoat used to distract us from looking into other possible reasons of what's damaging our atmosphere." February 2023, https://x.com/kurgatkogeyben/status/1626455056819036162?s=20
* "Red meat used as scapegoat in carbon emissions debate" 2019 https://www.farminguk.com/news/red-meat-used-as-scapegoat-in-carbon-emissions-debate_54508.html
* ".. When you start cutting the '''carbon''' credits pie, remember '''Irish farmers have skin''' in the '''game''' .." 2021
** https://x.com/gpse7en/status/1416856901439180807?s=20
** https://www.independent.ie/opinion/letters/when-you-start-cutting-the-carbon-credits-pie-remember-irish-farmers-have-skin-in-the-game/40663670.html
* "..Geologist Ian Plimer has criticised the move for Ireland to cull 200,000 head of cattle in a bold effort to meet climate targets..." 2023 December https://x.com/newstart_2024/status/1734092664629256533?s=20
* "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20
* see also Farmer protests: Netherlands, France, Germany..

==== Wildfires, smoke causes, influencers: arson vs climate change ====
"The astounding absurdity of a man arguing climate tax will .... prevent forest fires ignited through arson is not only extremely dangerous to Canada but worthy of a psychological evaluation". 2023 1min video https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1665803489316945920?s=20

"500 out of 650 fires in Alberta were caused by humans. We need to extricate the climate fear narrative from the claws of the climate alarmists. And we need better forest management & as well as more fire fighting equipment." 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1695174332350353875?s=20

"ALL 46 forest fires on Vancouver Island this year were caused by humans. Who wants to bet that the climate alarmists are insane enough to start a fire just so they can blame it on climate change?" 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1673876404340162561?s=20

Politicians: "these fires because of climate change"
* "these fires"
** "because of climate change"
*** “We’re seeing more and more of these fires because of climate change,” Trudeau posted on June 7. “These fires are affecting everyday routines, lives and livelihoods, and our air quality. We’ll keep working – here at home and with partners around the world – to tackle climate change and address its impacts.”
** Politicians always have lots to say about wildfires ..., 2023
*** https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/warmington-politicians-always-have-lots-to-say-about-wildfires-except-when-arson-charges-laid
**** One man charged-connected to numerous fires
***** Quebec police have charged a 37-year-old man with arson in connection with what the CBC reports as “numerous forest fires that burned earlier this summer in the province’s north.”
**** Catching arsonists not easy, resource intense, specialists teamwork
***** "Catching Paré was no easy task. Sûreté du Québec Sgt. Hugues Beaulieu told CBC detectives received help from “behaviour analysis experts, criminal profilers and forensic psychologists”

==== weather extremes, records, mild winter, winter 2024 Ontario ====
".. Winter never Really started!! We have had a few mild ones now..." 2023 Feb https://x.com/jamie_blom/status/1621465810182045697?s=20

"..Does Climate "boiling" mean we are going to have a mild winter?.." 2023 https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1689230762481012736?s=20

*

=== ''Useful as a distraction'' ===

==== Ignore yesterday's manipulations of environment and atmosphere ====
"..Anybody know the last time it rained in Feb in Calgary??? Chemtrails are working..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/TheoFleury14/status/1753916919462367664?s=20

"..Chemtrails in Calgary are the real deal and it’s on the record. I have a ton of Canadian documents that show Alberta is heavily sprayed and regularly. Anyone can get them by filing a ATIA at the Ministry of Environmental under the Weather Modification Regulations Act..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/offgridstone/status/1754003999538532576?s=20

"..Can we pay carbon tax to stop the chemtrail spraying?.." https://x.com/WeaponizedNews/status/1753891976787935314?s=20

"..Chemtrails are more prevalent in Northern latitudes. #ClimateScam Zoom In for normal contrails and remnant of earlier Chemtrail..." feb 2024 https://x.com/allthewayjumper/status/1753150996782477377?s=20

"..climate hysteria is to distract from real issues like pollution and toxic dumping.." feb 2024 https://x.com/buzzard89/status/1753099838412230682?s=20

==== Ignore massive increase in all-cause mortality ====
"..Judging by the engagement on this story, [massive increase in all-cause mortality] might be the next big thing to be blamed on climate change.." February 2024, https://x.com/OpenSquirrel/status/1755428139369447661?s=20

==== Ignore recent scandals, avoid holding elite accountable ====
"..Climate alarmists, enabling 'leaders', and globalist elites will destroy civil society attempting to achieve unnecessary unachieveble fabricated targets, and then hold everyone else accountable for their failures..." 2022 https://x.com/JoeTheberge/status/1587680239119130625?s=20

"..#ClimateChange is a scam. It's a slush fund for elites. 1. Will one penny of "carbon credits" be audited? .. 4. Who is accountable for the $$? 5. Transparency?.." 2022 https://x.com/Flight1917/status/1508976967755870209?s=20

"..... hold those accountable to the fullest of the law. Wait, SQUIRREL Climate Change.." February 2024 https://x.com/BobReeves0270/status/1754202289378840859?s=20

=== Excuse for Power changes, power grabs ===

==== Diminish Constitutional Protections, Freedoms, Rights ====
"..DANIELLE SMITH: The targets being put forward by climate minister Gilbeault are arbitrary, not based on data, not based on science, & seem to be plucked out of thin air. They’re unachievable & unconstitutional. He needs to zip it..." Sept 2023 , video https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1697649073787158543?s=20

"Ampeldämmerung: Scholz government in crisis after doubtful budgetary manoeuvre to fund Green climate fantasies with unused Covid funds is declared unconstitutional.." November 2023 https://x.com/eugyppius1/status/1724836975872467081?s=20

"Germany's Constitutional Court has ruled that the country's 2019 climate protection act is in part unconstitutional following a complaint by a coalition of climate activists, including Fridays for Future." https://x.com/GretaThunberg/status/1387815038984015877?s=20

"..Sask: "we maintain that the carbon tax is unconstitutional because the federal government is applying a tax unevenly across the country based on their evaluation of provincial climate change plans, which they have no constitutional right to do" October 2018 https://x.com/nspector4/status/1057630933010935809?s=20

==== shortages: water, food, electricity, medicine, wood.. ====
"The next climate scare job to be unleashed by the environmentalists will be the water shortage. If they can sell the population on the great water shortage man will be at their mercy! They stay awake late, it's just one after another!.." 2023 October https://x.com/yonkojohn/status/1712395911140134956?s=20

"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized ..., the lower mainland Climate Change Bedwetters do not have water meters in their homes, now have a drought an water shortage..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

==== newer virus/pandemic/bioweapon/inoculation/immunization ====
"..Climate change impacts on West Nile virus transmission.." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4342965/

"..Climate change may worsen spread of West Nile virus.." 2023 https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2023/08/10/west-nile-virus-spread-symptoms/

".. Mar 15, 2023 — West Nile, '''Lyme, and other diseases''' are on the rise with climate change " https://www.statnews.com/2023/03/15/climate-change-diseases-west-nile-dengue-lyme/

"..Klaus Schwab stresses the importance of protecting against "a new virus possibly, or other risks which we have on the global agenda" and climate change. Those journalists who don't critically report on the WEF mafia are complicit. 1984 is real... " feb 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1622480961723338752?s=20

"..the individual responsible for enabling this 'plandemic' through PCR test fraud is now warning of a new virus and attributing it to climate change..." may 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1655234854735208449?s=20

==== more treaties, free trade agreements ====
"Dr. Meryl Nass explains how the WHO's proposed pandemic treaty will enable the WHO "to take over jurisdiction of everything in the world by saying that climate change,.. animals, plants, water systems [and] ecosystems are all central to health". In addition to that, it will remove human rights protections, enforce censorship and digital passports,.." Feb 2024 https://x.com/stephiereine/status/1755323524879622276?s=20 quote above also from 4hour video "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MrIsXDKrtE International Covid Summit III part 2 European Parliament, Brussels]"

Canada ukraine FT/carbon clause

"..It’s cuz Trudeau rammed in a carbon tax amendment into a pre-existing deal. If this deal does not pass, nothing happens. We already have a free trade agreement.." February 2024 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1755618090510164380?s=20

==== more taxes, more inflation, lower gdp ====
"..Stephen Guilbeault becomes completely unhinged and accuses those who don't believe his Climate Plan as deniers while repeating propaganda of how carbon tax makes life more affordable. As a Canadian, how sick are you of the psychopathic Liberal Govt?.. " 2024 February https://x.com/govt_corrupt/status/1754994957260103818?s=20

==== concept of 'carbon footprint', tracking and restricting movement, purchases ====
"The Canadian Alibaba Group president J. Michael Evans boasts at the World Economic Forum about developing an individual carbon footprint tracker to monitor what you buy, what you eat, and where/how you travel. That individual carbon footprint tracker, however, most likely won't….. " 2023 February https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1629986426392842240?s=20

"So of course - in 15-minute cities - it would be up to the “consumer”, on how they chose to use their rationed carbon credits for travel <insert sarcasm> " August 2023 https://x.com/RWMaloneMD/status/1697280037613867008?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized for using a reliable Natural Gas Furnace, an having water meters in their homes, ..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T02:54:34Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views ==
=== Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy ===
* "Nobel Laureate: “Climate science has metastasized into massive shock-journalistic pseudoscience"
** ".Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, has criticized the climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's economy and the well-being of billions of people."." , Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics,, https://twitter.com/tlloydjones/status/1679446611364134914 https://gript.ie/nobel-laureate-climate-science-has-metastasized-into-massive-shock-journalistic-pseudoscience/
* "..The climate garbage is ramping up. I have studied it since 2005. - the temperature data is manipulated, no evidence of an increase - the CO2 rise is not due to fossil fuel burning, it's a planet!.." October 2022 https://x.com/denisrancourt/status/1581048532860948480?s=20

* "This insane climate extremist believes he can control the weather. And he wants you to believe it as well..." video, 2023 https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1689734767829233664?s=20
Causes, failed policy, forest management, law enforcement
*"..Climate Change = scapegoat for gov't policy failure. Canada's PM Trudeau & US pols use it all the time..." https://x.com/ClimateScam/status/1668271992183697410?s=20

=== Scapegoats ===

==== Carbon emissions, deforestation ====

==== Farming , meat consumption blamed for (Carbon emissions and deforestation) ====
"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..War on cow gas is stinky but necessary job in climate-.." 2023 march https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/war-cow-farts-is-stinky-necessary-job-2023-03-24/

".. Northern Ireland will need to '''lose more than 1 million sheep''' and cattle to meet its new legally binding climate emissions targets .." April 2022 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/apr/22/northern-ireland-faces-loss-of-1-million-sheep-and-cattle-to-meet-climate-targets

" Farmers in the Netherlands have been staging protests over emissions reduction targets since October 2019. .." 2023 November https://www.euronews.com/green/2023/11/30/dutch-farmers-could-be-paid-to-close-their-livestock-farms-under-new-scheme

"Carbon emissions could be a scapegoat used to distract us from looking into other possible reasons of what's damaging our atmosphere." February 2023, https://x.com/kurgatkogeyben/status/1626455056819036162?s=20
* "Red meat used as scapegoat in carbon emissions debate" 2019 https://www.farminguk.com/news/red-meat-used-as-scapegoat-in-carbon-emissions-debate_54508.html
* ".. When you start cutting the '''carbon''' credits pie, remember '''Irish farmers have skin''' in the '''game''' .." 2021
** https://x.com/gpse7en/status/1416856901439180807?s=20
** https://www.independent.ie/opinion/letters/when-you-start-cutting-the-carbon-credits-pie-remember-irish-farmers-have-skin-in-the-game/40663670.html
* "..Geologist Ian Plimer has criticised the move for Ireland to cull 200,000 head of cattle in a bold effort to meet climate targets..." 2023 December https://x.com/newstart_2024/status/1734092664629256533?s=20
* "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20
* see also Farmer protests: Netherlands, France, Germany..

==== Wildfires, smoke causes, influencers: arson vs climate change ====
"The astounding absurdity of a man arguing climate tax will .... prevent forest fires ignited through arson is not only extremely dangerous to Canada but worthy of a psychological evaluation". 2023 1min video https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1665803489316945920?s=20

"500 out of 650 fires in Alberta were caused by humans. We need to extricate the climate fear narrative from the claws of the climate alarmists. And we need better forest management & as well as more fire fighting equipment." 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1695174332350353875?s=20

"ALL 46 forest fires on Vancouver Island this year were caused by humans. Who wants to bet that the climate alarmists are insane enough to start a fire just so they can blame it on climate change?" 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1673876404340162561?s=20

Politicians: "these fires because of climate change"
* "these fires"
** "because of climate change"
*** “We’re seeing more and more of these fires because of climate change,” Trudeau posted on June 7. “These fires are affecting everyday routines, lives and livelihoods, and our air quality. We’ll keep working – here at home and with partners around the world – to tackle climate change and address its impacts.”
** Politicians always have lots to say about wildfires ..., 2023
*** https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/warmington-politicians-always-have-lots-to-say-about-wildfires-except-when-arson-charges-laid
**** One man charged-connected to numerous fires
***** Quebec police have charged a 37-year-old man with arson in connection with what the CBC reports as “numerous forest fires that burned earlier this summer in the province’s north.”
**** Catching arsonists not easy, resource intense, specialists teamwork
***** "Catching Paré was no easy task. Sûreté du Québec Sgt. Hugues Beaulieu told CBC detectives received help from “behaviour analysis experts, criminal profilers and forensic psychologists”

==== weather extremes, records, mild winter, winter 2024 Ontario ====
".. Winter never Really started!! We have had a few mild ones now..." 2023 Feb https://x.com/jamie_blom/status/1621465810182045697?s=20

"..Does Climate "boiling" mean we are going to have a mild winter?.." 2023 https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1689230762481012736?s=20

*

=== ''Useful as a distraction'' ===

==== Ignore yesterday's manipulations of environment and atmosphere ====
"..Anybody know the last time it rained in Feb in Calgary??? Chemtrails are working..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/TheoFleury14/status/1753916919462367664?s=20

"..Chemtrails in Calgary are the real deal and it’s on the record. I have a ton of Canadian documents that show Alberta is heavily sprayed and regularly. Anyone can get them by filing a ATIA at the Ministry of Environmental under the Weather Modification Regulations Act..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/offgridstone/status/1754003999538532576?s=20

"..Can we pay carbon tax to stop the chemtrail spraying?.." https://x.com/WeaponizedNews/status/1753891976787935314?s=20

"..Chemtrails are more prevalent in Northern latitudes. #ClimateScam Zoom In for normal contrails and remnant of earlier Chemtrail..." feb 2024 https://x.com/allthewayjumper/status/1753150996782477377?s=20

"..climate hysteria is to distract from real issues like pollution and toxic dumping.." feb 2024 https://x.com/buzzard89/status/1753099838412230682?s=20

==== Ignore massive increase in all-cause mortality ====
"..Judging by the engagement on this story, [massive increase in all-cause mortality] might be the next big thing to be blamed on climate change.." February 2024, https://x.com/OpenSquirrel/status/1755428139369447661?s=20

==== Ignore recent scandals, avoid holding elite accountable ====
"..Climate alarmists, enabling 'leaders', and globalist elites will destroy civil society attempting to achieve unnecessary unachieveble fabricated targets, and then hold everyone else accountable for their failures..." 2022 https://x.com/JoeTheberge/status/1587680239119130625?s=20

"..#ClimateChange is a scam. It's a slush fund for elites. 1. Will one penny of "carbon credits" be audited? .. 4. Who is accountable for the $$? 5. Transparency?.." 2022 https://x.com/Flight1917/status/1508976967755870209?s=20

"..... hold those accountable to the fullest of the law. Wait, SQUIRREL Climate Change.." February 2024 https://x.com/BobReeves0270/status/1754202289378840859?s=20

=== Excuse for Power changes, power grabs ===

==== Diminish Constitutional Protections, Freedoms, Rights ====
"..DANIELLE SMITH: The targets being put forward by climate minister Gilbeault are arbitrary, not based on data, not based on science, & seem to be plucked out of thin air. They’re unachievable & unconstitutional. He needs to zip it..." Sept 2023 , video https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1697649073787158543?s=20

"Ampeldämmerung: Scholz government in crisis after doubtful budgetary manoeuvre to fund Green climate fantasies with unused Covid funds is declared unconstitutional.." November 2023 https://x.com/eugyppius1/status/1724836975872467081?s=20

"Germany's Constitutional Court has ruled that the country's 2019 climate protection act is in part unconstitutional following a complaint by a coalition of climate activists, including Fridays for Future." https://x.com/GretaThunberg/status/1387815038984015877?s=20

"..Sask: "we maintain that the carbon tax is unconstitutional because the federal government is applying a tax unevenly across the country based on their evaluation of provincial climate change plans, which they have no constitutional right to do" October 2018 https://x.com/nspector4/status/1057630933010935809?s=20

==== shortages: water, food, electricity, medicine, wood.. ====
"The next climate scare job to be unleashed by the environmentalists will be the water shortage. If they can sell the population on the great water shortage man will be at their mercy! They stay awake late, it's just one after another!.." 2023 October https://x.com/yonkojohn/status/1712395911140134956?s=20

"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized ..., the lower mainland Climate Change Bedwetters do not have water meters in their homes, now have a drought an water shortage..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

==== newer virus/pandemic/bioweapon/inoculation/immunization ====
"..Climate change impacts on West Nile virus transmission.." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4342965/

"..Climate change may worsen spread of West Nile virus.." 2023 https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2023/08/10/west-nile-virus-spread-symptoms/

".. Mar 15, 2023 — West Nile, '''Lyme, and other diseases''' are on the rise with climate change " https://www.statnews.com/2023/03/15/climate-change-diseases-west-nile-dengue-lyme/

"..Klaus Schwab stresses the importance of protecting against "a new virus possibly, or other risks which we have on the global agenda" and climate change. Those journalists who don't critically report on the WEF mafia are complicit. 1984 is real... " feb 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1622480961723338752?s=20

"..the individual responsible for enabling this 'plandemic' through PCR test fraud is now warning of a new virus and attributing it to climate change..." may 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1655234854735208449?s=20

==== more treaties, free trade agreements ====
"Dr. Meryl Nass explains how the WHO's proposed pandemic treaty will enable the WHO "to take over jurisdiction of everything in the world by saying that climate change,.. animals, plants, water systems [and] ecosystems are all central to health". In addition to that, it will remove human rights protections, enforce censorship and digital passports,.." Feb 2024 https://x.com/stephiereine/status/1755323524879622276?s=20 quote above also from 4hour video "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MrIsXDKrtE International Covid Summit III part 2 European Parliament, Brussels]"

Canada ukraine FT/carbon clause

"..It’s cuz Trudeau rammed in a carbon tax amendment into a pre-existing deal. If this deal does not pass, nothing happens. We already have a free trade agreement.." February 2024 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1755618090510164380?s=20

==== more taxes, more inflation, lower gdp ====
"..Stephen Guilbeault becomes completely unhinged and accuses those who don't believe his Climate Plan as deniers while repeating propaganda of how carbon tax makes life more affordable. As a Canadian, how sick are you of the psychopathic Liberal Govt?.. " 2024 February https://x.com/govt_corrupt/status/1754994957260103818?s=20

==== concept of 'carbon footprint', tracking and restricting movement, purchases ====
"The Canadian Alibaba Group president J. Michael Evans boasts at the World Economic Forum about developing an individual carbon footprint tracker to monitor what you buy, what you eat, and where/how you travel. That individual carbon footprint tracker, however, most likely won't….. " 2023 February https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1629986426392842240?s=20

"So of course - in 15-minute cities - it would be up to the “consumer”, on how they chose to use their rationed carbon credits for travel <insert sarcasm> " August 2023 https://x.com/RWMaloneMD/status/1697280037613867008?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized for using a reliable Natural Gas Furnace, an having water meters in their homes, ..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T02:53:23Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views ==
=== Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy ===
* "Nobel Laureate: “Climate science has metastasized into massive shock-journalistic pseudoscience"
** ".Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, has criticized the climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's economy and the well-being of billions of people."." , Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics,, https://twitter.com/tlloydjones/status/1679446611364134914 https://gript.ie/nobel-laureate-climate-science-has-metastasized-into-massive-shock-journalistic-pseudoscience/
* "..The climate garbage is ramping up. I have studied it since 2005. - the temperature data is manipulated, no evidence of an increase - the CO2 rise is not due to fossil fuel burning, it's a planet!.." October 2022 https://x.com/denisrancourt/status/1581048532860948480?s=20

* "This insane climate extremist believes he can control the weather. And he wants you to believe it as well..." video, 2023 https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1689734767829233664?s=20
Causes, failed policy, forest management, law enforcement
*"..Climate Change = scapegoat for gov't policy failure. Canada's PM Trudeau & US pols use it all the time..." https://x.com/ClimateScam/status/1668271992183697410?s=20

=== ''Useful as a distraction'' ===

==== Ignore yesterday's manipulations of environment and atmosphere ====
"..Anybody know the last time it rained in Feb in Calgary??? Chemtrails are working..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/TheoFleury14/status/1753916919462367664?s=20

"..Chemtrails in Calgary are the real deal and it’s on the record. I have a ton of Canadian documents that show Alberta is heavily sprayed and regularly. Anyone can get them by filing a ATIA at the Ministry of Environmental under the Weather Modification Regulations Act..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/offgridstone/status/1754003999538532576?s=20

"..Can we pay carbon tax to stop the chemtrail spraying?.." https://x.com/WeaponizedNews/status/1753891976787935314?s=20

"..Chemtrails are more prevalent in Northern latitudes. #ClimateScam Zoom In for normal contrails and remnant of earlier Chemtrail..." feb 2024 https://x.com/allthewayjumper/status/1753150996782477377?s=20

"..climate hysteria is to distract from real issues like pollution and toxic dumping.." feb 2024 https://x.com/buzzard89/status/1753099838412230682?s=20

==== Ignore massive increase in all-cause mortality ====
"..Judging by the engagement on this story, [massive increase in all-cause mortality] might be the next big thing to be blamed on climate change.." February 2024, https://x.com/OpenSquirrel/status/1755428139369447661?s=20

==== Ignore recent scandals, avoid holding elite accountable ====
"..Climate alarmists, enabling 'leaders', and globalist elites will destroy civil society attempting to achieve unnecessary unachieveble fabricated targets, and then hold everyone else accountable for their failures..." 2022 https://x.com/JoeTheberge/status/1587680239119130625?s=20

"..#ClimateChange is a scam. It's a slush fund for elites. 1. Will one penny of "carbon credits" be audited? .. 4. Who is accountable for the $$? 5. Transparency?.." 2022 https://x.com/Flight1917/status/1508976967755870209?s=20

"..... hold those accountable to the fullest of the law. Wait, SQUIRREL Climate Change.." February 2024 https://x.com/BobReeves0270/status/1754202289378840859?s=20

=== Excuse for Power changes, power grabs ===

==== Diminish Constitutional Protections, Freedoms, Rights ====
"..DANIELLE SMITH: The targets being put forward by climate minister Gilbeault are arbitrary, not based on data, not based on science, & seem to be plucked out of thin air. They’re unachievable & unconstitutional. He needs to zip it..." Sept 2023 , video https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1697649073787158543?s=20

"Ampeldämmerung: Scholz government in crisis after doubtful budgetary manoeuvre to fund Green climate fantasies with unused Covid funds is declared unconstitutional.." November 2023 https://x.com/eugyppius1/status/1724836975872467081?s=20

"Germany's Constitutional Court has ruled that the country's 2019 climate protection act is in part unconstitutional following a complaint by a coalition of climate activists, including Fridays for Future." https://x.com/GretaThunberg/status/1387815038984015877?s=20

"..Sask: "we maintain that the carbon tax is unconstitutional because the federal government is applying a tax unevenly across the country based on their evaluation of provincial climate change plans, which they have no constitutional right to do" October 2018 https://x.com/nspector4/status/1057630933010935809?s=20

==== shortages: water, food, electricity, medicine, wood.. ====
"The next climate scare job to be unleashed by the environmentalists will be the water shortage. If they can sell the population on the great water shortage man will be at their mercy! They stay awake late, it's just one after another!.." 2023 October https://x.com/yonkojohn/status/1712395911140134956?s=20

"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized ..., the lower mainland Climate Change Bedwetters do not have water meters in their homes, now have a drought an water shortage..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

==== newer virus/pandemic/bioweapon/inoculation/immunization ====
"..Climate change impacts on West Nile virus transmission.." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4342965/

"..Climate change may worsen spread of West Nile virus.." 2023 https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2023/08/10/west-nile-virus-spread-symptoms/

".. Mar 15, 2023 — West Nile, '''Lyme, and other diseases''' are on the rise with climate change " https://www.statnews.com/2023/03/15/climate-change-diseases-west-nile-dengue-lyme/

"..Klaus Schwab stresses the importance of protecting against "a new virus possibly, or other risks which we have on the global agenda" and climate change. Those journalists who don't critically report on the WEF mafia are complicit. 1984 is real... " feb 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1622480961723338752?s=20

"..the individual responsible for enabling this 'plandemic' through PCR test fraud is now warning of a new virus and attributing it to climate change..." may 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1655234854735208449?s=20

==== more treaties, free trade agreements ====
"Dr. Meryl Nass explains how the WHO's proposed pandemic treaty will enable the WHO "to take over jurisdiction of everything in the world by saying that climate change,.. animals, plants, water systems [and] ecosystems are all central to health". In addition to that, it will remove human rights protections, enforce censorship and digital passports,.." Feb 2024 https://x.com/stephiereine/status/1755323524879622276?s=20 quote above also from 4hour video "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MrIsXDKrtE International Covid Summit III part 2 European Parliament, Brussels]"

Canada ukraine FT/carbon clause

"..It’s cuz Trudeau rammed in a carbon tax amendment into a pre-existing deal. If this deal does not pass, nothing happens. We already have a free trade agreement.." February 2024 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1755618090510164380?s=20

==== more taxes, more inflation, lower gdp ====
"..Stephen Guilbeault becomes completely unhinged and accuses those who don't believe his Climate Plan as deniers while repeating propaganda of how carbon tax makes life more affordable. As a Canadian, how sick are you of the psychopathic Liberal Govt?.. " 2024 February https://x.com/govt_corrupt/status/1754994957260103818?s=20

==== concept of 'carbon footprint', tracking and restricting movement, purchases ====
"The Canadian Alibaba Group president J. Michael Evans boasts at the World Economic Forum about developing an individual carbon footprint tracker to monitor what you buy, what you eat, and where/how you travel. That individual carbon footprint tracker, however, most likely won't….. " 2023 February https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1629986426392842240?s=20

"So of course - in 15-minute cities - it would be up to the “consumer”, on how they chose to use their rationed carbon credits for travel <insert sarcasm> " August 2023 https://x.com/RWMaloneMD/status/1697280037613867008?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized for using a reliable Natural Gas Furnace, an having water meters in their homes, ..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

=== Scapegoats ===

==== Carbon emissions, deforestation ====

==== Farming , meat consumption blamed for (Carbon emissions and deforestation) ====
"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..War on cow gas is stinky but necessary job in climate-.." 2023 march https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/war-cow-farts-is-stinky-necessary-job-2023-03-24/

".. Northern Ireland will need to '''lose more than 1 million sheep''' and cattle to meet its new legally binding climate emissions targets .." April 2022 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/apr/22/northern-ireland-faces-loss-of-1-million-sheep-and-cattle-to-meet-climate-targets

" Farmers in the Netherlands have been staging protests over emissions reduction targets since October 2019. .." 2023 November https://www.euronews.com/green/2023/11/30/dutch-farmers-could-be-paid-to-close-their-livestock-farms-under-new-scheme

"Carbon emissions could be a scapegoat used to distract us from looking into other possible reasons of what's damaging our atmosphere." February 2023, https://x.com/kurgatkogeyben/status/1626455056819036162?s=20
* "Red meat used as scapegoat in carbon emissions debate" 2019 https://www.farminguk.com/news/red-meat-used-as-scapegoat-in-carbon-emissions-debate_54508.html
* ".. When you start cutting the '''carbon''' credits pie, remember '''Irish farmers have skin''' in the '''game''' .." 2021
** https://x.com/gpse7en/status/1416856901439180807?s=20
** https://www.independent.ie/opinion/letters/when-you-start-cutting-the-carbon-credits-pie-remember-irish-farmers-have-skin-in-the-game/40663670.html
* "..Geologist Ian Plimer has criticised the move for Ireland to cull 200,000 head of cattle in a bold effort to meet climate targets..." 2023 December https://x.com/newstart_2024/status/1734092664629256533?s=20
* "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20
* see also Farmer protests: Netherlands, France, Germany..

==== Wildfires, smoke causes, influencers: arson vs climate change ====
"The astounding absurdity of a man arguing climate tax will .... prevent forest fires ignited through arson is not only extremely dangerous to Canada but worthy of a psychological evaluation". 2023 1min video https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1665803489316945920?s=20

"500 out of 650 fires in Alberta were caused by humans. We need to extricate the climate fear narrative from the claws of the climate alarmists. And we need better forest management & as well as more fire fighting equipment." 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1695174332350353875?s=20

"ALL 46 forest fires on Vancouver Island this year were caused by humans. Who wants to bet that the climate alarmists are insane enough to start a fire just so they can blame it on climate change?" 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1673876404340162561?s=20

Politicians: "these fires because of climate change"
* "these fires"
** "because of climate change"
*** “We’re seeing more and more of these fires because of climate change,” Trudeau posted on June 7. “These fires are affecting everyday routines, lives and livelihoods, and our air quality. We’ll keep working – here at home and with partners around the world – to tackle climate change and address its impacts.”
** Politicians always have lots to say about wildfires ..., 2023
*** https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/warmington-politicians-always-have-lots-to-say-about-wildfires-except-when-arson-charges-laid
**** One man charged-connected to numerous fires
***** Quebec police have charged a 37-year-old man with arson in connection with what the CBC reports as “numerous forest fires that burned earlier this summer in the province’s north.”
**** Catching arsonists not easy, resource intense, specialists teamwork
***** "Catching Paré was no easy task. Sûreté du Québec Sgt. Hugues Beaulieu told CBC detectives received help from “behaviour analysis experts, criminal profilers and forensic psychologists”

==== weather extremes, records, mild winter, winter 2024 Ontario ====
".. Winter never Really started!! We have had a few mild ones now..." 2023 Feb https://x.com/jamie_blom/status/1621465810182045697?s=20

"..Does Climate "boiling" mean we are going to have a mild winter?.." 2023 https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1689230762481012736?s=20

*

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T02:47:46Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views ==
=== Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy ===
* "Nobel Laureate: “Climate science has metastasized into massive shock-journalistic pseudoscience"
** ".Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics, has criticized the climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's economy and the well-being of billions of people."." , Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics,, https://twitter.com/tlloydjones/status/1679446611364134914 https://gript.ie/nobel-laureate-climate-science-has-metastasized-into-massive-shock-journalistic-pseudoscience/
* "..The climate garbage is ramping up. I have studied it since 2005. - the temperature data is manipulated, no evidence of an increase - the CO2 rise is not due to fossil fuel burning, it's a planet!.." October 2022 https://x.com/denisrancourt/status/1581048532860948480?s=20

* "This insane climate extremist believes he can control the weather. And he wants you to believe it as well..." video, 2023 https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1689734767829233664?s=20
Causes, failed policy, forest management, law enforcement
*"..Climate Change = scapegoat for gov't policy failure. Canada's PM Trudeau & US pols use it all the time..." https://x.com/ClimateScam/status/1668271992183697410?s=20

=== ''Useful as a distraction'' ===

==== Ignore yesterday's manipulations of environment and atmosphere ====
"..Anybody know the last time it rained in Feb in Calgary??? Chemtrails are working..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/TheoFleury14/status/1753916919462367664?s=20

"..Chemtrails in Calgary are the real deal and it’s on the record. I have a ton of Canadian documents that show Alberta is heavily sprayed and regularly. Anyone can get them by filing a ATIA at the Ministry of Environmental under the Weather Modification Regulations Act..." Feb 2024 https://x.com/offgridstone/status/1754003999538532576?s=20

"..Can we pay carbon tax to stop the chemtrail spraying?.." https://x.com/WeaponizedNews/status/1753891976787935314?s=20

"..Chemtrails are more prevalent in Northern latitudes. #ClimateScam Zoom In for normal contrails and remnant of earlier Chemtrail..." feb 2024 https://x.com/allthewayjumper/status/1753150996782477377?s=20

"..climate hysteria is to distract from real issues like pollution and toxic dumping.." feb 2024 https://x.com/buzzard89/status/1753099838412230682?s=20

==== Ignore massive increase in all-cause mortality ====
"..Judging by the engagement on this story, [massive increase in all-cause mortality] might be the next big thing to be blamed on climate change.." February 2024, https://x.com/OpenSquirrel/status/1755428139369447661?s=20

==== Ignore recent scandals, avoid holding elite accountable ====
"..Climate alarmists, enabling 'leaders', and globalist elites will destroy civil society attempting to achieve unnecessary unachieveble fabricated targets, and then hold everyone else accountable for their failures..." 2022 https://x.com/JoeTheberge/status/1587680239119130625?s=20

"..#ClimateChange is a scam. It's a slush fund for elites. 1. Will one penny of "carbon credits" be audited? .. 4. Who is accountable for the $$? 5. Transparency?.." 2022 https://x.com/Flight1917/status/1508976967755870209?s=20

"..... hold those accountable to the fullest of the law. Wait, SQUIRREL Climate Change.." February 2024 https://x.com/BobReeves0270/status/1754202289378840859?s=20

=== Excuse for Power changes, power grabs ===

==== Diminish of Constitutional Protections, Freedoms, Rights ====
"..DANIELLE SMITH: The targets being put forward by climate minister Gilbeault are arbitrary, not based on data, not based on science, & seem to be plucked out of thin air. They’re unachievable & unconstitutional. He needs to zip it..." Sept 2023 , video https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1697649073787158543?s=20

"Ampeldämmerung: Scholz government in crisis after doubtful budgetary manoeuvre to fund Green climate fantasies with unused Covid funds is declared unconstitutional.." November 2023 https://x.com/eugyppius1/status/1724836975872467081?s=20

"Germany's Constitutional Court has ruled that the country's 2019 climate protection act is in part unconstitutional following a complaint by a coalition of climate activists, including Fridays for Future." https://x.com/GretaThunberg/status/1387815038984015877?s=20

"..Sask: "we maintain that the carbon tax is unconstitutional because the federal government is applying a tax unevenly across the country based on their evaluation of provincial climate change plans, which they have no constitutional right to do" October 2018 https://x.com/nspector4/status/1057630933010935809?s=20

==== shortages: water, food, electricity, medicine, wood.. ====
"The next climate scare job to be unleashed by the environmentalists will be the water shortage. If they can sell the population on the great water shortage man will be at their mercy! They stay awake late, it's just one after another!.." 2023 October https://x.com/yonkojohn/status/1712395911140134956?s=20

"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized ..., the lower mainland Climate Change Bedwetters do not have water meters in their homes, now have a drought an water shortage..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

==== newer virus/pandemic/bioweapon/inoculation/immunization ====
"..Climate change impacts on West Nile virus transmission.." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4342965/

"..Climate change may worsen spread of West Nile virus.." 2023 https://www.washingtonpost.com/health/2023/08/10/west-nile-virus-spread-symptoms/

".. Mar 15, 2023 — West Nile, '''Lyme, and other diseases''' are on the rise with climate change " https://www.statnews.com/2023/03/15/climate-change-diseases-west-nile-dengue-lyme/

"..Klaus Schwab stresses the importance of protecting against "a new virus possibly, or other risks which we have on the global agenda" and climate change. Those journalists who don't critically report on the WEF mafia are complicit. 1984 is real... " feb 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1622480961723338752?s=20

"..the individual responsible for enabling this 'plandemic' through PCR test fraud is now warning of a new virus and attributing it to climate change..." may 2023 https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1655234854735208449?s=20

==== more treaties, free trade agreements ====
"Dr. Meryl Nass explains how the WHO's proposed pandemic treaty will enable the WHO "to take over jurisdiction of everything in the world by saying that climate change,.. animals, plants, water systems [and] ecosystems are all central to health". In addition to that, it will remove human rights protections, enforce censorship and digital passports,.." Feb 2024 https://x.com/stephiereine/status/1755323524879622276?s=20 quote above also from 4hour video "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4MrIsXDKrtE International Covid Summit III part 2 European Parliament, Brussels]"

Canada ukraine FT/carbon clause

"..It’s cuz Trudeau rammed in a carbon tax amendment into a pre-existing deal. If this deal does not pass, nothing happens. We already have a free trade agreement.." February 2024 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1755618090510164380?s=20

==== more taxes, more inflation, lower gdp ====
"..Stephen Guilbeault becomes completely unhinged and accuses those who don't believe his Climate Plan as deniers while repeating propaganda of how carbon tax makes life more affordable. As a Canadian, how sick are you of the psychopathic Liberal Govt?.. " 2024 February https://x.com/govt_corrupt/status/1754994957260103818?s=20

==== concept of 'carbon footprint', tracking and restricting movement, purchases ====
"The Canadian Alibaba Group president J. Michael Evans boasts at the World Economic Forum about developing an individual carbon footprint tracker to monitor what you buy, what you eat, and where/how you travel. That individual carbon footprint tracker, however, most likely won't….. " 2023 February https://x.com/goddeketal/status/1629986426392842240?s=20

"So of course - in 15-minute cities - it would be up to the “consumer”, on how they chose to use their rationed carbon credits for travel <insert sarcasm> " August 2023 https://x.com/RWMaloneMD/status/1697280037613867008?s=20

"..So as the North in BC are penalized for using a reliable Natural Gas Furnace, an having water meters in their homes, ..." October 2022 https://x.com/Northerngold01/status/1582326561872936966?s=20

=== Scapegoats ===

==== Carbon emissions, deforestation ====

==== Farming , meat consumption blamed for (Carbon emissions and deforestation) ====
"..Same is happening in Germany - our covid-crazed health minister .. is by now mixing up pandemics with climate and meat consumption and water shortage..." March 2022 https://x.com/HulludieWaldfae/status/1503517257795780616?s=20

"..War on cow gas is stinky but necessary job in climate-.." 2023 march https://www.reuters.com/breakingviews/war-cow-farts-is-stinky-necessary-job-2023-03-24/

".. Northern Ireland will need to '''lose more than 1 million sheep''' and cattle to meet its new legally binding climate emissions targets .." April 2022 https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/apr/22/northern-ireland-faces-loss-of-1-million-sheep-and-cattle-to-meet-climate-targets

" Farmers in the Netherlands have been staging protests over emissions reduction targets since October 2019. .." 2023 November https://www.euronews.com/green/2023/11/30/dutch-farmers-could-be-paid-to-close-their-livestock-farms-under-new-scheme

"Carbon emissions could be a scapegoat used to distract us from looking into other possible reasons of what's damaging our atmosphere." February 2023, https://x.com/kurgatkogeyben/status/1626455056819036162?s=20
* "Red meat used as scapegoat in carbon emissions debate" 2019 https://www.farminguk.com/news/red-meat-used-as-scapegoat-in-carbon-emissions-debate_54508.html
* ".. When you start cutting the '''carbon''' credits pie, remember '''Irish farmers have skin''' in the '''game''' .." 2021
** https://x.com/gpse7en/status/1416856901439180807?s=20
** https://www.independent.ie/opinion/letters/when-you-start-cutting-the-carbon-credits-pie-remember-irish-farmers-have-skin-in-the-game/40663670.html
* "..Geologist Ian Plimer has criticised the move for Ireland to cull 200,000 head of cattle in a bold effort to meet climate targets..." 2023 December https://x.com/newstart_2024/status/1734092664629256533?s=20
* "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20
* see also Farmer protests: Netherlands, France, Germany..

