<?xml version="1.0"?>
<feed xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" xml:lang="en">
	<id>https://www.conservapedia.com/api.php?action=feedcontributions&amp;feedformat=atom&amp;user=DanB</id>
	<title>Conservapedia - User contributions [en]</title>
	<link rel="self" type="application/atom+xml" href="https://www.conservapedia.com/api.php?action=feedcontributions&amp;feedformat=atom&amp;user=DanB"/>
	<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://www.conservapedia.com/Special:Contributions/DanB"/>
	<updated>2026-11-22T23:08:11Z</updated>
	<subtitle>User contributions</subtitle>
	<generator>MediaWiki 1.35.14</generator>
	<entry>
		<id>https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=File_talk:Atheism.png&amp;diff=521881</id>
		<title>File talk:Atheism.png</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=File_talk:Atheism.png&amp;diff=521881"/>
		<updated>2008-09-22T01:19:36Z</updated>

		<summary type="html">&lt;p&gt;DanB: tidied so Ken can use it&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;hr /&gt;
&lt;div&gt;Why do you need an image Ken you could make this using html tags it is just white text on a black background,&lt;br /&gt;
&amp;lt;div style=&amp;quot;background:black;color:white;text-align:center;font-size:30px;height:35px;width:200px;&amp;quot;&amp;gt;like this&amp;lt;/div&amp;gt;? [[User:DanB|DanB]] 21:15, 21 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;/div&gt;</summary>
		<author><name>DanB</name></author>
	</entry>
	<entry>
		<id>https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=File_talk:Atheism.png&amp;diff=521876</id>
		<title>File talk:Atheism.png</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=File_talk:Atheism.png&amp;diff=521876"/>
		<updated>2008-09-22T01:15:08Z</updated>

		<summary type="html">&lt;p&gt;DanB: New page: Why do you need an image Ken you could make this using html tags it is just white text on a black background, &amp;lt;div style=&amp;quot;background:black;color:white;text-align:center;font-size:250%&amp;quot;&amp;gt;lik...&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;hr /&gt;
&lt;div&gt;Why do you need an image Ken you could make this using html tags it is just white text on a black background,&lt;br /&gt;
&amp;lt;div style=&amp;quot;background:black;color:white;text-align:center;font-size:250%&amp;quot;&amp;gt;like this&amp;lt;/div&amp;gt;? [[User:DanB|DanB]] 21:15, 21 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;/div&gt;</summary>
		<author><name>DanB</name></author>
	</entry>
	<entry>
		<id>https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter&amp;diff=521838</id>
		<title>Talk:PNAS Response to Letter</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter&amp;diff=521838"/>
		<updated>2008-09-22T00:40:45Z</updated>

		<summary type="html">&lt;p&gt;DanB: /* Point 5 Confirmed */&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;hr /&gt;
&lt;div&gt;Notice: misrepresentations are not going to be allowed on this page.  Substantive comments only, please.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Note: earlier posts are archived [[Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter/Archive1|here]]. --[[User:BillA|BillA]] 17:05, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
== Point 5 Confirmed ==&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
I would like to contribute to this discussion because I have taught statistics to graduate biology students for 16 years.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
The combination of data from several experiments is a specialist and sometimes difficult area of statistical theory but a simple example shows why Aschafly’s concern about combining the results of three different experiments is not justified and why this aspect of his criticism of Lenski’s recent paper in PNAS is not valid.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Suppose we want to conduct a test of whether or not men are taller than women on average. For the sake of the example, I generated random heights of people from a population in which men had an average height of 175cm (5’10’) and women of 165cm (5’6”). The standard deviations of height in both sexes were 7cm. I think these numbers are approximately correct for people in the UK but the details aren’t important.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Suppose we take 5 samples of 2 men and 2 women. Here are the numbers I generated:&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
{| class=&amp;quot;wikitable&amp;quot;&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
! Man1 !! Man2 !! Woman1 !! Woman2 !! Men mean !! Women mean !! Mean difference !! t !! P&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 176 || 179 || 157 || 148 || 177.5 || 152.5 || 25 || 5.27 || 0.017&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 180 || 176 || 160 || 164 || 178   || 162   || 16 || 5.66 || 0.015&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 176 || 175 || 167 || 165 || 175.5 || 166   || 9.5 || 8.50 || 0.0068&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 169 || 171 || 168 || 173 || 170 || 170.5 || -0.5 || -0.19 || 0.57&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 179 || 175 || 166 || 178 || 177 || 172 || 5 || 0.79 || 0.26&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|}&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
P in the last column is the t-test probability for a one-side test of women being shorter than men. (Formally, it’s the probability of getting a value of t greater than that calculated from the data if women are in fact taller than men on average.)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Should the fact that, in the fourth sample, the average height of the women is taller than that of the men make us doubt that men are in fact taller on average? Should we be concerned about the last sample, in which the difference in height of the two sexes is rather small, though in the expected direction? No, in both cases. When we combine the data on all 10 men and all 10 women, we get this:&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
{| class=&amp;quot;wikitable&amp;quot;&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
! Men mean !! Women mean !! Mean difference !! t !! ''P''&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 175.6 || 164.6 || 11 || 3.85 || 0.00058&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|}&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Clearly, combining the data from several similar experiments strengthens the conclusions considerably, as shown by the fact that ''P'' is much smaller for the combined data than for any individual sample.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Although the combination of data from several experiments is a specialised area of statistics, I see nothing particularly incorrect about the approach used by Lenski and his colleagues. The general point is that it is valid to combine the results of different experiments if it is scientifically meaningful to do so. (For example: A. Combining the results of five samples of the heights of men and women is clearly valid. B. Combining three samples of heights of men and women with two samples of lengths of male and female squid clearly isn’t.) Generally speaking, the outcome of a combined analysis of several small experiments which all point in the same direction (or at least in a similar direction) will be more significant than that of any one of those experiments, as is shown in the larger table above.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
I hope this clarifies the extensive discussion on this point and puts Aschafly’s mind at rest on this subject. [[User:KennyMac|KennyMac]] 08:20, 18 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:That's very nicely put, thanks. You should work on some of the stats pages here. Of course, technically any sample is ultimately just a combination of ''n'' samples of size 1. [[User:MikeR|MikeR]] 13:28, 18 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:I'll take a look at this Friday.  It's not immediately obvious what the point is to your analysis above.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 23:46, 18 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
::&amp;quot;''The general point is that it is valid to combine the results of different experiments if it is scientifically meaningful to do so&amp;quot;''--[[User:KingOfNothing|KingOfNothing]] 00:57, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::This makes no sense as an argument. It may be true in this simple case that you can do one large or several small samples and get similar results - which is quite obvious and wouldn't need such a detailed rant. However, you provide no mathematical proof, just one example. [[User:Etc|Etc]] 01:08, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
:''&amp;quot;It's not immediately obvious what the point is to your analysis above&amp;quot;''. No surprise, Aschlafly, really. Maybe you should take your own advice: ''&amp;quot;I suggest you try harder with an open mind&amp;quot;''. --[[User:CrossC|CrossC]] 02:46, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
It is with great sadness that I note that the author of this - the only significant statistical explanation and discussion in this entire fiasco-  has [http://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&amp;amp;type=block&amp;amp;user=DeanS&amp;amp;page=User%3AKennyMac just been blocked] for five years.   Even his email is blocked, so he can't even appeal the action.   I don't see such manouvers as having contributed to the much vaunted &amp;quot;open mind&amp;quot; of which various people here speak.  [[User:BenHur|BenHur]] 10:27, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
'''REPLY''': I have now reviewed the above analysis, and it supports Point 5 rather than the PNAS paper.  Point 5 stated, &amp;quot;The Third Experiment was erroneously combined with the other two experiments based on outcome rather than sample size, thereby yielding a false claim of overall statistical significance.&amp;quot;  The analysis above does nothing more than reinforce Point 5 by combining experiments based on sample size.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
In Pavlovian manner, some Lenski types nod their head here in agreement at the above analysis, apparently unaware that it reinforces Point 5.&lt;br /&gt;
 &lt;br /&gt;
When combining results from samples that are vastly different in sample size, it is necessary to factor in the different sample sizes.  Apparently the PNAS paper failed to do that, which helps explain why it refuses to provide a meaningful response to Point 5.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:24, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
(rants below were deleted for being non-substantive in violation of this page's rules.)--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:24, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::I understand point 5 now, or at least I think I do.  What we have as a &amp;quot;sample&amp;quot; is either:&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::1. Individual cultures (Schlafly)&lt;br /&gt;
::::2. Cultures that developed cit+. (Lenski)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::Schlafly contends that the sample should be all the cultures and that Lenski has, improperly, filtered the sample by excluding the vast majority of it (i.e. all those cultures that did not become cit+).  Am I right in thinking this is the argument? --[[User:Toffeeman|Toffeeman]] 19:57, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::: No, we're talking about how Lenski combined a large study (which did not really support Lenski's hypothesis) with small studies (which Lenski claims does support his hypothesis).  The studies were not combined in a logical manner with proper weighting given to the much bigger size of the large study.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 23:15, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
:::::Aschlafly, have you read the paper on z-transforms which explains the statistical technique used? You can download a .pdf copy of the paper for free [http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118663174/abstract here]. --[[User:BillA|BillA]] 06:30, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::: You say &amp;quot;statistical technique used,&amp;quot; but you should have said &amp;quot;statistical technique ''cited''.&amp;quot;  In fact, a close reading of the Z-transform paper provides more support for Point 5: combined studies must be weighted based on sample size:  &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::::: &amp;quot;When there is variation in the sample size across studies, there can be a noticeable difference in the power of the two methods, with the weighted Z-approach being superior in all cases. As such, we should always prefer the weighted Z to the unweighted Z-approach when the independent studies test the same hypothesis.&amp;quot;[http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118663174/abstract see p. 1371].&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::: In other words, the cited paper actually ''supports'' Point 5.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 09:34, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
(unindent)Lenski used the weighted method.  See note 49 to the paper and the text around the combination.  Of course there is the question of on what basis Lenski weighted the results.  Lenski weighted the results on the basis of the Cit+ numbers and we may think it would have been better to weight on the basis of the number of replicates.    I have below the calculations (not mine) of combined P-values based on 1) no weighting, 2) weighting on the basis of Cit+ and 3) weighting on the basis of replicates.  The weighted Z-transformed = SUM(Weight x Z-score for each run)/SQRT(SUM(Weight^2 for each run))&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
{| class=&amp;quot;wikitable&amp;quot;&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
! Expt# !! p-value !! z-score !! #Cit+ muts !! #replicates&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 1 || 0.0085 || 2.387 || 4 || 72&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 2 || 0.0007 || 3.195 || 5 || 340&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 3 || 0.0823 || 1.390 || 8 || 2800&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|}&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Applying the formula described above.. &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
{| class=&amp;quot;wikitable&amp;quot;&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
! Weighting !! Z transformed !! p &lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| Equal || 4.025 || &amp;lt;0.001&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|By total Cit+|| 3.576 || &amp;lt;0.001&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|By total replicates|| 1.825 || 0.034&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|}&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
So weighting on the basis of the number of replicates considerably increases the P-value.  It remains, however, well within the range of statistical significance (0&amp;gt;P&amp;lt;0.05).  If we hold that Lenski should have weighted on the basis of replicates  then he should have rejected the null hypothesis and reached exactly the same conclusions that he did.  The entire paper would have been exactly the same except the sentence “the result is extremely significant (P&amp;lt;0.0001) whether or not….” Would read “the result is significant (P&amp;lt;0.04) whether or not”.  Point 5 establishes one number and an “extremely”.  Point 5, therefore, has no weight (excuse the pun).  &lt;br /&gt;