==== Wildfires, smoke causes, influencers: arson vs climate change ====
"The astounding absurdity of a man arguing climate tax will .... prevent forest fires ignited through arson is not only extremely dangerous to Canada but worthy of a psychological evaluation". 2023 1min video https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1665803489316945920?s=20

"500 out of 650 fires in Alberta were caused by humans. We need to extricate the climate fear narrative from the claws of the climate alarmists. And we need better forest management & as well as more fire fighting equipment." 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1695174332350353875?s=20

"ALL 46 forest fires on Vancouver Island this year were caused by humans. Who wants to bet that the climate alarmists are insane enough to start a fire just so they can blame it on climate change?" 2023 https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1673876404340162561?s=20

Politicians: "these fires because of climate change"
* "these fires"
** "because of climate change"
*** “We’re seeing more and more of these fires because of climate change,” Trudeau posted on June 7. “These fires are affecting everyday routines, lives and livelihoods, and our air quality. We’ll keep working – here at home and with partners around the world – to tackle climate change and address its impacts.”
** Politicians always have lots to say about wildfires ..., 2023
*** https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/warmington-politicians-always-have-lots-to-say-about-wildfires-except-when-arson-charges-laid
**** One man charged-connected to numerous fires
***** Quebec police have charged a 37-year-old man with arson in connection with what the CBC reports as “numerous forest fires that burned earlier this summer in the province’s north.”
**** Catching arsonists not easy, resource intense, specialists teamwork
***** "Catching Paré was no easy task. Sûreté du Québec Sgt. Hugues Beaulieu told CBC detectives received help from “behaviour analysis experts, criminal profilers and forensic psychologists”

==== weather extremes, records, mild winter, winter 2024 Ontario ====
".. Winter never Really started!! We have had a few mild ones now..." 2023 Feb https://x.com/jamie_blom/status/1621465810182045697?s=20

"..Does Climate "boiling" mean we are going to have a mild winter?.." 2023 https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1689230762481012736?s=20

*

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T00:34:01Z

Fallandtrip: /* Hold(ing) elite accountable */

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T00:32:40Z

Fallandtrip:

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T00:31:36Z

Fallandtrip:

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T00:30:42Z

Fallandtrip:

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-10T00:30:21Z

Fallandtrip:

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-09T14:39:58Z

Fallandtrip: more readable

Data:ClimateScam, Critical Opinions

2024-02-07T22:28:10Z

Fallandtrip: Created page with "== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views == === A Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy === * "..climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous cor..."

== Data: Climate Change, Critical Views ==

=== A Dangerous narrative threatens wellbeing of billions, economy ===
* "..climate emergency narrative calling it "a dangerous corruption of science that threatens the world's economy and the well-being of billions of people.".." , Dr John F Clauser, joint recipient of the 2022 Nobel Prize in Physics,, https://twitter.com/tlloydjones/status/1679446611364134914

=== Caused by failed policy ===

==== ''useful as a distraction, diversion, squirrel'' ====
* Failed policy
** "..Climate Change = scapegoat for gov't policy failure. Canada's PM Trudeau & US pols use it all the time..." https://x.com/ClimateScam/status/1668271992183697410?s=20

=== Excuse for Power changes, power grabs ===
*From CINOs and the Left

==== Relaxation and diminishing of Constitutional Rights and protections ====

==== shortages: water, food, electricity, medicine, wood.. ====

==== newer virus/pandemic/bioweapon/inoculation/immunization ====

==== more treaties, free trade agreements ====

==== more taxes, more inflation, lower gdp ====

==== more passport changes, surveillance, ====

==== tracking and restricting purchases, online activity ====

==== concept of 'carbon footprint', incentives/rewards programs ====
** for micromanaging 'carbon'
** justice changes
*** reducing jailtime for car theft
** transporation market
*** rising car insurance costs,
*** tracking movement,
** leninism,cultural marxism,
** water shortages,
** "War on freedom/sovereignty "

=== Scapegoats ===
* search data https://twitter.com/search?q=%23ClimateScam%20scapegoat&src=typed_query&f=top

==== livestock: restrictions on animals, pets ====
*** "... climate change activists are coming for your pets. There are rumblings but just watch- ..", 2022, https://x.com/TheYouthsCat1/status/1608504963638120449?s=20
*** see also Farmer protests: Netherlands, France, Germany..

==== weather extremes, records, mild winter, winter 2024 Ontario ====

==== weather manipulated, multiple times, illusion of cause and effect, as excuse for the above ====
* could be framed as
** seasonal record,
** ''cause summer dryness water shortages or fires''
***

==== carbon emissions ====
* Carbon emissions could be a scapegoat used to distract us from looking into other possible reasons of what's damaging our atmosphere. February 2023, https://x.com/kurgatkogeyben/status/1626455056819036162?s=20

==== smoke --arson reports: huge fires often known to be from arson ====

===== Politicians: "these fires because of climate change" =====
* "these fires"
** "because of climate change"
*** “We’re seeing more and more of these fires because of climate change,” Trudeau posted on June 7. “These fires are affecting everyday routines, lives and livelihoods, and our air quality. We’ll keep working – here at home and with partners around the world – to tackle climate change and address its impacts.”
** Politicians always have lots to say about wildfires ..., 2023
*** https://torontosun.com/opinion/columnists/warmington-politicians-always-have-lots-to-say-about-wildfires-except-when-arson-charges-laid
**** One man charged-connected to numerous fires
***** Quebec police have charged a 37-year-old man with arson in connection with what the CBC reports as “numerous forest fires that burned earlier this summer in the province’s north.”
**** Catching arsonists not easy, resource intense, specialists teamwork
***** "Catching Paré was no easy task. Sûreté du Québec Sgt. Hugues Beaulieu told CBC detectives received help from “behaviour analysis experts, criminal profilers and forensic psychologists”

Data: Why suspicious jab

2024-02-06T01:01:11Z

Fallandtrip:

== <big>"Why suspicious jab" -- Sample of opinions</big> ==

=== Unsatisfied by advice from sick jabbed people ===

* Last month a double-jabbed friend who got Covid from his double-jabbed wife (one gave Covid to their double-jabbed son) urged me to have jabs. Last week a triple-vaxxed friend whose entire triple-jabbed family got Covid gave the same advice, which I politely, responsibly, ignore. , 2022 https://x.com/CliffEdge19/status/1481724106416566280?s=20

=== Underwhelmed by Government's conflicts of interest for sources of info on jab safety ===
* It doesn’t really inspire confidence that the sources of info on vaccine safety are Big Pharma and the government. 2021, https://twitter.com/LisaMarieBoothe/status/1428419183272992771

=== Reports of On-field heart problems ===
* reported heart issues
** gaslighting
*** "loads of heart issues, its in their heads"..
**** Very frustrating tone to this article, presented as though its in their heads & theres no connection, basically focusing on people being suspicious of the jab, rather than focus on why since the huge jab uptakes has there been loads of heart issues.. , 2021, https://x.com/Centrefuter/status/1474286680488259585?s=20
***** links to athlete-gaslighting articles
****** https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/sportsnews/article-10339755/Premier-League-field-heart-issues-fuelled-suspicion-Covid-vaccines-players.html
****** Times https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/22/sports/soccer/premier-league-coronavirus-vaccine.html?referringSource=articleShare

=== Scam-factor ===
* On the last day they even offered me 500 dollars to stay and take the vaccine. That just made me even more hella suspicious. And confirmed my decision to not take the jab. Why would any Corp give out 500 to take the jab? Also I'm not anti vaxx. I'm anti scams, 2021, https://x.com/cash_override/status/1459156130668679171?s=20

=== Forcing Jab ===

==== Already immune ====
* Why is the world coercing people who already had the disease and have antibodies and/or T-cell immunity, into getting a jab? 2021, https://x.com/CCollated/status/1405809110914945028?s=20

==== High survivability ====
* for an infectious process with such high survivability
** tweets quoting deleted tweets
*** Desperation
**** Desperation kicking in for jabs and I leave it at this why are they going full throttle to jab and trying to discriminate against unjabbed very fucking suspicious , 2021, https://x.com/durhamsafc1994/status/1421610912763596801?s=20
*** Covid jab? Very suspicious…. Why the need for a story? 2021 https://x.com/tim_hidden/status/1433198388636381187?s=20
** I mean the forcing of this jab for an infectious process with such high survivability- there is a reason why people are hesitant! Did we see this sort of campaign for flu? It’s suspicious to want a needle in every arm for this. Red flags should go up everywhere! https://x.com/Fynnderella1/status/1417878422156681227?s=20

=== Population control, recent quotes, Boris Johnson ===
* (2007) ( pic,/ population control quotation) I wonder why anyone would be suspicious of this jab. https://x.com/JohnDra93154435/status/1353653149299568641?s=20
*

Data: Why suspicious jab

2024-02-06T00:47:04Z

Fallandtrip:

== <big>"Why suspicious jab" -- Sample of opinions</big> ==

=== Unsatisfied by advice from others ===

* Last month a double-jabbed friend who got Covid from his double-jabbed wife (one gave Covid to their double-jabbed son) urged me to have jabs. Last week a triple-vaxxed friend whose entire triple-jabbed family got Covid gave the same advice, which I politely, responsibly, ignore. , 2022 https://x.com/CliffEdge19/status/1481724106416566280?s=20

=== Underwhelmed by Government's conflicts of interest for sources of info on jab safety ===
* It doesn’t really inspire confidence that the sources of info on vaccine safety are Big Pharma and the government. 2021, https://twitter.com/LisaMarieBoothe/status/1428419183272992771

=== Reports of On-field heart problems ===
* reported heart issues
** gaslighting
*** "loads of heart issues, its in their heads"..
**** Very frustrating tone to this article, presented as though its in their heads & theres no connection, basically focusing on people being suspicious of the jab, rather than focus on why since the huge jab uptakes has there been loads of heart issues.. , 2021, https://x.com/Centrefuter/status/1474286680488259585?s=20
***** links to athlete-gaslighting articles
****** https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/sportsnews/article-10339755/Premier-League-field-heart-issues-fuelled-suspicion-Covid-vaccines-players.html
****** Times https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/22/sports/soccer/premier-league-coronavirus-vaccine.html?referringSource=articleShare

=== Scam-factor ===
* On the last day they even offered me 500 dollars to stay and take the vaccine. That just made me even more hella suspicious. And confirmed my decision to not take the jab. Why would any Corp give out 500 to take the jab? Also I'm not anti vaxx. I'm anti scams, 2021, https://x.com/cash_override/status/1459156130668679171?s=20

=== Forcing Jab ===

==== Already immune ====
* Why is the world coercing people who already had the disease and have antibodies and/or T-cell immunity, into getting a jab? 2021, https://x.com/CCollated/status/1405809110914945028?s=20

==== High survivability ====
* for an infectious process with such high survivability
** tweets quoting deleted tweets
*** Desperation
**** Desperation kicking in for jabs and I leave it at this why are they going full throttle to jab and trying to discriminate against unjabbed very fucking suspicious , 2021, https://x.com/durhamsafc1994/status/1421610912763596801?s=20
*** Covid jab? Very suspicious…. Why the need for a story? 2021 https://x.com/tim_hidden/status/1433198388636381187?s=20
** I mean the forcing of this jab for an infectious process with such high survivability- there is a reason why people are hesitant! Did we see this sort of campaign for flu? It’s suspicious to want a needle in every arm for this. Red flags should go up everywhere! https://x.com/Fynnderella1/status/1417878422156681227?s=20

=== Population control, recent quotes, Boris Johnson ===
* (2007) ( pic,/ population control quotation) I wonder why anyone would be suspicious of this jab. https://x.com/JohnDra93154435/status/1353653149299568641?s=20
*

Data: Why suspicious jab

2024-02-06T00:41:10Z

Fallandtrip: Opinion poll data sample, marginally biased.

== <big>"Why suspicious jab"</big> ==

=== Unsatisfied by advice from others ===

* Last month a double-jabbed friend who got Covid from his double-jabbed wife (one gave Covid to their double-jabbed son) urged me to have jabs. Last week a triple-vaxxed friend whose entire triple-jabbed family got Covid gave the same advice, which I politely, responsibly, ignore. , 2022 https://x.com/CliffEdge19/status/1481724106416566280?s=20

=== Underwhelmed by Government's conflicts of interest for sources of info on jab safety ===
* It doesn’t really inspire confidence that the sources of info on vaccine safety are Big Pharma and the government. 2021, https://twitter.com/LisaMarieBoothe/status/1428419183272992771

=== Reports of On-field heart problems ===
* reported heart issues
** gaslighting
*** "loads of heart issues, its in their heads"..
**** Very frustrating tone to this article, presented as though its in their heads & theres no connection, basically focusing on people being suspicious of the jab, rather than focus on why since the huge jab uptakes has there been loads of heart issues.. , 2021, https://x.com/Centrefuter/status/1474286680488259585?s=20
***** links to athlete-gaslighting articles
****** https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sport/sportsnews/article-10339755/Premier-League-field-heart-issues-fuelled-suspicion-Covid-vaccines-players.html
****** Times https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/22/sports/soccer/premier-league-coronavirus-vaccine.html?referringSource=articleShare

=== Scam-factor ===
* On the last day they even offered me 500 dollars to stay and take the vaccine. That just made me even more hella suspicious. And confirmed my decision to not take the jab. Why would any Corp give out 500 to take the jab? Also I'm not anti vaxx. I'm anti scams, 2021, https://x.com/cash_override/status/1459156130668679171?s=20

=== Forcing Jab ===

==== Already immune ====
* Why is the world coercing people who already had the disease and have antibodies and/or T-cell immunity, into getting a jab? 2021, https://x.com/CCollated/status/1405809110914945028?s=20

==== High survivability ====
* for an infectious process with such high survivability
** tweets quoting deleted tweets
*** Desperation
**** Desperation kicking in for jabs and I leave it at this why are they going full throttle to jab and trying to discriminate against unjabbed very fucking suspicious , 2021, https://x.com/durhamsafc1994/status/1421610912763596801?s=20
*** Covid jab? Very suspicious…. Why the need for a story? 2021 https://x.com/tim_hidden/status/1433198388636381187?s=20
** I mean the forcing of this jab for an infectious process with such high survivability- there is a reason why people are hesitant! Did we see this sort of campaign for flu? It’s suspicious to want a needle in every arm for this. Red flags should go up everywhere! https://x.com/Fynnderella1/status/1417878422156681227?s=20

=== Population control, recent quotes, Boris Johnson ===
* (2007) ( pic,/ population control quotation) I wonder why anyone would be suspicious of this jab. https://x.com/JohnDra93154435/status/1353653149299568641?s=20
*

Data: C40 Cities Agenda Ambitions

2024-02-03T04:29:08Z

Fallandtrip:

== Ambitions ==

* ''Comments''
** Emphases added
** ''Information may or may not be conclusive, hence the title prefix 'Data': use at own risk, for example Livestock section is draft''

=== Land use : Make changes to land use bylaws, --make it impossible to be self sufficient. ===
* Ontario, NWT too. It's everywhere. The C40 cities, Global Covenant of Mayors (WEF municipal level group), among other groups are making changes to land use bylaws to make it impossible to be self sufficient. It's the push to get people into the smart cities/give govt control. https://x.com/DeaMille17/status/1661030683752665089?s=20
* We @C40cities @WRIRossCities @ICLEI and @WBG_Cities are excited to hold the inaugural #theGPSC City Academy in Singapore at where 10 cities are gathered to learn about the integration of '''land''' '''use''', transport and climate action planning.. https://x.com/AndreaF_C40/status/1066878725122215936?s=20
* ''more data, search c40 (land use OR bylaws ) [https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top https://twitter.com/search?]''[https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top]

=== Wetlands ===
* "...most significant aspects of urban life and municipal management that wetlands improve and contribute towards.." https://citieswithnature.org/the-value-of-wetlands-for-cities/
* "..As we celebrate #WorldWetlandsDay on 2 February, let’s dive into why wetlands are important, especially when it comes to cities and urban spaces..." https://x.com/c40cities/status/1752972516799430774?s=20

=== Pets, Livestock -- Farm animal Restrictions, Removal ===
horses (farm), chickens, ..

* horses , Newfoundland Pony
** “The Town’s regulations have serious consequences for the survival of the Newfoundland Pony in municipalities across the Province,” said an emailed statement from the Newfoundland Pony Society, an organization started in 1979 and is responsible for preserving and protecting the Newfoundland Pony breed. , May 2023 https://www.saltwire.com/atlantic-canada/news/im-not-getting-rid-of-sparks-summerford-horse-owner-quits-council-vows-to-fight-to-keep-animal-after-town-orders-its-removal-100854501/
* chickens
** Unsorted
*** Chicken can stay as Kamloops agrees to delay animal-control bylaw Chickens can stay while city mulls plan, The Canadian Press May 14, 2014 , https://www.pentictonherald.ca/prairies/bc/article_4e596064-0862-5b2f-8ec4-1ad3b8fc626f.html
** Alberta: 2012 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/calgary-chicken-activist-loses-bylaw-challenge-1.1277278 from https://x.com/Canada_RF/status/243495424000946176?s=20
** Ontario: Fined for having 3 Backyard Hens , NorthBay ontario, 2017, https://www.gofundme.com/f/fined-for-having-3-backyard-hens?utm_source=customer&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet&utm_medium=copy_link-tip
**** petition to change bylaw https://www.change.org/p/b-r-johnson-allow-back-yard-chickens-in-north-bay-ontario-change-the-by-law-may-16th-17-sign-now
**** macleans article 2017 https://macleans.ca/society/how-a-north-bay-pig-is-standing-up-for-backyard-chickens/

=== Transportation -- encumber/reduce/crash car ownership market ===

=== Clean bus declaration ===
* @C40cities '''Clean''' '''Bus''' '''Declaration''' promotes switch to low- and zero-emission buses: <nowiki>http://bit.ly/1GrTFR2</nowiki> #LPAA https://x.com/UNFCCC/status/668266677696499712?s=20
* 26 cities have signed on to @c40cities #CleanBusDeclaration to purchase only eBuses by 2025. #Shenzhen is doing them one better: By the end of 2017, it will electrify all 14,500 of its public transit buses. Dec 5, 2017 https://x.com/JuliaThayne/status/938126074927570944?s=20
* " Showing Results 1-15 of 30 for 'clean bus' " https://blog.nationalgeographic.org/?s=clean+bus+&post_type=post
* @c40cities @Glen4ONT Are any '''Ontario''' '''cities''' signatories to the '''C40''' Clean Bus Declaration? @JimWatsonOttawa https://x.com/Ghoti20/status/615665015597735936?s=20
* ''more data, search https://twitter.com/search?q=Clean%20bus%20declaration&src=typed_query&f=top''

=== Incentives to reduce, trade in and scrap car ownership ===
* Across C40 cities, #Barcelona adopted free travel for those who got rid of polluting cars, #Stockholm expanded bus services, and #London has offered discounts on car clubs, bike hire and scrappage. '''2024''' https://x.com/c40cities/status/1749795375261847745?s=20
* "..Barcelona introduced free travel for three years for those who got rid of polluting cars, Stockholm expanded bus services.." '''2024''' https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20240122-from-london-to-new-york-can-quitting-cars-be-popular

=== Ultra Low Emissions Zones (ULEZ) and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs), AMPR Cameras ===
(video) "tradesmen risk fines", "we dont want this..", "..Ultra Low Emissions Zones (ULEZ) and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs) have nothing to do with saving the planet, and everything to do with restricting your freedom of movement.." 2023, UK, 1min video, https://x.com/PaulHut91434196/status/1645385622813646848?s=20

=== Speed limit reductions ===
Wales experiment
* 20mph: Wales first UK nation to drop speed limit from 30mph 17 September https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-66774379
** ''"a Welsh government-commissioned consultation found more were against the speed limit than in support of it. One of the Labour-led government's own documents said longer journeys could cause a "substantial" economic disadvantage."''
** ''The Welsh Conservatives said they were in favour of a 20mph limit outside schools, hospitals and care homes - but called the blanket rollout "disastrous, frankly ludicrous and a war on motorists".''
** Wales has become the first country in the UK to reduce speed limits in built-up areas from 30mph to 20mph in Wales from Sunday. Welsh ministers said a 20mph (32km/h) limit would reduce deaths and noise and encourage people to walk or cycle but it has caused controversy with some drivers.
* "One road in Wales now has eight speed limit changes in less than two miles following the switch to 20mph." Making driving an unpleasant experience is a key strategy of the war on motorists, with drivers bombarded with signage and fearful of big fines. https://x.com/RichardWellings/status/1729496787482812727?s=20
** links to
Towns in Ontario Canada

* [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0738991,-77.765902,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sEvwKbz7ShW_HVFcHGvJ71w!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu Streetview], Google maps, ''Speed limit sign '40km/h' halfway up hill,'' [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0760279,-77.7555241,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s2zzAk_guuO-2qOzhVehBPA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu 2nd sign,] 2min drive down same road, ''more obvious that the density is too low for this to make sense.''

=== Closing nuclear plants ===

* Ontario closing the Pickering nuclear plant. Sheila Gunn Reid, host for Rebel News on C40 cities. Then Lex Tan, the host of “Ringside Heat” gives us a recap of the WWE SummerSlam. Claire Sommer @KayakMediaTweet https://x.com/sauga960am/status/1554561769712091137?s=20

* Trudeau's criminal eco activist QC Minister wants to shut down '''Pickering''' '''nuclear plant''' & replace it with solar panels & windmills! Elect a clown expect a circus... Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy … #cdnpoli https://x.com/rexglacer/status/1456957830892859395?s=20 links to https://www.ipolitics.ca/news/guilbeault-refuses-to-declare-his-support-of-nuclear-energy
** Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy... Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault says “it’s not up to the government to decide” which sources of energy will reduce the country’s greenhouse-gas emissions to net zero by 2050. Nor would he say explicitly whether he supports nuclear energy, which he’d opposed in his work before entering politics in 2019. As for “which forms of energy […]. Published Nov 5, 2021 at 4:13pm
** ''more data, search'' https://twitter.com/search?q=Pickering%20nuclear%20plant&src=typed_query

=== Clothing purchases ===
* The C40 Cities targets for clothing purchases by 2030. The WEF & C40 Cities have the same goals. Details in link. <nowiki>https://expose-news.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Arup-C40-The-Future-of-Urban-Consumption-in-a-1-5C-World.pdf…</nowiki> https://x.com/stan_sands/status/1729209582898307422?s=20
** WEF has published a video in which they urge people to wash clothes less because washing clothes affects climate change... video link https://x.com/sophiadahl1/status/1729022360181977325?s=20

Data: C40 Cities Agenda Ambitions

2024-02-03T04:26:03Z

Fallandtrip:

== Ambitions ==

=== Make changes to land use bylaws, --make it impossible to be self sufficient. ===

* Ontario, NWT too. It's everywhere. The C40 cities, Global Covenant of Mayors (WEF municipal level group), among other groups are making changes to land use bylaws to make it impossible to be self sufficient. It's the push to get people into the smart cities/give govt control. https://x.com/DeaMille17/status/1661030683752665089?s=20
* We @C40cities @WRIRossCities @ICLEI and @WBG_Cities are excited to hold the inaugural #theGPSC City Academy in Singapore at where 10 cities are gathered to learn about the integration of '''land''' '''use''', transport and climate action planning.. https://x.com/AndreaF_C40/status/1066878725122215936?s=20
* ''more data, search c40 (land use OR bylaws ) [https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top https://twitter.com/search?]''[https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top]

=== Clean bus declaration ===

* @C40cities '''Clean''' '''Bus''' '''Declaration''' promotes switch to low- and zero-emission buses: <nowiki>http://bit.ly/1GrTFR2</nowiki> #LPAA https://x.com/UNFCCC/status/668266677696499712?s=20
* 26 cities have signed on to @c40cities #CleanBusDeclaration to purchase only eBuses by 2025. #Shenzhen is doing them one better: By the end of 2017, it will electrify all 14,500 of its public transit buses. Dec 5, 2017 https://x.com/JuliaThayne/status/938126074927570944?s=20
* " Showing Results 1-15 of 30 for 'clean bus' " https://blog.nationalgeographic.org/?s=clean+bus+&post_type=post
* @c40cities @Glen4ONT Are any '''Ontario''' '''cities''' signatories to the '''C40''' Clean Bus Declaration? @JimWatsonOttawa https://x.com/Ghoti20/status/615665015597735936?s=20
* ''more data, search https://twitter.com/search?q=Clean%20bus%20declaration&src=typed_query&f=top''

=== Closing nuclear plants ===

* Ontario closing the Pickering nuclear plant. Sheila Gunn Reid, host for Rebel News on C40 cities. Then Lex Tan, the host of “Ringside Heat” gives us a recap of the WWE SummerSlam. Claire Sommer @KayakMediaTweet https://x.com/sauga960am/status/1554561769712091137?s=20

* Trudeau's criminal eco activist QC Minister wants to shut down '''Pickering''' '''nuclear plant''' & replace it with solar panels & windmills! Elect a clown expect a circus... Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy … #cdnpoli https://x.com/rexglacer/status/1456957830892859395?s=20 links to https://www.ipolitics.ca/news/guilbeault-refuses-to-declare-his-support-of-nuclear-energy
** Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy... Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault says “it’s not up to the government to decide” which sources of energy will reduce the country’s greenhouse-gas emissions to net zero by 2050. Nor would he say explicitly whether he supports nuclear energy, which he’d opposed in his work before entering politics in 2019. As for “which forms of energy […]. Published Nov 5, 2021 at 4:13pm
** ''more data, search'' https://twitter.com/search?q=Pickering%20nuclear%20plant&src=typed_query

=== Speed limit reductions -- encumber/crash car ownership market ===
Brighton Ontario Canada

* [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0738991,-77.765902,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sEvwKbz7ShW_HVFcHGvJ71w!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu Streetview], Google maps,
** ''Speed limit sign '40km/h' halfway up hill''
* [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0760279,-77.7555241,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s2zzAk_guuO-2qOzhVehBPA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu 2nd sign,] 2min drive down same road
** ''more obvious that the density is too low for this to make sense.''

Wales experiment
* 20mph: Wales first UK nation to drop speed limit from 30mph 17 September https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-66774379
** ''"a Welsh government-commissioned consultation found more were against the speed limit than in support of it. One of the Labour-led government's own documents said longer journeys could cause a "substantial" economic disadvantage."''
** ''The Welsh Conservatives said they were in favour of a 20mph limit outside schools, hospitals and care homes - but called the blanket rollout "disastrous, frankly ludicrous and a war on motorists".''
** Wales has become the first country in the UK to reduce speed limits in built-up areas from 30mph to 20mph in Wales from Sunday. Welsh ministers said a 20mph (32km/h) limit would reduce deaths and noise and encourage people to walk or cycle but it has caused controversy with some drivers.
* "One road in Wales now has eight speed limit changes in less than two miles following the switch to 20mph." Making driving an unpleasant experience is a key strategy of the war on motorists, with drivers bombarded with signage and fearful of big fines. https://x.com/RichardWellings/status/1729496787482812727?s=20
** links to

=== Clothing purchases ===

* The C40 Cities targets for clothing purchases by 2030. The WEF & C40 Cities have the same goals. Details in link. <nowiki>https://expose-news.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Arup-C40-The-Future-of-Urban-Consumption-in-a-1-5C-World.pdf…</nowiki> https://x.com/stan_sands/status/1729209582898307422?s=20
** WEF has published a video in which they urge people to wash clothes less because washing clothes affects climate change... video link https://x.com/sophiadahl1/status/1729022360181977325?s=20

Data: C40 Cities Agenda Ambitions

2024-02-03T04:25:30Z

Fallandtrip:

* ''Comments''
** Emphases added
** ''Information may or may not be conclusive, hence the title prefix 'Data': use at own risk, for example Livestock section is draft''

== Ambitions ==

=== Land use ===

==== Make changes to land use bylaws, --make it impossible to be self sufficient. ====
* Ontario, NWT too. It's everywhere. The C40 cities, Global Covenant of Mayors (WEF municipal level group), among other groups are making changes to land use bylaws to make it impossible to be self sufficient. It's the push to get people into the smart cities/give govt control. https://x.com/DeaMille17/status/1661030683752665089?s=20
* We @C40cities @WRIRossCities @ICLEI and @WBG_Cities are excited to hold the inaugural #theGPSC City Academy in Singapore at where 10 cities are gathered to learn about the integration of '''land''' '''use''', transport and climate action planning.. https://x.com/AndreaF_C40/status/1066878725122215936?s=20
* ''more data, search c40 (land use OR bylaws ) [https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top https://twitter.com/search?]''[https://twitter.com/search?q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top q=c40%20(land%20use%20OR%20bylaws%20)&src=typed_query&f=top]

==== Wetlands ====

* "...most significant aspects of urban life and municipal management that wetlands improve and contribute towards.." https://citieswithnature.org/the-value-of-wetlands-for-cities/
* "..As we celebrate #WorldWetlandsDay on 2 February, let’s dive into why wetlands are important, especially when it comes to cities and urban spaces..." https://x.com/c40cities/status/1752972516799430774?s=20

=== Pets, Livestock ===

==== Farm animal Restrictions, Removal ====
horses (farm), chickens, ..

* horses , Newfoundland Pony
** “The Town’s regulations have serious consequences for the survival of the Newfoundland Pony in municipalities across the Province,” said an emailed statement from the Newfoundland Pony Society, an organization started in 1979 and is responsible for preserving and protecting the Newfoundland Pony breed. , May 2023 https://www.saltwire.com/atlantic-canada/news/im-not-getting-rid-of-sparks-summerford-horse-owner-quits-council-vows-to-fight-to-keep-animal-after-town-orders-its-removal-100854501/
* chickens
** Unsorted
*** Chicken can stay as Kamloops agrees to delay animal-control bylaw Chickens can stay while city mulls plan, The Canadian Press May 14, 2014 , https://www.pentictonherald.ca/prairies/bc/article_4e596064-0862-5b2f-8ec4-1ad3b8fc626f.html
** Alberta: 2012 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/calgary/calgary-chicken-activist-loses-bylaw-challenge-1.1277278 from https://x.com/Canada_RF/status/243495424000946176?s=20
** Ontario: Fined for having 3 Backyard Hens , NorthBay ontario, 2017, https://www.gofundme.com/f/fined-for-having-3-backyard-hens?utm_source=customer&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet&utm_medium=copy_link-tip
**** petition to change bylaw https://www.change.org/p/b-r-johnson-allow-back-yard-chickens-in-north-bay-ontario-change-the-by-law-may-16th-17-sign-now
**** macleans article 2017 https://macleans.ca/society/how-a-north-bay-pig-is-standing-up-for-backyard-chickens/

=== Transportation -- encumber/reduce/crash car ownership market ===

===== Clean bus declaration =====
* @C40cities '''Clean''' '''Bus''' '''Declaration''' promotes switch to low- and zero-emission buses: <nowiki>http://bit.ly/1GrTFR2</nowiki> #LPAA https://x.com/UNFCCC/status/668266677696499712?s=20
* 26 cities have signed on to @c40cities #CleanBusDeclaration to purchase only eBuses by 2025. #Shenzhen is doing them one better: By the end of 2017, it will electrify all 14,500 of its public transit buses. Dec 5, 2017 https://x.com/JuliaThayne/status/938126074927570944?s=20
* " Showing Results 1-15 of 30 for 'clean bus' " https://blog.nationalgeographic.org/?s=clean+bus+&post_type=post
* @c40cities @Glen4ONT Are any '''Ontario''' '''cities''' signatories to the '''C40''' Clean Bus Declaration? @JimWatsonOttawa https://x.com/Ghoti20/status/615665015597735936?s=20
* ''more data, search https://twitter.com/search?q=Clean%20bus%20declaration&src=typed_query&f=top''

==== Incentives to reduce, trade in and scrap car ownership ====

* Across C40 cities, #Barcelona adopted free travel for those who got rid of polluting cars, #Stockholm expanded bus services, and #London has offered discounts on car clubs, bike hire and scrappage. '''2024''' https://x.com/c40cities/status/1749795375261847745?s=20
* "..Barcelona introduced free travel for three years for those who got rid of polluting cars, Stockholm expanded bus services.." '''2024''' https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20240122-from-london-to-new-york-can-quitting-cars-be-popular

==== Ultra Low Emissions Zones (ULEZ) and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs), AMPR Cameras ====
(video) "tradesmen risk fines", "we dont want this..", "..Ultra Low Emissions Zones (ULEZ) and Low Traffic Neighbourhoods (LTNs) have nothing to do with saving the planet, and everything to do with restricting your freedom of movement.." 2023, UK, 1min video, https://x.com/PaulHut91434196/status/1645385622813646848?s=20

===== Speed limit reductions =====
Wales experiment
* 20mph: Wales first UK nation to drop speed limit from 30mph 17 September https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-66774379
** ''"a Welsh government-commissioned consultation found more were against the speed limit than in support of it. One of the Labour-led government's own documents said longer journeys could cause a "substantial" economic disadvantage."''
** ''The Welsh Conservatives said they were in favour of a 20mph limit outside schools, hospitals and care homes - but called the blanket rollout "disastrous, frankly ludicrous and a war on motorists".''
** Wales has become the first country in the UK to reduce speed limits in built-up areas from 30mph to 20mph in Wales from Sunday. Welsh ministers said a 20mph (32km/h) limit would reduce deaths and noise and encourage people to walk or cycle but it has caused controversy with some drivers.
* "One road in Wales now has eight speed limit changes in less than two miles following the switch to 20mph." Making driving an unpleasant experience is a key strategy of the war on motorists, with drivers bombarded with signage and fearful of big fines. https://x.com/RichardWellings/status/1729496787482812727?s=20
** links to
Towns in Ontario Canada

* [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0738991,-77.765902,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sEvwKbz7ShW_HVFcHGvJ71w!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu Streetview], Google maps, ''Speed limit sign '40km/h' halfway up hill,'' [https://www.google.com/maps/@44.0760279,-77.7555241,3a,75y,71.13h,89.05t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1s2zzAk_guuO-2qOzhVehBPA!2e0!7i16384!8i8192?entry=ttu 2nd sign,] 2min drive down same road, ''more obvious that the density is too low for this to make sense.''

=== Closing nuclear plants ===

* Ontario closing the Pickering nuclear plant. Sheila Gunn Reid, host for Rebel News on C40 cities. Then Lex Tan, the host of “Ringside Heat” gives us a recap of the WWE SummerSlam. Claire Sommer @KayakMediaTweet https://x.com/sauga960am/status/1554561769712091137?s=20

* Trudeau's criminal eco activist QC Minister wants to shut down '''Pickering''' '''nuclear plant''' & replace it with solar panels & windmills! Elect a clown expect a circus... Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy … #cdnpoli https://x.com/rexglacer/status/1456957830892859395?s=20 links to https://www.ipolitics.ca/news/guilbeault-refuses-to-declare-his-support-of-nuclear-energy
** Guilbeault refuses to declare his support of nuclear energy... Environment Minister Steven Guilbeault says “it’s not up to the government to decide” which sources of energy will reduce the country’s greenhouse-gas emissions to net zero by 2050. Nor would he say explicitly whether he supports nuclear energy, which he’d opposed in his work before entering politics in 2019. As for “which forms of energy […]. Published Nov 5, 2021 at 4:13pm
** ''more data, search'' https://twitter.com/search?q=Pickering%20nuclear%20plant&src=typed_query

=== Clothing purchases ===
* The C40 Cities targets for clothing purchases by 2030. The WEF & C40 Cities have the same goals. Details in link. <nowiki>https://expose-news.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/Arup-C40-The-Future-of-Urban-Consumption-in-a-1-5C-World.pdf…</nowiki> https://x.com/stan_sands/status/1729209582898307422?s=20
** WEF has published a video in which they urge people to wash clothes less because washing clothes affects climate change... video link https://x.com/sophiadahl1/status/1729022360181977325?s=20

Data: C40 Cities Agenda Ambitions

2024-02-02T21:00:44Z

Fallandtrip: Draft

Data: Hate, Invocation of Emergencies Act, MSM Messaging, Canada

2024-01-29T02:28:57Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: MSM Messaging to stoke Hate, Canada ==
''Comment: emphases added''

=== Polls to stoke Discrimination ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!Title of poll
Prominent Text or Title of Source Article
!Replies
|-
|'''Toronto Star'''2022
|"“Have your say: Should Ontario also '''implement a tax for unvaccinated''' people?” circa [https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/have-your-say-should-ontario-also-implement-a-tax-for-unvaccinated-people/article_8489fb66-6fe6-5caa-a811-8cda0dd31e98.html Jan 2022]
|
* Interesting. Result of the vote is "no". Liberal-friendly newspaper agrees with Ford [https://x.com/PamelaIngold/status/1481374244735008771?s=20 link]
* No, it sets a bad precedent when it comes to health-.. [https://x.com/Sharon75571311/status/1481314412787113987?s=20 link]
* This paper is '''disgusting''', but I feel for the one or two good reporters left.
* (pic) Another poll that might go "best of 7 series" to get their '''desired''' result.. [https://x.com/WinstonMitche20/status/1481326945761521664?s=20 2022]
|-
|'''Global News''' 2022
(Ipsos poll)
|" taxing the unvaxxed.. 52% Support a '''tax on the unvaccinated'''" 1000 Canadians surveyed, Ipsos, 0:10 [https://twitter.com/newstart_2024/status/1485671036695859209 video circa Jan 2022] [https://x.com/globalnewsto/status/1485638522635792384?s=20 and]
|
|-
|'''CTV''' Calgary
|"Should Alberta implement '''a tax''' on adults who are unvaccinated from covid-19? yes,no" approx 11000 votes, approx 80% "no" , [https://x.com/stevelanebitch/status/1481328424534913027?s=20 circa Jan 2022]
|
|-
|'''CTV''' Nanos poll
|"..More than 7 in 10 Canadians '''support barring unvaccinated people from businesses:''' Nanos survey .." Published [https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/more-than-7-in-10-canadians-support-barring-unvaccinated-people-from-businesses-nanos-survey-1.5269773 January 16, 2021]
|
* First, I call bullshit. Second, mandatory vaccination would be illegal. https://x.com/PaulMitchell_AB/status/1350655848029200385?s=20
* Here is a snap shot of how stupid and uneducated Canadians are. If you are vaccinated, what is there to worry about... https://x.com/Sharon75571311/status/1358908984393162752?s=20
* Where are these fn people being surveyed? I don’t believe that. Did they survey 10 triple masking fools who volunteered in order to receive a @JustinTrudeau glow in the dark poster for their basements? https://x.com/9_leafs/status/1358925209483554818?s=20
* Now do mental illness/drug addict patients. https://x.com/Bob31685906/status/1447548038004678662?s=20
* What the hell kind of question is that? .. Why make that link between 'threatening, disrespectful' and 'unvaccinated'? https://x.com/KoenSwinkels/status/1447343514879205376?s=20
|-
|'''National Post'''

('''Maru''' poll)
|[https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/more-than-one-in-four-canadians-support-jail-time-for-unvaccinated-poll "..More than one in four Canadians '''support''' '''jail time for the unvaccinated''', poll finds In the '''Maru poll, 27 per''' cent of respondents say it '''would be OK''' to jail the unvaccinated for up to five days.."] Published Jan 19, 2022
Maru poll Jan 2022 links: [https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6405fa1b78abf0232468c763/t/64e190b33e905269b9830c5d/1692504243719/Unvaccinated%2BFactum%2B19%2B02%2B22.pdf pdf], from [https://www.marugroup.net/public-opinion-polls/canada/unvaccinated-canadians here], from [https://www.rebelnews.com/more_than_one-quarter_of_canadians_support_jail_time_for_the_unvaccinated_new_poll_finds rebel artcile],
|
* '''No value''' what so ever. This means that 3 out of 4 Canadians don’t support jail time for the unvaccinated. https://x.com/CLangpap/status/1483850909381627907?s=20
* '''whats next''' , death penalty?
** What value is there in a poll like this other than appealing to our worst instincts and '''further dividing''' Canadians. '''What's next''' Asking if the unvaccinated should be '''executed'''? https://x.com/sunlorrie/status/1483847655914672131?s=20
* This is what happens when the Prime Minister creates division rather than unity. This shouldn't surprise anyone given Trudeaus comments, he's given permission for people to feel like this. Sunny Ways https://x.com/JimMurp77852985/status/1483920203717267456?s=20
|-
|'''CTV'''
'''web poll'''
|"web poll: Should those who remain unvaccinated '''face penalties'''?"
3 choices, ''approx results''