--[[User:Toffeeman|Toffeeman]] 15:18, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: Sorry, Toffeeman, a falsehood is still a falsehood.  Based on your own posting, if Lenski had applied the Whitlock Z-transform paper in a logical manner, the results would not have been nearly as striking as Lenski claimed (his paper said the results were &amp;quot;extremely significant&amp;quot;).  Moreover, I found Lenski's description of his application of the Whitlock paper to be particularly misleading.  Lenski's use of &amp;quot;whether or not&amp;quot;&amp;lt;ref&amp;gt;&amp;quot;We also used the Z-transformation method (49) to combine the probabilities from our three experiments, and '''the result is extremely significant (P &amp;lt; 0.0001) whether or not''' the experiments are weighted by the number of independent Cit+ mutants observed in each one.&amp;quot; (Lenski paper at 7902).&amp;lt;/ref&amp;gt; obscures the basic error that he did not apply Whitlock's paper in the straightforward, correct manner.  I think the wording in the Lenski paper deliberately obscures this falsehood from the reader.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: People have free will to embrace and defend falsehoods.  I don't expect them to change quickly or admit they were wrong.  But you'll find me defending and promoting the truth.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: Point 5 remains valid and the falsehood remains uncorrected by PNAS or Lenski.  Four other points in higher priority remain uncorrected by them also.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 16:47, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::'''''&amp;quot;a falsehood is still a falsehood&amp;quot;'''''.  Precisely, the null hypothesis should be considered false and the conclusions of the paper stand.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::Oh? Do you mean ''Lenski's falsehood''? And what falsehood is that?  Lenski said that he had calculated the P-value without weighting and that had come out at &amp;lt;0.0001.  That is true, not false.  Lenski said he had calculated the P-value weighting on the basis of the Cit+ replicates and that had come out at &amp;lt;0.0001.  That is true, not false.  There is no falsehood.  Lenski did not mention the results of weighting on the basis of replicate numbers.  He thus made no claim about weighting on the basis of replicate numbers.  If he made no claim he cannot have made a false claim.  &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::How do the words Lenski uses &amp;quot;mislead&amp;quot;.  If you read them as written what conclusion do you come to?  You are lead to the conclusion that the mutation was not &amp;quot;rare-but-equal&amp;quot;, instead it was contingent.  That is the right conclusion.  If Lenski had presented the data in a different manner (perhaps by including the results of weighting on the basis of replicate numbers) what conclusion do you come to?  You are again lead to the conclusion that the mutation was not &amp;quot;rare-but-equal&amp;quot;, instead it was contingent.  That is the right conclusion.  To mislead you must be lead to a conclusion that is incorrect.  By Lenski's paper you are not lead to a conclusion that is incorrect.  Thus is cannot be said to be &amp;quot;misleading&amp;quot;. &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::I shall not comment on your second paragraph, the temptation to ''&amp;quot;Tu Quoque&amp;quot;'' would be too great.  &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
--[[User:Toffeeman|Toffeeman]] 17:13, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::: The falsehood consists of pretending to apply the Whitlock Z-transform in a straightforward, logical and correct manner.  I think the Lenski paper is intentionally misleading by using the &amp;quot;whether or not&amp;quot; wording, when both alternatives are nonsensical.  Point 5 has been proven above to be correct in identify an error in the Lenski paper.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::: &amp;quot;Toffeeman&amp;quot;, your blocking history suggests you have been less than straightforward yourself.  Go elsewhere if you seek to be deceitful.  You're not fooling anyone here.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 17:54, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::Lenski did apply the Z-transformation correctly, both weighted and unweighted. The data points extracted from each replay are the ''generation numbers of those replicates that gave rise to Cit+ mutants''. Thus Replay 1 produced four data points: 30,500 31,500 32,500 32,500. Replay 2 produced five data points: 32,000 32,000 32,000 32,000 32,500. Replay 3 produced eight data points: 20,000 20,000 27,000 27,000 31,000 31,500 32,000 32,000. Thus the N for replay 1 is 4; replay 2 is 5 and replay 3 is 8. The fact that replay 3 used 38 times as many replicates as replay 1 does not mean that it should be weighted 38 times as much; it only produced twice as much data, not 38 times as much. &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::Suppose I want to find out what the average age of a murderer is in three cities. In L.A. I interview 72 random people and find that 4 of them were convicted of murder; I record the ages of the four. In Seattle I interview 340 people and find that 5 of them are convicted murderers; likewise in Singapore I interview 2800 and find 8 murderers. In the end, I have 4,5, and 8 data points from the three cities; the number of people I had to interview to obtain those data points doesn't factor into the analysis of what the average age of the murderers is.--[[User:Brossa|Brossa]] 00:06, 21 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::: In your first paragraph you simply repeat the error underlying Lenski's paper.  You, like the paper, incorrectly apply Whitlock's Z-transform.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::: The quality and reliability of data is proportional to sample size, and when different studies are combined they need to be weighted accordingly.  The results from a very large sample size would not be weighted equally with the results from a small sample size, as you and Lenski have done.  That's basic logic, though I'm not optimistic that you or Lenski will admit it.  Open-minded people who respect logic have no difficulty elevating logic over personal whim.-[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 11:30, 21 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::::Andy if you read Whitlock's paper you would see it say, and I quote, &amp;quot;Ideally each study is weighted proportional to the inverse of its error variance, that is, by the '''reciprocal of its squared standard error'''.&amp;quot; It says nothing about weighting according to sample size, which is what you seem to be insisting should be done.&lt;br /&gt;
::::::Also Whitlock acknowledges in the paper that there is no preference for weighted versus equal weighting, so the fact that both equal weighting and weighting by the standard error give a statistically significant result shows that the 3 experiments combined support rejection of the null hypothesis. [[User:DanB|DanB]] 20:39, 21 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
== References ==&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
&amp;lt;references/&amp;gt;&lt;/div&gt;</summary>
		<author><name>DanB</name></author>
	</entry>
	<entry>
		<id>https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter&amp;diff=521836</id>
		<title>Talk:PNAS Response to Letter</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter&amp;diff=521836"/>
		<updated>2008-09-22T00:39:21Z</updated>

		<summary type="html">&lt;p&gt;DanB: /* Point 5 Confirmed */&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;hr /&gt;
&lt;div&gt;Notice: misrepresentations are not going to be allowed on this page.  Substantive comments only, please.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Note: earlier posts are archived [[Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter/Archive1|here]]. --[[User:BillA|BillA]] 17:05, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
== Point 5 Confirmed ==&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
I would like to contribute to this discussion because I have taught statistics to graduate biology students for 16 years.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
The combination of data from several experiments is a specialist and sometimes difficult area of statistical theory but a simple example shows why Aschafly’s concern about combining the results of three different experiments is not justified and why this aspect of his criticism of Lenski’s recent paper in PNAS is not valid.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Suppose we want to conduct a test of whether or not men are taller than women on average. For the sake of the example, I generated random heights of people from a population in which men had an average height of 175cm (5’10’) and women of 165cm (5’6”). The standard deviations of height in both sexes were 7cm. I think these numbers are approximately correct for people in the UK but the details aren’t important.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Suppose we take 5 samples of 2 men and 2 women. Here are the numbers I generated:&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
{| class=&amp;quot;wikitable&amp;quot;&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
! Man1 !! Man2 !! Woman1 !! Woman2 !! Men mean !! Women mean !! Mean difference !! t !! P&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 176 || 179 || 157 || 148 || 177.5 || 152.5 || 25 || 5.27 || 0.017&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 180 || 176 || 160 || 164 || 178   || 162   || 16 || 5.66 || 0.015&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 176 || 175 || 167 || 165 || 175.5 || 166   || 9.5 || 8.50 || 0.0068&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 169 || 171 || 168 || 173 || 170 || 170.5 || -0.5 || -0.19 || 0.57&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 179 || 175 || 166 || 178 || 177 || 172 || 5 || 0.79 || 0.26&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|}&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
P in the last column is the t-test probability for a one-side test of women being shorter than men. (Formally, it’s the probability of getting a value of t greater than that calculated from the data if women are in fact taller than men on average.)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Should the fact that, in the fourth sample, the average height of the women is taller than that of the men make us doubt that men are in fact taller on average? Should we be concerned about the last sample, in which the difference in height of the two sexes is rather small, though in the expected direction? No, in both cases. When we combine the data on all 10 men and all 10 women, we get this:&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
{| class=&amp;quot;wikitable&amp;quot;&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
! Men mean !! Women mean !! Mean difference !! t !! ''P''&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 175.6 || 164.6 || 11 || 3.85 || 0.00058&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|}&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Clearly, combining the data from several similar experiments strengthens the conclusions considerably, as shown by the fact that ''P'' is much smaller for the combined data than for any individual sample.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Although the combination of data from several experiments is a specialised area of statistics, I see nothing particularly incorrect about the approach used by Lenski and his colleagues. The general point is that it is valid to combine the results of different experiments if it is scientifically meaningful to do so. (For example: A. Combining the results of five samples of the heights of men and women is clearly valid. B. Combining three samples of heights of men and women with two samples of lengths of male and female squid clearly isn’t.) Generally speaking, the outcome of a combined analysis of several small experiments which all point in the same direction (or at least in a similar direction) will be more significant than that of any one of those experiments, as is shown in the larger table above.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
I hope this clarifies the extensive discussion on this point and puts Aschafly’s mind at rest on this subject. [[User:KennyMac|KennyMac]] 08:20, 18 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:That's very nicely put, thanks. You should work on some of the stats pages here. Of course, technically any sample is ultimately just a combination of ''n'' samples of size 1. [[User:MikeR|MikeR]] 13:28, 18 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:I'll take a look at this Friday.  It's not immediately obvious what the point is to your analysis above.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 23:46, 18 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
::&amp;quot;''The general point is that it is valid to combine the results of different experiments if it is scientifically meaningful to do so&amp;quot;''--[[User:KingOfNothing|KingOfNothing]] 00:57, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::This makes no sense as an argument. It may be true in this simple case that you can do one large or several small samples and get similar results - which is quite obvious and wouldn't need such a detailed rant. However, you provide no mathematical proof, just one example. [[User:Etc|Etc]] 01:08, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
:''&amp;quot;It's not immediately obvious what the point is to your analysis above&amp;quot;''. No surprise, Aschlafly, really. Maybe you should take your own advice: ''&amp;quot;I suggest you try harder with an open mind&amp;quot;''. --[[User:CrossC|CrossC]] 02:46, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
It is with great sadness that I note that the author of this - the only significant statistical explanation and discussion in this entire fiasco-  has [http://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Special%3ALog&amp;amp;type=block&amp;amp;user=DeanS&amp;amp;page=User%3AKennyMac just been blocked] for five years.   Even his email is blocked, so he can't even appeal the action.   I don't see such manouvers as having contributed to the much vaunted &amp;quot;open mind&amp;quot; of which various people here speak.  [[User:BenHur|BenHur]] 10:27, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
'''REPLY''': I have now reviewed the above analysis, and it supports Point 5 rather than the PNAS paper.  Point 5 stated, &amp;quot;The Third Experiment was erroneously combined with the other two experiments based on outcome rather than sample size, thereby yielding a false claim of overall statistical significance.&amp;quot;  The analysis above does nothing more than reinforce Point 5 by combining experiments based on sample size.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
In Pavlovian manner, some Lenski types nod their head here in agreement at the above analysis, apparently unaware that it reinforces Point 5.&lt;br /&gt;
 &lt;br /&gt;
When combining results from samples that are vastly different in sample size, it is necessary to factor in the different sample sizes.  Apparently the PNAS paper failed to do that, which helps explain why it refuses to provide a meaningful response to Point 5.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:24, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