"'''Jail''' Time" (5%)

"Be '''Denied''' Healthcare" (8%)
"No Penalty" ('''87'''%)

Total votes
3400+ votes
''choices [https://x.com/_LoveMTB_/status/1484357114067709956?s=20 link]result links [https://x.com/JohnCrespi/status/1484401109544443906?s=20 1] [https://x.com/MichelleLA1981/status/1484352001903190018?s=20 2]''
|
* '''Beyond disgusting.''' Scary thing is it's '''being allowed''' by Govts globally. We have a PM who is openly stoking the fires of discrimination, fear, & anger of the vaxxed. This IS how 1930s Germany started. We ARE the scapegoats. It's terrifying to wonder how far this is going to go. https://x.com/brethordark/status/1484331225661591552?s=20
* Top notch poll @CTVNews. Really normal question. For those that don't live in canada, this is a mainstream news outlet. And you wonder why Canadians are running around sounding like '''mini hitlers'''
* Will the '''CTV Klan''' be cloaking themselves in a white sheet with a pointed hat next https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1484602049983655943?s=20
* If you want to understand the truly reprehensible scope of media '''degeneracy''', look no further than @CTVNews claiming to be the “Most trusted news. Anytime. Anywhere,” while they poll about '''the proposition''' that citizens should be JAILED simply for refusing one . Disgusting. https://x.com/Tinfoil_Travis/status/1484586702610079749?s=20
* '''This is a poll''' on a Canadian mainstream media website. It is '''disgusting'''. The poll asks if Unvaxxed people should be in jail, No Health care or No penalties. This is '''promoting open hate''' towards a group of people. CTV needs to be investigated <nowiki>https://windsor.ctvnews.ca/mobile/poll-el</nowiki> https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1484316578271219716?s=20
* '''whats next''' , death penalty?
** My guess is the '''next''' @CTVNews poll will be “Should '''the death penalty''' be automatic for the unvxxd?” https://x.com/debramhunter/status/1484363277568131074?s=20
|-
|'''Association for Canadian Studies (ASC''')
2021
|"Vaccinated Canadians feel entitled to ‘greater freedoms’ than non-vaccinated: poll".."..hesitation among vaccinated people to be among non-vaccinated people in dining rooms, gyms, airplanes, and at work.." -- [https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/vaccinated-canadians-feel-entitled-to-greater-freedoms-than-non-vaccinated-as-tensions-rise-poll Nat Post]
"A new poll put out by the (ASC) shows that Canadians who are fully vaccinated feel that they should be entitled to "greater freedoms" than the unvaccinated" 2021 [https://thepostmillennial.com/vaccinated-canadians-feel-they-deserve-more-freedoms-than-unvaccinated-canadians-poll postmillenial],
|
* My rights are not dependent on your "vaccination" status. [https://x.com/PaulMitchell_AB/status/1421161368158294016?s=20 link]
* Being jabbed doesn’t warrant more freedoms than the unjabbed. Although, the jabbed may inevitably have less time to enjoy them. Choose, WISELY! [https://x.com/KAMO1322/status/1421487719688065027?s=20 link]
* So for the thousands of black and First Nations families that are choosing not to vaccinate, these virtue signallars are telling THEM that they should have more rights than them? This is not a good look for them [https://x.com/marisolluzsol/status/1421202682904076289?s=20 link]
|-
|'''CP24'''2020
(Leger poll)
|" ..a new poll suggests Canadians are '''divided''' over whether getting it should be '''mandatory''' or voluntary.".." '''Older''' Canadians,.. were more likely to support a mandatory vaccine."... "[Liberal voters] were also most likely to agree with a '''mandatory''' vaccine while those leaning Conservative were least likely..." [https://www.cp24.com/news/canadians-divided-over-making-covid-19-vaccine-mandatory-poll-1.4914726 April 28, 2020] from [https://x.com/CP24/status/1255064484231761921?s=20 tweet]
|
* Mandatory vaccination after 2 years of isolation is not the right solution for a low death virus. Immunology 101 [https://x.com/CrasTalk/status/1255065631499706368?s=20 video, '''1Min''' apri 2020]
* I definitely wont be getting a vaccine! links to [https://www.zerohedge.com/health/robert-f-kennedy-jr-exposes-bill-gates-vaccine-agenda-scathing-report RFK link] archived , [https://x.com/Diplomatic_Soul/status/1255067015540281344?s=20 Apr 2020]
|}

=== Hate for Others' Protest ===

* ''Comment: "Illegal" verdict discussion available''

{| class="wikitable"
!
!Title
of poll or source article
!Replies
|-
|CP24
|"..Almost 2/3rds of Canadians oppose trucker convoy protest, poll suggests" [https://www.cp24.com/news/almost-2-3rds-of-canadians-oppose-trucker-convoy-protest-poll-suggests-1.5772347 Published February 8, 2022]
|
* tweets citing larger polls that contradict
** https://x.com/ACGanoLife/status/1491009882082152456?s=20
** https://x.com/eyeswide0pen__/status/1491062150550405126?s=20
* "A survey of 1500 people does not speak for the majority of Canadians" https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1491041685769388034?s=20
* Why don’t you say: 2/3rds of 1,500people surveyed? Instead of making your headline sound like 20,000,000 people oppose truckers https://x.com/Evil__Empire/status/1491158984782348289?s=20
* Gaslighting misinformation is coming hard now Its a media attempt to bolster Trudeau's dismal popularity by quoting Liberal party pollsters One poll only polled 500 Protected Class people in Ottawa https://x.com/BillTufts/status/1491035776108298241?s=20
|-
|'''CTV'''(nanos)
|"'''Most''' Canadians back invocation of Emergencies Act during 'Freedom Convoy' protests: Nanos"
[https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/most-canadians-back-invocation-of-emergencies-act-during-freedom-convoy-protests-nanos-1.6177341 Published Dec. 4, 2022]

tweet [https://x.com/CP24/status/1491007020656467971?s=20 link]
|
* contradictory poll info tweets
** 8% of 10000votes say 'dont back EA' https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1599860993597001728?s=20
** Canada's leading source of pro-government propaganda. ('''pic,''' cites CTVs contradictory web pll) https://x.com/miketmcmullen/status/1599799683257618433?s=20
** @CTV '''disregarded''' the results of their own poll and spread '''this misinformation'''!
** "..Umm... No, that's a misleading headline..." (pic) https://x.com/andrew_laidlow/status/1599834379790209024?s=20
** gonna call BS on that https://x.com/PeTePeCkQ/status/1599610313275498498?s=20
** ''" do you believe it was necessary to invoke the EA?"'' ''Results '''27000+ votes'<nowiki/>'''''<nowiki/>''', +67% 'NO'''sources [https://x.com/miketmcmullen/status/1599799683257618433?s=20 link 1]
* I'm sure '''the 1000 polled''' voted for #TrudeauPOS https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1599762696559202304?s=20
*
|}

Data: Hate, Invocation of Emergencies Act, MSM Messaging, Canada

2024-01-29T02:23:14Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: MSM Messaging to stoke Hate, Canada ==
''Comment: emphases added''

=== Polls to stoke Discrimination ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!Title of poll
Prominent Text or Title of Source Article
!Replies
|-
|'''Association for Canadian Studies (ASC''')
2021
|"Vaccinated Canadians feel entitled to ‘greater freedoms’ than non-vaccinated: poll".."..hesitation among vaccinated people to be among non-vaccinated people in dining rooms, gyms, airplanes, and at work.." -- [https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/vaccinated-canadians-feel-entitled-to-greater-freedoms-than-non-vaccinated-as-tensions-rise-poll Nat Post]
"A new poll put out by the (ASC) shows that Canadians who are fully vaccinated feel that they should be entitled to "greater freedoms" than the unvaccinated" 2021 [https://thepostmillennial.com/vaccinated-canadians-feel-they-deserve-more-freedoms-than-unvaccinated-canadians-poll postmillenial],
|
* My rights are not dependent on your "vaccination" status. [https://x.com/PaulMitchell_AB/status/1421161368158294016?s=20 link]
* Being jabbed doesn’t warrant more freedoms than the unjabbed. Although, the jabbed may inevitably have less time to enjoy them. Choose, WISELY! [https://x.com/KAMO1322/status/1421487719688065027?s=20 link]
* So for the thousands of black and First Nations families that are choosing not to vaccinate, these virtue signallars are telling THEM that they should have more rights than them? This is not a good look for them [https://x.com/marisolluzsol/status/1421202682904076289?s=20 link]
|-
|'''Toronto Star'''2022
|"“Have your say: Should Ontario also '''implement a tax for unvaccinated''' people?” circa [https://www.thestar.com/news/canada/have-your-say-should-ontario-also-implement-a-tax-for-unvaccinated-people/article_8489fb66-6fe6-5caa-a811-8cda0dd31e98.html Jan 2022]
|
* Interesting. Result of the vote is "no". Liberal-friendly newspaper agrees with Ford [https://x.com/PamelaIngold/status/1481374244735008771?s=20 link]
* No, it sets a bad precedent when it comes to health-.. [https://x.com/Sharon75571311/status/1481314412787113987?s=20 link]
* This paper is '''disgusting''', but I feel for the one or two good reporters left.
* (pic) Another poll that might go "best of 7 series" to get their '''desired''' result.. [https://x.com/WinstonMitche20/status/1481326945761521664?s=20 2022]
|-
|'''CP24'''2020
(Leger poll)
|" ..a new poll suggests Canadians are '''divided''' over whether getting it should be '''mandatory''' or voluntary.".." '''Older''' Canadians,.. were more likely to support a mandatory vaccine."... "[Liberal voters] were also most likely to agree with a '''mandatory''' vaccine while those leaning Conservative were least likely..." [https://www.cp24.com/news/canadians-divided-over-making-covid-19-vaccine-mandatory-poll-1.4914726 April 28, 2020] from [https://x.com/CP24/status/1255064484231761921?s=20 tweet]
|
* Mandatory vaccination after 2 years of isolation is not the right solution for a low death virus. Immunology 101 [https://x.com/CrasTalk/status/1255065631499706368?s=20 video, '''1Min''' apri 2020]
* I definitely wont be getting a vaccine! links to [https://www.zerohedge.com/health/robert-f-kennedy-jr-exposes-bill-gates-vaccine-agenda-scathing-report RFK link] archived , [https://x.com/Diplomatic_Soul/status/1255067015540281344?s=20 Apr 2020]
|-
|'''Global News''' 2022
(Ipsos poll)
|" taxing the unvaxxed.. 52% Support a '''tax on the unvaccinated'''" 1000 Canadians surveyed, Ipsos, 0:10 [https://twitter.com/newstart_2024/status/1485671036695859209 video circa Jan 2022] [https://x.com/globalnewsto/status/1485638522635792384?s=20 and]
|
|-
|'''CTV''' Calgary
|"Should Alberta implement '''a tax''' on adults who are unvaccinated from covid-19? yes,no" approx 11000 votes, approx 80% "no" , [https://x.com/stevelanebitch/status/1481328424534913027?s=20 circa Jan 2022]
|
|-
|'''National Post'''

('''Maru''' poll)
|[https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/more-than-one-in-four-canadians-support-jail-time-for-unvaccinated-poll "..More than one in four Canadians '''support''' '''jail time for the unvaccinated''', poll finds In the '''Maru poll, 27 per''' cent of respondents say it '''would be OK''' to jail the unvaccinated for up to five days.."] Published Jan 19, 2022
Maru poll Jan 2022 links: [https://static1.squarespace.com/static/6405fa1b78abf0232468c763/t/64e190b33e905269b9830c5d/1692504243719/Unvaccinated%2BFactum%2B19%2B02%2B22.pdf pdf], from [https://www.marugroup.net/public-opinion-polls/canada/unvaccinated-canadians here], from [https://www.rebelnews.com/more_than_one-quarter_of_canadians_support_jail_time_for_the_unvaccinated_new_poll_finds rebel artcile],
|
* '''No value''' what so ever. This means that 3 out of 4 Canadians don’t support jail time for the unvaccinated. https://x.com/CLangpap/status/1483850909381627907?s=20
* '''whats next''' , death penalty?
** What value is there in a poll like this other than appealing to our worst instincts and '''further dividing''' Canadians. '''What's next''' Asking if the unvaccinated should be '''executed'''? https://x.com/sunlorrie/status/1483847655914672131?s=20
* This is what happens when the Prime Minister creates division rather than unity. This shouldn't surprise anyone given Trudeaus comments, he's given permission for people to feel like this. Sunny Ways https://x.com/JimMurp77852985/status/1483920203717267456?s=20
|-
|'''CTV''' Nanos poll
|"..More than 7 in 10 Canadians '''support barring unvaccinated people from businesses:''' Nanos survey .." Published [https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/more-than-7-in-10-canadians-support-barring-unvaccinated-people-from-businesses-nanos-survey-1.5269773 January 16, 2021]
|
* First, I call bullshit. Second, mandatory vaccination would be illegal. https://x.com/PaulMitchell_AB/status/1350655848029200385?s=20
* Here is a snap shot of how stupid and uneducated Canadians are. If you are vaccinated, what is there to worry about... https://x.com/Sharon75571311/status/1358908984393162752?s=20
* Where are these fn people being surveyed? I don’t believe that. Did they survey 10 triple masking fools who volunteered in order to receive a @JustinTrudeau glow in the dark poster for their basements? https://x.com/9_leafs/status/1358925209483554818?s=20
* Now do mental illness/drug addict patients. https://x.com/Bob31685906/status/1447548038004678662?s=20
* What the hell kind of question is that? .. Why make that link between 'threatening, disrespectful' and 'unvaccinated'? https://x.com/KoenSwinkels/status/1447343514879205376?s=20
|-
|'''CTV'''
'''web poll'''
|"web poll: Should those who remain unvaccinated '''face penalties'''?"
3 choices, ''approx results''

"'''Jail''' Time" (5%)

"Be '''Denied''' Healthcare" (8%)
"No Penalty" ('''87'''%)

Total votes
3400+ votes
''choices [https://x.com/_LoveMTB_/status/1484357114067709956?s=20 link]result links [https://x.com/JohnCrespi/status/1484401109544443906?s=20 1] [https://x.com/MichelleLA1981/status/1484352001903190018?s=20 2]''
|
* '''Beyond disgusting.''' Scary thing is it's '''being allowed''' by Govts globally. We have a PM who is openly stoking the fires of discrimination, fear, & anger of the vaxxed. This IS how 1930s Germany started. We ARE the scapegoats. It's terrifying to wonder how far this is going to go. https://x.com/brethordark/status/1484331225661591552?s=20
* Top notch poll @CTVNews. Really normal question. For those that don't live in canada, this is a mainstream news outlet. And you wonder why Canadians are running around sounding like '''mini hitlers'''
* Will the '''CTV Klan''' be cloaking themselves in a white sheet with a pointed hat next https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1484602049983655943?s=20
* If you want to understand the truly reprehensible scope of media '''degeneracy''', look no further than @CTVNews claiming to be the “Most trusted news. Anytime. Anywhere,” while they poll about '''the proposition''' that citizens should be JAILED simply for refusing one . Disgusting. https://x.com/Tinfoil_Travis/status/1484586702610079749?s=20
* '''This is a poll''' on a Canadian mainstream media website. It is '''disgusting'''. The poll asks if Unvaxxed people should be in jail, No Health care or No penalties. This is '''promoting open hate''' towards a group of people. CTV needs to be investigated <nowiki>https://windsor.ctvnews.ca/mobile/poll-el</nowiki> https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1484316578271219716?s=20
* '''whats next''' , death penalty?
** My guess is the '''next''' @CTVNews poll will be “Should '''the death penalty''' be automatic for the unvxxd?” https://x.com/debramhunter/status/1484363277568131074?s=20
|}

=== Hate for Others' Protest ===

* ''Comment: "Illegal" verdict discussion available''

{| class="wikitable"
!
!Title
of poll or source article
!Replies
|-
|CP24
|"..Almost 2/3rds of Canadians oppose trucker convoy protest, poll suggests" [https://www.cp24.com/news/almost-2-3rds-of-canadians-oppose-trucker-convoy-protest-poll-suggests-1.5772347 Published February 8, 2022]
|
* tweets citing larger polls that contradict
** https://x.com/ACGanoLife/status/1491009882082152456?s=20
** https://x.com/eyeswide0pen__/status/1491062150550405126?s=20
* "A survey of 1500 people does not speak for the majority of Canadians" https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1491041685769388034?s=20
* Why don’t you say: 2/3rds of 1,500people surveyed? Instead of making your headline sound like 20,000,000 people oppose truckers https://x.com/Evil__Empire/status/1491158984782348289?s=20
* Gaslighting misinformation is coming hard now Its a media attempt to bolster Trudeau's dismal popularity by quoting Liberal party pollsters One poll only polled 500 Protected Class people in Ottawa https://x.com/BillTufts/status/1491035776108298241?s=20
|-
|'''CTV'''(nanos)
|"'''Most''' Canadians back invocation of Emergencies Act during 'Freedom Convoy' protests: Nanos"
[https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/most-canadians-back-invocation-of-emergencies-act-during-freedom-convoy-protests-nanos-1.6177341 Published Dec. 4, 2022]

tweet [https://x.com/CP24/status/1491007020656467971?s=20 link]
|
* contradictory poll info tweets
** 8% of 10000votes say 'dont back EA' https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1599860993597001728?s=20
** Canada's leading source of pro-government propaganda. ('''pic,''' cites CTVs contradictory web pll) https://x.com/miketmcmullen/status/1599799683257618433?s=20
** @CTV '''disregarded''' the results of their own poll and spread '''this misinformation'''!
** "..Umm... No, that's a misleading headline..." (pic) https://x.com/andrew_laidlow/status/1599834379790209024?s=20
** gonna call BS on that https://x.com/PeTePeCkQ/status/1599610313275498498?s=20
** ''" do you believe it was necessary to invoke the EA?"'' ''Results '''27000+ votes'<nowiki/>'''''<nowiki/>''', +67% 'NO'''sources [https://x.com/miketmcmullen/status/1599799683257618433?s=20 link 1]
* I'm sure '''the 1000 polled''' voted for #TrudeauPOS https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1599762696559202304?s=20
*
|}

Data: Hate, Invocation of Emergencies Act, MSM Messaging, Canada

2024-01-28T04:39:43Z

Fallandtrip: readability. spelling

== Data: MSM Messaging to stoke Hate, Canada ==
''Comment: emphases added''

=== Polls to stoke Discrimination ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!Title
or Text of poll or source article
!Replies
|-
|'''National Post'''
(Maru poll)
|[https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/more-than-one-in-four-canadians-support-jail-time-for-unvaccinated-poll "..More than one in four Canadians '''support''' '''jail time for the unvaccinated''', poll finds In the '''Maru poll, 27 per''' cent of respondents say it '''would be OK''' to jail the unvaccinated for up to five days.."] Published Jan 19, 2022
|
* '''No value''' what so ever. This means that 3 out of 4 Canadians don’t support jail time for the unvaccinated. https://x.com/CLangpap/status/1483850909381627907?s=20
* '''whats next''' , death penalty?
** What value is there in a poll like this other than appealing to our worst instincts and '''further dividing''' Canadians. '''What's next''' Asking if the unvaccinated should be '''executed'''? https://x.com/sunlorrie/status/1483847655914672131?s=20
* This is what happens when the Prime Minister creates division rather than unity. This shouldn't surprise anyone given Trudeaus comments, he's given permission for people to feel like this. Sunny Ways https://x.com/JimMurp77852985/status/1483920203717267456?s=20
|-
|'''CTV''' Nanos poll
|"..More than 7 in 10 Canadians '''support barring unvaccinated people from businesses:''' Nanos survey .." Published [https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/more-than-7-in-10-canadians-support-barring-unvaccinated-people-from-businesses-nanos-survey-1.5269773 January 16, 2021]
|
* First, I call bullshit. Second, mandatory vaccination would be illegal. https://x.com/PaulMitchell_AB/status/1350655848029200385?s=20
* Here is a snap shot of how stupid and uneducated Canadians are. If you are vaccinated, what is there to worry about... https://x.com/Sharon75571311/status/1358908984393162752?s=20
* Where are these fn people being surveyed? I don’t believe that. Did they survey 10 triple masking fools who volunteered in order to receive a @JustinTrudeau glow in the dark poster for their basements? https://x.com/9_leafs/status/1358925209483554818?s=20
* Now do mental illness/drug addict patients. https://x.com/Bob31685906/status/1447548038004678662?s=20
* What the hell kind of question is that? .. Why make that link between 'threatening, disrespectful' and 'unvaccinated'? https://x.com/KoenSwinkels/status/1447343514879205376?s=20
|-
|'''CTV'''
'''web poll'''
|"web poll: Should those who remain unvaccinated '''face penalties'''?"
3 choices, ''approx results''

"'''Jail''' Time" (5%)

"Be '''Denied''' Healthcare" (8%)
"No Penalty" ('''87'''%)

Total votes
3400+ votes
''choices [https://x.com/_LoveMTB_/status/1484357114067709956?s=20 link]result links [https://x.com/JohnCrespi/status/1484401109544443906?s=20 1] [https://x.com/MichelleLA1981/status/1484352001903190018?s=20 2]''
|
* '''Beyond disgusting.''' Scary thing is it's '''being allowed''' by Govts globally. We have a PM who is openly stoking the fires of discrimination, fear, & anger of the vaxxed. This IS how 1930s Germany started. We ARE the scapegoats. It's terrifying to wonder how far this is going to go. https://x.com/brethordark/status/1484331225661591552?s=20
* Top notch poll @CTVNews. Really normal question. For those that don't live in canada, this is a mainstream news outlet. And you wonder why Canadians are running around sounding like '''mini hitlers'''
* Will the '''CTV Klan''' be cloaking themselves in a white sheet with a pointed hat next https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1484602049983655943?s=20
* If you want to understand the truly reprehensible scope of media '''degeneracy''', look no further than @CTVNews claiming to be the “Most trusted news. Anytime. Anywhere,” while they poll about '''the proposition''' that citizens should be JAILED simply for refusing one . Disgusting. https://x.com/Tinfoil_Travis/status/1484586702610079749?s=20
* '''This is a poll''' on a Canadian mainstream media website. It is '''disgusting'''. The poll asks if Unvaxxed people should be in jail, No Health care or No penalties. This is '''promoting open hate''' towards a group of people. CTV needs to be investigated <nowiki>https://windsor.ctvnews.ca/mobile/poll-el</nowiki> https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1484316578271219716?s=20
* '''whats next''' , death penalty?
** My guess is the '''next''' @CTVNews poll will be “Should '''the death penalty''' be automatic for the unvxxd?” https://x.com/debramhunter/status/1484363277568131074?s=20
|}

=== Hate for Others' Protest ===

* ''Comment: "Illegal" verdict discussion available''

{| class="wikitable"
!
!Title
of poll or source article
!Replies
|-
|CP24
|"..Almost 2/3rds of Canadians oppose trucker convoy protest, poll suggests" [https://www.cp24.com/news/almost-2-3rds-of-canadians-oppose-trucker-convoy-protest-poll-suggests-1.5772347 Published February 8, 2022]
|
* tweets citing larger polls that contradict
** https://x.com/ACGanoLife/status/1491009882082152456?s=20
** https://x.com/eyeswide0pen__/status/1491062150550405126?s=20
* "A survey of 1500 people does not speak for the majority of Canadians" https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1491041685769388034?s=20
* Why don’t you say: 2/3rds of 1,500people surveyed? Instead of making your headline sound like 20,000,000 people oppose truckers https://x.com/Evil__Empire/status/1491158984782348289?s=20
* Gaslighting misinformation is coming hard now Its a media attempt to bolster Trudeau's dismal popularity by quoting Liberal party pollsters One poll only polled 500 Protected Class people in Ottawa https://x.com/BillTufts/status/1491035776108298241?s=20
|-
|'''CTV'''(nanos)
|"'''Most''' Canadians back invocation of Emergencies Act during 'Freedom Convoy' protests: Nanos"
[https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/most-canadians-back-invocation-of-emergencies-act-during-freedom-convoy-protests-nanos-1.6177341 Published Dec. 4, 2022]

tweet [https://x.com/CP24/status/1491007020656467971?s=20 link]
|
* contradictory poll info tweets
** 8% of 10000votes say 'dont back EA' https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1599860993597001728?s=20
** Canada's leading source of pro-government propaganda. ('''pic,''' cites CTVs contradictory web pll) https://x.com/miketmcmullen/status/1599799683257618433?s=20
** @CTV '''disregarded''' the results of their own poll and spread '''this misinformation'''!
** "..Umm... No, that's a misleading headline..." (pic) https://x.com/andrew_laidlow/status/1599834379790209024?s=20
** gonna call BS on that https://x.com/PeTePeCkQ/status/1599610313275498498?s=20
** ''" do you believe it was necessary to invoke the EA?"'' ''Results '''27000+ votes'<nowiki/>'''''<nowiki/>''', +67% 'NO'''sources [https://x.com/miketmcmullen/status/1599799683257618433?s=20 link 1]
* I'm sure '''the 1000 polled''' voted for #TrudeauPOS https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1599762696559202304?s=20
*
|}

Data: Hate, Invocation of Emergencies Act, MSM Messaging, Canada

2024-01-27T21:44:26Z

Fallandtrip: Created page with "== Data: Hate, Invocation of Emergencies Act, MSM Messaging, Canada == ''Comment: emphases added'' === Hate and Division undertones in messaging, MSM, Canada === {| class="wi..."

== Data: Hate, Invocation of Emergencies Act, MSM Messaging, Canada ==
''Comment: emphases added''

=== Hate and Division undertones in messaging, MSM, Canada ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+
!
!Title
or Text of poll or source article
!Replies
|-
|'''CTV'''
'''web poll'''
|"web poll: Should those who remain unvaccinated '''face penalties'''?"
3 choices, ''approx results''

"'''Jail''' Time" (5%)

"Be '''Denied''' Healthcare" (8%)
"No Penalty" ('''87'''%)

Total votes
3400+ votes
''choices [https://x.com/_LoveMTB_/status/1484357114067709956?s=20 link]result links [https://x.com/JohnCrespi/status/1484401109544443906?s=20 1] [https://x.com/MichelleLA1981/status/1484352001903190018?s=20 2]''
|
* Top notch poll @CTVNews. Really normal question. For those that don't live in canada, this is a mainstream news outlet. And you wonder why Canadians are running around sounding like '''mini hitlers'''
* Will the '''CTV Klan''' be cloaking themselves in a white sheet with a pointed hat next https://x.com/StevenT65674368/status/1484602049983655943?s=20
* If you want to understand the truly reprehensible scope of media '''degeneracy''', look no further than @CTVNews claiming to be the “Most trusted news. Anytime. Anywhere,” while they poll about '''the proposition''' that citizens should be JAILED simply for refusing one . Disgusting. https://x.com/Tinfoil_Travis/status/1484586702610079749?s=20
* '''This is a poll''' on a Canadian mainstream media website. It is '''disgusting'''. The poll asks if Unvaxxed people should be in jail, No Health care or No penalties. This is '''promoting open hate''' towards a group of people. CTV needs to be investigated <nowiki>https://windsor.ctvnews.ca/mobile/poll-el</nowiki> https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1484316578271219716?s=20
* '''Beyond disgusting.''' Scary thing is it's '''being allowed''' by Govts globally. We have a PM who is openly stoking the fires of discrimination, fear, & anger of the vaxxed. This IS how 1930s Germany started. We ARE the scapegoats. It's terrifying to wonder how far this is going to go. https://x.com/brethordark/status/1484331225661591552?s=20
* '''whats next''' , death penalty?
** My guess is the '''next''' @CTVNews poll will be “Should '''the death penalty''' be automatic for the unvxxd?” https://x.com/debramhunter/status/1484363277568131074?s=20
|-
|'''CTV''' Nanos poll
|"..More than 7 in 10 Canadians '''support barring unvaccinated people from businesses:''' Nanos survey .." Published [https://www.ctvnews.ca/health/coronavirus/more-than-7-in-10-canadians-support-barring-unvaccinated-people-from-businesses-nanos-survey-1.5269773 January 16, 2021]
|
* First, I call bullshit. Second, mandatory vaccination would be illegal. https://x.com/PaulMitchell_AB/status/1350655848029200385?s=20
* Here is a snap shot of how stupid and uneducated Canadians are. If you are vaccinated, what is there to worry about... https://x.com/Sharon75571311/status/1358908984393162752?s=20
* Where are these fn people being surveyed? I don’t believe that. Did they survey 10 triple masking fools who volunteered in order to receive a @JustinTrudeau glow in the dark poster for their basements? https://x.com/9_leafs/status/1358925209483554818?s=20
* Now do mental illness/drug addict patients. https://x.com/Bob31685906/status/1447548038004678662?s=20
* What the hell kind of question is that? .. Why make that link between 'threatening, disrespectful' and 'unvaccinated'? https://x.com/KoenSwinkels/status/1447343514879205376?s=20
|-
|'''National Post'''
(Maru poll)
|[https://nationalpost.com/news/canada/more-than-one-in-four-canadians-support-jail-time-for-unvaccinated-poll "..More than one in four Canadians '''support''' '''jail time for the unvaccinated''', poll finds In the '''Maru poll, 27 per''' cent of respondents say it '''would be OK''' to jail the unvaccinated for up to five days.."] Published Jan 19, 2022
|
* '''No value''' what so ever. This means that 3 out of 4 Canadians don’t support jail time for the unvaccinated. https://x.com/CLangpap/status/1483850909381627907?s=20
* '''whats next''' , death penalty?
** What value is there in a poll like this other than appealing to our worst instincts and '''further dividing''' Canadians. '''What's next''' Asking if the unvaccinated should be '''executed'''? https://x.com/sunlorrie/status/1483847655914672131?s=20
* This is what happens when the Prime Minister creates division rather than unity. This shouldn't surprise anyone given Trudeaus comments, he's given permission for people to feel like this. Sunny Ways https://x.com/JimMurp77852985/status/1483920203717267456?s=20
|}

=== Hate for Others' Protest: Support for Invocation of Emergency Act, MSM, Canada ===

* ''Comment: "Illegal" verdict discussion available''

{| class="wikitable"
!
!Title
of poll or source article
!Replies
|-
|CP24
|"..Almost 2/3rds of Canadians oppose trucker convoy protest, poll suggests" [https://www.cp24.com/news/almost-2-3rds-of-canadians-oppose-trucker-convoy-protest-poll-suggests-1.5772347 Published February 8, 2022]
|
* tweets citing larger polls that contradict
** https://x.com/ACGanoLife/status/1491009882082152456?s=20
** https://x.com/eyeswide0pen__/status/1491062150550405126?s=20
* "A survey of 1500 people does not speak for the majority of Canadians" https://x.com/ryangerritsen/status/1491041685769388034?s=20
* Why don’t you say: 2/3rds of 1,500people surveyed? Instead of making your headline sound like 20,000,000 people oppose truckers https://x.com/Evil__Empire/status/1491158984782348289?s=20
* Gaslighting misinformation is coming hard now Its a media attempt to bolster Trudeau's dismal popularity by quoting Liberal party pollsters One poll only polled 500 Protected Class people in Ottawa https://x.com/BillTufts/status/1491035776108298241?s=20
|-
|'''CTV'''(nanos)
|"'''Most''' Canadians back invocation of Emergencies Act during 'Freedom Convoy' protests: Nanos"
[https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/most-canadians-back-invocation-of-emergencies-act-during-freedom-convoy-protests-nanos-1.6177341 Published Dec. 4, 2022]

tweet [https://x.com/CP24/status/1491007020656467971?s=20 link]
|
* contradictory poll info tweets
** 8% of 10000votes say 'dont back EA' https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1599860993597001728?s=20
** Canada's leading source of pro-government propaganda. ('''pic,''' cites CTVs contradictory web pll) https://x.com/miketmcmullen/status/1599799683257618433?s=20
** @CTV '''disregarded''' the results of their own poll and spread '''this misinformation'''!
** "..Umm... No, that's a misleading headline..." (pic) https://x.com/andrew_laidlow/status/1599834379790209024?s=20
** gonna call BS on that https://x.com/PeTePeCkQ/status/1599610313275498498?s=20
** ''" do you believe it was necessary to invoke the EA?"'' ''Results '''27000+ votes'<nowiki/>'''''<nowiki/>''', +67% 'NO'''sources [https://x.com/miketmcmullen/status/1599799683257618433?s=20 link 1]
* I'm sure '''the 1000 polled''' voted for #TrudeauPOS https://x.com/tr6_guy/status/1599762696559202304?s=20
*
|}

Data:Ontario Covid deaths, Messaging

2024-01-27T17:19:57Z

Fallandtrip: Improved readability

== Data: MSM and Influencers' COVID-19 messaging regarding and at expense of Ontario deaths ==

* Comments:
** Shallow investigations, haste, hysteria:
*** ''Article titles and middle column data evidence a language trend and haste expected to see where there is intention to inflate public fear regarding covid-19''.

{| class="wikitable"
|+'''London, Ont''' Jan 2021
Y. Dabeh, A 19-year-old man
!
!Article Title
Tweet by influencer
!Critical Observations
at bottom of article
Repies
!
|-
|'''CBC'''
|[https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-teen-staff-covid-death-1.5885718 Ontario teen who '''died with COVID-19''' was refugee who worked as long-term care home cleaner]
|observation -- "..An investigation into his death is underway he said. He could not say whether the teen had underlying health conditions. .." "version of this story said the teenager died '''of''' COVID-19... ..health officials were '''not able to perform''' an autopsy '''to determine''' if the novel coronavirus was the primary cause of his death.." (clarification section)
tweets "..[https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353725558954328065?s=20 It is now nearly] 24 hours since this story was first published by CBC, and the state broadcaster has still not changed '''the unverified headline''' that Yassin Dabeh "'''died of COVID'''-19," which '''no authority''', including the local health unit, '''has claimed'''..."
|
|-
|'''CP24'''
|[https://www.cp24.com/news/london-ont-teen-who-worked-at-long-term-care-home-dies-after-covid-19-diagnosis-1.5279775 London, Ont. teen who worked at long-term care home '''dies after COVID-19 diagnosis''']
|"..However, at the time, the case was '''under investigation''' because officials said she died of health '''complications unrelated''' to COVID-19..."
|
|-
|'''lfpress'''
|[https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/tragic-teenager-becomes-london-areas-youngest-covid-19-victim London teenager becomes region's youngest COVID-19 victim]
|"..“The exact understanding for what has happened, the investigation is '''still ongoing''',” he said..."
|
|-
|'''Toronto Star'''
|[https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/teen-working-in-long-term-care-home-identified-as-yassin-dabeh-a-syrian-refugee-who/article_c1768353-91ed-549a-bcd7-5b06fe767e46.html Teen working in long-term-care home identified as Yassin Dabeh, a Syrian refugee who fled to Canada for a better life... the '''youngest person''' in the Middlesex-London area '''to die after being diagnosed''' with COVID-19.]
|observation "..Sinha noted that it is '''really hard to say''' at this stage '''what''' may have '''happened''' to Dabeh.
“It '''could have''' been something completely '''unrelated''' …"
|
|-
|'''highly influencials and top rated posts'''
|
|replies
|
|-
|@KateYoungLondon
Retired '''Member of Parliament'''. She/Her, Communications Chair Senior Libéral Commission
|[https://x.com/KateYoungLondon/status/1353491946501758977?s=20 "..This is so heartbreaking. Coming to Canada to start a new life only to be cut short '''by''' this vicious virus'''.''' #ldnont.."]
|"..This has not been confirmed. Delete your tweet, as of right now '''you are using this young man’s death''' as '''propaganda'''..." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353522819460698113?s=20
|
|-
|'''Catherine McKenna''' @cathmckenna Principal, Climate & Nature Solutions; Chair UN Net Zero; @ColumbiaClimate ; '''Fmr Minister Climate, Infrastructu'''re
|[https://twitter.com/cathmckenna/status/1353426141709701125 "..Very sad to hear about Yassin Dabeh, a frontline LTC worker who passed '''due to COVID.''' My heart goes out ...."]
|"...'''Why''' are you lying??? This is '''a covid cover up'''.." https://x.com/hozmeister1/status/1353714200296697863?s=20
"..'''using''' this young man's death for your empty '''virtue signaling'''..." [https://x.com/RyanVonMisesII/status/1353704644611092480?s=20 link]

"...This is not only '''presumptuous''', but it reads more like a justification for continued '''oppression''' (look young people DO die of this) than actual sympathy over one of the many tragic deaths of young people that occur daily in Ontario..." [https://x.com/Balacla27914533/status/1353563486463418369?s=20 link]

"..This is an '''irresponsible''' and '''unverified''' claim by Catherine McKenna. '''No one yet knows''' if Yassin Dabeh died "due to COVID." He tragically died after being diagnosed with COVID, but his case was considered "resolved.".. https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353510556368572416?s=20
"...You have '''no evidence''' of this being a COVID death and are sadly '''using this man’s tragic premature death'''. You have '''politicized''' this and that is '''incredibly shameful'''..." https://x.com/Charley2021/status/1353522824896524288?s=20

"..Now do teen suicides during lockdowns.." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353520699990798336?s=20
"...Catherine doesn't mind '''spreading''' the '''blatant lie''' that this man died of COVID and lap dog '''CP24 has no problem''' printing it..." https://x.com/WrongThinkMike/status/1354019474937147393?s=20
|
|-
|'''@theJagmeetSingh'''
|"..[https://twitter.com/theJagmeetSingh/status/1353385776285888514 His name was Yassin Dabeh and his death is a tragedy].
Essential workers are at risk every day.

Paid sick days, '''faster vaccine rollout''' out and access to PPE are needed urgently - '''to save lives'''.

My '''deep sympathy''' to family and friends, I grieve with you. .."
|
* "..Will never vote for anyone that '''uses a death''' for political gain..." https://x.com/Gmangolf/status/1353484475183869952?s=20

* "..[https://x.com/pauMA999/status/1353372661473107970?s=20 Here we go. '''They haven’t said''' if he died FROM Covid. They are '''investigating still'''. But hey, let’s make a headline to '''keep the fear going'''...] .."
* I’m hearing this '''wasn’t died of Covid'''..... I’m hearing suicide...... anyone know if this is true?? https://x.com/Karen22912/status/1354055705762934784?s=20
|
|-
|Brittlestar @brittlestar
|".. London, ON kid. 19 years old. Worked in an LTC as a cleaner. '''Died of COVID'''. - Help '''support''' the family of Yassin Dabeh .." [https://x.com/brittlestar/status/1354241716967120898?s=20 link]
|
|
|-
|go fund me
|"...Last week, the Dabeh family lost their son .. '''to covid19'''. They have hesitated to ask for help, but we have kept offering knowing the family has been dependent on Yassin's income to get by. '''The pandemic tragically took the life''' of this nineteen-year old.." [https://www.gofundme.com/f/kj4g5-help-support-the-family-of-yassin-dabeh?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet link]
|
|
|-
|@TareqHadhad
|[https://twitter.com/TareqHadhad/status/1353464498791669761 "..'''stolen''' '''from us''' ... '''heartbroken''' .. loss of Yassin Dabeh,.. who '''died of COVID-19'''..."]
|".[https://x.com/Athena1944/status/1353697281892081668?s=20 .@Athena1944 Jan 25, 2021] '''Wait''' for the facts. The '''cause''' of death is '''not clear'''. So says local health authority..."

"..[https://x.com/she_ide/status/1353602500658520066?s=20 Shegide @she_ide] Jan 25, 2021 This is very unusual. Only two other deaths in Canada under the age of 20. Also, it was a '''sudden''' death which '''doesn't fit the profile of Covid'''-19. I suppose it's possible he had an '''undiagnosed''' illness. Very sorry for the family and I hope public health can '''explain''' his death.." .