(rants below were deleted for being non-substantive in violation of this page's rules.)--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:24, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::I understand point 5 now, or at least I think I do.  What we have as a &amp;quot;sample&amp;quot; is either:&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::1. Individual cultures (Schlafly)&lt;br /&gt;
::::2. Cultures that developed cit+. (Lenski)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::Schlafly contends that the sample should be all the cultures and that Lenski has, improperly, filtered the sample by excluding the vast majority of it (i.e. all those cultures that did not become cit+).  Am I right in thinking this is the argument? --[[User:Toffeeman|Toffeeman]] 19:57, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::: No, we're talking about how Lenski combined a large study (which did not really support Lenski's hypothesis) with small studies (which Lenski claims does support his hypothesis).  The studies were not combined in a logical manner with proper weighting given to the much bigger size of the large study.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 23:15, 19 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
:::::Aschlafly, have you read the paper on z-transforms which explains the statistical technique used? You can download a .pdf copy of the paper for free [http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118663174/abstract here]. --[[User:BillA|BillA]] 06:30, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::: You say &amp;quot;statistical technique used,&amp;quot; but you should have said &amp;quot;statistical technique ''cited''.&amp;quot;  In fact, a close reading of the Z-transform paper provides more support for Point 5: combined studies must be weighted based on sample size:  &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::::: &amp;quot;When there is variation in the sample size across studies, there can be a noticeable difference in the power of the two methods, with the weighted Z-approach being superior in all cases. As such, we should always prefer the weighted Z to the unweighted Z-approach when the independent studies test the same hypothesis.&amp;quot;[http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/118663174/abstract see p. 1371].&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::: In other words, the cited paper actually ''supports'' Point 5.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 09:34, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
(unindent)Lenski used the weighted method.  See note 49 to the paper and the text around the combination.  Of course there is the question of on what basis Lenski weighted the results.  Lenski weighted the results on the basis of the Cit+ numbers and we may think it would have been better to weight on the basis of the number of replicates.    I have below the calculations (not mine) of combined P-values based on 1) no weighting, 2) weighting on the basis of Cit+ and 3) weighting on the basis of replicates.  The weighted Z-transformed = SUM(Weight x Z-score for each run)/SQRT(SUM(Weight^2 for each run))&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
{| class=&amp;quot;wikitable&amp;quot;&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
! Expt# !! p-value !! z-score !! #Cit+ muts !! #replicates&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 1 || 0.0085 || 2.387 || 4 || 72&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 2 || 0.0007 || 3.195 || 5 || 340&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| 3 || 0.0823 || 1.390 || 8 || 2800&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|}&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Applying the formula described above.. &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
{| class=&amp;quot;wikitable&amp;quot;&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
! Weighting !! Z transformed !! p &lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
| Equal || 4.025 || &amp;lt;0.001&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|By total Cit+|| 3.576 || &amp;lt;0.001&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|By total replicates|| 1.825 || 0.034&lt;br /&gt;
|-&lt;br /&gt;
|}&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
So weighting on the basis of the number of replicates considerably increases the P-value.  It remains, however, well within the range of statistical significance (0&amp;gt;P&amp;lt;0.05).  If we hold that Lenski should have weighted on the basis of replicates  then he should have rejected the null hypothesis and reached exactly the same conclusions that he did.  The entire paper would have been exactly the same except the sentence “the result is extremely significant (P&amp;lt;0.0001) whether or not….” Would read “the result is significant (P&amp;lt;0.04) whether or not”.  Point 5 establishes one number and an “extremely”.  Point 5, therefore, has no weight (excuse the pun).  &lt;br /&gt;
--[[User:Toffeeman|Toffeeman]] 15:18, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: Sorry, Toffeeman, a falsehood is still a falsehood.  Based on your own posting, if Lenski had applied the Whitlock Z-transform paper in a logical manner, the results would not have been nearly as striking as Lenski claimed (his paper said the results were &amp;quot;extremely significant&amp;quot;).  Moreover, I found Lenski's description of his application of the Whitlock paper to be particularly misleading.  Lenski's use of &amp;quot;whether or not&amp;quot;&amp;lt;ref&amp;gt;&amp;quot;We also used the Z-transformation method (49) to combine the probabilities from our three experiments, and '''the result is extremely significant (P &amp;lt; 0.0001) whether or not''' the experiments are weighted by the number of independent Cit+ mutants observed in each one.&amp;quot; (Lenski paper at 7902).&amp;lt;/ref&amp;gt; obscures the basic error that he did not apply Whitlock's paper in the straightforward, correct manner.  I think the wording in the Lenski paper deliberately obscures this falsehood from the reader.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: People have free will to embrace and defend falsehoods.  I don't expect them to change quickly or admit they were wrong.  But you'll find me defending and promoting the truth.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: Point 5 remains valid and the falsehood remains uncorrected by PNAS or Lenski.  Four other points in higher priority remain uncorrected by them also.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 16:47, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::'''''&amp;quot;a falsehood is still a falsehood&amp;quot;'''''.  Precisely, the null hypothesis should be considered false and the conclusions of the paper stand.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::Oh? Do you mean ''Lenski's falsehood''? And what falsehood is that?  Lenski said that he had calculated the P-value without weighting and that had come out at &amp;lt;0.0001.  That is true, not false.  Lenski said he had calculated the P-value weighting on the basis of the Cit+ replicates and that had come out at &amp;lt;0.0001.  That is true, not false.  There is no falsehood.  Lenski did not mention the results of weighting on the basis of replicate numbers.  He thus made no claim about weighting on the basis of replicate numbers.  If he made no claim he cannot have made a false claim.  &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::How do the words Lenski uses &amp;quot;mislead&amp;quot;.  If you read them as written what conclusion do you come to?  You are lead to the conclusion that the mutation was not &amp;quot;rare-but-equal&amp;quot;, instead it was contingent.  That is the right conclusion.  If Lenski had presented the data in a different manner (perhaps by including the results of weighting on the basis of replicate numbers) what conclusion do you come to?  You are again lead to the conclusion that the mutation was not &amp;quot;rare-but-equal&amp;quot;, instead it was contingent.  That is the right conclusion.  To mislead you must be lead to a conclusion that is incorrect.  By Lenski's paper you are not lead to a conclusion that is incorrect.  Thus is cannot be said to be &amp;quot;misleading&amp;quot;. &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::I shall not comment on your second paragraph, the temptation to ''&amp;quot;Tu Quoque&amp;quot;'' would be too great.  &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