"...comments on Hamilton Spec article so '''many are saying''' this was an OD etc '''not Covid'''. Very upsetting. '''Can''' you shed any '''light on this''' so I can counter these low life with facts?.." https://x.com/canadaobserver/status/1353525708677668864?s=20
|
|}

Data:Hard Questions for and Replies to Covid Cartel, Canada

2024-01-27T02:34:55Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data:Questions for and Replies to Covid Cartel, Canada ==

{| class="wikitable"
|+Data:Responses to Covid Cartel, Canada
! rowspan="2" |Covid Cartel Propagandists
! rowspan="2" |Canadian Response
!
!
|-
!
!
|-
|@CaulfieldTim
|
* "..Jealousy is always ugly..." [https://x.com/Michphil1998/status/1750853504732663944?s=20 Jan 25, 2024]
* "..Tucker Carlson is the voice of common sense.." [https://x.com/TheVotersSay/status/1751051799686234539?s=20 Jan 25]
* "..Have you diagnosed yourself with PTSD yet? 🤡 .." [https://x.com/Gigantor1982/status/1750744309920309371?s=20 Jan 25, 2024]
* "..Locking down young and healthy people (who were at very low risk from Covid) never made any sense..." [https://x.com/TheVotersSay/status/1749786995939758462?s=20 link]
* "..You’re just jealous he wouldn’t give you the time of day..." [https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1750752295242137870?s=20 link]
* "..I'll take "bury the lede for 500$ Alex"..." [https://x.com/gcomeaudotcom/status/1749644657393381825?s=20 link]
* "..It’s very clear more people want to listen to him than your left wing extremist propaganda.." [https://x.com/Michphil1998/status/1750912890297786816?s=20 Jan 26, 2024]
* "..I think the vast majority of Canadians now recognize that Canada’s Covid response did significantly more harm than good..." [https://x.com/nowoolovreyz/status/1749504998772216004?s=20 link]
|
|
|-
|@DFisman
|
* "...David, the deaths are tragic for sure, but when I run the numbers excluding LTC and congregate, the C19 death rate per 100k in Ontario is similar to estimated flu deaths per 100k in similar jurisdictions. How is @PooyaKazemi1983 (or I) being inaccurate?.." [https://x.com/rubiconcapital_/status/1374505111305691136?s=20 Mar 23, 2021]
* "..Who the hell are you to decide what an apology is?.."
* "..The world is thankful for your lowered sperm count and motility..."
* "..Another unintelligent & crude hot take from David. Maturity leaves the room when this man arrives.."
* "..The vax would be just as effective against potholes as it is against covid.....I have no doubt [covid] exists. As do many colds." [https://x.com/NotaliaMateo/status/1559943415864901634?s=20 Aug 17, 2022]
* "..I had the opportunity to reconnect last evening with a colleague who now runs a Covid vaccine side effects clinic. He is busy. He told horror stories. Avoid the vaccine if you can. There! Fixed it..." [https://x.com/ChickenGate/status/1570029057747599361?s=20 Sep 14, 2022]
* "..why would anyone listen to you? You are a fear monger whos theories have a record of being incorrect..." [https://x.com/SCatz8019/status/1749082406307668006?s=20 Jan 21]
* "..Please go live there. You can report back on how amazing life is and while pretending the Government is saving people from Covid. The assumption you can control people to control a virus is absurd.."
* "..GBD is the rock-solid management plan on a pandemic respiratory virus. That you don't know this or are seeking to disparage it is solid evidence that you're either ignorant of public health evidence or a paid pharma shill..." [https://x.com/unguenta/status/1749520616993022393?s=20 Jan 22]
* "..People have died from the useless vax that doesn't stop the spread. They took it to do their part to stop the pandemic because they believed the pharmaceuticals lies. Shame on you.."
* "..· For it to be defamation it would have to be untrue. Pot meet kettle..." [https://x.com/canmericanized/status/1478910007819350016?s=20 Jan 5, 2022] "..Sorry, it’s 2021. We’re not doing this bullshit anymore..." [https://x.com/thereds8/status/1345235158253924352?s=20 Jan 2, 2021]
* "..There are many #CAF members who would take great offence of this depiction of them. As a spouse of a serving member ... who generally appreciates your posts ... I am offended..." [https://x.com/lafortdi/status/1570869607308873729?s=20 Sep 16, 2022]
* "..You forgot the stock photo of a person of colour.." [https://x.com/warrenhuska/status/1570753495330091008?s=20 Sep 16, 2022] "..Opinions made to order...(pic)" [https://x.com/colossusPhD/status/1562668759705583616?s=20 Aug 25, 2022]
* "..How are you financed? Oh, right...(pic)" [https://x.com/colossusPhD/status/1562084086805676032?s=20 Aug 23, 2022]
* "..Oh, David. We know who pays you..(pic)." [https://x.com/colossusPhD/status/1559980942814584832?s=20 Aug 17, 2022]
*
|
|
|}

Data:Hard Questions for and Replies to Covid Cartel, Canada

2024-01-27T02:32:52Z

Fallandtrip: Added data

== Data:Questions for and Replies to Covid Cartel, Canada ==

{| class="wikitable"
|+Data:Responses to Covid Cartel, Canada
! rowspan="2" |Covid Cartel Propagandists
! rowspan="2" |Canadian Response
!
!
|-
!
!
|-
|@CaulfieldTim
|
* "..Jealousy is always ugly..." [https://x.com/Michphil1998/status/1750853504732663944?s=20 Jan 25, 2024]
* "..Tucker Carlson is the voice of common sense.." [https://x.com/TheVotersSay/status/1751051799686234539?s=20 Jan 25]
* "..Have you diagnosed yourself with PTSD yet? 🤡 .." [https://x.com/Gigantor1982/status/1750744309920309371?s=20 Jan 25, 2024]
* "..Locking down young and healthy people (who were at very low risk from Covid) never made any sense..." [https://x.com/TheVotersSay/status/1749786995939758462?s=20 link]
* "..You’re just jealous he wouldn’t give you the time of day..." https://x.com/KatKanada_TM/status/1750752295242137870?s=20
* "..I'll take "bury the lede for 500$ Alex"..." [https://x.com/gcomeaudotcom/status/1749644657393381825?s=20 link]
* "..It’s very clear more people want to listen to him than your left wing extremist propaganda.." [https://x.com/Michphil1998/status/1750912890297786816?s=20 Jan 26, 2024]
* "..I think the vast majority of Canadians now recognize that Canada’s Covid response did significantly more harm than good..." [https://x.com/nowoolovreyz/status/1749504998772216004?s=20 link]
|
|
|-
|@DFisman
|
* "...David, the deaths are tragic for sure, but when I run the numbers excluding LTC and congregate, the C19 death rate per 100k in Ontario is similar to estimated flu deaths per 100k in similar jurisdictions. How is @PooyaKazemi1983 (or I) being inaccurate?.." [https://x.com/rubiconcapital_/status/1374505111305691136?s=20 Mar 23, 2021]
* "..Who the hell are you to decide what an apology is?.."
* "..The world is thankful for your lowered sperm count and motility..."
* "..Another unintelligent & crude hot take from David. Maturity leaves the room when this man arrives.."
* "..The vax would be just as effective against potholes as it is against covid.....I have no doubt [covid] exists. As do many colds." [https://x.com/NotaliaMateo/status/1559943415864901634?s=20 Aug 17, 2022]
* "..I had the opportunity to reconnect last evening with a colleague who now runs a Covid vaccine side effects clinic. He is busy. He told horror stories. Avoid the vaccine if you can. There! Fixed it..." [https://x.com/ChickenGate/status/1570029057747599361?s=20 Sep 14, 2022]
* "..why would anyone listen to you? You are a fear monger whos theories have a record of being incorrect..." [https://x.com/SCatz8019/status/1749082406307668006?s=20 Jan 21]
* "..Please go live there. You can report back on how amazing life is and while pretending the Government is saving people from Covid. The assumption you can control people to control a virus is absurd.."
* "..GBD is the rock-solid management plan on a pandemic respiratory virus. That you don't know this or are seeking to disparage it is solid evidence that you're either ignorant of public health evidence or a paid pharma shill..." [https://x.com/unguenta/status/1749520616993022393?s=20 Jan 22]
* "..People have died from the useless vax that doesn't stop the spread. They took it to do their part to stop the pandemic because they believed the pharmaceuticals lies. Shame on you.."
* "..· For it to be defamation it would have to be untrue. Pot meet kettle..." [https://x.com/canmericanized/status/1478910007819350016?s=20 Jan 5, 2022] "..Sorry, it’s 2021. We’re not doing this bullshit anymore..." [https://x.com/thereds8/status/1345235158253924352?s=20 Jan 2, 2021]
* "..There are many #CAF members who would take great offence of this depiction of them. As a spouse of a serving member ... who generally appreciates your posts ... I am offended..." [https://x.com/lafortdi/status/1570869607308873729?s=20 Sep 16, 2022]
* "..You forgot the stock photo of a person of colour.." [https://x.com/warrenhuska/status/1570753495330091008?s=20 Sep 16, 2022] "..Opinions made to order...(pic)" [https://x.com/colossusPhD/status/1562668759705583616?s=20 Aug 25, 2022]
* "..How are you financed? Oh, right...(pic)" [https://x.com/colossusPhD/status/1562084086805676032?s=20 Aug 23, 2022]
* "..Oh, David. We know who pays you..(pic)." [https://x.com/colossusPhD/status/1559980942814584832?s=20 Aug 17, 2022]
*
|
|
|}

Data:Ontario Covid deaths, Messaging

2024-01-26T21:13:32Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: MSM and Influencers' COVID-19 messaging regarding and at expense of Ontario deaths ==

{| class="wikitable"
|+'''London, Ont''' Jan 2021
Y. Dabeh, A 19-year-old man
!
!Title
!Critical Observations
at bottom of article
Repies
!
|-
|'''cbc'''
|[https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-teen-staff-covid-death-1.5885718 Ontario teen who '''died with COVID-19''' was refugee who worked as long-term care home cleaner]
|observation -- "..An investigation into his death is underway he said. He could not say whether the teen had underlying health conditions. .." "version of this story said the teenager died '''of''' COVID-19... ..health officials were '''not able to perform''' an autopsy '''to determine''' if the novel coronavirus was the primary cause of his death.." (clarification section)
tweets "..[https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353725558954328065?s=20 It is now nearly] 24 hours since this story was first published by CBC, and the state broadcaster has still not changed '''the unverified headline''' that Yassin Dabeh "'''died of COVID'''-19," which '''no authority''', including the local health unit, '''has claimed'''..."
|
|-
|'''cp24'''
|[https://www.cp24.com/news/london-ont-teen-who-worked-at-long-term-care-home-dies-after-covid-19-diagnosis-1.5279775 London, Ont. teen who worked at long-term care home '''dies after COVID-19 diagnosis''']
|"..However, at the time, the case was '''under investigation''' because officials said she died of health '''complications unrelated''' to COVID-19..."
|
|-
|'''lfpress'''
|[https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/tragic-teenager-becomes-london-areas-youngest-covid-19-victim London teenager becomes region's youngest COVID-19 victim]
|"..“The exact understanding for what has happened, the investigation is '''still ongoing''',” he said..."
|
|-
|star
|[https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/teen-working-in-long-term-care-home-identified-as-yassin-dabeh-a-syrian-refugee-who/article_c1768353-91ed-549a-bcd7-5b06fe767e46.html Teen working in long-term-care home identified as Yassin Dabeh, a Syrian refugee who fled to Canada for a better life... the '''youngest person''' in the Middlesex-London area '''to die after being diagnosed''' with COVID-19.]
|observation "..Sinha noted that it is '''really hard to say''' at this stage '''what''' may have '''happened''' to Dabeh.
“It '''could have''' been something completely '''unrelated''' …"
|
|-
|'''highly influencials and top rated posts'''
|
|replies
|
|-
|@KateYoungLondon
Retired '''Member of Parliament'''. She/Her, Communications Chair Senior Libéral Commission
|[https://x.com/KateYoungLondon/status/1353491946501758977?s=20 "..This is so heartbreaking. Coming to Canada to start a new life only to be cut short '''by''' this vicious virus'''.''' #ldnont.."]
|"..This has not been confirmed. Delete your tweet, as of right now '''you are using this young man’s death''' as '''propaganda'''..." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353522819460698113?s=20
|
|-
|'''Catherine McKenna''' @cathmckenna Principal, Climate & Nature Solutions; Chair UN Net Zero; @ColumbiaClimate ; '''Fmr Minister Climate, Infrastructu'''re
|[https://twitter.com/cathmckenna/status/1353426141709701125 "..Very sad to hear about Yassin Dabeh, a frontline LTC worker who passed '''due to COVID.''' My heart goes out ...."]
|"...'''Why''' are you lying??? This is '''a covid cover up'''.." https://x.com/hozmeister1/status/1353714200296697863?s=20
"..'''using''' this young man's death for your empty '''virtue signaling'''..." [https://x.com/RyanVonMisesII/status/1353704644611092480?s=20 link]

"...This is not only '''presumptuous''', but it reads more like a justification for continued '''oppression''' (look young people DO die of this) than actual sympathy over one of the many tragic deaths of young people that occur daily in Ontario..." [https://x.com/Balacla27914533/status/1353563486463418369?s=20 link]

"..This is an '''irresponsible''' and '''unverified''' claim by Catherine McKenna. '''No one yet knows''' if Yassin Dabeh died "due to COVID." He tragically died after being diagnosed with COVID, but his case was considered "resolved.".. https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353510556368572416?s=20
"...You have '''no evidence''' of this being a COVID death and are sadly '''using this man’s tragic premature death'''. You have '''politicized''' this and that is '''incredibly shameful'''..." https://x.com/Charley2021/status/1353522824896524288?s=20

"..Now do teen suicides during lockdowns.." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353520699990798336?s=20
"...Catherine doesn't mind '''spreading''' the '''blatant lie''' that this man died of COVID and lap dog '''CP24 has no problem''' printing it..." https://x.com/WrongThinkMike/status/1354019474937147393?s=20
|
|-
|'''@theJagmeetSingh'''
|"..[https://twitter.com/theJagmeetSingh/status/1353385776285888514 His name was Yassin Dabeh and his death is a tragedy].
Essential workers are at risk every day.

Paid sick days, '''faster vaccine rollout''' out and access to PPE are needed urgently - '''to save lives'''.

My '''deep sympathy''' to family and friends, I grieve with you. .."
|
* "..Will never vote for anyone that '''uses a death''' for political gain..." https://x.com/Gmangolf/status/1353484475183869952?s=20

* "..[https://x.com/pauMA999/status/1353372661473107970?s=20 Here we go. '''They haven’t said''' if he died FROM Covid. They are '''investigating still'''. But hey, let’s make a headline to '''keep the fear going'''...] .."
* I’m hearing this '''wasn’t died of Covid'''..... I’m hearing suicide...... anyone know if this is true?? https://x.com/Karen22912/status/1354055705762934784?s=20
|
|-
|Brittlestar @brittlestar
|".. London, ON kid. 19 years old. Worked in an LTC as a cleaner. '''Died of COVID'''. - Help '''support''' the family of Yassin Dabeh .." [https://x.com/brittlestar/status/1354241716967120898?s=20 link]
|
|
|-
|go fund me
|"...Last week, the Dabeh family lost their son .. '''to covid19'''. They have hesitated to ask for help, but we have kept offering knowing the family has been dependent on Yassin's income to get by. '''The pandemic tragically took the life''' of this nineteen-year old.." [https://www.gofundme.com/f/kj4g5-help-support-the-family-of-yassin-dabeh?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet link]
|
|
|-
|@TareqHadhad
|[https://twitter.com/TareqHadhad/status/1353464498791669761 "..'''stolen''' '''from us''' ... '''heartbroken''' .. loss of Yassin Dabeh,.. who '''died of COVID-19'''..."]
|".[https://x.com/Athena1944/status/1353697281892081668?s=20 .@Athena1944 Jan 25, 2021] '''Wait''' for the facts. The '''cause''' of death is '''not clear'''. So says local health authority..."

"..[https://x.com/she_ide/status/1353602500658520066?s=20 Shegide @she_ide] Jan 25, 2021 This is very unusual. Only two other deaths in Canada under the age of 20. Also, it was a '''sudden''' death which '''doesn't fit the profile of Covid'''-19. I suppose it's possible he had an '''undiagnosed''' illness. Very sorry for the family and I hope public health can '''explain''' his death.." .

"...comments on Hamilton Spec article so '''many are saying''' this was an OD etc '''not Covid'''. Very upsetting. '''Can''' you shed any '''light on this''' so I can counter these low life with facts?.." https://x.com/canadaobserver/status/1353525708677668864?s=20
|
|}

Data:Ontario Covid deaths, Messaging

2024-01-26T21:02:09Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: MSM and Influencers' COVID-19 messaging regarding and at expense of Ontario deaths ==

=== 19-year-old Ontario man ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+'''London, Ont''' Jan 2021
* Y. Dabeh, A 19-year-old man
!
!Title
!Critical Observations
at bottom of article
Repies
!
|-
|'''cbc'''
|[https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-teen-staff-covid-death-1.5885718 Ontario teen who '''died with COVID-19''' was refugee who worked as long-term care home cleaner]
|observation -- "..An investigation into his death is underway he said. He could not say whether the teen had underlying health conditions. .." "version of this story said the teenager died '''of''' COVID-19... ..health officials were '''not able to perform''' an autopsy '''to determine''' if the novel coronavirus was the primary cause of his death.." (clarification section)
tweets "..[https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353725558954328065?s=20 It is now nearly] 24 hours since this story was first published by CBC, and the state broadcaster has still not changed '''the unverified headline''' that Yassin Dabeh "'''died of COVID'''-19," which '''no authority''', including the local health unit, '''has claimed'''..."
|
|-
|'''cp24'''
|[https://www.cp24.com/news/london-ont-teen-who-worked-at-long-term-care-home-dies-after-covid-19-diagnosis-1.5279775 London, Ont. teen who worked at long-term care home '''dies after COVID-19 diagnosis''']
|"..However, at the time, the case was '''under investigation''' because officials said she died of health '''complications unrelated''' to COVID-19..."
|
|-
|'''lfpress'''
|[https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/tragic-teenager-becomes-london-areas-youngest-covid-19-victim London teenager becomes region's youngest COVID-19 victim]
|"..“The exact understanding for what has happened, the investigation is '''still ongoing''',” he said..."
|
|-
|star
|[https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/teen-working-in-long-term-care-home-identified-as-yassin-dabeh-a-syrian-refugee-who/article_c1768353-91ed-549a-bcd7-5b06fe767e46.html Teen working in long-term-care home identified as Yassin Dabeh, a Syrian refugee who fled to Canada for a better life... the '''youngest person''' in the Middlesex-London area '''to die after being diagnosed''' with COVID-19.]
|observation "..Sinha noted that it is '''really hard to say''' at this stage '''what''' may have '''happened''' to Dabeh.
“It '''could have''' been something completely '''unrelated''' …"
|
|-
|'''highly influencials and top rated posts'''
|
|replies
|
|-
|@KateYoungLondon
Retired '''Member of Parliament'''. She/Her, Communications Chair Senior Libéral Commission
|[https://x.com/KateYoungLondon/status/1353491946501758977?s=20 "..This is so heartbreaking. Coming to Canada to start a new life only to be cut short '''by''' this vicious virus'''.''' #ldnont.."]
|"..This has not been confirmed. Delete your tweet, as of right now '''you are using this young man’s death''' as '''propaganda'''..." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353522819460698113?s=20
|
|-
|'''Catherine McKenna''' @cathmckenna Principal, Climate & Nature Solutions; Chair UN Net Zero; @ColumbiaClimate ; '''Fmr Minister Climate, Infrastructu'''re
|[https://twitter.com/cathmckenna/status/1353426141709701125 "..Very sad to hear about Yassin Dabeh, a frontline LTC worker who passed '''due to COVID.''' My heart goes out ...."]
|"...'''Why''' are you lying??? This is '''a covid cover up'''.." https://x.com/hozmeister1/status/1353714200296697863?s=20
"..'''using''' this young man's death for your empty '''virtue signaling'''..." [https://x.com/RyanVonMisesII/status/1353704644611092480?s=20 link]

"...This is not only '''presumptuous''', but it reads more like a justification for continued '''oppression''' (look young people DO die of this) than actual sympathy over one of the many tragic deaths of young people that occur daily in Ontario..." [https://x.com/Balacla27914533/status/1353563486463418369?s=20 link]

"..This is an '''irresponsible''' and '''unverified''' claim by Catherine McKenna. '''No one yet knows''' if Yassin Dabeh died "due to COVID." He tragically died after being diagnosed with COVID, but his case was considered "resolved.".. https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353510556368572416?s=20
"...You have '''no evidence''' of this being a COVID death and are sadly '''using this man’s tragic premature death'''. You have '''politicized''' this and that is '''incredibly shameful'''..." https://x.com/Charley2021/status/1353522824896524288?s=20

"..Now do teen suicides during lockdowns.." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353520699990798336?s=20
"...Catherine doesn't mind '''spreading''' the '''blatant lie''' that this man died of COVID and lap dog '''CP24 has no problem''' printing it..." https://x.com/WrongThinkMike/status/1354019474937147393?s=20
|
|-
|'''@theJagmeetSingh'''
|"..[https://twitter.com/theJagmeetSingh/status/1353385776285888514 His name was Yassin Dabeh and his death is a tragedy].
Essential workers are at risk every day.

Paid sick days, '''faster vaccine rollout''' out and access to PPE are needed urgently - '''to save lives'''.

My '''deep sympathy''' to family and friends, I grieve with you. .."
|
* "..Will never vote for anyone that '''uses a death''' for political gain..." https://x.com/Gmangolf/status/1353484475183869952?s=20

* "..[https://x.com/pauMA999/status/1353372661473107970?s=20 Here we go. '''They haven’t said''' if he died FROM Covid. They are '''investigating still'''. But hey, let’s make a headline to '''keep the fear going'''...] .."
* I’m hearing this '''wasn’t died of Covid'''..... I’m hearing suicide...... anyone know if this is true?? https://x.com/Karen22912/status/1354055705762934784?s=20
|
|-
|Brittlestar @brittlestar
|".. London, ON kid. 19 years old. Worked in an LTC as a cleaner. '''Died of COVID'''. - Help '''support''' the family of Yassin Dabeh .." [https://x.com/brittlestar/status/1354241716967120898?s=20 link]
|
|
|-
|go fund me
|"...Last week, the Dabeh family lost their son .. '''to covid19'''. They have hesitated to ask for help, but we have kept offering knowing the family has been dependent on Yassin's income to get by. '''The pandemic tragically took the life''' of this nineteen-year old.." [https://www.gofundme.com/f/kj4g5-help-support-the-family-of-yassin-dabeh?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet link]
|
|
|-
|@TareqHadhad
|[https://twitter.com/TareqHadhad/status/1353464498791669761 "..'''stolen''' '''from us''' ... '''heartbroken''' .. loss of Yassin Dabeh,.. who '''died of COVID-19'''..."]
|".[https://x.com/Athena1944/status/1353697281892081668?s=20 .@Athena1944 Jan 25, 2021] '''Wait''' for the facts. The '''cause''' of death is '''not clear'''. So says local health authority..."

"..[https://x.com/she_ide/status/1353602500658520066?s=20 Shegide @she_ide] Jan 25, 2021 This is very unusual. Only two other deaths in Canada under the age of 20. Also, it was a '''sudden''' death which '''doesn't fit the profile of Covid'''-19. I suppose it's possible he had an '''undiagnosed''' illness. Very sorry for the family and I hope public health can '''explain''' his death.." .

"...comments on Hamilton Spec article so '''many are saying''' this was an OD etc '''not Covid'''. Very upsetting. '''Can''' you shed any '''light on this''' so I can counter these low life with facts?.." https://x.com/canadaobserver/status/1353525708677668864?s=20
|
|}

Data:Ontario Covid deaths, Messaging

2024-01-26T21:01:20Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: MSM and Influencers' COVID-19 messaging regarding and at expense of Ontario deaths ==

=== 19-year-old Ontario man ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+'''London, Ont''' Jan 2021
* Yassin Dabeh, A 19-year-old man
!
!Title
!Critical Observations
at bottom of article
Repies
!
|-
|'''cbc'''
|[https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-teen-staff-covid-death-1.5885718 Ontario teen who '''died with COVID-19''' was refugee who worked as long-term care home cleaner]
|observation -- "..An investigation into his death is underway he said. He could not say whether the teen had underlying health conditions. .." "version of this story said the teenager died '''of''' COVID-19... ..health officials were '''not able to perform''' an autopsy '''to determine''' if the novel coronavirus was the primary cause of his death.." (clarification section)
tweets "..[https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353725558954328065?s=20 It is now nearly] 24 hours since this story was first published by CBC, and the state broadcaster has still not changed '''the unverified headline''' that Yassin Dabeh "'''died of COVID'''-19," which '''no authority''', including the local health unit, '''has claimed'''..."
|
|-
|'''cp24'''
|[https://www.cp24.com/news/london-ont-teen-who-worked-at-long-term-care-home-dies-after-covid-19-diagnosis-1.5279775 London, Ont. teen who worked at long-term care home '''dies after COVID-19 diagnosis''']
|"..However, at the time, the case was '''under investigation''' because officials said she died of health '''complications unrelated''' to COVID-19..."
|
|-
|'''lfpress'''
|[https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/tragic-teenager-becomes-london-areas-youngest-covid-19-victim London teenager becomes region's youngest COVID-19 victim]
|"..“The exact understanding for what has happened, the investigation is '''still ongoing''',” he said..."
|
|-
|star
|[https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/teen-working-in-long-term-care-home-identified-as-yassin-dabeh-a-syrian-refugee-who/article_c1768353-91ed-549a-bcd7-5b06fe767e46.html Teen working in long-term-care home identified as Yassin Dabeh, a Syrian refugee who fled to Canada for a better life... the '''youngest person''' in the Middlesex-London area '''to die after being diagnosed''' with COVID-19.]
|observation "..Sinha noted that it is '''really hard to say''' at this stage '''what''' may have '''happened''' to Dabeh.
“It '''could have''' been something completely '''unrelated''' …"
|
|-
|'''highly influencials and top rated posts'''
|
|replies
|
|-
|@KateYoungLondon
Retired '''Member of Parliament'''. She/Her, Communications Chair Senior Libéral Commission
|[https://x.com/KateYoungLondon/status/1353491946501758977?s=20 "..This is so heartbreaking. Coming to Canada to start a new life only to be cut short '''by''' this vicious virus'''.''' #ldnont.."]
|"..This has not been confirmed. Delete your tweet, as of right now '''you are using this young man’s death''' as '''propaganda'''..." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353522819460698113?s=20
|
|-
|'''Catherine McKenna''' @cathmckenna Principal, Climate & Nature Solutions; Chair UN Net Zero; @ColumbiaClimate ; '''Fmr Minister Climate, Infrastructu'''re
|[https://twitter.com/cathmckenna/status/1353426141709701125 "..Very sad to hear about Yassin Dabeh, a frontline LTC worker who passed '''due to COVID.''' My heart goes out ...."]
|"...'''Why''' are you lying??? This is '''a covid cover up'''.." https://x.com/hozmeister1/status/1353714200296697863?s=20
"..'''using''' this young man's death for your empty '''virtue signaling'''..." [https://x.com/RyanVonMisesII/status/1353704644611092480?s=20 link]

"...This is not only '''presumptuous''', but it reads more like a justification for continued '''oppression''' (look young people DO die of this) than actual sympathy over one of the many tragic deaths of young people that occur daily in Ontario..." [https://x.com/Balacla27914533/status/1353563486463418369?s=20 link]

"..This is an '''irresponsible''' and '''unverified''' claim by Catherine McKenna. '''No one yet knows''' if Yassin Dabeh died "due to COVID." He tragically died after being diagnosed with COVID, but his case was considered "resolved.".. https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353510556368572416?s=20
"...You have '''no evidence''' of this being a COVID death and are sadly '''using this man’s tragic premature death'''. You have '''politicized''' this and that is '''incredibly shameful'''..." https://x.com/Charley2021/status/1353522824896524288?s=20

"..Now do teen suicides during lockdowns.." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353520699990798336?s=20
"...Catherine doesn't mind '''spreading''' the '''blatant lie''' that this man died of COVID and lap dog '''CP24 has no problem''' printing it..." https://x.com/WrongThinkMike/status/1354019474937147393?s=20
|
|-
|'''@theJagmeetSingh'''
|"..[https://twitter.com/theJagmeetSingh/status/1353385776285888514 His name was Yassin Dabeh and his death is a tragedy].
Essential workers are at risk every day.

Paid sick days, '''faster vaccine rollout''' out and access to PPE are needed urgently - '''to save lives'''.

My '''deep sympathy''' to family and friends, I grieve with you. .."
|
* "..Will never vote for anyone that '''uses a death''' for political gain..." https://x.com/Gmangolf/status/1353484475183869952?s=20

* "..[https://x.com/pauMA999/status/1353372661473107970?s=20 Here we go. '''They haven’t said''' if he died FROM Covid. They are '''investigating still'''. But hey, let’s make a headline to '''keep the fear going'''...] .."
* I’m hearing this '''wasn’t died of Covid'''..... I’m hearing suicide...... anyone know if this is true?? https://x.com/Karen22912/status/1354055705762934784?s=20
|
|-
|Brittlestar @brittlestar
|".. London, ON kid. 19 years old. Worked in an LTC as a cleaner. '''Died of COVID'''. - Help '''support''' the family of Yassin Dabeh .." [https://x.com/brittlestar/status/1354241716967120898?s=20 link]
|
|
|-
|go fund me
|"...Last week, the Dabeh family lost their son .. '''to covid19'''. They have hesitated to ask for help, but we have kept offering knowing the family has been dependent on Yassin's income to get by. '''The pandemic tragically took the life''' of this nineteen-year old.." [https://www.gofundme.com/f/kj4g5-help-support-the-family-of-yassin-dabeh?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet link]
|
|
|-
|@TareqHadhad
|[https://twitter.com/TareqHadhad/status/1353464498791669761 "..'''stolen''' '''from us''' ... '''heartbroken''' .. loss of Yassin Dabeh,.. who '''died of COVID-19'''..."]
|".[https://x.com/Athena1944/status/1353697281892081668?s=20 .@Athena1944 Jan 25, 2021] '''Wait''' for the facts. The '''cause''' of death is '''not clear'''. So says local health authority..."

"..[https://x.com/she_ide/status/1353602500658520066?s=20 Shegide @she_ide] Jan 25, 2021 This is very unusual. Only two other deaths in Canada under the age of 20. Also, it was a '''sudden''' death which '''doesn't fit the profile of Covid'''-19. I suppose it's possible he had an '''undiagnosed''' illness. Very sorry for the family and I hope public health can '''explain''' his death.." .

"...comments on Hamilton Spec article so '''many are saying''' this was an OD etc '''not Covid'''. Very upsetting. '''Can''' you shed any '''light on this''' so I can counter these low life with facts?.." https://x.com/canadaobserver/status/1353525708677668864?s=20
|
|}

Data:Ontario Covid deaths, Messaging

2024-01-26T20:54:34Z

Fallandtrip:

== Data: MSM and Influencers' messaging in regard to Ontario deaths ==

=== 19-year-old Ontario man ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+'''London, Ont''' Jan 2021
* Yassin Dabeh, A 19-year-old man
!
!Title
!Critical Observations
at bottom of article
Repies
!
|-
|'''cbc'''
|[https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-teen-staff-covid-death-1.5885718 Ontario teen who '''died with COVID-19''' was refugee who worked as long-term care home cleaner]
|observation -- "..An investigation into his death is underway he said. He could not say whether the teen had underlying health conditions. .." "version of this story said the teenager died '''of''' COVID-19... ..health officials were '''not able to perform''' an autopsy '''to determine''' if the novel coronavirus was the primary cause of his death.." (clarification section)
tweets "..[https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353725558954328065?s=20 It is now nearly] 24 hours since this story was first published by CBC, and the state broadcaster has still not changed '''the unverified headline''' that Yassin Dabeh "'''died of COVID'''-19," which '''no authority''', including the local health unit, '''has claimed'''..."
|
|-
|'''cp24'''
|[https://www.cp24.com/news/london-ont-teen-who-worked-at-long-term-care-home-dies-after-covid-19-diagnosis-1.5279775 London, Ont. teen who worked at long-term care home '''dies after COVID-19 diagnosis''']
|"..However, at the time, the case was '''under investigation''' because officials said she died of health '''complications unrelated''' to COVID-19..."
|
|-
|'''lfpress'''
|[https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/tragic-teenager-becomes-london-areas-youngest-covid-19-victim London teenager becomes region's youngest COVID-19 victim]
|"..“The exact understanding for what has happened, the investigation is '''still ongoing''',” he said..."
|
|-
|star
|[https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/teen-working-in-long-term-care-home-identified-as-yassin-dabeh-a-syrian-refugee-who/article_c1768353-91ed-549a-bcd7-5b06fe767e46.html Teen working in long-term-care home identified as Yassin Dabeh, a Syrian refugee who fled to Canada for a better life... the '''youngest person''' in the Middlesex-London area '''to die after being diagnosed''' with COVID-19.]
|observation "..Sinha noted that it is '''really hard to say''' at this stage '''what''' may have '''happened''' to Dabeh.
“It '''could have''' been something completely '''unrelated''' …"
|
|-
|'''highly influencials and top rated posts'''
|
|replies
|
|-
|@KateYoungLondon
Retired '''Member of Parliament'''. She/Her, Communications Chair Senior Libéral Commission
|[https://x.com/KateYoungLondon/status/1353491946501758977?s=20 "..This is so heartbreaking. Coming to Canada to start a new life only to be cut short '''by''' this vicious virus'''.''' #ldnont.."]
|"..This has not been confirmed. Delete your tweet, as of right now '''you are using this young man’s death''' as '''propaganda'''..." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353522819460698113?s=20
|
|-
|'''Catherine McKenna''' @cathmckenna Principal, Climate & Nature Solutions; Chair UN Net Zero; @ColumbiaClimate ; '''Fmr Minister Climate, Infrastructu'''re
|[https://twitter.com/cathmckenna/status/1353426141709701125 "..Very sad to hear about Yassin Dabeh, a frontline LTC worker who passed '''due to COVID.''' My heart goes out ...."]
|"...'''Why''' are you lying??? This is '''a covid cover up'''.." https://x.com/hozmeister1/status/1353714200296697863?s=20
"..'''using''' this young man's death for your empty '''virtue signaling'''..." [https://x.com/RyanVonMisesII/status/1353704644611092480?s=20 link]

"...This is not only '''presumptuous''', but it reads more like a justification for continued '''oppression''' (look young people DO die of this) than actual sympathy over one of the many tragic deaths of young people that occur daily in Ontario..." [https://x.com/Balacla27914533/status/1353563486463418369?s=20 link]

"..This is an '''irresponsible''' and '''unverified''' claim by Catherine McKenna. '''No one yet knows''' if Yassin Dabeh died "due to COVID." He tragically died after being diagnosed with COVID, but his case was considered "resolved.".. https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353510556368572416?s=20
"...You have '''no evidence''' of this being a COVID death and are sadly '''using this man’s tragic premature death'''. You have '''politicized''' this and that is '''incredibly shameful'''..." https://x.com/Charley2021/status/1353522824896524288?s=20

"..Now do teen suicides during lockdowns.." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353520699990798336?s=20
"...Catherine doesn't mind '''spreading''' the '''blatant lie''' that this man died of COVID and lap dog '''CP24 has no problem''' printing it..." https://x.com/WrongThinkMike/status/1354019474937147393?s=20
|
|-
|'''@theJagmeetSingh'''
|"..[https://twitter.com/theJagmeetSingh/status/1353385776285888514 His name was Yassin Dabeh and his death is a tragedy].
Essential workers are at risk every day.

Paid sick days, '''faster vaccine rollout''' out and access to PPE are needed urgently - '''to save lives'''.

My '''deep sympathy''' to family and friends, I grieve with you. .."
|
* "..Will never vote for anyone that '''uses a death''' for political gain..." https://x.com/Gmangolf/status/1353484475183869952?s=20

* "..[https://x.com/pauMA999/status/1353372661473107970?s=20 Here we go. '''They haven’t said''' if he died FROM Covid. They are '''investigating still'''. But hey, let’s make a headline to '''keep the fear going'''...] .."
* I’m hearing this '''wasn’t died of Covid'''..... I’m hearing suicide...... anyone know if this is true?? https://x.com/Karen22912/status/1354055705762934784?s=20
|
|-
|Brittlestar @brittlestar
|".. London, ON kid. 19 years old. Worked in an LTC as a cleaner. '''Died of COVID'''. - Help '''support''' the family of Yassin Dabeh .." [https://x.com/brittlestar/status/1354241716967120898?s=20 link]
|
|
|-
|go fund me
|"...Last week, the Dabeh family lost their son .. '''to covid19'''. They have hesitated to ask for help, but we have kept offering knowing the family has been dependent on Yassin's income to get by. '''The pandemic tragically took the life''' of this nineteen-year old.." [https://www.gofundme.com/f/kj4g5-help-support-the-family-of-yassin-dabeh?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet link]
|
|
|-
|@TareqHadhad
|[https://twitter.com/TareqHadhad/status/1353464498791669761 "..'''stolen''' '''from us''' ... '''heartbroken''' .. loss of Yassin Dabeh,.. who '''died of COVID-19'''..."]
|".[https://x.com/Athena1944/status/1353697281892081668?s=20 .@Athena1944 Jan 25, 2021] '''Wait''' for the facts. The '''cause''' of death is '''not clear'''. So says local health authority..."

"..[https://x.com/she_ide/status/1353602500658520066?s=20 Shegide @she_ide] Jan 25, 2021 This is very unusual. Only two other deaths in Canada under the age of 20. Also, it was a '''sudden''' death which '''doesn't fit the profile of Covid'''-19. I suppose it's possible he had an '''undiagnosed''' illness. Very sorry for the family and I hope public health can '''explain''' his death.." .