--[[User:Toffeeman|Toffeeman]] 17:13, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::: The falsehood consists of pretending to apply the Whitlock Z-transform in a straightforward, logical and correct manner.  I think the Lenski paper is intentionally misleading by using the &amp;quot;whether or not&amp;quot; wording, when both alternatives are nonsensical.  Point 5 has been proven above to be correct in identify an error in the Lenski paper.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::: &amp;quot;Toffeeman&amp;quot;, your blocking history suggests you have been less than straightforward yourself.  Go elsewhere if you seek to be deceitful.  You're not fooling anyone here.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 17:54, 20 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::Lenski did apply the Z-transformation correctly, both weighted and unweighted. The data points extracted from each replay are the ''generation numbers of those replicates that gave rise to Cit+ mutants''. Thus Replay 1 produced four data points: 30,500 31,500 32,500 32,500. Replay 2 produced five data points: 32,000 32,000 32,000 32,000 32,500. Replay 3 produced eight data points: 20,000 20,000 27,000 27,000 31,000 31,500 32,000 32,000. Thus the N for replay 1 is 4; replay 2 is 5 and replay 3 is 8. The fact that replay 3 used 38 times as many replicates as replay 1 does not mean that it should be weighted 38 times as much; it only produced twice as much data, not 38 times as much. &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::Suppose I want to find out what the average age of a murderer is in three cities. In L.A. I interview 72 random people and find that 4 of them were convicted of murder; I record the ages of the four. In Seattle I interview 340 people and find that 5 of them are convicted murderers; likewise in Singapore I interview 2800 and find 8 murderers. In the end, I have 4,5, and 8 data points from the three cities; the number of people I had to interview to obtain those data points doesn't factor into the analysis of what the average age of the murderers is.--[[User:Brossa|Brossa]] 00:06, 21 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::: In your first paragraph you simply repeat the error underlying Lenski's paper.  You, like the paper, incorrectly apply Whitlock's Z-transform.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::: The quality and reliability of data is proportional to sample size, and when different studies are combined they need to be weighted accordingly.  The results from a very large sample size would not be weighted equally with the results from a small sample size, as you and Lenski have done.  That's basic logic, though I'm not optimistic that you or Lenski will admit it.  Open-minded people who respect logic have no difficulty elevating logic over personal whim.-[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 11:30, 21 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::::Andy if you read Whitlock's paper you would see it say, and I quote, &amp;quot;Ideally each study is weighted proportional to the inverse of its error variance, that is, by the reciprocal of its squared standard error.&amp;quot; It says nothing about weighting according to sample size, which is what you seem to insisting should be done.&lt;br /&gt;
::::::Also Whitlock acknowledges in the paper that there is no preference for weighted versus equal weighting, so the fact that both equal weighting and weighting by the standard error give a statistically significant result shows that the 3 experiments combined support rejection of the null hypothesis. [[User:DanB|DanB]] 20:39, 21 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
== References ==&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
&amp;lt;references/&amp;gt;&lt;/div&gt;</summary>
		<author><name>DanB</name></author>
	</entry>
	<entry>
		<id>https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter&amp;diff=517552</id>
		<title>Talk:PNAS Response to Letter</title>
		<link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="https://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter&amp;diff=517552"/>
		<updated>2008-09-16T01:11:47Z</updated>

		<summary type="html">&lt;p&gt;DanB: /* Please provide your statistical analysis */&lt;/p&gt;
&lt;hr /&gt;
&lt;div&gt;Notice: misrepresentations are not going to be allowed on this page.  Substantive comments only, please.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
In this day and age, scientists have their own agenda and have corrupted science. Just look at global warming or cloning or stem cells as proof. With that said, the only way to get the real truth is by suing in court. Unfortunately, scientists are bound to vast wealth and have the power to defend themselves vigorously. If ever a fund was set up to pay for a suit, I would contribute. It is a classic case whereby the truth be known, the truth will prevail. -- [[Image:50 star flag.png|14px]] [[User:Jpatt|jp]] 22:14, 12 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: Thanks, Jpatt.  One additional beauty of the truth is that it remains the truth no how much some deny it.  PNAS can deny its errors all it likes, but that doesn't change the fact they are errors.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 22:21, 12 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::Well said, Andy and Jpatt. It is perhaps worth pointing out that the President of the NAS is a &amp;quot;climate scientist&amp;quot;. If the Academy is dominated by [[pseudoscience]] of that kind, it's hardly a surprise that their response was to cover up and deny the truth. Nevertheless, they had to be given their chance to make good before further steps are taken. I suggest now that the issue be put to potentially supportive congressmen/women and senators, given the public funding for Lenski's activities. [[User:Bugler|Bugler]] 05:46, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::: Right.  The next step is to criticize the taxpayer funding of this junk science.  When the authors and the publishing organization will not even address statistical errors in the work, then it's time to pull the public funding.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 10:13, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::They did address your claims of statistical errors: they said that you were wrong to the degree that they were able to determine what you were talking about. You made a qualitative argument and got a qualitative response.--[[User:Brossa|Brossa]] 11:00, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::: Which of the 5 specific errors do you think they addressed?  None, as far as I can tell.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 11:11, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::The response addresses your qualitative claims about the paper's statistical methods raised in points two, three, and five by the following:&amp;quot;Nevertheless, from a statistical point of view, it is proper to combine the results of independent experiments, as Blount et al. '''did correctly in their original paper'''&amp;quot;(emphasis added); in fact the longest paragraph in the response deals entirely with the statistical claims of the letter and dismisses them.--[[User:Brossa|Brossa]] 11:32, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::But that's never going to happen because the data availability requirements for public funding have already been met. [[User:Jirby|Jirby]] 11:03, 13 September 2008 (EDT)10:56, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::: No, I don't think the researchers have met NSF guidelines as referenced in the letter.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 11:11, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Proof?[[User:Jirby|Jirby]] 11:26, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: As I said, the NSF guidelines are references in the [[Letter to PNAS|letter]].--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 11:29, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
You mean the notebooks and ect? [[User:Jirby|Jirby]] 11:32, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:Oh my dear God, I can't believe this!! Where has this beautiful country gone to if even science is not reliable anymore nowadays. Hope things will change in the future. Good thing there still are people like Mr. Schlafly, &amp;lt;includeonly&amp;gt;suckadick moron&amp;lt;/includeonly&amp;gt;who have the brains and power to stand up, and turn the people of America in the right direction again. [[User:Raul|Raul]] 12:24, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Mr. Schlafly, I have a question BTW. Was this letter received on a paper, or electronically? Because if it was on a paper, perhaps it would be a good idea to scan it, and post it. It would add a lot to the encyclopedic value of the article. [[User:Raul|Raul]] 12:26, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: PNAS procedures required me to submit the letter electronically using its own electronic submission software.  When the PNAS acknowledged that my submission complied with all its requirements, it also said that the authors of the original paper had been notified of my letter.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 12:39, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Too bad. It doesn't make much sense though, guess that tells a lot about PNAS. What they should care about is the actual text, not the medium it is in. That's not the case IMHO for encyclopedias however. If not for anything else, a scan would have been useful as a reference for the digital text. Oh well... [[User:Raul|Raul]] 12:53, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Honest question, is it against the rules to disagree with Andrew Schlafly or criticize that letter? I just want to know so I don't end up in the same situation as other people who have been censored here.--[[User:IanG|IanG]] 17:03, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
:I believe this this page is only for discussion of the response, which is quite straightforward.  Criticism of the letter should have gone on it's talk page, but it's too late now.  Oh well.  There is no censorship on Conservapedia.  Your comment is not substantive - please refactor it. Praise Jesus, [[User:Pila|Pila]] 17:26, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:: if you REALLY believe that Lenski has committed acedemic FRAUD then lodge a formal complaint with his University. They are taken very seriously and can lead to loss of tenure and dismissal from the university, and with that on his record no other institution would hire him on any basis. [[User:Markr|Markr]] 19:40, 13 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
(deleted non-substantive comments).  Again, the heading on this page will be enforced:  &amp;quot;Substantive comments only, please.&amp;quot;  If you have a substantive comment about the identified errors and the PNAS's failure to address them, then please comment.  Non-substantive comments will be removed.  This is an encyclopedic-based search for the truth, not a blog or a place to refuse to contribute in a substantive manner.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 20:29, 14 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:Since you've taken the liberty of deciding what is substantive or not in deleting posts like my last one, then I have a serious, respectful question to ask;  What exactly do you mean by &amp;quot;substantive&amp;quot;?   I didn't attack you or your letter; I was attempting to state that the PNAS response did, in fact, address the points of your letter.  Whether one considers the PNAS response to be ''correct'' or not is a separate matter - they read your objections and responded to them instead of ignoring them, that's all.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:My last post would therefore seem to have met Webster's definition of ''substantive'' - &amp;quot;having or expressing substance&amp;quot;, but apparently the measure of &amp;quot;substantive&amp;quot; for a comment on this page appears to be whether it agrees with your view or not.  That's your prerogative, but if you intended to allow comments on this page other than endorsements of your view, then please let me know what I did wrong.  --[[User:DinsdaleP|DinsdaleP]] 21:00, 14 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::  Dinsdale, we're here to think and learn.  You can look at my letter, look at the PNAS's response, and provide some ''substantive'' insights.  We're not here to say something like, uh, go ask someone else if a (9th grade-level) graph is correct or not.  If you think the substantive issues are beyond your depth, and I don't, then comment on them in a substantive and intellectual and specific way.  This is not another waste-of-time blog, and it's not going to become one.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 21:19, 14 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::DinsdaleP, you did attack ASchalfy at least indirectly. Suggesting that the PNAS response has merit might also be interpreted by some that the letter ASchafly sent wasn't the very best it could be. Now, contrast that to my deleted comment suggesting that a time-tested response would be to actually try reproducing the experiment. Many bad experiments are exposed when others fail to get the same results as the original authors. I think this would be an excellent, substantive avenue to pursue.--[[User:Argon|Argon]] 21:23, 14 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
ASchlafly- you said above, &amp;quot;PNAS can deny its errors all it likes, but that doesn't change the fact they are errors&amp;quot;.   As you say, in a fair discussion of the merits of two sides of an argument, it's important that both sides take a good, hard look at their own propositions.  Since your position is that PNAS has errors on its own side, I'm just curious to know if you are in any way prepared to accept that there might be errors in your own argument, or are you ''absolutely 100% certain'' that your position is error-free?   I'm wondering if perhaps before submitting this issue to funding authorities, you would be prepared to have an independent statistical expert take a look at your proposal?   [[User:BenHur|BenHur]] 22:17, 14 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:The only thing I was criticizing in my original comment today was the Main Page headline statement that &amp;quot;PNAS refuses to address the 5 errors in the Lenski study identified by the Letter to PNAS&amp;quot;.  What I pointed out is the fact that they ''did'' in fact respond, by criticizing the statistical analysis used by Aschlafly.  I'm not supporting or attacking Mr. Schlafly's analysis, because I'm the first one to admit that I have no expertise in this area.  My conclusion was a constructive suggestion that Mr. Schlafly present a rebuttal to the PNAS decision by showing how his analysis and conclusions were not erroneous in the manner they claimed.  A public, statistical defense of Mr. Schlafly's work, perhaps accompanied by the endorsement of some regarded experts in the field, would be the best response to PNAS choosing to respond by email instead of through the journal.  &lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:I wrote both the original draft letter to PNAS from Mr. Schlafly's notes and my earlier comments today with the intent of contributing constructively.  I hope this clarification of my view is substantive enough to remain.  --[[User:DinsdaleP|DinsdaleP]] 22:24, 14 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Folks, I've pointed out five ''very specific'' statistical (logical) errors.  The torrent of nonsense above even includes an absurd demand for me to try to repeat the experiments, as thought that would somehow correct a flawed paper.&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