"...comments on Hamilton Spec article so '''many are saying''' this was an OD etc '''not Covid'''. Very upsetting. '''Can''' you shed any '''light on this''' so I can counter these low life with facts?.." https://x.com/canadaobserver/status/1353525708677668864?s=20
|
|}

Data:Ontario Covid deaths, Messaging

2024-01-26T20:49:58Z

Fallandtrip: Table with data showing mainstream media's influence

== Data: MSM and Influencers' messaging in regard to Ontario deaths ==

=== 19-year-old Ontario man ===
{| class="wikitable"
|+'''London, Ont''' Jan 2021
* Yassin Dabeh, A 19-year-old man
!
!Title
!critical observations
at bottom of article
repies,
observations given low priority
!
|-
|'''cbc'''
|[https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-teen-staff-covid-death-1.5885718 Ontario teen who '''died with COVID-19''' was refugee who worked as long-term care home cleaner]
|observation -- "..An investigation into his death is underway he said. He could not say whether the teen had underlying health conditions. .." "version of this story said the teenager died '''of''' COVID-19... ..health officials were '''not able to perform''' an autopsy '''to determine''' if the novel coronavirus was the primary cause of his death.." (clarification section)
tweets "..[https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353725558954328065?s=20 It is now nearly] 24 hours since this story was first published by CBC, and the state broadcaster has still not changed '''the unverified headline''' that Yassin Dabeh "'''died of COVID'''-19," which '''no authority''', including the local health unit, '''has claimed'''..."
|
|-
|'''cp24'''
|[https://www.cp24.com/news/london-ont-teen-who-worked-at-long-term-care-home-dies-after-covid-19-diagnosis-1.5279775 London, Ont. teen who worked at long-term care home '''dies after COVID-19 diagnosis''']
|"..However, at the time, the case was '''under investigation''' because officials said she died of health '''complications unrelated''' to COVID-19..."
|
|-
|'''lfpress'''
|[https://lfpress.com/news/local-news/tragic-teenager-becomes-london-areas-youngest-covid-19-victim London teenager becomes region's youngest COVID-19 victim]
|"..“The exact understanding for what has happened, the investigation is '''still ongoing''',” he said..."
|
|-
|star
|[https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/teen-working-in-long-term-care-home-identified-as-yassin-dabeh-a-syrian-refugee-who/article_c1768353-91ed-549a-bcd7-5b06fe767e46.html Teen working in long-term-care home identified as Yassin Dabeh, a Syrian refugee who fled to Canada for a better life... the '''youngest person''' in the Middlesex-London area '''to die after being diagnosed''' with COVID-19.]
|observation "..Sinha noted that it is '''really hard to say''' at this stage '''what''' may have '''happened''' to Dabeh.
“It '''could have''' been something completely '''unrelated''' …"
|
|-
|'''highly influencials and top rated posts'''
|
|replies
|
|-
|@KateYoungLondon
Retired '''Member of Parliament'''. She/Her, Communications Chair Senior Libéral Commission
|[https://x.com/KateYoungLondon/status/1353491946501758977?s=20 "..This is so heartbreaking. Coming to Canada to start a new life only to be cut short '''by''' this vicious virus'''.''' #ldnont.."]
|"..This has not been confirmed. Delete your tweet, as of right now '''you are using this young man’s death''' as '''propaganda'''..." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353522819460698113?s=20
|
|-
|'''Catherine McKenna''' @cathmckenna Principal, Climate & Nature Solutions; Chair UN Net Zero; @ColumbiaClimate ; '''Fmr Minister Climate, Infrastructu'''re
|[https://twitter.com/cathmckenna/status/1353426141709701125 "..Very sad to hear about Yassin Dabeh, a frontline LTC worker who passed '''due to COVID.''' My heart goes out ...."]
|"...'''Why''' are you lying??? This is '''a covid cover up'''.." https://x.com/hozmeister1/status/1353714200296697863?s=20
"..'''using''' this young man's death for your empty '''virtue signaling'''..." [https://x.com/RyanVonMisesII/status/1353704644611092480?s=20 link]

"...This is not only '''presumptuous''', but it reads more like a justification for continued '''oppression''' (look young people DO die of this) than actual sympathy over one of the many tragic deaths of young people that occur daily in Ontario..." [https://x.com/Balacla27914533/status/1353563486463418369?s=20 link]

"..This is an '''irresponsible''' and '''unverified''' claim by Catherine McKenna. '''No one yet knows''' if Yassin Dabeh died "due to COVID." He tragically died after being diagnosed with COVID, but his case was considered "resolved.".. https://x.com/AndrewLawton/status/1353510556368572416?s=20
"...You have '''no evidence''' of this being a COVID death and are sadly '''using this man’s tragic premature death'''. You have '''politicized''' this and that is '''incredibly shameful'''..." https://x.com/Charley2021/status/1353522824896524288?s=20

"..Now do teen suicides during lockdowns.." https://x.com/GovGone/status/1353520699990798336?s=20
"...Catherine doesn't mind '''spreading''' the '''blatant lie''' that this man died of COVID and lap dog '''CP24 has no problem''' printing it..." https://x.com/WrongThinkMike/status/1354019474937147393?s=20
|
|-
|'''@theJagmeetSingh'''
|"..[https://twitter.com/theJagmeetSingh/status/1353385776285888514 His name was Yassin Dabeh and his death is a tragedy].
Essential workers are at risk every day.

Paid sick days, '''faster vaccine rollout''' out and access to PPE are needed urgently - '''to save lives'''.

My '''deep sympathy''' to family and friends, I grieve with you. .."
|
* "..Will never vote for anyone that '''uses a death''' for political gain..." https://x.com/Gmangolf/status/1353484475183869952?s=20

* "..[https://x.com/pauMA999/status/1353372661473107970?s=20 Here we go. '''They haven’t said''' if he died FROM Covid. They are '''investigating still'''. But hey, let’s make a headline to '''keep the fear going'''...] .."
* I’m hearing this '''wasn’t died of Covid'''..... I’m hearing suicide...... anyone know if this is true?? https://x.com/Karen22912/status/1354055705762934784?s=20
|
|-
|Brittlestar @brittlestar
|".. London, ON kid. 19 years old. Worked in an LTC as a cleaner. '''Died of COVID'''. - Help '''support''' the family of Yassin Dabeh .." [https://x.com/brittlestar/status/1354241716967120898?s=20 link]
|
|
|-
|go fund me
|"...Last week, the Dabeh family lost their son .. '''to covid19'''. They have hesitated to ask for help, but we have kept offering knowing the family has been dependent on Yassin's income to get by. '''The pandemic tragically took the life''' of this nineteen-year old.." [https://www.gofundme.com/f/kj4g5-help-support-the-family-of-yassin-dabeh?utm_source=twitter&utm_medium=social&utm_campaign=p_cp+share-sheet link]
|
|
|-
|@TareqHadhad
|[https://twitter.com/TareqHadhad/status/1353464498791669761 "..'''stolen''' '''from us''' ... '''heartbroken''' .. loss of Yassin Dabeh,.. who '''died of COVID-19'''..."]
|".[https://x.com/Athena1944/status/1353697281892081668?s=20 .@Athena1944 Jan 25, 2021] '''Wait''' for the facts. The '''cause''' of death is '''not clear'''. So says local health authority..."

"..[https://x.com/she_ide/status/1353602500658520066?s=20 Shegide @she_ide] Jan 25, 2021 This is very unusual. Only two other deaths in Canada under the age of 20. Also, it was a '''sudden''' death which '''doesn't fit the profile of Covid'''-19. I suppose it's possible he had an '''undiagnosed''' illness. Very sorry for the family and I hope public health can '''explain''' his death.." .

"...comments on Hamilton Spec article so '''many are saying''' this was an OD etc '''not Covid'''. Very upsetting. '''Can''' you shed any '''light on this''' so I can counter these low life with facts?.." https://x.com/canadaobserver/status/1353525708677668864?s=20
|
|}

Talk:Digital ID

2023-05-02T18:33:30Z

Fallandtrip:

Ukraine has a Digital ID, one of the first to do so. Everything is online, you birth certificate, driver license, unemployment insurance, social security, etc. [[Ukraine#Digital_ID]]. [[User:RobSmith|RobS]][[User talk:RobSmith|Z+]] 21:41, June 16, 2022 (EDT)
:While the intro paragraph might be accurate, I would suggest a bit less editorializing. I agree that digital IDs are a bad idea, but I think it would be more effective and helpful to our readers if we first just introduce what it is and how it functions, then get in to pros (yes, there are a few), and cons (which in my opinion are much more significant), and provide references to back it all up. Sure, there are hidden motivations for those in authority to push digital IDs, but some readers may not even be familiar with what one is. I would therefore suggest that we start there. --[[User:DavidB4|DavidB4]] ([[User talk:DavidB4|TALK]]) 03:43, June 17, 2022 (EDT)
::The basic idea is that your driver license will be on your phone - which seems inevitable at some point. That's a good place to begin. Eventually everyone will need to do electronic income tax filing, or make unemployment claims that way. Getting Obamacare and all that stuff is done online. So you need to begin with the basic idea of a birth certificate, social security number, and driver license, and build it from there (as long as the US still has some private medical insurers, the issue of medical records online should be dealt with last, which would probably need its own page anyway). [[User:RobSmith|RobS]][[User talk:RobSmith|Z+]] 03:57, June 17, 2022 (EDT)

::The idea is, all your interactions with government will be done with a digital ID - even if you appeared in the DMV or Social Security office in person, they still would need your Digital ID number, probably a Q code off your phone. [[User:RobSmith|RobS]][[User talk:RobSmith|Z+]] 04:00, June 17, 2022 (EDT)

::The editorializing can go in a separate ==Criticism== section. [[User:RobSmith|RobS]][[User talk:RobSmith|Z+]] 04:04, June 17, 2022 (EDT)

Right on. Excellent suggestions above by all means.
Have in mind to clean up my recent changes including a better intro section with 2+ definitions and attempt to explain how 2 types of digital ID meet the defintion. Not sure if it could write easily, but I'd like to (''without'' editorializing or 'giving them ideas') amplify the subtopics (ie privacy and access control) that directly concern civil liberties with examples. Newish here and not sure about free time yet.--
[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 17:10, January 15, 2023 (EST)

Grateful for the community on this site. Requires tight combination of specialized knowledge of both the topic and how to layout in wikitext. Currently reading this book "Scanned" which is relevant. May be something I can cut out later but an email address for a throw-away account in case it could make sense to be reached by community. (roll.dice476@gmail.com) --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 17:53, January 15, 2023 (EST)

Global deployment section. links. Removed Background section. Let me know if new version sounds editorialized still. 👍 --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 21:20, January 16, 2023 (EST)

Article could benefit from simplicity. Took out most of my recent edits. Made a separate page for 'access control' (topic where I believe digital identity has most of its scandals). Im a noob so I might not yet have the best sense of how to link to AC or to the ukraine war subsection about digital ID. --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 00:13, January 18, 2023 (EST)

:I don't necessarily think all of what you added then removed, doesn't have value being there. But perhaps it could be condensed and simplified a little. --[[User:DavidB4|DavidB4]] ([[User talk:DavidB4|TALK]]) 00:38, January 18, 2023 (EST)

:: May roll these out gradually from backups.--[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 14:49, January 21, 2023 (EST)

Definition section.. would like to use the word 'exclusive' somehow in referring to the 'single authoritative party' to better hint at the authoritarianism relative to current (multi-root) predecessor-trust models. But this notion may yet sound too editorialized. --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 14:47, January 21, 2023 (EST)
:Not necessarily; maybe if you preface it with something like, "As of 2023, bla bla bla had exclusive..." to preempt future changes or criticism. [[User:RobSmith|RobS]][[User talk:RobSmith|''Give Peace a chance'']] 16:43, January 21, 2023 (EST)
:: Cool--[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 22:45, January 25, 2023 (EST)
 
Would like to add something somewhere along line of "[digital ID] also refers to a trend by governments toward withholding service in exchange for mandatory biometric data collection and authentication.".. citing below links. --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 22:45, January 25, 2023 (EST)
::Argentina SIM, artle linked at https://twitter.com/StatisticsBC/status/1618358521317425152?s=20&t=bqhPhFJNzVIU_Tx_kt467g
::Alberta drivers licences https://www.alberta.ca/id-requirements-for-identification-cards.aspx
::paywalled article https://thecountersignal.com/digitial-id-coercion-nigeria-blocks-73-million-phones/
::https://twitter.com/search?q=nigeria%20digital%20id&src=typed_query
::article linked at https://twitter.com/WomeninID/status/1608372402055954434?s=20&t=bqhPhFJNzVIU_Tx_kt467g
Would also like to find way of updating definition with something macrotrend-sounding like "Dig ID refers to a collection of trends: a small trend to consolidate commerce with politics(such as the links for frozen bank accounts), trend to remove your (stuff and) cards (decentralized methods of proving ID), a trend to replace them with (authoritarian need for centralizing) your most intimate data (biometrics)." Must be getting warmer . --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 23:07, January 25, 2023 (EST)
::Might move (refactor?) stuff like a) this idea for alternate (critical) definition and b) all previous critical remarks into the 'Criticism' section over time. Downside with explaining stuff 'too well' is it might 'lock in' unwanted tyranny by 'giving the answers' (not that this writer is likely to have that kind of insight).--[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 13:50, January 26, 2023 (EST)
:::Big update 4000ish units.. Did big chunk of that refactoring. Later I wish to expand on what is unique to other countries experiences. --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 15:44, January 26, 2023 (EST)

Feels like more work could be done. Would like to ... Simplify how it works, review recent reports, comment on Diia and Aadhaar, link to Pandemic Treaty, tighten the explanation of connections with SDGs. Good critical ideas are on Wikipedia's talk page. 👍🏼 --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 18:01, January 29, 2023 (EST)
::Wikipedia's 'digital identity' page has had a large content warning message at the top as well as the section 'Digital rhetoric' for what looks like years.. talk page refers to their article as being a mess as well, looks like. Tbf Im a noob to wikis and digital ID as well. I like one of their talk page posts about identity being something ''attributed'' by one's society/environment rather than as 'a thing' one possesses. --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 18:14, January 30, 2023 (EST) 
 
Monday
:Felt urgent to get coverage of UK's digital identity situation...
:Canada and Criticism sections are starting to get complex so I might soon move them to new pages with a condensed version left behind.
::Not sure yet if there's a way of making one page inherit sets of links from another page.. Likely not a good idea.--[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 18:20, January 30, 2023 (EST)

Would like to consider to start new sections perhaps for the following
::* Resources (books, reports, surveys, pdfs)
::* Deadlines coming up, by country (ie UK's march deadline and Canada has a DTB tender deadline in sept) --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 00:21, January 31, 2023 (EST)

Found interesting quotes today, while out looking for evidence for carbon tracking.
::"Dr. Naomi Wolf, an author and Rhodes Scholar, predicted that the vaccine passport would eventually track every aspect of people’s lives and would violate the U.S. Constitution, the Americans With Disabilities Act, and HIPAA." from https://lc.org/newsroom/details/111722-world-leaders-agree-to-implement-vaccine-passports-1 from https://rwmalonemd.substack.com/p/global-news-a-global-passport-for?sd=pf
:::the quote could help a subsection of criticism: Potential laws/rights being violated. Mixed feelings about using Wolf as a source so this could be tedious.
::Carbon stuff I wanted to use along with vaxpass stuff to plan a 'tutorial' section at the top that is more user-friendly and connects digital ID to familiars like the QR code apps.
::The reader could use a shorter article as well with simpler explanations, so my plan would be to move the Canada and Criticisms to other pages but leave behind a paragraph of the key points--[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 00:04, February 2, 2023 (EST)
:::
Sadly I have become unemployed and mostly preoccupied with IRL. Please jump in at will, whomever feels inclined to take over. --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 20:15, February 3, 2023 (EST)
:I'm sorry to hear that! I hope all goes well on that front! --[[User:DavidB4|DavidB4]] ([[User talk:DavidB4|TALK]]) 21:39, February 4, 2023 (EST)

Must somehow get around to tidying this article. Could expand on the appeal of digital id, cbdc and biometics from many angles ie Star Trek, as well as improving criticism section but shorter and with links to focused subarticles. Had ideas about returning the size to be very short . Also wonder if there is a portal for community members on discord etc. Doesn't appear to be private messaging on this platform, perhaps a good thing. --[[User:Fallandtrip|Fallandtrip]] ([[User talk:Fallandtrip|talk]]) 14:33, May 2, 2023 (EDT)

Talk:Digital ID

2023-02-04T01:15:16Z

Fallandtrip:

Digital ID

2023-02-03T03:44:10Z

Fallandtrip:

{{Progress}}

 
''See also Digital health credentials, [[Covid passport]], [[Vaccine passports]]'' 
 

Digital ID refers to ''an extension of current physical ID documents such as driver’s licences, passports and bank cards.. Digital ID is a way to verify who we are online securely, in a manner that offers data protection and safeguards our personal information (interac.ca)''<ref>https://www.interac.ca/en/content/ideas/what-is-digital-identity</ref>.
 

==Purpose==
Through the beginning of the twenty-first century, identity was typically affirmed by the use of paper or plastic cards, issued by third parties. In the United States, the [[Department of Motor Vehicles]] issues Driver Licenses, and other government identification cards. States may also issue ID cards of some form as well, such as welfare cards, gun permits, and fishing licenses. Organizations such as libraries, and membership-only clubs may issue identification cards as well. Additionally, independent companies may issue ID cards of a sort, such as insurance cards, gym membership cards, credit and debit cards, and other customer identification cards (for "rewards programs" and customer behavior tracking for marketing purposes). A digital ID system is designed to serve multiple purposes, eliminating the need for each separate identification card.<ref>https://www.globalgovernmentforum.com/digital-id-what-is-it-why-is-it-needed-and-how-are-governments-developing-it/</ref>
It also provides much greater control to a single authoritative party, rather than a diverse collection of entities, each for their own purposes. This could theoretically be useful in fighting crime<ref>https://www.dawn.com/news/1730768/safe-city-seeks-high-resolution-photos-of-over-4000-criminals-from-nadra</ref><ref>https://www.biometricupdate.com/202301/pakistan-id-authority-shares-data-of-4k-wanted-people-for-biometric-matching</ref>. However, that same single authority can use their power for negative purposes as well. For example, an opponent of the politicians in power could suddenly find their digital ID has been revoked, meaning that they can no longer bank<ref name = "bank1">"Bank Apologizes over Trucker Convoy account freeze ", Marc Patrone , May 30, 2022 , https://bjdichter.substack.com/p/bank-apologizes-over-trucker-convoy?r=10rk8l&</ref><ref name = "bank2">"..yesterday my ability to e-transfer funds was suddenly re-activated.”, Andrea Lee, May 2022, https://twitter.com/RealAndyLeeShow/status/1531645687548366848</ref><ref name = "bank3">Canadian Veteran banned from Scotiabank (phone audio) , Jan 20, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9R6SaXqxTI</ref><ref name = "bank4">https://twitter.com/rick_ppc/status/1616783852730474496</ref>, travel, buy food, earn money, or do much of anything else, all at once. The single ID authority would yield incredible power over its citizens, which some people see as a benefit and purpose of digital ID.<ref>https://thecountersignal.com/why-is-a-digital-id-so-dangerous/</ref><ref>https://www.wired.com/story/digital-ids-are-more-dangerous-than-you-think/</ref>
 
==International Treaties and Agendas==
The International treaties presented below describe ''groups agreeing to work together on'' international digital credential (ID) systems. One of the mechanisms is presented as the solution to global health crisis.

===United Nations===
The United Nations has 2 agendas which, between the 2, promote digital identity: United Nations ''Legal Identity Agenda'' and United Nations ''Development Programme Digital Strategy 2022-2025'' 
::For example, the word 'digital' actually occurs once on the landing page for the legal identity agenda: "''Proof of legal identity is defined as a credential, such as birth certificate, identity card or digital identity credential''"<ref>Legal Identity Agenda https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda </ref> 
Of note, UN LIA has a "Task Force" whose responsibilities include to ''oversee the implementation'' of the UN LIA at the ''regional and national'' level<ref>"UN Legal Identity Task Force (UN LIA TF) " https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda</ref>
''See discussion of both in [[UN Agendas]]''
===G20 Indonesia summit===
In November 2022, G20 members signed a declaration for the adoption of a global vaccine passport:
::''We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification message, under the framework of the [[International Health Regulations| International health regulations (WHO IHR)]] 2005 , to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize in build on the success of the existing standards and digital Covid-19 Certificates. (Point 23, G20 Bali Leaders' declaration, The White House)''<ref>p23, "......We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification methods, under the framework of the International health regulations (IHR 2005), to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, and recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize and build on the success of the existing standards and digital COVID-19 certificates. " https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/11/16/g20-bali-leaders-declaration/</ref><ref>secondary sources, tweet thread, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1593186333878816768</ref>

Notice 2 things with wording loose enough for the following:
::*The adoption of vaccine passports (digital ''health credential'' ID) for to facilitate all international travel.
::*WHO determines what crisis qualifies and which vaccinations one must have.

=== World Health Organization Pandemic Treaty ===
See [[International Health Regulations|International Health Regulations (IHRs) 2005]]

== Federated ID Systems ==
To federate<ref>"SSO is meant to authenticate one person across different systems. FIM will allow one user access to many applications over any number of networks..", from "Federated Identity Management vs. SSO: Which is Better?" Javed Shah, December 16, 2021 https://www.1kosmos.com/identity-management/federated-identity-management-vs-sso/</ref><ref>Compare and Contrast — Federated Identity vs Self-sovereign Identity Apr 26, 2021 https://academy.affinidi.com/compare-and-contrast-federated-identity-vs-self-sovereign-identity-227a85cbab18</ref><ref>White Paper: "Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach In this brief, we highlight why Canada needs a digital identity system, how other countries have .." May 30, 2018 https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref> a digital ID system refers to making national legislation. 

Ukraine was one of the first countries to federate a digital identity system Diia<ref>Video, “Ukraine exports its digital ID technology Ukraine’s government services smartphone app, Diia, has become so “successful” that other countries are interested in replicating it. One of those countries is Estonia, one of the world’s most digitized countries.” https://twitter.com/bigDkenna1/status/1618393202557345792</ref><ref>Video, "Diia (Short For "The State And I"): Mobile Application And Web Portal Review. My Personal Experience" Liza Clinical Wizard, Jan 28, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ath4RcBMo_0</ref>. India also has Aadhaar. Estonia has taken a unique 'decentralized' approach to a national digital ID system<ref>"Estonia's approach to digital ID... Decentralized and very different - but that didn't stop them being at the forefront of developing vaccine passports with the WHO." Jan 24 Alex Klaushofer , https://khmezek.substack.com/p/ukraines-diia-city-initiative-the , from "Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU." https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>.

== UK ==
On March 1st a consultation <ref>https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-legislation-to-help-more-people-prove-their-identity-online/consultation-on-draft-legislation-to-support-identity-verification</ref> (''a survey'') about digital identity verification and data sharing between public authorities comes to a close<ref name="whose-data">Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU , Alex Klaushofer Jan 23 2023, https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>. Launched on January 4th, the proposed changes will spend a short time under public consideration. Review and criticism videos are available.<ref>Video 34:40 "Digital IDs are coming - but there's still time to have YOUR say!" Geoff Buys Cars Jan 10, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COx6vl3i-L4</ref><ref>Video 9:19 "UK Government digital ID" funkyprepper Jan 12, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swciKHYS1Hg</ref><ref>Video 26:24 "Urgent! UK Government's Digital Identity Survey" Richard Vobes Jan 11, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcrwXQdGkn0</ref><ref name="whose-data"></ref><ref>Video 25:45 "Digital ID Arrives in Britain" 53,076+ views The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters Jan 17, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSqpSHN1iUs</ref>

== Canada==
Adopted by Canada and all other 192 [[United Nations]] Member States in 2015, the [[2030 Agenda]] is a 15-year global framework centered on an ambitious set of 17 [[Sustainable Development Goals]] (SDGs).<ref>"Canada and the Sustainable Development Goals ", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/agenda-2030.html</ref><ref>"Funding program", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/news/2019/05/sustainable-development-goals-sdg-funding-program.html</ref>

There are many government affiliated organizations working to advance digital identity systems in Canada. See [[ktdi.org]], [[Policy Horizons]] and [https://diacc.ca/faq/ Digital Identity and Authentication Council of Canada]

=== Airports / Known Traveller Digital Identity ===
The Known Traveller Digital Identity (KTDI) program is a collaboration between the government of Canada, the [[World Economic Forum]] and private sector to develop a secure and efficient digital identity system for air travel. The program aims to use biometric and digital identity technologies to create a more seamless and secure travel experience for passengers.
:The KTDI program was first announced in 2018 by the Government of Canada as part of its National Strategy for Secure Travelling Abroad. The aim of the program is to enhance the security of air travel while also making the travel experience more convenient and efficient for passengers. The program aims to use biometric data such as facial recognition, fingerprint, and iris scans to confirm the identity of passengers, making it easier for them to move through the airport and board their flights.
:The program has a pilot phase, with several Canadian airports participating in testing and evaluating the technology. Once fully implemented, the program will be available to all Canadian citizens and permanent residents with a valid passport.
It's worth noting that the implementation of the program is in line with the national strategy of Canada to enhance security and improve the passenger experience, but it also raises concerns about privacy, security, and accessibility. The government of Canada has stated that the personal information collected through the program will be protected and used only for the specific purpose of the program, and that the use of biometrics will be optional for passengers.

=== Border Land Travel / ArriveCAN===
The ArriveCAN app is an official government of Canada app that is used to help digitize border crossing into the country. "''Travellers returning to Canada: You are required to provide info upon entry for COVID19. Download the ArriveCAN app to do it quickly and limit points of contact at the border''"<ref>Health Canada and PHAC @GovCanHealth, Apr 29, 2020, https://twitter.com/GovCanHealth/status/1255602952045289474</ref>.
The app is available for download on the App Store and Google Play and is free to use. ''Concerns'' surround whether the app is mandatory to use.

=== Digital Health Credential Systems / Provinces ===
By 2021 Most provinces in Canada had announced plans to implement a [[Vaccine passports|digital vaccine certification system]], such as Ontario, which will use a digital version of the [[Covid passport|COVID-19 vaccination record card]] and a mobile app called the "COVID-19 Vaccination Record" to allow residents to demonstrate their vaccination status.

According to an ''unverified source''<ref>screenshot ".. tender for a Canadian Health Passport.." Dec 7 2022, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1600614353446883328</ref>, Canada's Digital Transformation Branch (DTB, within Health Canada) has issued a tender for a Canadian Health Passport which includes requirements for proof of vaccination for domestic and international travel. Another ''unverified source'' says this comes into effect Sept 2023.<ref>https://twitter.com/UNDERTHEBED/status/1601315955208257536</ref>

===Bankers Association ===
In Feb 2022, Neil Parmenter of the Canadian Bankers Association promoted digital identity advancement as being on the cusp of a revolution in how people authenticate online.<ref>"Canadian bankers association - Digital ID",World Reflection, 2min clip, circa Feb 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpUFY1-GmCA, cited by https://twitter.com/KathrynLouiseBC/status/1604916667523682305</ref>

==Criticisms==

Many critics take broad views of what is digital identity. For example, a pervasive take in places like UK and Canada is that digital ID is already here (youtuber Coin Bureau<ref>Video "Digital IDs Are HERE!! Why You Should Be WORRIED!!.." Coin Bureau, Dec 11, 2022 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwRSzNTp2ko&t=169s</ref>, see notes on surveilance and bank freezing). Concerns about digital identity are addressed in books such as "''Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom''"(2022)<ref>"Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom Paperback "– March 17, 2022 by Nick Corbishley (Author) https://www.amazon.com/Scanned-Vaccine-Passports-Digital-Personal/dp/1645021629</ref> as well, where the main concerns are to privacy and personal liberties but end up being concerned with all levels of human needs.

===Composite Definition ===
One writer proposes to view digital identity as a composite (set) of concurrent trends:
# tying commerce/banking with politics (frozen bank accounts<ref name = "bank1"> </ref><ref name = "bank2"> </ref><ref name = "bank3"> </ref><ref name = "bank4"> </ref>, vilification of anonymity<ref>"The US Justice Department is part of WEF's Partnership against Cybercrime, which is run by an Israeli intelligence veteran and pushes for the end of online anonymity and the merging of Wall Street w their regulators and intelligence agencies. "Jan 18, 2023 https://twitter.com/_whitneywebb/status/1615754783494930432</ref><ref>"We investigated how objective, behavioral data on [[social media]] use was correlated with the Dark Tetrad facets and the HEXACO traits., " from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191886922004652, from "Don't allow the anonymous troll-demons to post with the real verified people @elonmusk . Put them in their own hell.." Nov 18, 2022 https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/1593691037121228801</ref> and privacy<ref>"..privacy and freedom of expression issues that have not been addressed by the government of Canada." Sep 19, 2022 PrivacyLawyer - David Fraser, "My main problem with Bill C 11: The regulation of user-generated content " https://youtu.be/KKx_0UfdsT0 </ref>, 
# promotion of Customer-rewards and [[Points Programs|digital points]] systems, [[Universal basic income]] and [[social credit system|social credit systems]], promotions of CBDC agendas),
# trends to ''require'' one's most intimate data ([[biometrics]]<ref>"Integration of blockchain and biometrics to redefine digital identity by 2030: report" Nov 12, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/integration-of-blockchain-and-biometrics-to-redefine-digital-identity-by-2030-report</ref>) for [[Multifactor Authentication|authentication]] and [[Access Control|access]]<ref>"Sentry Enterprise’s plans to supply enterprises with physical and logical access control through its biometric SentryCards..." from "Stage set for next round of secure access control biometrics adoption" Jan 22, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/stage-set-for-next-round-of-secure-access-control-biometrics-adoption</ref> to commerce(Amazon One<ref>Video "Pay with the palm of your hand.." Jan 27, 2023 https://twitter.com/george_orwell3/status/1619113034571730944</ref>), services, and to perhaps remove one's cards<ref>video, Jan 27, 2023, https://youtu.be/cwj4unWn6vw</ref> ('' decentralized methods of proving ID''),
# centralized and restricted access to essentials like gas<ref>Video "Sri Lanka is using digital gas ration books now. How do you think this will be abused?" Aug 9, 2022 https://twitter.com/YALiberty/status/1557079415116500994</ref><ref>"Digital ration cards in Sri Lanka for fuel. .. they literally won't serve you, and to make matters worse the petrol stations all over Sri Lanka now have fully automatic weapons at the petrol stations because you can imagine people's response.. " Sep 5, 2022 https://twitter.com/Alessa11alexa/status/1566855907962658818</ref><ref>"The integration of P97 mobile commerce platform with Cerence Pay makes voice biometric payments available at more than 30 percent of fuel retailers in the U.S., according to the announcement" from "Cerence biometrics partnership brings voice purchases to US gas stations" May 18, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202105/cerence-biometrics-partnership-brings-voice-purchases-to-us-gas-stations</ref>, food<ref>"AnyVision explores biometrics in food distribution and logistics applications" Jun 9, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202106/anyvision-explores-biometrics-in-food-distribution-and-logistics-applications</ref><ref>"Yoti discusses digital identity use to monitor food and cash rations" Nov 23, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/yoti-discusses-digital-identity-use-to-monitor-food-and-cash-rations</ref><ref>"Integrated Biometrics case study details fingerprint verification of food aid recipients in Yemen" Apr 8, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202004/integrated-biometrics-case-study-details-fingerprint-verification-of-food-aid-recipients-in-yemen </ref> 
# rising authoritarianism<ref>"The allure of Chinese ‘digital authoritarianism’ for Latin America" Jan 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/the-allure-of-chinese-digital-authoritarianism-for-latin-america</ref><ref>"IBIA Annual Membership Meeting to feature presentation on COVID-19, authoritarianism and biometrics Jun"Jun 30, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202006/ibia-annual-membership-meeting-to-feature-presentation-on-covid-19-authoritarianism-and-biometrics</ref><ref>"Authoritarianism in South Korea keeps peeking around the curtain... ", from "orea’s out front with digital IDs, but national history could be decisive in success" Oct 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202210/koreas-out-front-with-digital-ids-but-national-history-could-be-decisive-in-success</ref>
# Digital Health Credential systems, ''see [[International Health Regulations|WHO Pandemic Treaty (International Health Regulations IHRs)]], [[Covid passport|covid vaccine passports]])''

===Predictable===
Many critics view these developments as to be expected and predicted by earlier trends. Perhaps the biggest predictor trend is the decline in the level of individual [[freedom]], respect for [[natural law]] and [[unalienable rights]], and [[self-governance]] in [[The West|Western countries]]. This decline is accompanied by the decline in biblical values which affirm the importance of freedom.<ref>Behreandt, Dennis (January 3, 2020). [https://www.thenewamerican.com/print-magazine/item/34261-the-divine-message-of-freedom The Divine Message of Freedom]</ref>. See also [[War on freedom]], and books like RFK's "''The Real Anthony Fauci.. Global War on Democracy and Public Health''"<ref>"The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health " Nov. 16 2021 Robert F. Kennedy Jr. https://www.amazon.ca/Real-Anthony-Fauci-Pharma-Democracy/dp/1510766804</ref>

===Data and Access===
Digital ID proponents tend also to seek to centralize data and control access to it: A Digital ID system is a centralized approach to '''trust'''. See [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Early_CA_infrastructure|HTTPS/SSL history]] for problems with centralized trust models. Digital ID proponents also seek to centralize very large<ref>"..now reportedly contains information on 5,500 law enforcement agencies in all 50 states and multiple territories and districts." from "US biometric surveillance database reaches 10,000 data points " Nov 21, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202211/us-biometric-surveillance-database-reaches-10000-data-points</ref><ref>"Government databases could replace document-based ID verification: Sumsub CTO" Dec 12, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202212/government-databases-could-replace-document-based-id-verification-sumsub-cto</ref> datasets and '''databases'''<ref>Video "Dangers of plants and centralized data" Matt Gubba, circa Jan 22, https://twitter.com/Raul_Aztec/status/1617187582743388237</ref>. This sort of policy is attractive externally (to hackers and bad actors) and internally(poor morale and ethic, human error, incompetence<ref> "Bumbling NYPD contractor nearly infects fingerprint database with ransomware " Dec 13, 2019 https://www.biometricupdate.com/201912/bumbling-nypd-contractor-nearly-infects-fingerprint-database-with-ransomware</ref> ).

===Privacy ===
Many are concerned that federated digital identity places too much importance on "''who'' are you" (as if what a service provider can establish from cards and multifactor authentication falls short and that knowledge of one's business history is needed at each new signup):
::''It is important to differentiate between digital identification and digital authentication. Digital authentication is something most of us do every day – logging on to our favourite social media site, signing into an account with our preferred ecommerce retailer, or even accessing our mobile device through a thumb scan. Authentication is the act of proving that the person accessing my account or device is me, usually through a PIN, password, biometric identifier or other form factor. Authentication is designed to answer the question “Is that you?” Identification, by contrast, is more complex. Identification is intended to answer the question “Who are you?” Digital ID is the challenge of answering “Who are you? with a high degree of certainty, without resorting to face-to-face interaction and the exchange of physical documents.''<ref>"White Paper: Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach", Posted on: May 30, 2018, https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref>

=== Travel, Carbon tracking ===
December 2021, just before Christmas, Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) acknowledged that it ''secretly'' tracked location data from at least 33 million mobile devices to analyze people's movements during COVID-19 quarantines.<ref>Video, press conference, tweet Jan 18, 2022, https://twitter.com/Aslapes11/status/1483389677096820742</ref>. Concerns are whether this behaviour continues to this day or has suitable checks and balances. 

''Canada's Net-Zero Challenge<ref>"Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act - Canada.ca" 
https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/canadian-net-zero-emissions-accountability-act.html</ref><ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/challenge.html</ref> is a voluntary initiative that encourages companies to develop and implement credible and effective plans to transition their facilities and operations to net-zero emissions by 2050.''<ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/2022/08/net-zero-challenge.html</ref>

==See also==
* [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Digital_certificates|Digital Certificates]]
* [[Digital_Signature|Digital Signature]]
* [[Access Control]]
* [[Ukraine#Digital_ID|Ukraine Digital_ID]]
* [[Sustainable Development Goals|Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs)]]
* [[The Great Reset|Agenda: Great Reset and 4th Industrial Revolution (WEF)]]
* [[Right to Privacy]]
* [[Surveillance]]
* [[Social credit system]]
* [[Creeping socialism]]
* [[War_on_Freedom#Big_Tech | Big tech's role in war on freedom (War on Freedom) ]]

==References==
{{reflist}}

[[Category:Uncategorized]]

Digital ID

2023-02-03T03:43:13Z

Fallandtrip:

{{Progress}}

 
''See also Digital health credentials, [[Covid passport]], [[Vaccine passports]]'' 
 

Digital ID refers to ''an extension of current physical ID documents such as driver’s licences, passports and bank cards.. Digital ID is a way to verify who we are online securely, in a manner that offers data protection and safeguards our personal information (interac.ca)''<ref>https://www.interac.ca/en/content/ideas/what-is-digital-identity</ref>.
 

==Purpose==
Through the beginning of the twenty-first century, identity was typically affirmed by the use of paper or plastic cards, issued by third parties. In the United States, the [[Department of Motor Vehicles]] issues Driver Licenses, and other government identification cards. States may also issue ID cards of some form as well, such as welfare cards, gun permits, and fishing licenses. Organizations such as libraries, and membership-only clubs may issue identification cards as well. Additionally, independent companies may issue ID cards of a sort, such as insurance cards, gym membership cards, credit and debit cards, and other customer identification cards (for "rewards programs" and customer behavior tracking for marketing purposes). A digital ID system is designed to serve multiple purposes, eliminating the need for each separate identification card.<ref>https://www.globalgovernmentforum.com/digital-id-what-is-it-why-is-it-needed-and-how-are-governments-developing-it/</ref>
It also provides much greater control to a single authoritative party, rather than a diverse collection of entities, each for their own purposes. This could theoretically be useful in fighting crime<ref>https://www.dawn.com/news/1730768/safe-city-seeks-high-resolution-photos-of-over-4000-criminals-from-nadra</ref><ref>https://www.biometricupdate.com/202301/pakistan-id-authority-shares-data-of-4k-wanted-people-for-biometric-matching</ref>. However, that same single authority can use their power for negative purposes as well. For example, an opponent of the politicians in power could suddenly find their digital ID has been revoked, meaning that they can no longer bank<ref name = "bank1">"Bank Apologizes over Trucker Convoy account freeze ", Marc Patrone , May 30, 2022 , https://bjdichter.substack.com/p/bank-apologizes-over-trucker-convoy?r=10rk8l&</ref><ref name = "bank2">"..yesterday my ability to e-transfer funds was suddenly re-activated.”, Andrea Lee, May 2022, https://twitter.com/RealAndyLeeShow/status/1531645687548366848</ref><ref name = "bank3">Canadian Veteran banned from Scotiabank (phone audio) , Jan 20, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9R6SaXqxTI</ref><ref name = "bank4">https://twitter.com/rick_ppc/status/1616783852730474496</ref>, travel, buy food, earn money, or do much of anything else, all at once. The single ID authority would yield incredible power over its citizens, which some people see as a benefit and purpose of digital ID.<ref>https://thecountersignal.com/why-is-a-digital-id-so-dangerous/</ref><ref>https://www.wired.com/story/digital-ids-are-more-dangerous-than-you-think/</ref>
 
==International Treaties and Agendas==
The International treaties presented below describe ''groups agreeing to work together on'' international digital credential (ID) systems. One of the mechanisms is presented as the solution to global health crisis.

===United Nations===
The United Nations has 2 agendas which, between the 2, promote digital identity: United Nations ''Legal Identity Agenda'' and United Nations ''Development Programme Digital Strategy 2022-2025'' 
::For example, the word 'digital' actually occurs once on the landing page for the legal identity agenda: "''Proof of legal identity is defined as a credential, such as birth certificate, identity card or digital identity credential''"<ref>Legal Identity Agenda https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda </ref> 
Of note, UN LIA has a "Task Force" whose responsibilities include to ''oversee the implementation'' of the UN LIA at the ''regional and national'' level<ref>"UN Legal Identity Task Force (UN LIA TF) " https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda</ref>
''See discussion of both in [[UN Agendas]]''
===G20 Indonesia summit===
In November 2022, G20 members signed a declaration for the adoption of a global vaccine passport:
::''We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification message, under the framework of the [[International Health Regulations| International health regulations (WHO IHR)]] 2005 , to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize in build on the success of the existing standards and digital Covid-19 Certificates. (Point 23, G20 Bali Leaders' declaration, The White House)''<ref>p23, "......We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification methods, under the framework of the International health regulations (IHR 2005), to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, and recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize and build on the success of the existing standards and digital COVID-19 certificates. " https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/11/16/g20-bali-leaders-declaration/</ref><ref>secondary sources, tweet thread, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1593186333878816768</ref>

Notice 2 things with wording loose enough for the following:
::*The adoption of vaccine passports (digital ''health credential'' ID) for to facilitate all international travel.
::*WHO determines what crisis qualifies and which vaccinations one must have.

=== World Health Organization Pandemic Treaty ===
See [[International Health Regulations|International Health Regulations (IHRs) 2005]]

== Federated ID Systems ==
To federate<ref>"SSO is meant to authenticate one person across different systems. FIM will allow one user access to many applications over any number of networks..", from "Federated Identity Management vs. SSO: Which is Better?" Javed Shah, December 16, 2021 https://www.1kosmos.com/identity-management/federated-identity-management-vs-sso/</ref><ref>Compare and Contrast — Federated Identity vs Self-sovereign Identity Apr 26, 2021 https://academy.affinidi.com/compare-and-contrast-federated-identity-vs-self-sovereign-identity-227a85cbab18</ref><ref>White Paper: "Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach In this brief, we highlight why Canada needs a digital identity system, how other countries have .." May 30, 2018 https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref> a digital ID system refers to making national legislation. 

Ukraine was one of the first countries to federate a digital identity system Diia<ref>Video, “Ukraine exports its digital ID technology Ukraine’s government services smartphone app, Diia, has become so “successful” that other countries are interested in replicating it. One of those countries is Estonia, one of the world’s most digitized countries.” https://twitter.com/bigDkenna1/status/1618393202557345792</ref><ref>Video, "Diia (Short For "The State And I"): Mobile Application And Web Portal Review. My Personal Experience" Liza Clinical Wizard, Jan 28, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ath4RcBMo_0</ref>. India also has Aadhaar. Estonia has taken a unique 'decentralized' approach to a national digital ID system<ref>"Estonia's approach to digital ID... Decentralized and very different - but that didn't stop them being at the forefront of developing vaccine passports with the WHO." Jan 24 Alex Klaushofer , https://khmezek.substack.com/p/ukraines-diia-city-initiative-the , from "Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU." https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>.

== UK ==
On March 1st a consultation <ref>https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-legislation-to-help-more-people-prove-their-identity-online/consultation-on-draft-legislation-to-support-identity-verification</ref> (''a survey'') about digital identity verification and data sharing between public authorities comes to a close<ref name="whose-data">Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU , Alex Klaushofer Jan 23 2023, https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>. Launched on January 4th, the proposed changes will spend a short time under public consideration. Review and criticism videos are available.<ref>Video 34:40 "Digital IDs are coming - but there's still time to have YOUR say!" Geoff Buys Cars Jan 10, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COx6vl3i-L4</ref><ref>Video 9:19 "UK Government digital ID" funkyprepper Jan 12, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swciKHYS1Hg</ref><ref>Video 26:24 "Urgent! UK Government's Digital Identity Survey" Richard Vobes Jan 11, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcrwXQdGkn0</ref><ref name="whose-data"></ref><ref>Video 25:45 "Digital ID Arrives in Britain" 53,076+ views The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters Jan 17, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSqpSHN1iUs</ref>

== Canada==
Adopted by Canada and all other 192 [[United Nations]] Member States in 2015, the [[2030 Agenda]] is a 15-year global framework centered on an ambitious set of 17 [[Sustainable Development Goals]] (SDGs).<ref>"Canada and the Sustainable Development Goals ", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/agenda-2030.html</ref><ref>"Funding program", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/news/2019/05/sustainable-development-goals-sdg-funding-program.html</ref>

There are many government affiliated organizations working to advance digital identity systems in Canada. See [[ktdi.org]], [[Policy Horizons]] and [https://diacc.ca/faq/ Digital Identity and Authentication Council of Canada]

=== Airports / Known Traveller Digital Identity ===
The Known Traveller Digital Identity (KTDI) program is a collaboration between the government of Canada, the [[World Economic Forum]] and private sector to develop a secure and efficient digital identity system for air travel. The program aims to use biometric and digital identity technologies to create a more seamless and secure travel experience for passengers.
:The KTDI program was first announced in 2018 by the Government of Canada as part of its National Strategy for Secure Travelling Abroad. The aim of the program is to enhance the security of air travel while also making the travel experience more convenient and efficient for passengers. The program aims to use biometric data such as facial recognition, fingerprint, and iris scans to confirm the identity of passengers, making it easier for them to move through the airport and board their flights.
:The program has a pilot phase, with several Canadian airports participating in testing and evaluating the technology. Once fully implemented, the program will be available to all Canadian citizens and permanent residents with a valid passport.
It's worth noting that the implementation of the program is in line with the national strategy of Canada to enhance security and improve the passenger experience, but it also raises concerns about privacy, security, and accessibility. The government of Canada has stated that the personal information collected through the program will be protected and used only for the specific purpose of the program, and that the use of biometrics will be optional for passengers.

=== Border Land Travel / ArriveCAN===
The ArriveCAN app is an official government of Canada app that is used to help digitize border crossing into the country. "''Travellers returning to Canada: You are required to provide info upon entry for COVID19. Download the ArriveCAN app to do it quickly and limit points of contact at the border''"<ref>Health Canada and PHAC @GovCanHealth, Apr 29, 2020, https://twitter.com/GovCanHealth/status/1255602952045289474</ref>.
The app is available for download on the App Store and Google Play and is free to use. ''Concerns'' surround whether the app is mandatory to use.

=== Digital Health Credential Systems / Provinces ===
By 2021 Most provinces in Canada had announced plans to implement a [[Vaccine passports|digital vaccine certification system]], such as Ontario, which will use a digital version of the [[Covid passport|COVID-19 vaccination record card]] and a mobile app called the "COVID-19 Vaccination Record" to allow residents to demonstrate their vaccination status.

According to an ''unverified source''<ref>screenshot ".. tender for a Canadian Health Passport.." Dec 7 2022, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1600614353446883328</ref>, Canada's Digital Transformation Branch (DTB, within Health Canada) has issued a tender for a Canadian Health Passport which includes requirements for proof of vaccination for domestic and international travel. Another ''unverified source'' says this comes into effect Sept 2023.<ref>https://twitter.com/UNDERTHEBED/status/1601315955208257536</ref>

===Bankers Association ===
In Feb 2022, Neil Parmenter of the Canadian Bankers Association promoted digital identity advancement as being on the cusp of a revolution in how people authenticate online.<ref>"Canadian bankers association - Digital ID",World Reflection, 2min clip, circa Feb 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpUFY1-GmCA, cited by https://twitter.com/KathrynLouiseBC/status/1604916667523682305</ref>

==Criticisms==

Many critics take broad views of what is digital identity. For example, a pervasive take in places like UK and Canada is that digital ID is already here (youtuber Coin Bureau<ref>Video "Digital IDs Are HERE!! Why You Should Be WORRIED!!.." Coin Bureau, Dec 11, 2022 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwRSzNTp2ko&t=169s</ref>, see notes on surveilance and bank freezing). Concerns about digital identity are addressed in books such as "''Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom''"(2022)<ref>"Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom Paperback "– March 17, 2022 by Nick Corbishley (Author) https://www.amazon.com/Scanned-Vaccine-Passports-Digital-Personal/dp/1645021629</ref> as well, where the main concerns are to privacy and personal liberties but end up being concerned with all levels of human needs.

===Composite Definition ===
One writer proposes to view digital identity as a composite (set) of concurrent trends:
# tying commerce/banking with politics (frozen bank accounts<ref name = "bank1"> </ref><ref name = "bank2"> </ref><ref name = "bank3"> </ref><ref name = "bank4"> </ref>, vilification of anonymity<ref>"The US Justice Department is part of WEF's Partnership against Cybercrime, which is run by an Israeli intelligence veteran and pushes for the end of online anonymity and the merging of Wall Street w their regulators and intelligence agencies. "Jan 18, 2023 https://twitter.com/_whitneywebb/status/1615754783494930432</ref><ref>"We investigated how objective, behavioral data on [[social media]] use was correlated with the Dark Tetrad facets and the HEXACO traits., " from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191886922004652, from "Don't allow the anonymous troll-demons to post with the real verified people @elonmusk . Put them in their own hell.." Nov 18, 2022 https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/1593691037121228801</ref> and privacy<ref>"..privacy and freedom of expression issues that have not been addressed by the government of Canada." Sep 19, 2022 PrivacyLawyer - David Fraser, "My main problem with Bill C 11: The regulation of user-generated content " https://youtu.be/KKx_0UfdsT0 </ref>, 
# promotion of [[Points Programs|digital points]] systems, [[Universal basic income]] and [[social credit system|social credit systems]], promotions of CBDC agendas),
# trends to ''require'' one's most intimate data ([[biometrics]]<ref>"Integration of blockchain and biometrics to redefine digital identity by 2030: report" Nov 12, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/integration-of-blockchain-and-biometrics-to-redefine-digital-identity-by-2030-report</ref>) for [[Multifactor Authentication|authentication]] and [[Access Control|access]]<ref>"Sentry Enterprise’s plans to supply enterprises with physical and logical access control through its biometric SentryCards..." from "Stage set for next round of secure access control biometrics adoption" Jan 22, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/stage-set-for-next-round-of-secure-access-control-biometrics-adoption</ref> to commerce(Amazon One<ref>Video "Pay with the palm of your hand.." Jan 27, 2023 https://twitter.com/george_orwell3/status/1619113034571730944</ref>), services, and to perhaps remove one's cards<ref>video, Jan 27, 2023, https://youtu.be/cwj4unWn6vw</ref> ('' decentralized methods of proving ID''),
# centralized and restricted access to essentials like gas<ref>Video "Sri Lanka is using digital gas ration books now. How do you think this will be abused?" Aug 9, 2022 https://twitter.com/YALiberty/status/1557079415116500994</ref><ref>"Digital ration cards in Sri Lanka for fuel. .. they literally won't serve you, and to make matters worse the petrol stations all over Sri Lanka now have fully automatic weapons at the petrol stations because you can imagine people's response.. " Sep 5, 2022 https://twitter.com/Alessa11alexa/status/1566855907962658818</ref><ref>"The integration of P97 mobile commerce platform with Cerence Pay makes voice biometric payments available at more than 30 percent of fuel retailers in the U.S., according to the announcement" from "Cerence biometrics partnership brings voice purchases to US gas stations" May 18, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202105/cerence-biometrics-partnership-brings-voice-purchases-to-us-gas-stations</ref>, food<ref>"AnyVision explores biometrics in food distribution and logistics applications" Jun 9, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202106/anyvision-explores-biometrics-in-food-distribution-and-logistics-applications</ref><ref>"Yoti discusses digital identity use to monitor food and cash rations" Nov 23, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/yoti-discusses-digital-identity-use-to-monitor-food-and-cash-rations</ref><ref>"Integrated Biometrics case study details fingerprint verification of food aid recipients in Yemen" Apr 8, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202004/integrated-biometrics-case-study-details-fingerprint-verification-of-food-aid-recipients-in-yemen </ref> 
# rising authoritarianism<ref>"The allure of Chinese ‘digital authoritarianism’ for Latin America" Jan 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/the-allure-of-chinese-digital-authoritarianism-for-latin-america</ref><ref>"IBIA Annual Membership Meeting to feature presentation on COVID-19, authoritarianism and biometrics Jun"Jun 30, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202006/ibia-annual-membership-meeting-to-feature-presentation-on-covid-19-authoritarianism-and-biometrics</ref><ref>"Authoritarianism in South Korea keeps peeking around the curtain... ", from "orea’s out front with digital IDs, but national history could be decisive in success" Oct 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202210/koreas-out-front-with-digital-ids-but-national-history-could-be-decisive-in-success</ref>
# Digital Health Credential systems, ''see [[International Health Regulations|WHO Pandemic Treaty (International Health Regulations IHRs)]], [[Covid passport|covid vaccine passports]])''

===Predictable===
Many critics view these developments as to be expected and predicted by earlier trends. Perhaps the biggest predictor trend is the decline in the level of individual [[freedom]], respect for [[natural law]] and [[unalienable rights]], and [[self-governance]] in [[The West|Western countries]]. This decline is accompanied by the decline in biblical values which affirm the importance of freedom.<ref>Behreandt, Dennis (January 3, 2020). [https://www.thenewamerican.com/print-magazine/item/34261-the-divine-message-of-freedom The Divine Message of Freedom]</ref>. See also [[War on freedom]], and books like RFK's "''The Real Anthony Fauci.. Global War on Democracy and Public Health''"<ref>"The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health " Nov. 16 2021 Robert F. Kennedy Jr. https://www.amazon.ca/Real-Anthony-Fauci-Pharma-Democracy/dp/1510766804</ref>

===Data and Access===
Digital ID proponents tend also to seek to centralize data and control access to it: A Digital ID system is a centralized approach to '''trust'''. See [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Early_CA_infrastructure|HTTPS/SSL history]] for problems with centralized trust models. Digital ID proponents also seek to centralize very large<ref>"..now reportedly contains information on 5,500 law enforcement agencies in all 50 states and multiple territories and districts." from "US biometric surveillance database reaches 10,000 data points " Nov 21, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202211/us-biometric-surveillance-database-reaches-10000-data-points</ref><ref>"Government databases could replace document-based ID verification: Sumsub CTO" Dec 12, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202212/government-databases-could-replace-document-based-id-verification-sumsub-cto</ref> datasets and '''databases'''<ref>Video "Dangers of plants and centralized data" Matt Gubba, circa Jan 22, https://twitter.com/Raul_Aztec/status/1617187582743388237</ref>. This sort of policy is attractive externally (to hackers and bad actors) and internally(poor morale and ethic, human error, incompetence<ref> "Bumbling NYPD contractor nearly infects fingerprint database with ransomware " Dec 13, 2019 https://www.biometricupdate.com/201912/bumbling-nypd-contractor-nearly-infects-fingerprint-database-with-ransomware</ref> ).

===Privacy ===
Many are concerned that federated digital identity places too much importance on "''who'' are you" (as if what a service provider can establish from cards and multifactor authentication falls short and that knowledge of one's business history is needed at each new signup):
::''It is important to differentiate between digital identification and digital authentication. Digital authentication is something most of us do every day – logging on to our favourite social media site, signing into an account with our preferred ecommerce retailer, or even accessing our mobile device through a thumb scan. Authentication is the act of proving that the person accessing my account or device is me, usually through a PIN, password, biometric identifier or other form factor. Authentication is designed to answer the question “Is that you?” Identification, by contrast, is more complex. Identification is intended to answer the question “Who are you?” Digital ID is the challenge of answering “Who are you? with a high degree of certainty, without resorting to face-to-face interaction and the exchange of physical documents.''<ref>"White Paper: Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach", Posted on: May 30, 2018, https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref>

=== Travel, Carbon tracking ===
December 2021, just before Christmas, Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) acknowledged that it ''secretly'' tracked location data from at least 33 million mobile devices to analyze people's movements during COVID-19 quarantines.<ref>Video, press conference, tweet Jan 18, 2022, https://twitter.com/Aslapes11/status/1483389677096820742</ref>. Concerns are whether this behaviour continues to this day or has suitable checks and balances. 

''Canada's Net-Zero Challenge<ref>"Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act - Canada.ca" 
https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/canadian-net-zero-emissions-accountability-act.html</ref><ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/challenge.html</ref> is a voluntary initiative that encourages companies to develop and implement credible and effective plans to transition their facilities and operations to net-zero emissions by 2050.''<ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/2022/08/net-zero-challenge.html</ref>

==See also==
* [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Digital_certificates|Digital Certificates]]
* [[Digital_Signature|Digital Signature]]
* [[Access Control]]
* [[Ukraine#Digital_ID|Ukraine Digital_ID]]
* [[Sustainable Development Goals|Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs)]]
* [[The Great Reset|Agenda: Great Reset and 4th Industrial Revolution (WEF)]]
* [[Right to Privacy]]
* [[Surveillance]]
* [[Social credit system]]
* [[Creeping socialism]]
* [[War_on_Freedom#Big_Tech | Big tech's role in war on freedom (War on Freedom) ]]

==References==
{{reflist}}

[[Category:Uncategorized]]

Points Programs

2023-02-03T03:41:59Z

Fallandtrip: Created page with "See also Customer-loyalty cards, === Background === The use of points cards by Canadian businesses dates back to the 1980s and 1990s, when loyalty programs first emerged as..."

See also Customer-loyalty cards,

=== Background ===

The use of points cards by Canadian businesses dates back to the 1980s and 1990s, when loyalty programs first emerged as a marketing tool for companies to reward and retain customers. Some of the earliest loyalty programs in Canada were offered by retailers and supermarkets, who offered customers points or rewards for making purchases.

In the late 1990s and early 2000s, the use of points cards expanded to other industries, including the travel and entertainment sectors. Airlines, hotels, and movie theater chains began offering their own loyalty programs, which allowed customers to earn points or miles for purchases and to redeem those points for travel or entertainment-related rewards.

Over the past two decades, the use of points cards has become increasingly popular in Canada, and many businesses across a variety of industries now offer loyalty programs. The growth of digital technology has made it easier for companies to track and reward customer behavior, and has also allowed customers to easily manage their rewards and track their progress online. Today, points cards continue to be a popular way for Canadian businesses to incentivize customer loyalty and to build long-term relationships with their customers.

== Canadian Food Service Apps ==

To make a payment at Tim Hortons using a phone app, follow these steps:
Download the Tim Hortons app from the App Store or Google Play store.
Create an account or log in to an existing account.
Add payment information to your account, such as a credit or debit card.
When you're ready to make a purchase at Tim Hortons, open the app and select the items you'd like to purchase.
At the checkout, select the "Pay with App" option.
Review your order and confirm the payment.
Show the cashier the confirmation code or QR code generated by the app to complete the transaction.

Note: Availability of the app payment option may vary depending on the location.

To redeem points for food using the McDonald's phone app, follow these steps:
Download the McDonald's app from the App Store or Google Play store.
Create an account or log in to an existing account.
Earn points by making purchases at participating McDonald's restaurants.
Select the "Rewards" section of the app to view your available points.
Select the food item or menu items you'd like to purchase.
At the checkout, select the option to redeem points.
Confirm the redemption of points and complete the purchase.

Note: Availability and terms of the rewards program may vary by location. Be sure to check the terms and conditions of the rewards program in your area before redeeming points.

==Entertainment apps==

Scene points cards are used by customers in Canada who are members of the Scene loyalty program. The Scene program is a Canadian loyalty program offered by Cineplex, a Canadian entertainment company. The program rewards members for purchasing movie tickets and concessions, as well as for participating in various other activities. Scene points can be redeemed for a variety of rewards, including free movie tickets, concessions, and merchandise. Scene is popular among Canadians who are frequent movie-goers and who enjoy earning rewards for their purchases.

Talk:Digital ID

2023-02-02T05:04:22Z

Fallandtrip:

Digital ID

2023-02-02T01:13:51Z

Fallandtrip:

{{Progress}}

 
''See also Digital health credentials, [[Covid passport]], [[Vaccine passports]]'' 
 

Digital ID refers to ''an extension of current physical ID documents such as driver’s licences, passports and bank cards.. Digital ID is a way to verify who we are online securely, in a manner that offers data protection and safeguards our personal information (interac.ca)''<ref>https://www.interac.ca/en/content/ideas/what-is-digital-identity</ref>.
 

==Purpose==
Through the beginning of the twenty-first century, identity was typically affirmed by the use of paper or plastic cards, issued by third parties. In the United States, the [[Department of Motor Vehicles]] issues Driver Licenses, and other government identification cards. States may also issue ID cards of some form as well, such as welfare cards, gun permits, and fishing licenses. Organizations such as libraries, and membership-only clubs may issue identification cards as well. Additionally, independent companies may issue ID cards of a sort, such as insurance cards, gym membership cards, credit and debit cards, and other customer identification cards (for "rewards programs" and customer behavior tracking for marketing purposes). A digital ID system is designed to serve multiple purposes, eliminating the need for each separate identification card.<ref>https://www.globalgovernmentforum.com/digital-id-what-is-it-why-is-it-needed-and-how-are-governments-developing-it/</ref>
It also provides much greater control to a single authoritative party, rather than a diverse collection of entities, each for their own purposes. This could theoretically be useful in fighting crime<ref>https://www.dawn.com/news/1730768/safe-city-seeks-high-resolution-photos-of-over-4000-criminals-from-nadra</ref><ref>https://www.biometricupdate.com/202301/pakistan-id-authority-shares-data-of-4k-wanted-people-for-biometric-matching</ref>. However, that same single authority can use their power for negative purposes as well. For example, an opponent of the politicians in power could suddenly find their digital ID has been revoked, meaning that they can no longer bank<ref name = "bank1">"Bank Apologizes over Trucker Convoy account freeze ", Marc Patrone , May 30, 2022 , https://bjdichter.substack.com/p/bank-apologizes-over-trucker-convoy?r=10rk8l&</ref><ref name = "bank2">"..yesterday my ability to e-transfer funds was suddenly re-activated.”, Andrea Lee, May 2022, https://twitter.com/RealAndyLeeShow/status/1531645687548366848</ref><ref name = "bank3">Canadian Veteran banned from Scotiabank (phone audio) , Jan 20, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9R6SaXqxTI</ref><ref name = "bank4">https://twitter.com/rick_ppc/status/1616783852730474496</ref>, travel, buy food, earn money, or do much of anything else, all at once. The single ID authority would yield incredible power over its citizens, which some people see as a benefit and purpose of digital ID.<ref>https://thecountersignal.com/why-is-a-digital-id-so-dangerous/</ref><ref>https://www.wired.com/story/digital-ids-are-more-dangerous-than-you-think/</ref>
 
==International Treaties and Agendas==
The International treaties presented below describe ''groups agreeing to work together on'' international digital credential (ID) systems. One of the mechanisms is presented as the solution to global health crisis.

===United Nations===
The United Nations has 2 agendas which, between the 2, promote digital identity: United Nations ''Legal Identity Agenda'' and United Nations ''Development Programme Digital Strategy 2022-2025'' 
::For example, the word 'digital' actually occurs once on the landing page for the legal identity agenda: "''Proof of legal identity is defined as a credential, such as birth certificate, identity card or digital identity credential''"<ref>Legal Identity Agenda https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda </ref> 
Of note, UN LIA has a "Task Force" whose responsibilities include to ''oversee the implementation'' of the UN LIA at the ''regional and national'' level<ref>"UN Legal Identity Task Force (UN LIA TF) " https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda</ref>
''See discussion of both in [[UN Agendas]]''
===G20 Indonesia summit===
In November 2022, G20 members signed a declaration for the adoption of a global vaccine passport:
::''We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification message, under the framework of the [[International Health Regulations| International health regulations (WHO IHR)]] 2005 , to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize in build on the success of the existing standards and digital Covid-19 Certificates. (Point 23, G20 Bali Leaders' declaration, The White House)''<ref>p23, "......We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification methods, under the framework of the International health regulations (IHR 2005), to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, and recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize and build on the success of the existing standards and digital COVID-19 certificates. " https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/11/16/g20-bali-leaders-declaration/</ref><ref>secondary sources, tweet thread, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1593186333878816768</ref>

Notice 2 things with wording loose enough for the following:
::*The adoption of vaccine passports (digital ''health credential'' ID) for to facilitate all international travel.
::*WHO determines what crisis qualifies and which vaccinations one must have.

=== World Health Organization Pandemic Treaty ===
See [[International Health Regulations|International Health Regulations (IHRs) 2005]]

== Federated ID Systems ==
To federate<ref>"SSO is meant to authenticate one person across different systems. FIM will allow one user access to many applications over any number of networks..", from "Federated Identity Management vs. SSO: Which is Better?" Javed Shah, December 16, 2021 https://www.1kosmos.com/identity-management/federated-identity-management-vs-sso/</ref><ref>Compare and Contrast — Federated Identity vs Self-sovereign Identity Apr 26, 2021 https://academy.affinidi.com/compare-and-contrast-federated-identity-vs-self-sovereign-identity-227a85cbab18</ref><ref>White Paper: "Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach In this brief, we highlight why Canada needs a digital identity system, how other countries have .." May 30, 2018 https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref> a digital ID system refers to making national legislation. 

Ukraine was one of the first countries to federate a digital identity system Diia<ref>Video, “Ukraine exports its digital ID technology Ukraine’s government services smartphone app, Diia, has become so “successful” that other countries are interested in replicating it. One of those countries is Estonia, one of the world’s most digitized countries.” https://twitter.com/bigDkenna1/status/1618393202557345792</ref><ref>Video, "Diia (Short For "The State And I"): Mobile Application And Web Portal Review. My Personal Experience" Liza Clinical Wizard, Jan 28, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ath4RcBMo_0</ref>. India also has Aadhaar. Estonia has taken a unique 'decentralized' approach to a national digital ID system<ref>"Estonia's approach to digital ID... Decentralized and very different - but that didn't stop them being at the forefront of developing vaccine passports with the WHO." Jan 24 Alex Klaushofer , https://khmezek.substack.com/p/ukraines-diia-city-initiative-the , from "Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU." https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>.

== UK ==
On March 1st a consultation <ref>https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-legislation-to-help-more-people-prove-their-identity-online/consultation-on-draft-legislation-to-support-identity-verification</ref> (''a survey'') about digital identity verification and data sharing between public authorities comes to a close<ref name="whose-data">Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU , Alex Klaushofer Jan 23 2023, https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>. Launched on January 4th, the proposed changes will spend a short time under public consideration. Review and criticism videos are available.<ref>Video 34:40 "Digital IDs are coming - but there's still time to have YOUR say!" Geoff Buys Cars Jan 10, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COx6vl3i-L4</ref><ref>Video 9:19 "UK Government digital ID" funkyprepper Jan 12, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swciKHYS1Hg</ref><ref>Video 26:24 "Urgent! UK Government's Digital Identity Survey" Richard Vobes Jan 11, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcrwXQdGkn0</ref><ref name="whose-data"></ref><ref>Video 25:45 "Digital ID Arrives in Britain" 53,076+ views The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters Jan 17, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSqpSHN1iUs</ref>

== Canada==
Adopted by Canada and all other 192 [[United Nations]] Member States in 2015, the [[2030 Agenda]] is a 15-year global framework centered on an ambitious set of 17 [[Sustainable Development Goals]] (SDGs).<ref>"Canada and the Sustainable Development Goals ", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/agenda-2030.html</ref><ref>"Funding program", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/news/2019/05/sustainable-development-goals-sdg-funding-program.html</ref>

There are many government affiliated organizations working to advance digital identity systems in Canada. See [[ktdi.org]], [[Policy Horizons]] and [https://diacc.ca/faq/ Digital Identity and Authentication Council of Canada]

=== Airports / Known Traveller Digital Identity ===
The Known Traveller Digital Identity (KTDI) program is a collaboration between the government of Canada, the [[World Economic Forum]] and private sector to develop a secure and efficient digital identity system for air travel. The program aims to use biometric and digital identity technologies to create a more seamless and secure travel experience for passengers.
:The KTDI program was first announced in 2018 by the Government of Canada as part of its National Strategy for Secure Travelling Abroad. The aim of the program is to enhance the security of air travel while also making the travel experience more convenient and efficient for passengers. The program aims to use biometric data such as facial recognition, fingerprint, and iris scans to confirm the identity of passengers, making it easier for them to move through the airport and board their flights.
:The program has a pilot phase, with several Canadian airports participating in testing and evaluating the technology. Once fully implemented, the program will be available to all Canadian citizens and permanent residents with a valid passport.
It's worth noting that the implementation of the program is in line with the national strategy of Canada to enhance security and improve the passenger experience, but it also raises concerns about privacy, security, and accessibility. The government of Canada has stated that the personal information collected through the program will be protected and used only for the specific purpose of the program, and that the use of biometrics will be optional for passengers.

=== Border Land Travel / ArriveCAN===
The ArriveCAN app is an official government of Canada app that is used to help digitize border crossing into the country. "''Travellers returning to Canada: You are required to provide info upon entry for COVID19. Download the ArriveCAN app to do it quickly and limit points of contact at the border''"<ref>Health Canada and PHAC @GovCanHealth, Apr 29, 2020, https://twitter.com/GovCanHealth/status/1255602952045289474</ref>.
The app is available for download on the App Store and Google Play and is free to use. ''Concerns'' surround whether the app is mandatory to use.

=== Digital Health Credential Systems / Provinces ===
By 2021 Most provinces in Canada had announced plans to implement a [[Vaccine passports|digital vaccine certification system]], such as Ontario, which will use a digital version of the [[Covid passport|COVID-19 vaccination record card]] and a mobile app called the "COVID-19 Vaccination Record" to allow residents to demonstrate their vaccination status.

According to an ''unverified source''<ref>screenshot ".. tender for a Canadian Health Passport.." Dec 7 2022, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1600614353446883328</ref>, Canada's Digital Transformation Branch (DTB, within Health Canada) has issued a tender for a Canadian Health Passport which includes requirements for proof of vaccination for domestic and international travel. Another ''unverified source'' says this comes into effect Sept 2023.<ref>https://twitter.com/UNDERTHEBED/status/1601315955208257536</ref>

===Bankers Association ===
In Feb 2022, Neil Parmenter of the Canadian Bankers Association promoted digital identity advancement as being on the cusp of a revolution in how people authenticate online.<ref>"Canadian bankers association - Digital ID",World Reflection, 2min clip, circa Feb 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpUFY1-GmCA, cited by https://twitter.com/KathrynLouiseBC/status/1604916667523682305</ref>

==Criticisms==

Many critics take broad views of what is digital identity. For example, a pervasive take in places like UK and Canada is that digital ID is already here (youtuber Coin Bureau<ref>Video "Digital IDs Are HERE!! Why You Should Be WORRIED!!.." Coin Bureau, Dec 11, 2022 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwRSzNTp2ko&t=169s</ref>, see notes on surveilance and bank freezing). Concerns about digital identity are addressed in books such as "''Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom''"(2022)<ref>"Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom Paperback "– March 17, 2022 by Nick Corbishley (Author) https://www.amazon.com/Scanned-Vaccine-Passports-Digital-Personal/dp/1645021629</ref> as well, where the main concerns are to privacy and personal liberties but end up being concerned with all levels of human needs.

===Composite Definition ===
One writer proposes to view digital identity as a composite (set) of concurrent trends:
# tying commerce/banking with politics (frozen bank accounts<ref name = "bank1"> </ref><ref name = "bank2"> </ref><ref name = "bank3"> </ref><ref name = "bank4"> </ref>, vilification of anonymity<ref>"The US Justice Department is part of WEF's Partnership against Cybercrime, which is run by an Israeli intelligence veteran and pushes for the end of online anonymity and the merging of Wall Street w their regulators and intelligence agencies. "Jan 18, 2023 https://twitter.com/_whitneywebb/status/1615754783494930432</ref><ref>"We investigated how objective, behavioral data on [[social media]] use was correlated with the Dark Tetrad facets and the HEXACO traits., " from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191886922004652, from "Don't allow the anonymous troll-demons to post with the real verified people @elonmusk . Put them in their own hell.." Nov 18, 2022 https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/1593691037121228801</ref> and privacy<ref>"..privacy and freedom of expression issues that have not been addressed by the government of Canada." Sep 19, 2022 PrivacyLawyer - David Fraser, "My main problem with Bill C 11: The regulation of user-generated content " https://youtu.be/KKx_0UfdsT0 </ref>, 
# promotion of digital points systems, [[Universal basic income]] and [[social credit system|social credit systems]], promotions of CBDC agendas),
# trends to ''require'' one's most intimate data ([[biometrics]]<ref>"Integration of blockchain and biometrics to redefine digital identity by 2030: report" Nov 12, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/integration-of-blockchain-and-biometrics-to-redefine-digital-identity-by-2030-report</ref>) for [[Multifactor Authentication|authentication]] and [[Access Control|access]]<ref>"Sentry Enterprise’s plans to supply enterprises with physical and logical access control through its biometric SentryCards..." from "Stage set for next round of secure access control biometrics adoption" Jan 22, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/stage-set-for-next-round-of-secure-access-control-biometrics-adoption</ref> to commerce(Amazon One<ref>Video "Pay with the palm of your hand.." Jan 27, 2023 https://twitter.com/george_orwell3/status/1619113034571730944</ref>), services, and to perhaps remove one's cards<ref>video, Jan 27, 2023, https://youtu.be/cwj4unWn6vw</ref> ('' decentralized methods of proving ID''),
# centralized and restricted access to essentials like gas<ref>Video "Sri Lanka is using digital gas ration books now. How do you think this will be abused?" Aug 9, 2022 https://twitter.com/YALiberty/status/1557079415116500994</ref><ref>"Digital ration cards in Sri Lanka for fuel. .. they literally won't serve you, and to make matters worse the petrol stations all over Sri Lanka now have fully automatic weapons at the petrol stations because you can imagine people's response.. " Sep 5, 2022 https://twitter.com/Alessa11alexa/status/1566855907962658818</ref><ref>"The integration of P97 mobile commerce platform with Cerence Pay makes voice biometric payments available at more than 30 percent of fuel retailers in the U.S., according to the announcement" from "Cerence biometrics partnership brings voice purchases to US gas stations" May 18, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202105/cerence-biometrics-partnership-brings-voice-purchases-to-us-gas-stations</ref>, food<ref>"AnyVision explores biometrics in food distribution and logistics applications" Jun 9, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202106/anyvision-explores-biometrics-in-food-distribution-and-logistics-applications</ref><ref>"Yoti discusses digital identity use to monitor food and cash rations" Nov 23, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/yoti-discusses-digital-identity-use-to-monitor-food-and-cash-rations</ref><ref>"Integrated Biometrics case study details fingerprint verification of food aid recipients in Yemen" Apr 8, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202004/integrated-biometrics-case-study-details-fingerprint-verification-of-food-aid-recipients-in-yemen </ref> 
# rising authoritarianism<ref>"The allure of Chinese ‘digital authoritarianism’ for Latin America" Jan 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/the-allure-of-chinese-digital-authoritarianism-for-latin-america</ref><ref>"IBIA Annual Membership Meeting to feature presentation on COVID-19, authoritarianism and biometrics Jun"Jun 30, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202006/ibia-annual-membership-meeting-to-feature-presentation-on-covid-19-authoritarianism-and-biometrics</ref><ref>"Authoritarianism in South Korea keeps peeking around the curtain... ", from "orea’s out front with digital IDs, but national history could be decisive in success" Oct 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202210/koreas-out-front-with-digital-ids-but-national-history-could-be-decisive-in-success</ref>
# Digital Health Credential systems, ''see [[International Health Regulations|WHO Pandemic Treaty (International Health Regulations IHRs)]], [[Covid passport|covid vaccine passports]])''

===Predictable===
Many critics view these developments as to be expected and predicted by earlier trends. Perhaps the biggest predictor trend is the decline in the level of individual [[freedom]], respect for [[natural law]] and [[unalienable rights]], and [[self-governance]] in [[The West|Western countries]]. This decline is accompanied by the decline in biblical values which affirm the importance of freedom.<ref>Behreandt, Dennis (January 3, 2020). [https://www.thenewamerican.com/print-magazine/item/34261-the-divine-message-of-freedom The Divine Message of Freedom]</ref>. See also [[War on freedom]], and books like RFK's "''The Real Anthony Fauci.. Global War on Democracy and Public Health''"<ref>"The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health " Nov. 16 2021 Robert F. Kennedy Jr. https://www.amazon.ca/Real-Anthony-Fauci-Pharma-Democracy/dp/1510766804</ref>

===Data and Access===
Digital ID proponents tend also to seek to centralize data and control access to it: A Digital ID system is a centralized approach to '''trust'''. See [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Early_CA_infrastructure|HTTPS/SSL history]] for problems with centralized trust models. Digital ID proponents also seek to centralize very large<ref>"..now reportedly contains information on 5,500 law enforcement agencies in all 50 states and multiple territories and districts." from "US biometric surveillance database reaches 10,000 data points " Nov 21, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202211/us-biometric-surveillance-database-reaches-10000-data-points</ref><ref>"Government databases could replace document-based ID verification: Sumsub CTO" Dec 12, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202212/government-databases-could-replace-document-based-id-verification-sumsub-cto</ref> datasets and '''databases'''<ref>Video "Dangers of plants and centralized data" Matt Gubba, circa Jan 22, https://twitter.com/Raul_Aztec/status/1617187582743388237</ref>. This sort of policy is attractive externally (to hackers and bad actors) and internally(poor morale and ethic, human error, incompetence<ref> "Bumbling NYPD contractor nearly infects fingerprint database with ransomware " Dec 13, 2019 https://www.biometricupdate.com/201912/bumbling-nypd-contractor-nearly-infects-fingerprint-database-with-ransomware</ref> ).

===Privacy ===
Many are concerned that federated digital identity places too much importance on "''who'' are you" (as if what a service provider can establish from cards and multifactor authentication falls short and that knowledge of one's business history is needed at each new signup):
::''It is important to differentiate between digital identification and digital authentication. Digital authentication is something most of us do every day – logging on to our favourite social media site, signing into an account with our preferred ecommerce retailer, or even accessing our mobile device through a thumb scan. Authentication is the act of proving that the person accessing my account or device is me, usually through a PIN, password, biometric identifier or other form factor. Authentication is designed to answer the question “Is that you?” Identification, by contrast, is more complex. Identification is intended to answer the question “Who are you?” Digital ID is the challenge of answering “Who are you? with a high degree of certainty, without resorting to face-to-face interaction and the exchange of physical documents.''<ref>"White Paper: Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach", Posted on: May 30, 2018, https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref>

=== Travel, Carbon tracking ===
December 2021, just before Christmas, Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) acknowledged that it ''secretly'' tracked location data from at least 33 million mobile devices to analyze people's movements during COVID-19 quarantines.<ref>Video, press conference, tweet Jan 18, 2022, https://twitter.com/Aslapes11/status/1483389677096820742</ref>. Concerns are whether this behaviour continues to this day or has suitable checks and balances. 

''Canada's Net-Zero Challenge<ref>"Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act - Canada.ca" 
https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/canadian-net-zero-emissions-accountability-act.html</ref><ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/challenge.html</ref> is a voluntary initiative that encourages companies to develop and implement credible and effective plans to transition their facilities and operations to net-zero emissions by 2050.''<ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/2022/08/net-zero-challenge.html</ref>

==See also==
* [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Digital_certificates|Digital Certificates]]
* [[Digital_Signature|Digital Signature]]
* [[Access Control]]
* [[Ukraine#Digital_ID|Ukraine Digital_ID]]
* [[Sustainable Development Goals|Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs)]]
* [[The Great Reset|Agenda: Great Reset and 4th Industrial Revolution (WEF)]]
* [[Right to Privacy]]
* [[Surveillance]]
* [[Social credit system]]
* [[Creeping socialism]]
* [[War_on_Freedom#Big_Tech | Big tech's role in war on freedom (War on Freedom) ]]

==References==
{{reflist}}

[[Category:Uncategorized]]

Digital ID

2023-02-01T15:44:33Z

Fallandtrip:

{{Progress}}

 
''See also Digital health credentials, [[Covid passport]], [[Vaccine passports]]'' 
 

Digital ID refers to ''an extension of current physical ID documents such as driver’s licences, passports and bank cards.. Digital ID is a way to verify who we are online securely, in a manner that offers data protection and safeguards our personal information (interac.ca)''<ref>https://www.interac.ca/en/content/ideas/what-is-digital-identity</ref>.
 

==Purpose==
Through the beginning of the twenty-first century, identity was typically affirmed by the use of paper or plastic cards, issued by third parties. In the United States, the [[Department of Motor Vehicles]] issues Driver Licenses, and other government identification cards. States may also issue ID cards of some form as well, such as welfare cards, gun permits, and fishing licenses. Organizations such as libraries, and membership-only clubs may issue identification cards as well. Additionally, independent companies may issue ID cards of a sort, such as insurance cards, gym membership cards, credit and debit cards, and other customer identification cards (for "rewards programs" and customer behavior tracking for marketing purposes). A digital ID system is designed to serve multiple purposes, eliminating the need for each separate identification card.<ref>https://www.globalgovernmentforum.com/digital-id-what-is-it-why-is-it-needed-and-how-are-governments-developing-it/</ref>
It also provides much greater control to a single authoritative party, rather than a diverse collection of entities, each for their own purposes. This could theoretically be useful in fighting crime<ref>https://www.dawn.com/news/1730768/safe-city-seeks-high-resolution-photos-of-over-4000-criminals-from-nadra</ref><ref>https://www.biometricupdate.com/202301/pakistan-id-authority-shares-data-of-4k-wanted-people-for-biometric-matching</ref>. However, that same single authority can use their power for negative purposes as well. For example, an opponent of the politicians in power could suddenly find their digital ID has been revoked, meaning that they can no longer bank<ref name = "bank1">"Bank Apologizes over Trucker Convoy account freeze ", Marc Patrone , May 30, 2022 , https://bjdichter.substack.com/p/bank-apologizes-over-trucker-convoy?r=10rk8l&</ref><ref name = "bank2">"..yesterday my ability to e-transfer funds was suddenly re-activated.”, Andrea Lee, May 2022, https://twitter.com/RealAndyLeeShow/status/1531645687548366848</ref><ref name = "bank3">Canadian Veteran banned from Scotiabank (phone audio) , Jan 20, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9R6SaXqxTI</ref><ref name = "bank4">https://twitter.com/rick_ppc/status/1616783852730474496</ref>, travel, buy food, earn money, or do much of anything else, all at once. The single ID authority would yield incredible power over its citizens, which some people see as a benefit and purpose of digital ID.<ref>https://thecountersignal.com/why-is-a-digital-id-so-dangerous/</ref><ref>https://www.wired.com/story/digital-ids-are-more-dangerous-than-you-think/</ref>
 
==International Treaties and Agendas==
The International treaties presented below describe ''groups agreeing to work together on'' international digital credential (ID) system, even if it is removed and only in the policy levels. One of the mechanisms is presented as the solution to global health crisis.