The math is wrong in the PNAS paper.  No one at PNAS is even willing to put his name on a response claiming that the math is correct, because it isn't.  I'm not going to allow further nonsensical postings here.  If you want to address the statistical (logical) errors in a specific way, fine.  If you feel it is beyond your depth to do so, then move on.  Thanks and Godspeed.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 22:49, 14 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:&amp;quot;The paper incorrectly applied a Monte Carlo resampling test to exclude the null hypothesis for rarely occurring events.&amp;quot; Specifically, why is it incorrect to apply a Monte Carlo test in this circumstance, or why was their application incorrect? Do your own calculations produce a p-value that differs from the published p-value of 0.08?&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:&amp;quot;The Third Experiment was erroneously combined with the other two experiments based on outcome rather than sample size, thereby yielding a false claim of overall statistical significance.&amp;quot;  This sounds as though you disagree with the use of the Z-transform technique used to combine the data from the three replay experiments, or believe that the Z-transform analysis was performed incorrectly. Which do you disagree with - the technique, the application, or both, and why? --[[User:Brossa|Brossa]] 23:31, 14 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:: {removed personal and non-substantive attack that violated clear rules for this discussion; also, unsubstantiated claims of expertise are not allowed - --[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:16, 15 September 2008 (EDT))&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::: I'm still a little unclear on your position ASchlafly - are you ''absolutely 100% certain'' your own statistical analysis is correct on this?   Before you proceed further it's important to know that the technical analysis you are presenting is indeed indisputable.   [[User:BenHur|BenHur]] 12:01, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::: Ben, if you have at least a 9th grade-level education, then you can look at the 5 errors and decide for yourself, and comment in a substantive manner.  Yes, they are obvious and basic errors, and the fact that the reviewer of my letter at PNAS would not attach his name to a specific denial speaks volumes.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 17:11, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::Aschlafly, I'm a little confused as to why you [http://www.conservapedia.com/index.php?title=Talk:PNAS_Response_to_Letter&amp;amp;curid=73292&amp;amp;diff=517424&amp;amp;oldid=517408 removed this comment of mine]?   I did not cast any aspersions on your argument, and was merely answering your question as you posed it to me?   Is &amp;quot;declining to comment&amp;quot; an indictable offense?   [[User:BenHur|BenHur]] 19:20, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::: Your comment was not an &amp;quot;indictable offense,&amp;quot; but it violated the rules of this page:  &amp;quot;Substantive comments only, please.&amp;quot;  Got it?  Either say something substantive, or edit somewhere else.  Thanks.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:33, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::::: This is confusing.   Is &amp;quot;I agree with your thesis&amp;quot; or &amp;quot;your methods are 100% correct&amp;quot; a substantive comment?   It can be very hard to infer your intent, Mr.Schalfly, I'm sorry to say.   I have no quarrel with you, but I'm becoming confused as to what is and isn't appropriate comment on what is labelled a &amp;quot;Talk Page&amp;quot;.   Are there special rules for this Talk Page?  If so, perhaps the title on the page might be changed?    [[User:BenHur|BenHur]] 19:42, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::::: No, your quoted phrases are obviously not substantive comments.  Your statement of agreement means nothing.  I doubt you are even using your real name, for starters, which renders your agreement evens sillier.  I repeat for the nth time, say something substantive or edit somewhere else.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:52, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::::::::: (removed another non-substantive posting)--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 20:28, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::Aschafly, perhaps you did not realize that my earlier questions were meant for you. I wish to address the statistical errors in a specific way, which requires a better understanding of your position. I will repeat my main questions: why was it incorrect to apply Monte Carlo techniques to the data in the paper, or in what way was the Monte Carlo technique performed incorrectly? Second, why was it incorrect to apply the Z-transform to the data from the three replays, or in what way was the Z-transform performed incorrectly? In lieu of the Monte Carlo/Z-transform techniques, what statistical calculations ''should'' have been performed? Feel free to be technical; I have more than a ninth grade education.--[[User:Brossa|Brossa]] 17:38, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:::::: If you're skipping over the main points, then concede their validity or explain why you've skipped over them.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:14, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
== Please provide your statistical analysis ==&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
Andrew, If you are so sure that your statistical analysis of the Lenski paper is correct, you should publish it on Conservapedia. [[User:MickA|MickA]] 17:38, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
: I did.  Which point don't you understand?--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 19:13, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
::Andy this is the hollywood breast cancer argument over again. You have made a series of vague statements without any actual numbers to back this up. [[User:DanB|DanB]] 21:11, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
I think regardless of what the details behind the statistical analysis are, the shame here is that PNAS refused to address anything specific in their response. They simply glossed over everything that was said in the letter sent to them and gave a generic, unsubstantive response. All the people here that are trying to argue with ASchlafly about his position should instead focus on why is it that PNAS refuses to directly address our concerns. --[[User:DRamon|DRamon]] 21:01, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;br /&gt;
&lt;br /&gt;
:PNAS have directly addressed his concerns. They made it quite clear that there is no obvious (&amp;quot;subtle or obscure&amp;quot;) statistical errors. If Andy's letter had raised any serious concerns then they would have asked the authors to respond. The only reason this is continuing is Andy &amp;quot;twice as many statistic courses as you&amp;quot; won't accept that he is wrong. [[User:DanB|DanB]] 21:11, 15 September 2008 (EDT)&lt;/div&gt;</summary>
		<author><name>DanB</name></author>
	</entry>
</feed>