===United Nations===
The United Nations has 2 agendas which, between the 2, promote digital identity: United Nations ''Legal Identity Agenda'' and United Nations ''Development Programme Digital Strategy 2022-2025'' 
::For example, the word 'digital' actually occurs once on the landing page for the legal identity agenda: "''Proof of legal identity is defined as a credential, such as birth certificate, identity card or digital identity credential''"<ref>Legal Identity Agenda https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda </ref> 
Of note, UN LIA has a "Task Force" whose responsibilities include to ''oversee the implementation'' of the UN LIA at the ''regional and national'' level<ref>"UN Legal Identity Task Force (UN LIA TF) " https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda</ref>
''See discussion of both in [[UN Agendas]]''
===G20 Indonesia summit===
In November 2022, G20 members signed a declaration for the adoption of a global vaccine passport:
::''We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification message, under the framework of the [[International Health Regulations| International health regulations (WHO IHR)]] 2005 , to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize in build on the success of the existing standards and digital Covid-19 Certificates. (Point 23, G20 Bali Leaders' declaration, The White House)''<ref>p23, "......We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification methods, under the framework of the International health regulations (IHR 2005), to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, and recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize and build on the success of the existing standards and digital COVID-19 certificates. " https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/11/16/g20-bali-leaders-declaration/</ref><ref>secondary sources, tweet thread, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1593186333878816768</ref>

Notice 2 things with wording loose enough for the following:
::*The adoption of vaccine passports (digital ''health credential'' ID) for to facilitate all international travel.
::*WHO determines what crisis qualifies and which vaccinations one must have.

=== World Health Organization Pandemic Treaty ===
See [[International Health Regulations|International Health Regulations (IHRs) 2005]]

== Federated ID Systems ==
To federate<ref>"SSO is meant to authenticate one person across different systems. FIM will allow one user access to many applications over any number of networks..", from "Federated Identity Management vs. SSO: Which is Better?" Javed Shah, December 16, 2021 https://www.1kosmos.com/identity-management/federated-identity-management-vs-sso/</ref><ref>Compare and Contrast — Federated Identity vs Self-sovereign Identity Apr 26, 2021 https://academy.affinidi.com/compare-and-contrast-federated-identity-vs-self-sovereign-identity-227a85cbab18</ref><ref>White Paper: "Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach In this brief, we highlight why Canada needs a digital identity system, how other countries have .." May 30, 2018 https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref> a digital ID system refers to making national legislation. 

Ukraine was one of the first countries to federate a digital identity system Diia<ref>Video, “Ukraine exports its digital ID technology Ukraine’s government services smartphone app, Diia, has become so “successful” that other countries are interested in replicating it. One of those countries is Estonia, one of the world’s most digitized countries.” https://twitter.com/bigDkenna1/status/1618393202557345792</ref><ref>Video, "Diia (Short For "The State And I"): Mobile Application And Web Portal Review. My Personal Experience" Liza Clinical Wizard, Jan 28, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ath4RcBMo_0</ref>. India also has Aadhaar. Estonia has taken a unique 'decentralized' approach to a national digital ID system<ref>"Estonia's approach to digital ID... Decentralized and very different - but that didn't stop them being at the forefront of developing vaccine passports with the WHO." Jan 24 Alex Klaushofer , https://khmezek.substack.com/p/ukraines-diia-city-initiative-the , from "Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU." https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>.

== UK ==
On March 1st a consultation <ref>https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-legislation-to-help-more-people-prove-their-identity-online/consultation-on-draft-legislation-to-support-identity-verification</ref> (''a survey'') about digital identity verification and data sharing between public authorities comes to a close<ref name="whose-data">Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU , Alex Klaushofer Jan 23 2023, https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>. Launched on January 4th, the proposed changes will spend a short time under public consideration. Review and criticism videos are available.<ref>Video 34:40 "Digital IDs are coming - but there's still time to have YOUR say!" Geoff Buys Cars Jan 10, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COx6vl3i-L4</ref><ref>Video 9:19 "UK Government digital ID" funkyprepper Jan 12, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swciKHYS1Hg</ref><ref>Video 26:24 "Urgent! UK Government's Digital Identity Survey" Richard Vobes Jan 11, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcrwXQdGkn0</ref><ref name="whose-data"></ref><ref>Video 25:45 "Digital ID Arrives in Britain" 53,076+ views The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters Jan 17, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSqpSHN1iUs</ref>

== Canada==
Adopted by Canada and all other 192 [[United Nations]] Member States in 2015, the [[2030 Agenda]] is a 15-year global framework centered on an ambitious set of 17 [[Sustainable Development Goals]] (SDGs).<ref>"Canada and the Sustainable Development Goals ", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/agenda-2030.html</ref><ref>"Funding program", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/news/2019/05/sustainable-development-goals-sdg-funding-program.html</ref>

There are many government affiliated organizations working to advance digital identity systems in Canada. See [[ktdi.org]], [[Policy Horizons]] and [https://diacc.ca/faq/ Digital Identity and Authentication Council of Canada]

=== Airports / Known Traveller Digital Identity ===
The Known Traveller Digital Identity (KTDI) program is a collaboration between the government of Canada, the [[World Economic Forum]] and private sector to develop a secure and efficient digital identity system for air travel. The program aims to use biometric and digital identity technologies to create a more seamless and secure travel experience for passengers.
:The KTDI program was first announced in 2018 by the Government of Canada as part of its National Strategy for Secure Travelling Abroad. The aim of the program is to enhance the security of air travel while also making the travel experience more convenient and efficient for passengers. The program aims to use biometric data such as facial recognition, fingerprint, and iris scans to confirm the identity of passengers, making it easier for them to move through the airport and board their flights.
:The program has a pilot phase, with several Canadian airports participating in testing and evaluating the technology. Once fully implemented, the program will be available to all Canadian citizens and permanent residents with a valid passport.
It's worth noting that the implementation of the program is in line with the national strategy of Canada to enhance security and improve the passenger experience, but it also raises concerns about privacy, security, and accessibility. The government of Canada has stated that the personal information collected through the program will be protected and used only for the specific purpose of the program, and that the use of biometrics will be optional for passengers.

=== Border Land Travel / ArriveCAN===
The ArriveCAN app is an official government of Canada app that is used to help digitize border crossing into the country. "''Travellers returning to Canada: You are required to provide info upon entry for COVID19. Download the ArriveCAN app to do it quickly and limit points of contact at the border''"<ref>Health Canada and PHAC @GovCanHealth, Apr 29, 2020, https://twitter.com/GovCanHealth/status/1255602952045289474</ref>.
The app is available for download on the App Store and Google Play and is free to use. ''Concerns'' surround whether the app is mandatory to use.

=== Digital Health Credential Systems / Provinces ===
By 2021 Most provinces in Canada had announced plans to implement a [[Vaccine passports|digital vaccine certification system]], such as Ontario, which will use a digital version of the [[Covid passport|COVID-19 vaccination record card]] and a mobile app called the "COVID-19 Vaccination Record" to allow residents to demonstrate their vaccination status.

According to an ''unverified source''<ref>screenshot ".. tender for a Canadian Health Passport.." Dec 7 2022, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1600614353446883328</ref>, Canada's Digital Transformation Branch (DTB, within Health Canada) has issued a tender for a Canadian Health Passport which includes requirements for proof of vaccination for domestic and international travel. Another ''unverified source'' says this comes into effect Sept 2023.<ref>https://twitter.com/UNDERTHEBED/status/1601315955208257536</ref>

===Bankers Association ===
In Feb 2022, Neil Parmenter of the Canadian Bankers Association promoted digital identity advancement as being on the cusp of a revolution in how people authenticate online.<ref>"Canadian bankers association - Digital ID",World Reflection, 2min clip, circa Feb 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpUFY1-GmCA, cited by https://twitter.com/KathrynLouiseBC/status/1604916667523682305</ref>

==Criticisms==

Many critics take broad views of what is digital identity. For example, a pervasive take in places like UK and Canada is that digital ID is already here (youtuber Coin Bureau<ref>Video "Digital IDs Are HERE!! Why You Should Be WORRIED!!.." Coin Bureau, Dec 11, 2022 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwRSzNTp2ko&t=169s</ref>, see notes on surveilance and bank freezing). Concerns about digital identity are addressed in books such as "''Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom''"(2022)<ref>"Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom Paperback "– March 17, 2022 by Nick Corbishley (Author) https://www.amazon.com/Scanned-Vaccine-Passports-Digital-Personal/dp/1645021629</ref> as well, where the main concerns are to privacy and personal liberties but end up being concerned with all levels of human needs.

===Composite Definition ===
One writer proposes to view digital identity as a composite (set) of concurrent trends:
# tying commerce/banking with politics (frozen bank accounts<ref name = "bank1"> </ref><ref name = "bank2"> </ref><ref name = "bank3"> </ref><ref name = "bank4"> </ref>, vilification of anonymity<ref>"The US Justice Department is part of WEF's Partnership against Cybercrime, which is run by an Israeli intelligence veteran and pushes for the end of online anonymity and the merging of Wall Street w their regulators and intelligence agencies. "Jan 18, 2023 https://twitter.com/_whitneywebb/status/1615754783494930432</ref><ref>"We investigated how objective, behavioral data on [[social media]] use was correlated with the Dark Tetrad facets and the HEXACO traits., " from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191886922004652, from "Don't allow the anonymous troll-demons to post with the real verified people @elonmusk . Put them in their own hell.." Nov 18, 2022 https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/1593691037121228801</ref> and privacy<ref>"..privacy and freedom of expression issues that have not been addressed by the government of Canada." Sep 19, 2022 PrivacyLawyer - David Fraser, "My main problem with Bill C 11: The regulation of user-generated content " https://youtu.be/KKx_0UfdsT0 </ref>, 
# promotion of digital points systems, [[Universal basic income]] and [[social credit system|social credit systems]], promotions of CBDC agendas),
# trends to ''require'' one's most intimate data ([[biometrics]]<ref>"Integration of blockchain and biometrics to redefine digital identity by 2030: report" Nov 12, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/integration-of-blockchain-and-biometrics-to-redefine-digital-identity-by-2030-report</ref>) for [[Multifactor Authentication|authentication]] and [[Access Control|access]]<ref>"Sentry Enterprise’s plans to supply enterprises with physical and logical access control through its biometric SentryCards..." from "Stage set for next round of secure access control biometrics adoption" Jan 22, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/stage-set-for-next-round-of-secure-access-control-biometrics-adoption</ref> to commerce(Amazon One<ref>Video "Pay with the palm of your hand.." Jan 27, 2023 https://twitter.com/george_orwell3/status/1619113034571730944</ref>), services, and to perhaps remove one's cards<ref>video, Jan 27, 2023, https://youtu.be/cwj4unWn6vw</ref> ('' decentralized methods of proving ID''),
# centralized and restricted access to essentials like gas<ref>Video "Sri Lanka is using digital gas ration books now. How do you think this will be abused?" Aug 9, 2022 https://twitter.com/YALiberty/status/1557079415116500994</ref><ref>"Digital ration cards in Sri Lanka for fuel. .. they literally won't serve you, and to make matters worse the petrol stations all over Sri Lanka now have fully automatic weapons at the petrol stations because you can imagine people's response.. " Sep 5, 2022 https://twitter.com/Alessa11alexa/status/1566855907962658818</ref><ref>"The integration of P97 mobile commerce platform with Cerence Pay makes voice biometric payments available at more than 30 percent of fuel retailers in the U.S., according to the announcement" from "Cerence biometrics partnership brings voice purchases to US gas stations" May 18, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202105/cerence-biometrics-partnership-brings-voice-purchases-to-us-gas-stations</ref>, food<ref>"AnyVision explores biometrics in food distribution and logistics applications" Jun 9, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202106/anyvision-explores-biometrics-in-food-distribution-and-logistics-applications</ref><ref>"Yoti discusses digital identity use to monitor food and cash rations" Nov 23, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/yoti-discusses-digital-identity-use-to-monitor-food-and-cash-rations</ref><ref>"Integrated Biometrics case study details fingerprint verification of food aid recipients in Yemen" Apr 8, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202004/integrated-biometrics-case-study-details-fingerprint-verification-of-food-aid-recipients-in-yemen </ref> 
# rising authoritarianism<ref>"The allure of Chinese ‘digital authoritarianism’ for Latin America" Jan 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/the-allure-of-chinese-digital-authoritarianism-for-latin-america</ref><ref>"IBIA Annual Membership Meeting to feature presentation on COVID-19, authoritarianism and biometrics Jun"Jun 30, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202006/ibia-annual-membership-meeting-to-feature-presentation-on-covid-19-authoritarianism-and-biometrics</ref><ref>"Authoritarianism in South Korea keeps peeking around the curtain... ", from "orea’s out front with digital IDs, but national history could be decisive in success" Oct 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202210/koreas-out-front-with-digital-ids-but-national-history-could-be-decisive-in-success</ref>
# Digital Health Credential systems, ''see [[International Health Regulations|WHO Pandemic Treaty (International Health Regulations IHRs)]], [[Covid passport|covid vaccine passports]])''

===Predictable===
Many critics view these developments as to be expected and predicted by earlier trends. Perhaps the biggest predictor trend is the decline in the level of individual [[freedom]], respect for [[natural law]] and [[unalienable rights]], and [[self-governance]] in [[The West|Western countries]]. This decline is accompanied by the decline in biblical values which affirm the importance of freedom.<ref>Behreandt, Dennis (January 3, 2020). [https://www.thenewamerican.com/print-magazine/item/34261-the-divine-message-of-freedom The Divine Message of Freedom]</ref>. See also [[War on freedom]], and books like RFK's "''The Real Anthony Fauci.. Global War on Democracy and Public Health''"<ref>"The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health " Nov. 16 2021 Robert F. Kennedy Jr. https://www.amazon.ca/Real-Anthony-Fauci-Pharma-Democracy/dp/1510766804</ref>

===Data and Access===
Digital ID proponents tend also to seek to centralize data and control access to it: A Digital ID system is a centralized approach to '''trust'''. See [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Early_CA_infrastructure|HTTPS/SSL history]] for problems with centralized trust models. Digital ID proponents also seek to centralize very large<ref>"..now reportedly contains information on 5,500 law enforcement agencies in all 50 states and multiple territories and districts." from "US biometric surveillance database reaches 10,000 data points " Nov 21, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202211/us-biometric-surveillance-database-reaches-10000-data-points</ref><ref>"Government databases could replace document-based ID verification: Sumsub CTO" Dec 12, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202212/government-databases-could-replace-document-based-id-verification-sumsub-cto</ref> datasets and '''databases'''<ref>Video "Dangers of plants and centralized data" Matt Gubba, circa Jan 22, https://twitter.com/Raul_Aztec/status/1617187582743388237</ref>. This sort of policy is attractive externally (to hackers and bad actors) and internally(poor morale and ethic, human error, incompetence<ref> "Bumbling NYPD contractor nearly infects fingerprint database with ransomware " Dec 13, 2019 https://www.biometricupdate.com/201912/bumbling-nypd-contractor-nearly-infects-fingerprint-database-with-ransomware</ref> ).

===Privacy ===
Many are concerned that federated digital identity places too much importance on "''who'' are you" (as if what a service provider can establish from cards and multifactor authentication falls short and that knowledge of one's business history is needed at each new signup):
::''It is important to differentiate between digital identification and digital authentication. Digital authentication is something most of us do every day – logging on to our favourite social media site, signing into an account with our preferred ecommerce retailer, or even accessing our mobile device through a thumb scan. Authentication is the act of proving that the person accessing my account or device is me, usually through a PIN, password, biometric identifier or other form factor. Authentication is designed to answer the question “Is that you?” Identification, by contrast, is more complex. Identification is intended to answer the question “Who are you?” Digital ID is the challenge of answering “Who are you? with a high degree of certainty, without resorting to face-to-face interaction and the exchange of physical documents.''<ref>"White Paper: Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach", Posted on: May 30, 2018, https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref>

=== Travel, Carbon tracking ===
December 2021, just before Christmas, Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) acknowledged that it ''secretly'' tracked location data from at least 33 million mobile devices to analyze people's movements during COVID-19 quarantines.<ref>Video, press conference, tweet Jan 18, 2022, https://twitter.com/Aslapes11/status/1483389677096820742</ref>. Concerns are whether this behaviour continues to this day or has suitable checks and balances. 

''Canada's Net-Zero Challenge<ref>"Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act - Canada.ca" 
https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/canadian-net-zero-emissions-accountability-act.html</ref><ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/challenge.html</ref> is a voluntary initiative that encourages companies to develop and implement credible and effective plans to transition their facilities and operations to net-zero emissions by 2050.''<ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/2022/08/net-zero-challenge.html</ref>

==See also==
* [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Digital_certificates|Digital Certificates]]
* [[Digital_Signature|Digital Signature]]
* [[Access Control]]
* [[Ukraine#Digital_ID|Ukraine Digital_ID]]
* [[Sustainable Development Goals|Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs)]]
* [[The Great Reset|Agenda: Great Reset and 4th Industrial Revolution (WEF)]]
* [[Right to Privacy]]
* [[Surveillance]]
* [[Social credit system]]
* [[Creeping socialism]]
* [[War_on_Freedom#Big_Tech | Big tech's role in war on freedom (War on Freedom) ]]

==References==
{{reflist}}

[[Category:Uncategorized]]

User talk:Fallandtrip

2023-02-01T05:31:52Z

Fallandtrip: Blanked the page

Digital ID

2023-01-31T05:59:23Z

Fallandtrip:

{{Progress}}

 
''See also Digital health credentials, [[Covid passport]], [[Vaccine passports]]'' 
 

Digital ID refers to ''an extension of current physical ID documents such as driver’s licences, passports and bank cards.. Digital ID is a way to verify who we are online securely, in a manner that offers data protection and safeguards our personal information (interac.ca)''<ref>https://www.interac.ca/en/content/ideas/what-is-digital-identity</ref>.
 

==Purpose==
Through the beginning of the twenty-first century, identity was typically affirmed by the use of paper or plastic cards, issued by third parties. In the United States, the [[Department of Motor Vehicles]] issues Driver Licenses, and other government identification cards. States may also issue ID cards of some form as well, such as welfare cards, gun permits, and fishing licenses. Organizations such as libraries, and membership-only clubs may issue identification cards as well. Additionally, independent companies may issue ID cards of a sort, such as insurance cards, gym membership cards, credit and debit cards, and other customer identification cards (for "rewards programs" and customer behavior tracking for marketing purposes). A digital ID system is designed to serve multiple purposes, eliminating the need for each separate identification card.<ref>https://www.globalgovernmentforum.com/digital-id-what-is-it-why-is-it-needed-and-how-are-governments-developing-it/</ref>
It also provides much greater control to a single authoritative party, rather than a diverse collection of entities, each for their own purposes. This could theoretically be useful in fighting crime<ref>https://www.dawn.com/news/1730768/safe-city-seeks-high-resolution-photos-of-over-4000-criminals-from-nadra</ref><ref>https://www.biometricupdate.com/202301/pakistan-id-authority-shares-data-of-4k-wanted-people-for-biometric-matching</ref>. However, that same single authority can use their power for negative purposes as well. For example, an opponent of the politicians in power could suddenly find their digital ID has been revoked, meaning that they can no longer bank<ref name = "bank1">"Bank Apologizes over Trucker Convoy account freeze ", Marc Patrone , May 30, 2022 , https://bjdichter.substack.com/p/bank-apologizes-over-trucker-convoy?r=10rk8l&</ref><ref name = "bank2">"..yesterday my ability to e-transfer funds was suddenly re-activated.”, Andrea Lee, May 2022, https://twitter.com/RealAndyLeeShow/status/1531645687548366848</ref><ref name = "bank3">Canadian Veteran banned from Scotiabank (phone audio) , Jan 20, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9R6SaXqxTI</ref><ref name = "bank4">https://twitter.com/rick_ppc/status/1616783852730474496</ref>, travel, buy food, earn money, or do much of anything else, all at once. The single ID authority would yield incredible power over its citizens, which some people see as a benefit and purpose of digital ID.<ref>https://thecountersignal.com/why-is-a-digital-id-so-dangerous/</ref><ref>https://www.wired.com/story/digital-ids-are-more-dangerous-than-you-think/</ref>
 
==International Treaties and Agendas==
The International treaties presented below describe ''groups agreeing to work together on'' international digital credential (ID) system, even if it is removed and only in the policy levels. One of the mechanisms is presented as the solution to global health crisis.

===United Nations===
The United Nations has 2 agendas which, between the 2, promote digital identity: United Nations ''Legal Identity Agenda'' and United Nations ''Development Programme Digital Strategy 2022-2025'' 
::For example, the word 'digital' actually occurs once on the landing page for the legal identity agenda: "''Proof of legal identity is defined as a credential, such as birth certificate, identity card or digital identity credential''"<ref>Legal Identity Agenda https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda </ref> 
Of note, UN LIA has a "Task Force" whose responsibilities include to ''oversee the implementation'' of the UN LIA at the ''regional and national'' level<ref>"UN Legal Identity Task Force (UN LIA TF) " https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda</ref>
''See discussion of both in [[UN Agendas]]''
===G20 Indonesia summit===
In November 2022, G20 members signed a declaration for the adoption of a global vaccine passport:
::''We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification message, under the framework of the [[International Health Regulations| International health regulations (WHO IHR)]] 2005 , to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize in build on the success of the existing standards and digital Covid-19 Certificates. (Point 23, G20 Bali Leaders' declaration, The White House)''<ref>p23, "......We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification methods, under the framework of the International health regulations (IHR 2005), to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, and recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize and build on the success of the existing standards and digital COVID-19 certificates. " https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/11/16/g20-bali-leaders-declaration/</ref><ref>secondary sources, tweet thread, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1593186333878816768</ref>

Notice 2 things with wording loose enough for the following:
::*The adoption of vaccine passports (digital ''health credential'' ID) for to facilitate all international travel.
::*WHO determines what crisis qualifies and which vaccinations one must have.

=== World Health Organization Pandemic Treaty ===
See [[International Health Regulations|International Health Regulations (IHRs) 2005]]

== Federated ID Systems ==
To federate<ref>"SSO is meant to authenticate one person across different systems. FIM will allow one user access to many applications over any number of networks..", from "Federated Identity Management vs. SSO: Which is Better?" Javed Shah, December 16, 2021 https://www.1kosmos.com/identity-management/federated-identity-management-vs-sso/</ref><ref>Compare and Contrast — Federated Identity vs Self-sovereign Identity Apr 26, 2021 https://academy.affinidi.com/compare-and-contrast-federated-identity-vs-self-sovereign-identity-227a85cbab18</ref><ref>White Paper: "Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach In this brief, we highlight why Canada needs a digital identity system, how other countries have .." May 30, 2018 https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref> a digital ID system refers to making national legislation. 

Ukraine was one of the first countries to federate a digital identity system Diia<ref>Video, “Ukraine exports its digital ID technology Ukraine’s government services smartphone app, Diia, has become so “successful” that other countries are interested in replicating it. One of those countries is Estonia, one of the world’s most digitized countries.” https://twitter.com/bigDkenna1/status/1618393202557345792</ref><ref>Video, "Diia (Short For "The State And I"): Mobile Application And Web Portal Review. My Personal Experience" Liza Clinical Wizard, Jan 28, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ath4RcBMo_0</ref>. India also has Aadhaar. Estonia has taken a unique 'decentralized' approach to a national digital ID system<ref>"Estonia's approach to digital ID... Decentralized and very different - but that didn't stop them being at the forefront of developing vaccine passports with the WHO." Jan 24 Alex Klaushofer , https://khmezek.substack.com/p/ukraines-diia-city-initiative-the , from "Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU." https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>.

== UK ==
On March 1st a consultation <ref>https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-legislation-to-help-more-people-prove-their-identity-online/consultation-on-draft-legislation-to-support-identity-verification</ref> (''a survey'') about digital identity verification and data sharing between public authorities comes to a close<ref name="whose-data">Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU , Alex Klaushofer Jan 23 2023, https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>. Launched on January 4th, the proposed changes will spend a short time under public consideration. Review and criticism videos are available.<ref>Video 34:40 "Digital IDs are coming - but there's still time to have YOUR say!" Geoff Buys Cars Jan 10, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COx6vl3i-L4</ref><ref>Video 9:19 "UK Government digital ID" funkyprepper Jan 12, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swciKHYS1Hg</ref><ref>Video 26:24 "Urgent! UK Government's Digital Identity Survey" Richard Vobes Jan 11, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcrwXQdGkn0</ref><ref name="whose-data"></ref><ref>Video 25:45 "Digital ID Arrives in Britain" 53,076+ views The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters Jan 17, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSqpSHN1iUs</ref>

== Canada==
Adopted by Canada and all other 192 [[United Nations]] Member States in 2015, the [[2030 Agenda]] is a 15-year global framework centered on an ambitious set of 17 [[Sustainable Development Goals]] (SDGs).<ref>"Canada and the Sustainable Development Goals ", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/agenda-2030.html</ref><ref>"Funding program", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/news/2019/05/sustainable-development-goals-sdg-funding-program.html</ref>

There are many government affiliated organizations working to advance digital identity systems in Canada. See [[ktdi.org]], [[Policy Horizons]] and [https://diacc.ca/faq/ Digital Identity and Authentication Council of Canada]

=== Airports / Known Traveller Digital Identity ===
The Known Traveller Digital Identity (KTDI) program is a collaboration between the government of Canada, the [[World Economic Forum]] and private sector to develop a secure and efficient digital identity system for air travel. The program aims to use biometric and digital identity technologies to create a more seamless and secure travel experience for passengers.
:The KTDI program was first announced in 2018 by the Government of Canada as part of its National Strategy for Secure Travelling Abroad. The aim of the program is to enhance the security of air travel while also making the travel experience more convenient and efficient for passengers. The program aims to use biometric data such as facial recognition, fingerprint, and iris scans to confirm the identity of passengers, making it easier for them to move through the airport and board their flights.
:The program has a pilot phase, with several Canadian airports participating in testing and evaluating the technology. Once fully implemented, the program will be available to all Canadian citizens and permanent residents with a valid passport.
It's worth noting that the implementation of the program is in line with the national strategy of Canada to enhance security and improve the passenger experience, but it also raises concerns about privacy, security, and accessibility. The government of Canada has stated that the personal information collected through the program will be protected and used only for the specific purpose of the program, and that the use of biometrics will be optional for passengers.

=== Border Land Travel / ArriveCAN===
The ArriveCAN app is an official government of Canada app that is used to help digitize border crossing into the country. "''Travellers returning to Canada: You are required to provide info upon entry for COVID19. Download the ArriveCAN app to do it quickly and limit points of contact at the border''"<ref>Health Canada and PHAC @GovCanHealth, Apr 29, 2020, https://twitter.com/GovCanHealth/status/1255602952045289474</ref>.
The app is available for download on the App Store and Google Play and is free to use. ''Concerns'' surround whether the app is mandatory to use.

=== Digital Health Credential Systems / Provinces ===
By 2021 Most provinces in Canada had announced plans to implement a [[Vaccine passports|digital vaccine certification system]], such as Ontario, which will use a digital version of the [[Covid passport|COVID-19 vaccination record card]] and a mobile app called the "COVID-19 Vaccination Record" to allow residents to demonstrate their vaccination status.

According to an ''unverified source''<ref>screenshot ".. tender for a Canadian Health Passport.." Dec 7 2022, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1600614353446883328</ref>, Canada's Digital Transformation Branch (DTB, within Health Canada) has issued a tender for a Canadian Health Passport which includes requirements for proof of vaccination for domestic and international travel. Another ''unverified source'' says this comes into effect Sept 2023.<ref>https://twitter.com/UNDERTHEBED/status/1601315955208257536</ref>

===Bankers Association ===
In Feb 2022, Neil Parmenter of the Canadian Bankers Association promoted digital identity advancement as being on the cusp of a revolution in how people authenticate online.<ref>"Canadian bankers association - Digital ID",World Reflection, 2min clip, circa Feb 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpUFY1-GmCA, cited by https://twitter.com/KathrynLouiseBC/status/1604916667523682305</ref>

==Criticisms==

Many critics take broad views of what is digital identity. For example, a pervasive take in places like UK and Canada is that digital ID is already here (youtuber Coin Bureau<ref>Video "Digital IDs Are HERE!! Why You Should Be WORRIED!!.." Coin Bureau, Dec 11, 2022 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwRSzNTp2ko&t=169s</ref>, see notes on surveilance and bank freezing). Concerns about digital identity are addressed in books such as "''Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom''"(2022)<ref>"Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom Paperback "– March 17, 2022 by Nick Corbishley (Author) https://www.amazon.com/Scanned-Vaccine-Passports-Digital-Personal/dp/1645021629</ref> as well, where the main concerns are to privacy and personal liberties but end up being concerned with all levels of human needs.

===Composite Definition ===
One writer proposes to view digital identity as a composite (set) of concurrent trends:
# tying commerce/banking with politics (frozen bank accounts<ref name = "bank1"> </ref><ref name = "bank2"> </ref><ref name = "bank3"> </ref><ref name = "bank4"> </ref>, vilification of anonymity<ref>"The US Justice Department is part of WEF's Partnership against Cybercrime, which is run by an Israeli intelligence veteran and pushes for the end of online anonymity and the merging of Wall Street w their regulators and intelligence agencies. "Jan 18, 2023 https://twitter.com/_whitneywebb/status/1615754783494930432</ref><ref>"We investigated how objective, behavioral data on [[social media]] use was correlated with the Dark Tetrad facets and the HEXACO traits., " from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191886922004652, from "Don't allow the anonymous troll-demons to post with the real verified people @elonmusk . Put them in their own hell.." Nov 18, 2022 https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/1593691037121228801</ref> and privacy<ref>"..privacy and freedom of expression issues that have not been addressed by the government of Canada." Sep 19, 2022 PrivacyLawyer - David Fraser, "My main problem with Bill C 11: The regulation of user-generated content " https://youtu.be/KKx_0UfdsT0 </ref>, promotion of points systems and [[social credit system|social credit systems]], promotions of CBDC agendas),
# trends to ''require'' one's most intimate data ([[biometrics]]<ref>"Integration of blockchain and biometrics to redefine digital identity by 2030: report" Nov 12, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/integration-of-blockchain-and-biometrics-to-redefine-digital-identity-by-2030-report</ref>) for [[Multifactor Authentication|authentication]] and [[Access Control|access]]<ref>"Sentry Enterprise’s plans to supply enterprises with physical and logical access control through its biometric SentryCards..." from "Stage set for next round of secure access control biometrics adoption" Jan 22, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/stage-set-for-next-round-of-secure-access-control-biometrics-adoption</ref> to commerce(Amazon One<ref>Video "Pay with the palm of your hand.." Jan 27, 2023 https://twitter.com/george_orwell3/status/1619113034571730944</ref>), services, and to perhaps remove one's cards<ref>video, Jan 27, 2023, https://youtu.be/cwj4unWn6vw</ref> ('' decentralized methods of proving ID''),
# centralized and restricted access to essentials like gas<ref>Video "Sri Lanka is using digital gas ration books now. How do you think this will be abused?" Aug 9, 2022 https://twitter.com/YALiberty/status/1557079415116500994</ref><ref>"Digital ration cards in Sri Lanka for fuel. .. they literally won't serve you, and to make matters worse the petrol stations all over Sri Lanka now have fully automatic weapons at the petrol stations because you can imagine people's response.. " Sep 5, 2022 https://twitter.com/Alessa11alexa/status/1566855907962658818</ref><ref>"The integration of P97 mobile commerce platform with Cerence Pay makes voice biometric payments available at more than 30 percent of fuel retailers in the U.S., according to the announcement" from "Cerence biometrics partnership brings voice purchases to US gas stations" May 18, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202105/cerence-biometrics-partnership-brings-voice-purchases-to-us-gas-stations</ref>, food<ref>"AnyVision explores biometrics in food distribution and logistics applications" Jun 9, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202106/anyvision-explores-biometrics-in-food-distribution-and-logistics-applications</ref><ref>"Yoti discusses digital identity use to monitor food and cash rations" Nov 23, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/yoti-discusses-digital-identity-use-to-monitor-food-and-cash-rations</ref><ref>"Integrated Biometrics case study details fingerprint verification of food aid recipients in Yemen" Apr 8, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202004/integrated-biometrics-case-study-details-fingerprint-verification-of-food-aid-recipients-in-yemen </ref> 
# rising authoritarianism<ref>"The allure of Chinese ‘digital authoritarianism’ for Latin America" Jan 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/the-allure-of-chinese-digital-authoritarianism-for-latin-america</ref><ref>"IBIA Annual Membership Meeting to feature presentation on COVID-19, authoritarianism and biometrics Jun"Jun 30, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202006/ibia-annual-membership-meeting-to-feature-presentation-on-covid-19-authoritarianism-and-biometrics</ref><ref>"Authoritarianism in South Korea keeps peeking around the curtain... ", from "orea’s out front with digital IDs, but national history could be decisive in success" Oct 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202210/koreas-out-front-with-digital-ids-but-national-history-could-be-decisive-in-success</ref>
# Digital Health Credential systems, ''see [[International Health Regulations|WHO Pandemic Treaty (International Health Regulations IHRs)]], [[Covid passport|covid vaccine passports]])''

===Predictable===
Many critics view these developments as to be expected and predicted by earlier trends. Perhaps the biggest predictor trend is the decline in the level of individual [[freedom]], respect for [[natural law]] and [[unalienable rights]], and [[self-governance]] in [[The West|Western countries]]. This decline is accompanied by the decline in biblical values which affirm the importance of freedom.<ref>Behreandt, Dennis (January 3, 2020). [https://www.thenewamerican.com/print-magazine/item/34261-the-divine-message-of-freedom The Divine Message of Freedom]</ref>. See also [[War on freedom]], and books like RFK's "''The Real Anthony Fauci.. Global War on Democracy and Public Health''"<ref>"The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health " Nov. 16 2021 Robert F. Kennedy Jr. https://www.amazon.ca/Real-Anthony-Fauci-Pharma-Democracy/dp/1510766804</ref>

===Data and Access===
Digital ID proponents tend also to seek to centralize data and control access to it: A Digital ID system is a centralized approach to '''trust'''. See [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Early_CA_infrastructure|HTTPS/SSL history]] for problems with centralized trust models. Digital ID proponents also seek to centralize very large<ref>"..now reportedly contains information on 5,500 law enforcement agencies in all 50 states and multiple territories and districts." from "US biometric surveillance database reaches 10,000 data points " Nov 21, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202211/us-biometric-surveillance-database-reaches-10000-data-points</ref><ref>"Government databases could replace document-based ID verification: Sumsub CTO" Dec 12, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202212/government-databases-could-replace-document-based-id-verification-sumsub-cto</ref> datasets and '''databases'''<ref>Video "Dangers of plants and centralized data" Matt Gubba, circa Jan 22, https://twitter.com/Raul_Aztec/status/1617187582743388237</ref>. This sort of policy is attractive externally (to hackers and bad actors) and internally(poor morale and ethic, human error, incompetence<ref> "Bumbling NYPD contractor nearly infects fingerprint database with ransomware " Dec 13, 2019 https://www.biometricupdate.com/201912/bumbling-nypd-contractor-nearly-infects-fingerprint-database-with-ransomware</ref> ).

===Privacy ===
Many are concerned that federated digital identity places too much importance on "''who'' are you" (as if what a service provider can establish from cards and multifactor authentication falls short and that knowledge of one's business history is needed at each new signup):
::''It is important to differentiate between digital identification and digital authentication. Digital authentication is something most of us do every day – logging on to our favourite social media site, signing into an account with our preferred ecommerce retailer, or even accessing our mobile device through a thumb scan. Authentication is the act of proving that the person accessing my account or device is me, usually through a PIN, password, biometric identifier or other form factor. Authentication is designed to answer the question “Is that you?” Identification, by contrast, is more complex. Identification is intended to answer the question “Who are you?” Digital ID is the challenge of answering “Who are you? with a high degree of certainty, without resorting to face-to-face interaction and the exchange of physical documents.''<ref>"White Paper: Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach", Posted on: May 30, 2018, https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref>

=== Travel, Carbon tracking ===
December 2021, just before Christmas, Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) acknowledged that it ''secretly'' tracked location data from at least 33 million mobile devices to analyze people's movements during COVID-19 quarantines.<ref>Video, press conference, tweet Jan 18, 2022, https://twitter.com/Aslapes11/status/1483389677096820742</ref>. Concerns are whether this behaviour continues to this day or has suitable checks and balances. 

''Canada's Net-Zero Challenge<ref>"Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act - Canada.ca" 
https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/canadian-net-zero-emissions-accountability-act.html</ref><ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/challenge.html</ref> is a voluntary initiative that encourages companies to develop and implement credible and effective plans to transition their facilities and operations to net-zero emissions by 2050.''<ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/2022/08/net-zero-challenge.html</ref>

==See also==
* [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Digital_certificates|Digital Certificates]]
* [[Digital_Signature|Digital Signature]]
* [[Access Control]]
* [[Ukraine#Digital_ID|Ukraine Digital_ID]]
* [[Sustainable Development Goals|Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs)]]
* [[The Great Reset|Agenda: Great Reset and 4th Industrial Revolution (WEF)]]
* [[Right to Privacy]]
* [[Surveillance]]
* [[Social credit system]]
* [[Creeping socialism]]
* [[War_on_Freedom#Big_Tech | Big tech's role in war on freedom (War on Freedom) ]]

==References==
{{reflist}}

[[Category:Uncategorized]]

Digital ID

2023-01-31T05:32:32Z

Fallandtrip:

{{Progress}}

 
''See also Digital health credentials, [[Covid passport]], [[Vaccine passports]]'' 
 

Digital ID refers to ''an extension of current physical ID documents such as driver’s licences, passports and bank cards.. Digital ID is a way to verify who we are online securely, in a manner that offers data protection and safeguards our personal information (interac.ca)''<ref>https://www.interac.ca/en/content/ideas/what-is-digital-identity</ref>.
 

==Purpose==
Through the beginning of the twenty-first century, identity was typically affirmed by the use of paper or plastic cards, issued by third parties. In the United States, the [[Department of Motor Vehicles]] issues Driver Licenses, and other government identification cards. States may also issue ID cards of some form as well, such as welfare cards, gun permits, and fishing licenses. Organizations such as libraries, and membership-only clubs may issue identification cards as well. Additionally, independent companies may issue ID cards of a sort, such as insurance cards, gym membership cards, credit and debit cards, and other customer identification cards (for "rewards programs" and customer behavior tracking for marketing purposes). A digital ID system is designed to serve multiple purposes, eliminating the need for each separate identification card.<ref>https://www.globalgovernmentforum.com/digital-id-what-is-it-why-is-it-needed-and-how-are-governments-developing-it/</ref>
It also provides much greater control to a single authoritative party, rather than a diverse collection of entities, each for their own purposes. This could theoretically be useful in fighting crime<ref>https://www.dawn.com/news/1730768/safe-city-seeks-high-resolution-photos-of-over-4000-criminals-from-nadra</ref><ref>https://www.biometricupdate.com/202301/pakistan-id-authority-shares-data-of-4k-wanted-people-for-biometric-matching</ref>. However, that same single authority can use their power for negative purposes as well. For example, an opponent of the politicians in power could suddenly find their digital ID has been revoked, meaning that they can no longer bank<ref name = "bank1">"Bank Apologizes over Trucker Convoy account freeze ", Marc Patrone , May 30, 2022 , https://bjdichter.substack.com/p/bank-apologizes-over-trucker-convoy?r=10rk8l&</ref><ref name = "bank2">"..yesterday my ability to e-transfer funds was suddenly re-activated.”, Andrea Lee, May 2022, https://twitter.com/RealAndyLeeShow/status/1531645687548366848</ref><ref name = "bank3">Canadian Veteran banned from Scotiabank (phone audio) , Jan 20, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9R6SaXqxTI</ref><ref name = "bank4">https://twitter.com/rick_ppc/status/1616783852730474496</ref>, travel, buy food, earn money, or do much of anything else, all at once. The single ID authority would yield incredible power over its citizens, which some people see as a benefit and purpose of digital ID.<ref>https://thecountersignal.com/why-is-a-digital-id-so-dangerous/</ref><ref>https://www.wired.com/story/digital-ids-are-more-dangerous-than-you-think/</ref>
 
==International Treaties and Agendas==
The International treaties presented below describe ''groups agreeing to work together on'' international digital credential (ID) system, even if it is removed and only in the policy levels. One of the mechanisms is presented as the solution to global health crisis.

===United Nations===
The United Nations has 2 agendas which, between the 2, promote digital identity: United Nations ''Legal Identity Agenda'' and United Nations ''Development Programme Digital Strategy 2022-2025'' 
::For example, the word 'digital' actually occurs once on the landing page for the legal identity agenda: "''Proof of legal identity is defined as a credential, such as birth certificate, identity card or digital identity credential''"<ref>Legal Identity Agenda https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda </ref> 
Of note, UN LIA has a "Task Force" whose responsibilities include to ''oversee the implementation'' of the UN LIA at the ''regional and national'' level<ref>"UN Legal Identity Task Force (UN LIA TF) " https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda</ref>
''See discussion of both in [[UN Agendas]]''
===G20 Indonesia summit===
In November 2022, G20 members signed a declaration for the adoption of a global vaccine passport:
::''We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification message, under the framework of the [[International Health Regulations| International health regulations (WHO IHR)]] 2005 , to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize in build on the success of the existing standards and digital Covid-19 Certificates. (Point 23, G20 Bali Leaders' declaration, The White House)''<ref>p23, "......We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification methods, under the framework of the International health regulations (IHR 2005), to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, and recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize and build on the success of the existing standards and digital COVID-19 certificates. " https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/11/16/g20-bali-leaders-declaration/</ref><ref>secondary sources, tweet thread, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1593186333878816768</ref>

Notice 2 things with wording loose enough for the following:
::*The adoption of vaccine passports (digital ''health credential'' ID) for to facilitate all international travel.
::*WHO determines what crisis qualifies and which vaccinations one must have.

=== World Health Organization Pandemic Treaty ===
See [[International Health Regulations|International Health Regulations (IHRs) 2005]]

== Federated ID Systems ==
To federate<ref>"SSO is meant to authenticate one person across different systems. FIM will allow one user access to many applications over any number of networks..", from "Federated Identity Management vs. SSO: Which is Better?" Javed Shah, December 16, 2021 https://www.1kosmos.com/identity-management/federated-identity-management-vs-sso/</ref><ref>Compare and Contrast — Federated Identity vs Self-sovereign Identity Apr 26, 2021 https://academy.affinidi.com/compare-and-contrast-federated-identity-vs-self-sovereign-identity-227a85cbab18</ref><ref>White Paper: "Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach In this brief, we highlight why Canada needs a digital identity system, how other countries have .." May 30, 2018 https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref> a digital ID system refers to making national legislation. 

Ukraine was one of the first countries to federate a digital identity system Diia<ref>Video, “Ukraine exports its digital ID technology Ukraine’s government services smartphone app, Diia, has become so “successful” that other countries are interested in replicating it. One of those countries is Estonia, one of the world’s most digitized countries.” https://twitter.com/bigDkenna1/status/1618393202557345792</ref><ref>Video, "Diia (Short For "The State And I"): Mobile Application And Web Portal Review. My Personal Experience" Liza Clinical Wizard, Jan 28, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ath4RcBMo_0</ref>. India also has Aadhaar. Estonia has taken a unique 'decentralized' approach to a national digital ID system<ref>"Estonia's approach to digital ID... Decentralized and very different - but that didn't stop them being at the forefront of developing vaccine passports with the WHO." Jan 24 Alex Klaushofer , https://khmezek.substack.com/p/ukraines-diia-city-initiative-the , from "Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU." https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>.

== UK ==
On March 1st a consultation <ref>https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-legislation-to-help-more-people-prove-their-identity-online/consultation-on-draft-legislation-to-support-identity-verification</ref> (''a survey'') about digital identity verification and data sharing between public authorities comes to a close<ref name="whose-data">Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU , Alex Klaushofer Jan 23 2023, https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>. Launched on January 4th, the proposed changes will spend a short time under public consideration. Review and criticism videos are available.<ref>Video 34:40 "Digital IDs are coming - but there's still time to have YOUR say!" Geoff Buys Cars Jan 10, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COx6vl3i-L4</ref><ref>Video 9:19 "UK Government digital ID" funkyprepper Jan 12, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swciKHYS1Hg</ref><ref>Video 26:24 "Urgent! UK Government's Digital Identity Survey" Richard Vobes Jan 11, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcrwXQdGkn0</ref><ref name="whose-data"></ref><ref>Video 25:45 "Digital ID Arrives in Britain" 53,076+ views The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters Jan 17, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSqpSHN1iUs</ref>

== Canada==
Adopted by Canada and all other 192 [[United Nations]] Member States in 2015, the [[2030 Agenda]] is a 15-year global framework centered on an ambitious set of 17 [[Sustainable Development Goals]] (SDGs).<ref>"Canada and the Sustainable Development Goals ", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/agenda-2030.html</ref><ref>"Funding program", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/news/2019/05/sustainable-development-goals-sdg-funding-program.html</ref>

There are many government affiliated organizations working to advance digital identity systems in Canada. See [[ktdi.org]], [[Policy Horizons]] and [https://diacc.ca/faq/ Digital Identity and Authentication Council of Canada]

=== Airports / Known Traveller Digital Identity ===
The Known Traveller Digital Identity (KTDI) program is a collaboration between the government of Canada, the [[World Economic Forum]] and private sector to develop a secure and efficient digital identity system for air travel. The program aims to use biometric and digital identity technologies to create a more seamless and secure travel experience for passengers.
:The KTDI program was first announced in 2018 by the Government of Canada as part of its National Strategy for Secure Travelling Abroad. The aim of the program is to enhance the security of air travel while also making the travel experience more convenient and efficient for passengers. The program aims to use biometric data such as facial recognition, fingerprint, and iris scans to confirm the identity of passengers, making it easier for them to move through the airport and board their flights.
:The program has a pilot phase, with several Canadian airports participating in testing and evaluating the technology. Once fully implemented, the program will be available to all Canadian citizens and permanent residents with a valid passport.
It's worth noting that the implementation of the program is in line with the national strategy of Canada to enhance security and improve the passenger experience, but it also raises concerns about privacy, security, and accessibility. The government of Canada has stated that the personal information collected through the program will be protected and used only for the specific purpose of the program, and that the use of biometrics will be optional for passengers.

=== Border Land Travel / ArriveCAN===
The ArriveCAN app is an official government of Canada app that is used to help digitize border crossing into the country. "''Travellers returning to Canada: You are required to provide info upon entry for COVID19. Download the ArriveCAN app to do it quickly and limit points of contact at the border''"<ref>Health Canada and PHAC @GovCanHealth, Apr 29, 2020, https://twitter.com/GovCanHealth/status/1255602952045289474</ref>.
The app is available for download on the App Store and Google Play and is free to use. ''Concerns'' surround whether the app is mandatory to use.

=== Digital Health Credential Systems / Provinces ===
By 2021 Most provinces in Canada had announced plans to implement a [[Vaccine passports|digital vaccine certification system]], such as Ontario, which will use a digital version of the [[Covid passport|COVID-19 vaccination record card]] and a mobile app called the "COVID-19 Vaccination Record" to allow residents to demonstrate their vaccination status.

According to an ''unverified source''<ref>screenshot ".. tender for a Canadian Health Passport.." Dec 7 2022, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1600614353446883328</ref>, Canada's Digital Transformation Branch (DTB, within Health Canada) has issued a tender for a Canadian Health Passport which includes requirements for proof of vaccination for domestic and international travel. Another ''unverified source'' says this comes into effect Sept 2023.<ref>https://twitter.com/UNDERTHEBED/status/1601315955208257536</ref>

===Bankers Association ===
In Feb 2022, Neil Parmenter of the Canadian Bankers Association promoted digital identity advancement as being on the cusp of a revolution in how people authenticate online.<ref>"Canadian bankers association - Digital ID",World Reflection, 2min clip, circa Feb 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpUFY1-GmCA, cited by https://twitter.com/KathrynLouiseBC/status/1604916667523682305</ref>

==Criticisms==

Many critics take broad views of what is digital identity. For example, a pervasive take in places like UK and Canada is that digital ID is already here (youtuber Coin Bureau<ref>Video "Digital IDs Are HERE!! Why You Should Be WORRIED!!.." Coin Bureau, Dec 11, 2022 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwRSzNTp2ko&t=169s</ref>, see notes on surveilance and bank freezing). Concerns about digital identity are addressed in books such as "''Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom''"(2022)<ref>"Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom Paperback "– March 17, 2022 by Nick Corbishley (Author) https://www.amazon.com/Scanned-Vaccine-Passports-Digital-Personal/dp/1645021629</ref> as well, where the thrust pertains to privacy and personal liberties. This section covers an alternative definition and then expands on areas of ongoing concern.
===Composite Definition ===
One writer proposes to view digital identity as a composite (set) of concurrent trends:
# tying commerce/banking with politics (frozen bank accounts<ref name = "bank1"> </ref><ref name = "bank2"> </ref><ref name = "bank3"> </ref><ref name = "bank4"> </ref>, vilification of anonymity<ref>"The US Justice Department is part of WEF's Partnership against Cybercrime, which is run by an Israeli intelligence veteran and pushes for the end of online anonymity and the merging of Wall Street w their regulators and intelligence agencies. "Jan 18, 2023 https://twitter.com/_whitneywebb/status/1615754783494930432</ref><ref>"We investigated how objective, behavioral data on [[social media]] use was correlated with the Dark Tetrad facets and the HEXACO traits., " from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191886922004652, from "Don't allow the anonymous troll-demons to post with the real verified people @elonmusk . Put them in their own hell.." Nov 18, 2022 https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/1593691037121228801</ref> and privacy<ref>"..privacy and freedom of expression issues that have not been addressed by the government of Canada." Sep 19, 2022 PrivacyLawyer - David Fraser, "My main problem with Bill C 11: The regulation of user-generated content " https://youtu.be/KKx_0UfdsT0 </ref>, promotion of points systems and [[social credit system|social credit systems]], promotions of CBDC agendas),
# trends to ''require'' one's most intimate data ([[biometrics]]<ref>"Integration of blockchain and biometrics to redefine digital identity by 2030: report" Nov 12, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/integration-of-blockchain-and-biometrics-to-redefine-digital-identity-by-2030-report</ref>) for [[Multifactor Authentication|authentication]] and [[Access Control|access]]<ref>"Sentry Enterprise’s plans to supply enterprises with physical and logical access control through its biometric SentryCards..." from "Stage set for next round of secure access control biometrics adoption" Jan 22, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/stage-set-for-next-round-of-secure-access-control-biometrics-adoption</ref> to commerce(Amazon One<ref>Video "Pay with the palm of your hand.." Jan 27, 2023 https://twitter.com/george_orwell3/status/1619113034571730944</ref>), services, and to perhaps remove one's cards<ref>video, Jan 27, 2023, https://youtu.be/cwj4unWn6vw</ref> ('' decentralized methods of proving ID''),
# centralized and restricted access to essentials like gas<ref>Video "Sri Lanka is using digital gas ration books now. How do you think this will be abused?" Aug 9, 2022 https://twitter.com/YALiberty/status/1557079415116500994</ref><ref>"Digital ration cards in Sri Lanka for fuel. .. they literally won't serve you, and to make matters worse the petrol stations all over Sri Lanka now have fully automatic weapons at the petrol stations because you can imagine people's response.. " Sep 5, 2022 https://twitter.com/Alessa11alexa/status/1566855907962658818</ref><ref>"The integration of P97 mobile commerce platform with Cerence Pay makes voice biometric payments available at more than 30 percent of fuel retailers in the U.S., according to the announcement" from "Cerence biometrics partnership brings voice purchases to US gas stations" May 18, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202105/cerence-biometrics-partnership-brings-voice-purchases-to-us-gas-stations</ref>, food<ref>"AnyVision explores biometrics in food distribution and logistics applications" Jun 9, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202106/anyvision-explores-biometrics-in-food-distribution-and-logistics-applications</ref><ref>"Yoti discusses digital identity use to monitor food and cash rations" Nov 23, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/yoti-discusses-digital-identity-use-to-monitor-food-and-cash-rations</ref><ref>"Integrated Biometrics case study details fingerprint verification of food aid recipients in Yemen" Apr 8, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202004/integrated-biometrics-case-study-details-fingerprint-verification-of-food-aid-recipients-in-yemen </ref> 
# rising authoritarianism<ref>"The allure of Chinese ‘digital authoritarianism’ for Latin America" Jan 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/the-allure-of-chinese-digital-authoritarianism-for-latin-america</ref><ref>"IBIA Annual Membership Meeting to feature presentation on COVID-19, authoritarianism and biometrics Jun"Jun 30, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202006/ibia-annual-membership-meeting-to-feature-presentation-on-covid-19-authoritarianism-and-biometrics</ref><ref>"Authoritarianism in South Korea keeps peeking around the curtain... ", from "orea’s out front with digital IDs, but national history could be decisive in success" Oct 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202210/koreas-out-front-with-digital-ids-but-national-history-could-be-decisive-in-success</ref>
# Digital Health Credential systems, ''see [[International Health Regulations|WHO Pandemic Treaty (International Health Regulations IHRs)]], [[Covid passport|covid vaccine passports]])''

===Predictable===
Many critics view these developments as to be expected and predicted by earlier trends. Perhaps the biggest predictor trend is the decline in the level of individual [[freedom]], respect for [[natural law]] and [[unalienable rights]], and [[self-governance]] in [[The West|Western countries]]. This decline is accompanied by the decline in biblical values which affirm the importance of freedom.<ref>Behreandt, Dennis (January 3, 2020). [https://www.thenewamerican.com/print-magazine/item/34261-the-divine-message-of-freedom The Divine Message of Freedom]</ref>. See also [[War on freedom]], and books like RFK's "''The Real Anthony Fauci.. Global War on Democracy and Public Health''"<ref>"The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health " Nov. 16 2021 Robert F. Kennedy Jr. https://www.amazon.ca/Real-Anthony-Fauci-Pharma-Democracy/dp/1510766804</ref>

===Data and Access===
Digital ID proponents tend also to seek to centralize data and control access to it: A Digital ID system is a centralized approach to '''trust'''. See [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Early_CA_infrastructure|HTTPS/SSL history]] for problems with centralized trust models. Digital ID proponents also seek to centralize very large<ref>"..now reportedly contains information on 5,500 law enforcement agencies in all 50 states and multiple territories and districts." from "US biometric surveillance database reaches 10,000 data points " Nov 21, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202211/us-biometric-surveillance-database-reaches-10000-data-points</ref><ref>"Government databases could replace document-based ID verification: Sumsub CTO" Dec 12, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202212/government-databases-could-replace-document-based-id-verification-sumsub-cto</ref> datasets and '''databases'''<ref>Video "Dangers of plants and centralized data" Matt Gubba, circa Jan 22, https://twitter.com/Raul_Aztec/status/1617187582743388237</ref>. This sort of policy is attractive externally (to hackers and bad actors) and internally(poor morale and ethic, human error, incompetence<ref> "Bumbling NYPD contractor nearly infects fingerprint database with ransomware " Dec 13, 2019 https://www.biometricupdate.com/201912/bumbling-nypd-contractor-nearly-infects-fingerprint-database-with-ransomware</ref> ).

===Privacy ===
Many are concerned that federated digital identity places too much importance on "''who'' are you" (as if what a service provider can establish from cards and multifactor authentication falls short and that knowledge of one's business history is needed at each new signup):
::''It is important to differentiate between digital identification and digital authentication. Digital authentication is something most of us do every day – logging on to our favourite social media site, signing into an account with our preferred ecommerce retailer, or even accessing our mobile device through a thumb scan. Authentication is the act of proving that the person accessing my account or device is me, usually through a PIN, password, biometric identifier or other form factor. Authentication is designed to answer the question “Is that you?” Identification, by contrast, is more complex. Identification is intended to answer the question “Who are you?” Digital ID is the challenge of answering “Who are you? with a high degree of certainty, without resorting to face-to-face interaction and the exchange of physical documents.''<ref>"White Paper: Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach", Posted on: May 30, 2018, https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref>

=== Travel, Carbon tracking ===
December 2021, just before Christmas, Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) acknowledged that it ''secretly'' tracked location data from at least 33 million mobile devices to analyze people's movements during COVID-19 quarantines.<ref>Video, press conference, tweet Jan 18, 2022, https://twitter.com/Aslapes11/status/1483389677096820742</ref>. Concerns are whether this behaviour continues to this day or has suitable checks and balances. 

''Canada's Net-Zero Challenge<ref>"Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act - Canada.ca" 
https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/canadian-net-zero-emissions-accountability-act.html</ref><ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/challenge.html</ref> is a voluntary initiative that encourages companies to develop and implement credible and effective plans to transition their facilities and operations to net-zero emissions by 2050.''<ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/2022/08/net-zero-challenge.html</ref>

==See also==
* [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Digital_certificates|Digital Certificates]]
* [[Digital_Signature|Digital Signature]]
* [[Access Control]]
* [[Ukraine#Digital_ID|Ukraine Digital_ID]]
* [[Sustainable Development Goals|Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs)]]
* [[The Great Reset|Agenda: Great Reset and 4th Industrial Revolution (WEF)]]
* [[Right to Privacy]]
* [[Surveillance]]
* [[Social credit system]]
* [[Creeping socialism]]
* [[War_on_Freedom#Big_Tech | Big tech's role in war on freedom (War on Freedom) ]]

==References==
{{reflist}}

[[Category:Uncategorized]]

Talk:Digital ID

2023-01-31T05:21:35Z

Fallandtrip:

Digital ID

2023-01-31T05:06:26Z

Fallandtrip:

{{Progress}}

 
''See also Digital health credentials, [[Covid passport]], [[Vaccine passports]]'' 
 

Digital ID refers to ''an extension of current physical ID documents such as driver’s licences, passports and bank cards.. Digital ID is a way to verify who we are online securely, in a manner that offers data protection and safeguards our personal information (interac.ca)''<ref>https://www.interac.ca/en/content/ideas/what-is-digital-identity</ref>.
 

==Purpose==
Through the beginning of the twenty-first century, identity was typically affirmed by the use of paper or plastic cards, issued by third parties. In the United States, the [[Department of Motor Vehicles]] issues Driver Licenses, and other government identification cards. States may also issue ID cards of some form as well, such as welfare cards, gun permits, and fishing licenses. Organizations such as libraries, and membership-only clubs may issue identification cards as well. Additionally, independent companies may issue ID cards of a sort, such as insurance cards, gym membership cards, credit and debit cards, and other customer identification cards (for "rewards programs" and customer behavior tracking for marketing purposes). A digital ID system is designed to serve multiple purposes, eliminating the need for each separate identification card.<ref>https://www.globalgovernmentforum.com/digital-id-what-is-it-why-is-it-needed-and-how-are-governments-developing-it/</ref>
It also provides much greater control to a single authoritative party, rather than a diverse collection of entities, each for their own purposes. This could theoretically be useful in fighting crime<ref>https://www.dawn.com/news/1730768/safe-city-seeks-high-resolution-photos-of-over-4000-criminals-from-nadra</ref><ref>https://www.biometricupdate.com/202301/pakistan-id-authority-shares-data-of-4k-wanted-people-for-biometric-matching</ref>. However, that same single authority can use their power for negative purposes as well. For example, an opponent of the politicians in power could suddenly find their digital ID has been revoked, meaning that they can no longer bank<ref name = "bank1">"Bank Apologizes over Trucker Convoy account freeze ", Marc Patrone , May 30, 2022 , https://bjdichter.substack.com/p/bank-apologizes-over-trucker-convoy?r=10rk8l&</ref><ref name = "bank2">"..yesterday my ability to e-transfer funds was suddenly re-activated.”, Andrea Lee, May 2022, https://twitter.com/RealAndyLeeShow/status/1531645687548366848</ref><ref name = "bank3">Canadian Veteran banned from Scotiabank (phone audio) , Jan 20, 2023, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A9R6SaXqxTI</ref><ref name = "bank4">https://twitter.com/rick_ppc/status/1616783852730474496</ref>, travel, buy food, earn money, or do much of anything else, all at once. The single ID authority would yield incredible power over its citizens, which some people see as a benefit and purpose of digital ID.<ref>https://thecountersignal.com/why-is-a-digital-id-so-dangerous/</ref><ref>https://www.wired.com/story/digital-ids-are-more-dangerous-than-you-think/</ref>
 
==International Treaties and Agendas==
International treaties converge on an international digital credential (ID) system. One of the mechanisms is presented as the solution to global health crisis.

===UN===
The United Nations has 2 agendas which, between the 2, promote digital identity: United Nations Legal Identity Agenda and United Nations Development Programme Digital Strategy 2022-2025 
::For example, the word 'digital' actually occurs once on the landing page for the legal identity agenda: "''Proof of legal identity is defined as a credential, such as birth certificate, identity card or digital identity credential''"<ref>Legal Identity Agenda https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda </ref> 
Of note, UN LIA has a "Task Force" whose responsibilities include to ''oversee the implementation'' of the UN LIA at the ''regional and national'' level<ref>"UN Legal Identity Task Force (UN LIA TF) " https://unstats.un.org/legal-identity-agenda</ref>
''See discussion of both in [[UN Agendas]]''
===G20 Indonesia summit===
In November 2022, G20 members signed a declaration for the adoption of a global vaccine passport:
::''We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification message, under the framework of the [[International Health Regulations| International health regulations (WHO IHR)]] 2005 , to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize in build on the success of the existing standards and digital Covid-19 Certificates. (Point 23, G20 Bali Leaders' declaration, The White House)''<ref>p23, "......We acknowledge the importance of shared technical standards and verification methods, under the framework of the International health regulations (IHR 2005), to facilitate seamless international travel, interoperability, and recognizing digital solutions and non-digital solutions, including proof of vaccinations. We support continued international dialogue and collaboration on the establishment of trusted global digital health networks as part of the efforts to strengthen prevention and response to future pandemics, that should capitalize and build on the success of the existing standards and digital COVID-19 certificates. " https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/11/16/g20-bali-leaders-declaration/</ref><ref>secondary sources, tweet thread, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1593186333878816768</ref>

Notice 2 things with wording loose enough for the following:
::*The adoption of vaccine passports (digital ''health credential'' ID) for to facilitate all international travel.
::*WHO determines what crisis qualifies and which vaccinations one must have.

== Federated ID Systems ==
To federate<ref>"SSO is meant to authenticate one person across different systems. FIM will allow one user access to many applications over any number of networks..", from "Federated Identity Management vs. SSO: Which is Better?" Javed Shah, December 16, 2021 https://www.1kosmos.com/identity-management/federated-identity-management-vs-sso/</ref><ref>Compare and Contrast — Federated Identity vs Self-sovereign Identity Apr 26, 2021 https://academy.affinidi.com/compare-and-contrast-federated-identity-vs-self-sovereign-identity-227a85cbab18</ref><ref>White Paper: "Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach In this brief, we highlight why Canada needs a digital identity system, how other countries have .." May 30, 2018 https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref> a digital ID system refers to making national legislation. 

Ukraine was one of the first countries to federate a digital identity system Diia<ref>Video, “Ukraine exports its digital ID technology Ukraine’s government services smartphone app, Diia, has become so “successful” that other countries are interested in replicating it. One of those countries is Estonia, one of the world’s most digitized countries.” https://twitter.com/bigDkenna1/status/1618393202557345792</ref><ref>Video, "Diia (Short For "The State And I"): Mobile Application And Web Portal Review. My Personal Experience" Liza Clinical Wizard, Jan 28, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ath4RcBMo_0</ref>. India also has Aadhaar. Estonia has taken a unique 'decentralized' approach to a national digital ID system<ref>"Estonia's approach to digital ID... Decentralized and very different - but that didn't stop them being at the forefront of developing vaccine passports with the WHO." Jan 24 Alex Klaushofer , https://khmezek.substack.com/p/ukraines-diia-city-initiative-the , from "Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU." https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>.

== UK ==
On March 1st a consultation <ref>https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-legislation-to-help-more-people-prove-their-identity-online/consultation-on-draft-legislation-to-support-identity-verification</ref> (''a survey'') about digital identity verification and data sharing between public authorities comes to a close<ref name="whose-data">Whose data is it anyway? The UK government plans to share a lot of information about YOU , Alex Klaushofer Jan 23 2023, https://alexklaushofer.substack.com/p/whose-data-is-it-anyway?r=bkpk4&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web</ref>. Launched on January 4th, the proposed changes will spend a short time under public consideration. Review and criticism videos are available.<ref>Video 34:40 "Digital IDs are coming - but there's still time to have YOUR say!" Geoff Buys Cars Jan 10, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=COx6vl3i-L4</ref><ref>Video 9:19 "UK Government digital ID" funkyprepper Jan 12, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=swciKHYS1Hg</ref><ref>Video 26:24 "Urgent! UK Government's Digital Identity Survey" Richard Vobes Jan 11, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcrwXQdGkn0</ref><ref name="whose-data"></ref><ref>Video 25:45 "Digital ID Arrives in Britain" 53,076+ views The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters Jan 17, 2023 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSqpSHN1iUs</ref>

== Canada==
Adopted by Canada and all other 192 [[United Nations]] Member States in 2015, the [[2030 Agenda]] is a 15-year global framework centered on an ambitious set of 17 [[Sustainable Development Goals]] (SDGs).<ref>"Canada and the Sustainable Development Goals ", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/programs/agenda-2030.html</ref><ref>"Funding program", https://www.canada.ca/en/employment-social-development/news/2019/05/sustainable-development-goals-sdg-funding-program.html</ref>

There are many government affiliated organizations working to advance digital identity systems in Canada. See [[ktdi.org]], [[Policy Horizons]] and [https://diacc.ca/faq/ Digital Identity and Authentication Council of Canada]

=== Airports / Known Traveller Digital Identity ===
The Known Traveller Digital Identity (KTDI) program is a collaboration between the government of Canada, the [[World Economic Forum]] and private sector to develop a secure and efficient digital identity system for air travel. The program aims to use biometric and digital identity technologies to create a more seamless and secure travel experience for passengers.
:The KTDI program was first announced in 2018 by the Government of Canada as part of its National Strategy for Secure Travelling Abroad. The aim of the program is to enhance the security of air travel while also making the travel experience more convenient and efficient for passengers. The program aims to use biometric data such as facial recognition, fingerprint, and iris scans to confirm the identity of passengers, making it easier for them to move through the airport and board their flights.
:The program has a pilot phase, with several Canadian airports participating in testing and evaluating the technology. Once fully implemented, the program will be available to all Canadian citizens and permanent residents with a valid passport.
It's worth noting that the implementation of the program is in line with the national strategy of Canada to enhance security and improve the passenger experience, but it also raises concerns about privacy, security, and accessibility. The government of Canada has stated that the personal information collected through the program will be protected and used only for the specific purpose of the program, and that the use of biometrics will be optional for passengers.

=== Border Land Travel / ArriveCAN===
The ArriveCAN app is an official government of Canada app that is used to help digitize border crossing into the country. "''Travellers returning to Canada: You are required to provide info upon entry for COVID19. Download the ArriveCAN app to do it quickly and limit points of contact at the border''"<ref>Health Canada and PHAC @GovCanHealth, Apr 29, 2020, https://twitter.com/GovCanHealth/status/1255602952045289474</ref>.
The app is available for download on the App Store and Google Play and is free to use. ''Concerns'' surround whether the app is mandatory to use.

=== Digital Health Credential Systems / Provinces ===
By 2021 Most provinces in Canada had announced plans to implement a [[Vaccine passports|digital vaccine certification system]], such as Ontario, which will use a digital version of the [[Covid passport|COVID-19 vaccination record card]] and a mobile app called the "COVID-19 Vaccination Record" to allow residents to demonstrate their vaccination status.

According to an ''unverified source''<ref>screenshot ".. tender for a Canadian Health Passport.." Dec 7 2022, https://twitter.com/BernieSpofforth/status/1600614353446883328</ref>, Canada's Digital Transformation Branch (DTB, within Health Canada) has issued a tender for a Canadian Health Passport which includes requirements for proof of vaccination for domestic and international travel. Another ''unverified source'' says this comes into effect Sept 2023.<ref>https://twitter.com/UNDERTHEBED/status/1601315955208257536</ref>

===Bankers Association ===
In Feb 2022, Neil Parmenter of the Canadian Bankers Association promoted digital identity advancement as being on the cusp of a revolution in how people authenticate online.<ref>"Canadian bankers association - Digital ID",World Reflection, 2min clip, circa Feb 2022, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gpUFY1-GmCA, cited by https://twitter.com/KathrynLouiseBC/status/1604916667523682305</ref>

==Criticisms==

Many critics take broad views of what is digital identity. For example, a pervasive take in places like UK and Canada is that digital ID is already here (youtuber Coin Bureau<ref>Video "Digital IDs Are HERE!! Why You Should Be WORRIED!!.." Coin Bureau, Dec 11, 2022 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwRSzNTp2ko&t=169s</ref>, see notes on surveilance and bank freezing). Concerns about digital identity are addressed in books such as "''Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom''"(2022)<ref>"Scanned: Why Vaccine Passports and Digital IDs Will Mean the End of Privacy and Personal Freedom Paperback "– March 17, 2022 by Nick Corbishley (Author) https://www.amazon.com/Scanned-Vaccine-Passports-Digital-Personal/dp/1645021629</ref> as well, where the thrust pertains to privacy and personal liberties. This section covers an alternative definition and then expands on areas of ongoing concern.
===Composite Definition ===
One writer proposes to view digital identity as a composite (set) of concurrent trends:
# tying commerce/banking with politics (frozen bank accounts<ref name = "bank1"> </ref><ref name = "bank2"> </ref><ref name = "bank3"> </ref><ref name = "bank4"> </ref>, vilification of anonymity<ref>"The US Justice Department is part of WEF's Partnership against Cybercrime, which is run by an Israeli intelligence veteran and pushes for the end of online anonymity and the merging of Wall Street w their regulators and intelligence agencies. "Jan 18, 2023 https://twitter.com/_whitneywebb/status/1615754783494930432</ref><ref>"We investigated how objective, behavioral data on [[social media]] use was correlated with the Dark Tetrad facets and the HEXACO traits., " from https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0191886922004652, from "Don't allow the anonymous troll-demons to post with the real verified people @elonmusk . Put them in their own hell.." Nov 18, 2022 https://twitter.com/jordanbpeterson/status/1593691037121228801</ref> and privacy<ref>"..privacy and freedom of expression issues that have not been addressed by the government of Canada." Sep 19, 2022 PrivacyLawyer - David Fraser, "My main problem with Bill C 11: The regulation of user-generated content " https://youtu.be/KKx_0UfdsT0 </ref>, promotion of points systems and [[social credit system|social credit systems]], promotions of CBDC agendas),
# trends to ''require'' one's most intimate data ([[biometrics]]<ref>"Integration of blockchain and biometrics to redefine digital identity by 2030: report" Nov 12, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/integration-of-blockchain-and-biometrics-to-redefine-digital-identity-by-2030-report</ref>) for [[Multifactor Authentication|authentication]] and [[Access Control|access]]<ref>"Sentry Enterprise’s plans to supply enterprises with physical and logical access control through its biometric SentryCards..." from "Stage set for next round of secure access control biometrics adoption" Jan 22, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/stage-set-for-next-round-of-secure-access-control-biometrics-adoption</ref> to commerce(Amazon One<ref>Video "Pay with the palm of your hand.." Jan 27, 2023 https://twitter.com/george_orwell3/status/1619113034571730944</ref>), services, and to perhaps remove one's cards<ref>video, Jan 27, 2023, https://youtu.be/cwj4unWn6vw</ref> ('' decentralized methods of proving ID''),
# centralized and restricted access to essentials like gas<ref>Video "Sri Lanka is using digital gas ration books now. How do you think this will be abused?" Aug 9, 2022 https://twitter.com/YALiberty/status/1557079415116500994</ref><ref>"Digital ration cards in Sri Lanka for fuel. .. they literally won't serve you, and to make matters worse the petrol stations all over Sri Lanka now have fully automatic weapons at the petrol stations because you can imagine people's response.. " Sep 5, 2022 https://twitter.com/Alessa11alexa/status/1566855907962658818</ref><ref>"The integration of P97 mobile commerce platform with Cerence Pay makes voice biometric payments available at more than 30 percent of fuel retailers in the U.S., according to the announcement" from "Cerence biometrics partnership brings voice purchases to US gas stations" May 18, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202105/cerence-biometrics-partnership-brings-voice-purchases-to-us-gas-stations</ref>, food<ref>"AnyVision explores biometrics in food distribution and logistics applications" Jun 9, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202106/anyvision-explores-biometrics-in-food-distribution-and-logistics-applications</ref><ref>"Yoti discusses digital identity use to monitor food and cash rations" Nov 23, 2021 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202111/yoti-discusses-digital-identity-use-to-monitor-food-and-cash-rations</ref><ref>"Integrated Biometrics case study details fingerprint verification of food aid recipients in Yemen" Apr 8, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202004/integrated-biometrics-case-study-details-fingerprint-verification-of-food-aid-recipients-in-yemen </ref> 
# rising authoritarianism<ref>"The allure of Chinese ‘digital authoritarianism’ for Latin America" Jan 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202201/the-allure-of-chinese-digital-authoritarianism-for-latin-america</ref><ref>"IBIA Annual Membership Meeting to feature presentation on COVID-19, authoritarianism and biometrics Jun"Jun 30, 2020 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202006/ibia-annual-membership-meeting-to-feature-presentation-on-covid-19-authoritarianism-and-biometrics</ref><ref>"Authoritarianism in South Korea keeps peeking around the curtain... ", from "orea’s out front with digital IDs, but national history could be decisive in success" Oct 17, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202210/koreas-out-front-with-digital-ids-but-national-history-could-be-decisive-in-success</ref>
# Digital Health Credential systems, ''see [[International Health Regulations|WHO Pandemic Treaty (International Health Regulations IHRs)]], [[Covid passport|covid vaccine passports]])''

===Predictable===
Many critics view these developments as to be expected and predicted by earlier trends. Perhaps the biggest predictor trend is the decline in the level of individual [[freedom]], respect for [[natural law]] and [[unalienable rights]], and [[self-governance]] in [[The West|Western countries]]. This decline is accompanied by the decline in biblical values which affirm the importance of freedom.<ref>Behreandt, Dennis (January 3, 2020). [https://www.thenewamerican.com/print-magazine/item/34261-the-divine-message-of-freedom The Divine Message of Freedom]</ref>. See also [[War on freedom]], and books like RFK's "''The Real Anthony Fauci.. Global War on Democracy and Public Health''"<ref>"The Real Anthony Fauci: Bill Gates, Big Pharma, and the Global War on Democracy and Public Health " Nov. 16 2021 Robert F. Kennedy Jr. https://www.amazon.ca/Real-Anthony-Fauci-Pharma-Democracy/dp/1510766804</ref>

===Data and Access===
Digital ID proponents tend also to seek to centralize data and control access to it: A Digital ID system is a centralized approach to '''trust'''. See [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Early_CA_infrastructure|HTTPS/SSL history]] for problems with centralized trust models. Digital ID proponents also seek to centralize very large<ref>"..now reportedly contains information on 5,500 law enforcement agencies in all 50 states and multiple territories and districts." from "US biometric surveillance database reaches 10,000 data points " Nov 21, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202211/us-biometric-surveillance-database-reaches-10000-data-points</ref><ref>"Government databases could replace document-based ID verification: Sumsub CTO" Dec 12, 2022 https://www.biometricupdate.com/202212/government-databases-could-replace-document-based-id-verification-sumsub-cto</ref> datasets and '''databases'''<ref>Video "Dangers of plants and centralized data" Matt Gubba, circa Jan 22, https://twitter.com/Raul_Aztec/status/1617187582743388237</ref>. This sort of policy is attractive externally (to hackers and bad actors) and internally(poor morale and ethic, human error, incompetence<ref> "Bumbling NYPD contractor nearly infects fingerprint database with ransomware " Dec 13, 2019 https://www.biometricupdate.com/201912/bumbling-nypd-contractor-nearly-infects-fingerprint-database-with-ransomware</ref> ).

===Privacy ===
Many are concerned that federated digital identity places too much importance on "''who'' are you" (as if what a service provider can establish from cards and multifactor authentication falls short and that knowledge of one's business history is needed at each new signup):
::''It is important to differentiate between digital identification and digital authentication. Digital authentication is something most of us do every day – logging on to our favourite social media site, signing into an account with our preferred ecommerce retailer, or even accessing our mobile device through a thumb scan. Authentication is the act of proving that the person accessing my account or device is me, usually through a PIN, password, biometric identifier or other form factor. Authentication is designed to answer the question “Is that you?” Identification, by contrast, is more complex. Identification is intended to answer the question “Who are you?” Digital ID is the challenge of answering “Who are you? with a high degree of certainty, without resorting to face-to-face interaction and the exchange of physical documents.''<ref>"White Paper: Canada’s Digital ID Future - A Federated Approach", Posted on: May 30, 2018, https://cba.ca/embracing-digital-id-in-canada</ref>

=== Travel, Carbon tracking ===
December 2021, just before Christmas, Public Health Agency of Canada (PHAC) acknowledged that it ''secretly'' tracked location data from at least 33 million mobile devices to analyze people's movements during COVID-19 quarantines.<ref>Video, press conference, tweet Jan 18, 2022, https://twitter.com/Aslapes11/status/1483389677096820742</ref>. Concerns are whether this behaviour continues to this day or has suitable checks and balances. 

''Canada's Net-Zero Challenge<ref>"Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act - Canada.ca" 
https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/canadian-net-zero-emissions-accountability-act.html</ref><ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/weather/climatechange/climate-plan/net-zero-emissions-2050/challenge.html</ref> is a voluntary initiative that encourages companies to develop and implement credible and effective plans to transition their facilities and operations to net-zero emissions by 2050.''<ref>https://www.canada.ca/en/environment-climate-change/news/2022/08/net-zero-challenge.html</ref>

==See also==
* [[Trusted_Root_Certificate_Authority_(CA)#Digital_certificates|Digital Certificates]]
* [[Digital_Signature|Digital Signature]]
* [[Access Control]]
* [[Ukraine#Digital_ID|Ukraine Digital_ID]]
* [[Sustainable Development Goals|Sustainable Development Goals (UN SDGs)]]
* [[The Great Reset|Agenda: Great Reset and 4th Industrial Revolution (WEF)]]
* [[Right to Privacy]]
* [[Surveillance]]
* [[Social credit system]]
* [[Creeping socialism]]
* [[War_on_Freedom#Big_Tech | Big tech's role in war on freedom (War on Freedom) ]]

==References==
{{reflist}}

[[Category:Uncategorized]]